JWST NIRCam coronagraphy finds no giant planets around Altair
JWST looked for young giant planets around Altair, one of the nearest young bright stars, and found none down to sub-Jupiter masses beyond 5 au. We checked why 4.4 microns is the colour to look in.
Altair, the bright star in the constellation Aquila, is only about 17 light-years away and, at under 100 million years old, surprisingly young. Young giant planets are still warm from their birth, so they glow in infrared light. That makes Altair one of the best stars in the sky to look for planets by taking their picture directly. A team using the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) did exactly that, twice, and found nothing orbiting it. The nothing is useful: it rules out planets bigger than Jupiter over most of the system. Below we use the blackbody calculator to see why the search works best at a wavelength of 4.4 microns, and the habitable zone calculator to show that only a planet still warm from its birth could have been seen.
What they found
The team pointed JWST’s near-infrared camera, NIRCam, at Altair on two dates, with a small mask (a coronagraph) blocking the star’s light. NIRCam can take two pictures at once, one in a red filter centred near 2.0 microns (F200W) and one in a longer-wave filter centred near 4.4 microns (F444W). After removing what was left of the starlight, the 4.4-micron images could show a planet two million times fainter than Altair at 1 arcsecond from the star, about seven million times fainter at 2 arcseconds, and around thirty million times fainter beyond 4 arcseconds.
The first pictures showed several faint dots. In the second pictures none of them had moved across the sky together with Altair, as a real planet would, and their colours matched distant background stars. So the team found no planets. Using models of how young giant planets cool, they turned the limits into masses: anything heavier than a little under Jupiter’s mass beyond about 5 astronomical units (au), or a little under Saturn’s mass beyond about 10 au, would have been seen.
The team also checked how Altair moves against the background stars, and found it should stay at least a few arcseconds from any background star for the next 10 to 20 years. That makes it a clean reference star for future instruments such as the coronagraph on NASA’s Roman Space Telescope.
Why it matters
Most known planets were found indirectly, by the dimming when they cross their star or by the star’s wobble. Direct pictures are rarer, and they work best for big, young planets far from their star, exactly the region the indirect methods miss. Each deep search of a nearby young star, even an empty one, tells us how common wide giant planets are. Altair is an unusual case: it spins so fast that it is squashed, it has no known companion, no dusty disc and no family of stars born with it, and yet it is young. Knowing that it has no wide giants is a piece of the puzzle of how planets form around stars heavier than the Sun.
How they did it
The coronagraph mask blocks most of Altair’s light, but some leaks round its edge as a pattern of speckles. The team removed these speckles with image processing, comparing pictures taken at different telescope angles and of a reference star. They then planted fake planets in the data to measure how faint a planet could be and still be found, at each distance from the star. The two filters work together: a real cool planet is far brighter at 4.4 microns than at 2 microns, while a background star looks much the same in both, so the colours sort one from the other.
Checked with the tools
We do not have the JWST images, so we checked the physics behind the search with fibub’s maths, using the reach stated in the paper’s abstract, the paper’s distance of 5.13 parsecs, and rounded published values for Altair’s temperature (7,700 K) and size (1.8 times the Sun). We treated both the star and the planet as perfect glowing bodies (black bodies) and assumed a planet 1.15 times the size of Jupiter, typical for a young giant. These are our simplifications, not the paper’s models.
Step 1: from arcseconds to au. At 5.13 parsecs, 1 arcsecond on the sky is 5.13 au, because 1 arcsecond at 1 parsec is exactly 1 au; the measurement and parallax activity shows where this rule comes from. So the reach at 1, 2 and 4 arcseconds applies at about 5.1, 10.3 and 20.5 au: roughly the distances of Jupiter, Saturn and Uranus from the Sun. The same black-body maths gives Altair a power output about 10 times the Sun’s.
Step 2: why 4.4 microns? Figure 1 shows how bright a planet looks next to Altair, for planets from 150 K to 1,050 K. A 500 K planet is about 3.5 millionths as bright as Altair at 4.4 microns, but only about 4 billionths as bright at 2.0 microns: around 900 times better contrast at the longer wavelength. Cool planets give out most of their light in the infrared, while a 7,700 K star gives out most of its light at visible wavelengths. That is why the planet search uses F444W and why F200W is good for spotting background stars, which are bright in both.
Step 3: how warm would a planet have to be? Reading across Figure 1, a planet of this size matches the paper’s reach if it is about 460 K at 5 au, 340 K at 10 au and 290 K at 20 au. Now compare that with the warmth Altair’s light alone would give a planet at those distances, from the equilibrium temperature in the Habitable zone calculator: only about 200 K, 140 K and 100 K (Figure 2). Starlight cannot heat a planet enough to be seen. Any planet found this way must still be glowing from the heat of its formation, which is why the search only works because Altair is young.
| Check | Paper | Our tool result |
|---|---|---|
| 1, 2, 4 arcseconds in au | 5.1, 10.3 and beyond 20 au | 5.1, 10.3 and 20.5 au |
| Best wavelength for cool planets | F444W (4.4 µm) | about 900 times better contrast than 2.0 µm for a 500 K planet |
| Temperature needed to be seen | (in mass terms, from cooling models) | about 460 K at 5 au, 340 K at 10 au, 290 K at 20 au |
| Warmth from starlight alone | not given | about 200 K, 140 K and 100 K |
The temperatures in Step 3 are a little higher than what the paper’s models need. Real giant planets are not perfect black bodies: their atmospheres let extra light out near 4 to 5 microns, so a real planet at a given temperature is brighter there than our simple sum. Read our temperatures as rough upper values. The masses (sub-Jupiter beyond 5 au, sub-Saturn beyond 10 au) need models of how a young planet cools, which we have not done.
How we made the graphs
Both charts come from scripts/blog-figures/altair-jwst-nircam-giant-planet-search.mjs in fibub’s public code, which calls the tools’ own functions rather than drawing by hand:
planckLamandstarfromsrc/lib/sci/blackbody.ts, the maths behind the blackbody calculator, give the glow of the star and the planet at each wavelength, and Altair’s power output.tEqfromsrc/lib/sci/habitable.ts, the maths behind the habitable zone calculator, gives the temperature starlight alone would give a planet.
The paper’s numbers (distance and reach) and the literature values for Altair are labelled in the script; the planet size and albedo are marked as our assumptions. Running the script prints every number quoted here and redraws the charts.
How we test the maths
These functions are checked against known results on every change to fibub (tests/sci.mjs):
- Planck’s law must put the Sun’s peak at 502 nm, matching Wien’s law, and the whole spectrum must add up to exactly the Sun’s power: one solar luminosity, absolute magnitude 4.82.
- The Sun’s share of light between 400 and 700 nm must come out at 36.6%.
- The equilibrium temperature maths must give Earth 254 K, the textbook value, for an albedo of 0.306.
Check it yourself
- Open the blackbody calculator. Under I know, choose The temperature (K) and type 7700.
- Type 1.8 in Radius (Suns) and 5.13 in Distance (parsecs). The luminosity reads about 10 Suns, and you can see where Altair’s light peaks: around 376 nm, in the near ultraviolet.
- Type 500 in Compare with (K, optional). The two curves show at a glance why a cool planet is best seen far out in the infrared.
- Now open the habitable zone calculator. Type 7700 in Temperature (K), 10.3 in Luminosity (Suns) and 1.8 in Mass (Suns).
- Type 5.13 in Distance from the star (AU) and 0.3 in Albedo. The equilibrium temperature reads about 200 K: far too cold to be seen by JWST at that distance, which is the point of Step 3 above.
What researchers can use it for
- Choose a filter: compare a target star and a planet of a given temperature in the blackbody calculator to see which wavelength gives the best contrast.
- Turn an imaging limit into a temperature: as in Step 3, before reaching for full atmosphere models.
- Convert arcseconds to au: multiply by the distance in parsecs; the measurement and parallax activity explains why.
- Teach direct imaging: the two tools together show students why young stars are the best hunting grounds.
The fine print
- Our checks treat star and planet as perfect black bodies, with an assumed planet size of 1.15 Jupiter radii and rounded values for Altair. The paper uses detailed planet atmosphere models (Sonora Flame Skimmer) instead.
- “A few × 10⁻⁸” beyond 4 arcseconds was taken as 3 × 10⁻⁸ for our sums.
- The limits apply to planets in the parts of the image the team could search; a planet hidden behind the mask, or passing very close to the star at the time, could be missed.
- No planet found is not the same as no planet there. Smaller or older, cooler planets would be too faint.
Sources
- Meshkat, T., Beichman, C., Llop-Sayson, J., Bryden, G. et al. (2026), Searching for Planets around Altair with JWST/NIRCam, The Astronomical Journal 172, 280; arXiv:2611.13132 (posted 9 November 2026). Licence CC BY 4.0, checked on the arXiv page, 2026-11-16. Values used here, from the abstract: distance 5.13 pc, age 88 ± 10 million years, F444W contrast of about 2 × 10⁻⁶ at 1 arcsecond, 1.5 × 10⁻⁷ at 2 arcseconds and a few × 10⁻⁸ beyond 4 arcseconds.
- Altair's temperature (about 7,700 K, rounded average of a hotter pole and cooler equator) and radius (about 1.8 solar radii, average of polar and equatorial): Monnier, J. D. et al. (2007), Imaging the Surface of Altair, Science 317, 342.
- Planck's law and the small-angle rule (1 arcsecond at 1 parsec is 1 astronomical unit): standard physics.
If you are an author or publisher and want a credit or a passage changed or removed, tell us and we will act quickly.