Home / Courses / CSIR NET Physics / Practice / Microstates, entropy and the statistical ensembles

Microstates, entropy and the statistical ensembles

Statistical physics · 86 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    In the microcanonical ensemble, which set of quantities is held fixed for every member system?
    1. T, V and N
    2. E, V and N
    3. μ, V and T
    4. T, P and N
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The microcanonical ensemble describes an isolated system: no energy or particles cross the walls, so E, V and N are fixed. (T,V,N is canonical; μ,V,T is grand canonical; T,P,N is the isothermal-isobaric ensemble.)
  2. MCQWarm-up

    A small system exchanges energy, but not particles, with a very large heat bath at temperature T. The probability of finding it in a microstate of energy Ei is proportional to
    1. Eie−Ei/kT
    2. 1/Ei
    3. e−Ei/kT
    4. a constant, the same for every microstate
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    This is the canonical ensemble. The bath has ΩR(Etot−Ei) states; expanding ln⁡ΩR to first order gives Pi∝e−Ei/kT, the Boltzmann factor.

    Why people get this wrong: A constant probability is the microcanonical rule for an isolated system, not for a system in a bath.

  3. MCQWarm-up

    Boltzmann’s formula connects the entropy of an isolated system to the number Ω of accessible microstates as
    1. S=kΩ
    2. S=keΩ
    3. S=Ω/k
    4. S=kln⁡Ω
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    S=kln⁡Ω. The logarithm makes entropy additive: two independent systems have Ω=Ω1Ω2, so S=S1+S2.
  4. MCQWarm-up

    In the grand canonical ensemble the system exchanges with its reservoir
    1. both energy and particles
    2. energy only
    3. particles only
    4. neither energy nor particles
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Grand canonical: the walls pass both energy and particles, so the reservoir fixes T and the chemical potential μ. Both E and N fluctuate.
  5. MCQWarm-up

    The postulate of equal a priori probabilities states that, for an isolated system in equilibrium,
    1. every energy level is equally likely
    2. every accessible microstate is equally likely
    3. every macrostate is equally likely
    4. the lowest-energy state is the most likely
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    All microstates consistent with the fixed E,V,N are equally probable. Macrostates are then not equally likely: a macrostate with more microstates is more probable, which is why entropy tends to increase.

    Why people get this wrong: Microstates are equally likely; macrostates are not.

  6. MSQWarm-up

    For a system described by the canonical ensemble, which statements are correct?
    1. The temperature is fixed by the bath
    2. The energy of the system fluctuates
    3. The number of particles fluctuates
    4. Microstates of lower energy are more probable
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    The bath fixes T; energy flows in and out, so E fluctuates; Pi∝e−Ei/kT falls with energy, so lower-energy microstates are more likely. The walls do not pass particles, so N is fixed.
  7. NATWarm-up

    An isolated system has 1020 equally likely microstates. Its entropy is ______ ×10−22 J/K (k=1.381×10−23 J/K).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 6.36 (±0.03)

    S=kln⁡Ω=1.381×10−23×20ln⁡10=1.381×10−23×46.05=6.36×10−22 J/K. Even an enormous number of microstates gives a tiny entropy in J/K; macroscopic entropies need ln⁡Ω∼1023.

    Why people get this wrong: Using log10⁡ instead of the natural logarithm gives 2.76×10−22 J/K.

  8. NATStandard

    Six distinguishable spin-1/2 particles sit in a magnetic field. The number of microstates with exactly two spins pointing up is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 15

    Choose which 2 of the 6 particles point up: (62)=6⋅52=15.
  9. MCQStandard

    For N=100 independent two-state particles with zero field (both states have the same energy), the macrostate "n particles in the upper state" with the largest entropy has
    1. n=0
    2. n=25
    3. n=100
    4. n=50
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Ω(n)=(100n) is largest at the middle, n=50. This macrostate alone holds about 8% of all 2100 microstates, and the states near it hold nearly all of them.
  10. MCQStandard

    Two isolated systems with Ω1(E1) and Ω2(E2) are brought into thermal contact, with E1+E2 fixed. The most probable division of energy satisfies
    1. Ω1=Ω2
    2. E1=E2
    3. ∂ln⁡Ω1∂E1=∂ln⁡Ω2∂E2
    4. ∂Ω1∂E1=∂Ω2∂E2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Maximise ln⁡[Ω1(E1)Ω2(E−E1)] over E1: ∂ln⁡Ω1/∂E1−∂ln⁡Ω2/∂E2=0. With S=kln⁡Ω and 1/T=∂S/∂E, this is T1=T2.

    Why people get this wrong: Equal energies or equal numbers of states are not the condition; equal slopes of ln⁡Ω are.

  11. MCQStandard

    In statistical mechanics the temperature of an isolated system is defined by
    1. 1T=(∂S∂E)V,N
    2. T=(∂S∂E)V,N
    3. 1T=(∂E∂S)V,N
    4. T=SE
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    1/T=(∂S/∂E)V,N, equivalently T=(∂E/∂S)V,N, which matches dE=TdS−PdV+μdN.
  12. NATStandard

    A system is found in three microstates with probabilities 1/2, 1/4 and 1/4. Its Gibbs entropy S=−k∑ipiln⁡pi, in units of k, is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.04 (±0.01)

    S/k=−[12ln⁡12+2⋅14ln⁡14]=12ln⁡2+12ln⁡4=32ln⁡2≈1.04. A uniform distribution over 3 states would give the maximum, ln⁡3≈1.10.
  13. NATStandard

    Two non-degenerate states of a molecule differ in energy by 0.050 eV. At 300 K, the ratio of the population of the upper state to that of the lower state is ______. (k=8.617×10−5 eV/K)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.145 (±0.003)

    kT=8.617×10−5×300=0.02585 eV. Ratio =e−0.050/0.02585=e−1.934≈0.145.
  14. MCQStandard

    Liouville’s theorem for a Hamiltonian system states that
    1. the energy of every phase point is the same
    2. the density of phase points is constant along the flow, so phase-space volume is conserved
    3. every trajectory visits every point of the energy surface
    4. phase points crowd towards the lowest-energy region
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    dρ/dt=∂ρ/∂t+{ρ,H}=0: the phase-space flow is incompressible. A blob of phase points changes shape but keeps its volume.

    Why people get this wrong: Visiting every point of the energy surface is the ergodic hypothesis, a different (and much harder) statement.

  15. MCQStandard

    The ergodic hypothesis is the assumption that
    1. entropy always increases
    2. the system is in contact with a heat bath
    3. the long-time average of a quantity equals its ensemble average
    4. all energy levels are equally spaced
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    A real measurement averages over time; theory averages over an ensemble. Ergodicity says a single system, followed long enough, spends equal times in equal phase-space areas of its energy surface, so the two averages agree.
  16. MCQStandard

    A one-dimensional harmonic oscillator H=p2/2m+mω2x2/2 has energy at most E. Dividing the phase-space area of this region by h gives the number of quantum states below E as about
    1. E/ℏω
    2. 2πE/ω
    3. E/hω
    4. ℏω/E
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The region H≤E is an ellipse with semi-axes 2mE (in p) and 2E/mω2 (in x), area π2mE2E/mω2=2πE/ω. Divide by h=2πℏ: E/ℏω, matching the levels (n+12)ℏω.

    Why people get this wrong: 2πE/ω is the area itself, which has units of action, not a number.

  17. MCQStandard

    In the grand canonical ensemble the probability of a microstate with N particles and energy E is proportional to
    1. e−β(E+μN)
    2. e−βEμN
    3. e−βE/N!
    4. e−β(E−μN)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    The reservoir loses energy E and N particles; ln⁡ΩR falls by βE−βμN (since ∂SR/∂NR=−μ/T). So P∝e−β(E−μN)=zNe−βE with fugacity z=eβμ.

    Why people get this wrong: Sign: a higher μ favours more particles, so μN enters with a minus sign inside the bracket.

  18. NATStandard

    An Einstein solid has 3 oscillators sharing 3 identical energy quanta. The number of microstates is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 10

    Distribute q indistinguishable quanta among N distinguishable oscillators: Ω=(q+N−1q)=(53)=10 (stars and bars). Check by listing: (3,0,0)×3, (2,1,0)×6, (1,1,1)×1.
  19. NATStandard

    One mole of spin-1/2 particles in zero field has 2NA equally likely microstates. Its entropy is ______ J/K.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 5.76 J/K (±0.02)

    S=kln⁡2NA=NAkln⁡2=Rln⁡2=8.314×0.693≈5.76 J/K.
  20. MSQStandard

    Which properties does the Boltzmann entropy S=kln⁡Ω have?
    1. It is additive for independent systems
    2. It is zero when the system has exactly one accessible microstate
    3. It can be negative for a system with many microstates
    4. It increases when a constraint inside an isolated system is removed
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    Ω12=Ω1Ω2 gives S12=S1+S2. One microstate: ln⁡1=0 (the third law picture). Ω≥1, so S≥0. Removing a constraint (a partition, say) can only add accessible microstates, so S rises or stays the same.
  21. MCQStandard

    A large system is in equilibrium with a heat bath at temperature T>0. Which statement is correct?
    1. The most probable single microstate is one whose energy equals ⟨E⟩.
    2. The system is most likely to be found with energy close to its ground-state energy.
    3. The most probable microstate is the ground state, yet the most probable energy is close to ⟨E⟩.
    4. All microstates are equally probable, because the bath fixes the temperature.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Each microstate has probability ∝e−Ei/kT, largest for the ground state. But the probability of an energy E is Ω(E)e−E/kT, and Ω(E) grows enormously fast with E. The product has a sharp peak near ⟨E⟩. Individual microstates there are each less likely than the ground state, but there are vastly more of them.

    Why people get this wrong: "Most probable microstate" and "most probable energy" are different questions; the density of states makes the difference.

  22. NATStandard

    An isolated set of N≫1 two-level units has exactly one quarter of them excited. Using Stirling's formula, its entropy per unit, S/Nk, is ______ (three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.562 (±0.003)

    Ω=N!n!(N−n)! with n=N/4. Stirling gives ln⁡Ω≈−N[fln⁡f+(1−f)ln⁡(1−f)] with f=1/4: S/Nk=0.25ln⁡4+0.75ln⁡(4/3)=0.347+0.216=0.562. The maximum, ln⁡2=0.693, is at half excitation.

    Why people get this wrong: Keeping only −fln⁡f (0.347) misses the entropy from choosing which units stay unexcited.

  23. MCQExam level

    In the canonical ensemble the mean square fluctuation of the energy is
    1. kTCV
    2. k2TCV
    3. kT2CV
    4. kT2/CV
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    ⟨E⟩=−∂ln⁡Z/∂β and ⟨(ΔE)2⟩=∂2ln⁡Z/∂β2=−∂⟨E⟩/∂β=kT2∂⟨E⟩/∂T=kT2CV.

    Why people get this wrong: Check units: kT2CV has units of J2 because k and CV are both J/K.

  24. NATExam level

    A classical monatomic ideal gas of N=600 atoms is in contact with a heat bath. The relative energy fluctuation ΔErms/⟨E⟩ is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.0333 (±0.0005)

    ⟨(ΔE)2⟩=kT2⋅32Nk and ⟨E⟩=32NkT. Ratio =32NkT/(32NkT)=2/3N=1/900=1/30≈0.0333. For a mole it is about 10−12, which is why ensembles agree for large systems.
  25. MCQExam level

    For a classical ideal gas in the grand canonical ensemble, the mean square fluctuation of the particle number ⟨(ΔN)2⟩ equals
    1. ⟨N⟩2
    2. ⟨N⟩
    3. ⟨N⟩
    4. 1
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    ⟨(ΔN)2⟩=kT(∂⟨N⟩/∂μ)T,V. For the ideal gas ⟨N⟩=(V/λ3)eβμ, so ∂⟨N⟩/∂μ=β⟨N⟩ and the variance is ⟨N⟩: Poisson statistics. Relative size 1/⟨N⟩.

    Why people get this wrong: ⟨N⟩ is the rms fluctuation, not its square.

  26. NATExam level

    N independent two-level systems (energies 0 and ε=0.010 eV) are isolated with a quarter of them excited. Using S=kln⁡(Nn) with Stirling’s formula, the temperature is ______ K. (k=8.617×10−5 eV/K)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 105.6 K (±1)

    With E=nε, S/k≈Nln⁡N−nln⁡n−(N−n)ln⁡(N−n), so 1kT=1ε∂(S/k)∂n=1εln⁡N−nn. With n=N/4, ln⁡3: T=0.0108.617×10−5×1.0986≈105.6 K.
  27. MSQExam level

    For an isolated collection of N two-level systems (energies 0 and ε) with n excited, which statements are correct?
    1. The temperature is negative when n>N/2
    2. A negative-temperature state gives heat to any positive-temperature system it touches
    3. An ideal gas of free particles can also reach negative temperature
    4. At n=N/2, 1/T=0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    1/kT=ε−1ln⁡[(N−n)/n] is negative for n>N/2 and zero at n=N/2. Negative T is "hotter than infinite": a β<0 system gains entropy by giving energy away, so heat flows out of it into anything at positive T. A free gas has no upper bound on energy, so S(E) never turns over and T cannot be negative.

    Why people get this wrong: Negative temperature needs a bounded energy spectrum (spins, two-level atoms), never a free gas.

  28. MCQExam level

    A hypothetical gas has Ω(E,V)∝VNE2N. Its heat capacity at constant volume per particle is
    1. 32k
    2. k
    3. 4k
    4. 2k
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    S=Nkln⁡V+2Nkln⁡E+const, so 1/T=∂S/∂E=2Nk/E, giving E=2NkT and CV=2Nk: 2k per particle. (An ordinary monatomic gas has E3N/2 and 32k.) The same S gives P/T=Nk/V, the ideal gas law.
  29. NATExam level

    In a ball of radius R in d=100 dimensions, the fraction of the volume lying in the outer shell 0.99R<r<R is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.634 (±0.005)

    Volume scales as Rd, so the inner ball holds 0.99100=e100ln⁡0.99≈0.366 of the volume. The shell holds 1−0.366=0.634. For d=3N∼1024 essentially all the volume is at the surface, so counting states "with energy below E" or "within a thin shell at E" gives the same entropy.
  30. MCQExam level

    Why do the microcanonical, canonical and grand canonical ensembles give the same thermodynamics for a macroscopic system?
    1. Because the Hamiltonian is the same
    2. Because the relative fluctuations of E and N scale as 1/N and vanish in the thermodynamic limit
    3. Because the temperature is always fixed
    4. Because each ensemble has the same partition function
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    In the canonical ensemble E is not fixed, but its distribution is so sharply peaked (ΔE/E∼N−1/2) that it is effectively fixed. Exceptions occur where fluctuations become large, such as at a critical point.

← All topics · Timed mock test →