Microstates, entropy and the statistical ensembles
Statistical physics · 86 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQWarm-up
In the microcanonical ensemble, which set of quantities is held fixed for every member system?- , and
- , and
- , and
- , and
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The microcanonical ensemble describes an isolated system: no energy or particles cross the walls, so , and are fixed. ( is canonical; is grand canonical; is the isothermal-isobaric ensemble.) -
MCQWarm-up
A small system exchanges energy, but not particles, with a very large heat bath at temperature . The probability of finding it in a microstate of energy is proportional to- a constant, the same for every microstate
Answer and solution
Answer: C
This is the canonical ensemble. The bath has states; expanding to first order gives , the Boltzmann factor.Why people get this wrong: A constant probability is the microcanonical rule for an isolated system, not for a system in a bath.
-
MCQWarm-up
Boltzmann’s formula connects the entropy of an isolated system to the number of accessible microstates asAnswer and solution
Answer: D
. The logarithm makes entropy additive: two independent systems have , so . -
MCQWarm-up
In the grand canonical ensemble the system exchanges with its reservoir- both energy and particles
- energy only
- particles only
- neither energy nor particles
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Grand canonical: the walls pass both energy and particles, so the reservoir fixes and the chemical potential . Both and fluctuate. -
MCQWarm-up
The postulate of equal a priori probabilities states that, for an isolated system in equilibrium,- every energy level is equally likely
- every accessible microstate is equally likely
- every macrostate is equally likely
- the lowest-energy state is the most likely
Answer and solution
Answer: B
All microstates consistent with the fixed are equally probable. Macrostates are then not equally likely: a macrostate with more microstates is more probable, which is why entropy tends to increase.Why people get this wrong: Microstates are equally likely; macrostates are not.
-
MSQWarm-up
For a system described by the canonical ensemble, which statements are correct?- The temperature is fixed by the bath
- The energy of the system fluctuates
- The number of particles fluctuates
- Microstates of lower energy are more probable
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, D
The bath fixes ; energy flows in and out, so fluctuates; falls with energy, so lower-energy microstates are more likely. The walls do not pass particles, so is fixed. -
NATWarm-up
An isolated system has equally likely microstates. Its entropy is ______ J/K ( J/K).Answer and solution
Answer: 6.36 (±0.03)
J/K. Even an enormous number of microstates gives a tiny entropy in J/K; macroscopic entropies need .Why people get this wrong: Using instead of the natural logarithm gives J/K.
-
NATStandard
Six distinguishable spin-1/2 particles sit in a magnetic field. The number of microstates with exactly two spins pointing up is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 15
Choose which 2 of the 6 particles point up: . -
MCQStandard
For independent two-state particles with zero field (both states have the same energy), the macrostate " particles in the upper state" with the largest entropy hasAnswer and solution
Answer: D
is largest at the middle, . This macrostate alone holds about 8% of all microstates, and the states near it hold nearly all of them. -
MCQStandard
Two isolated systems with and are brought into thermal contact, with fixed. The most probable division of energy satisfiesAnswer and solution
Answer: C
Maximise over : . With and , this is .Why people get this wrong: Equal energies or equal numbers of states are not the condition; equal slopes of are.
-
MCQStandard
In statistical mechanics the temperature of an isolated system is defined byAnswer and solution
Answer: A
, equivalently , which matches . -
NATStandard
A system is found in three microstates with probabilities , and . Its Gibbs entropy , in units of , is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 1.04 (±0.01)
. A uniform distribution over 3 states would give the maximum, . -
NATStandard
Two non-degenerate states of a molecule differ in energy by eV. At K, the ratio of the population of the upper state to that of the lower state is ______. ( eV/K)Answer and solution
Answer: 0.145 (±0.003)
eV. Ratio . -
MCQStandard
Liouville’s theorem for a Hamiltonian system states that- the energy of every phase point is the same
- the density of phase points is constant along the flow, so phase-space volume is conserved
- every trajectory visits every point of the energy surface
- phase points crowd towards the lowest-energy region
Answer and solution
Answer: B
: the phase-space flow is incompressible. A blob of phase points changes shape but keeps its volume.Why people get this wrong: Visiting every point of the energy surface is the ergodic hypothesis, a different (and much harder) statement.
-
MCQStandard
The ergodic hypothesis is the assumption that- entropy always increases
- the system is in contact with a heat bath
- the long-time average of a quantity equals its ensemble average
- all energy levels are equally spaced
Answer and solution
Answer: C
A real measurement averages over time; theory averages over an ensemble. Ergodicity says a single system, followed long enough, spends equal times in equal phase-space areas of its energy surface, so the two averages agree. -
MCQStandard
A one-dimensional harmonic oscillator has energy at most . Dividing the phase-space area of this region by gives the number of quantum states below as aboutAnswer and solution
Answer: A
The region is an ellipse with semi-axes (in ) and (in ), area . Divide by : , matching the levels .Why people get this wrong: is the area itself, which has units of action, not a number.
-
MCQStandard
In the grand canonical ensemble the probability of a microstate with particles and energy is proportional toAnswer and solution
Answer: D
The reservoir loses energy and particles; falls by (since ). So with fugacity .Why people get this wrong: Sign: a higher favours more particles, so enters with a minus sign inside the bracket.
-
NATStandard
An Einstein solid has 3 oscillators sharing 3 identical energy quanta. The number of microstates is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 10
Distribute indistinguishable quanta among distinguishable oscillators: (stars and bars). Check by listing: (3,0,0)×3, (2,1,0)×6, (1,1,1)×1. -
NATStandard
One mole of spin-1/2 particles in zero field has equally likely microstates. Its entropy is ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 5.76 J/K (±0.02)
J/K. -
MSQStandard
Which properties does the Boltzmann entropy have?- It is additive for independent systems
- It is zero when the system has exactly one accessible microstate
- It can be negative for a system with many microstates
- It increases when a constraint inside an isolated system is removed
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, D
gives . One microstate: (the third law picture). , so . Removing a constraint (a partition, say) can only add accessible microstates, so rises or stays the same. -
MCQStandard
A large system is in equilibrium with a heat bath at temperature . Which statement is correct?- The most probable single microstate is one whose energy equals .
- The system is most likely to be found with energy close to its ground-state energy.
- The most probable microstate is the ground state, yet the most probable energy is close to .
- All microstates are equally probable, because the bath fixes the temperature.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Each microstate has probability , largest for the ground state. But the probability of an energy is , and grows enormously fast with . The product has a sharp peak near . Individual microstates there are each less likely than the ground state, but there are vastly more of them.Why people get this wrong: "Most probable microstate" and "most probable energy" are different questions; the density of states makes the difference.
-
NATStandard
An isolated set of two-level units has exactly one quarter of them excited. Using Stirling's formula, its entropy per unit, , is ______ (three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.562 (±0.003)
with . Stirling gives with : . The maximum, , is at half excitation.Why people get this wrong: Keeping only () misses the entropy from choosing which units stay unexcited.
-
MCQExam level
In the canonical ensemble the mean square fluctuation of the energy isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
and .Why people get this wrong: Check units: has units of J because and are both J/K.
-
NATExam level
A classical monatomic ideal gas of atoms is in contact with a heat bath. The relative energy fluctuation is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 0.0333 (±0.0005)
and . Ratio . For a mole it is about , which is why ensembles agree for large systems. -
MCQExam level
For a classical ideal gas in the grand canonical ensemble, the mean square fluctuation of the particle number equalsAnswer and solution
Answer: C
. For the ideal gas , so and the variance is : Poisson statistics. Relative size .Why people get this wrong: is the rms fluctuation, not its square.
-
NATExam level
independent two-level systems (energies and eV) are isolated with a quarter of them excited. Using with Stirling’s formula, the temperature is ______ K. ( eV/K)Answer and solution
Answer: 105.6 K (±1)
With , , so . With , : K. -
MSQExam level
For an isolated collection of two-level systems (energies and ) with excited, which statements are correct?- The temperature is negative when
- A negative-temperature state gives heat to any positive-temperature system it touches
- An ideal gas of free particles can also reach negative temperature
- At ,
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, D
is negative for and zero at . Negative is "hotter than infinite": a system gains entropy by giving energy away, so heat flows out of it into anything at positive . A free gas has no upper bound on energy, so never turns over and cannot be negative.Why people get this wrong: Negative temperature needs a bounded energy spectrum (spins, two-level atoms), never a free gas.
-
MCQExam level
A hypothetical gas has . Its heat capacity at constant volume per particle isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
, so , giving and : per particle. (An ordinary monatomic gas has and .) The same gives , the ideal gas law. -
NATExam level
In a ball of radius in dimensions, the fraction of the volume lying in the outer shell is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 0.634 (±0.005)
Volume scales as , so the inner ball holds of the volume. The shell holds . For essentially all the volume is at the surface, so counting states "with energy below " or "within a thin shell at " gives the same entropy. -
MCQExam level
Why do the microcanonical, canonical and grand canonical ensembles give the same thermodynamics for a macroscopic system?- Because the Hamiltonian is the same
- Because the relative fluctuations of and scale as and vanish in the thermodynamic limit
- Because the temperature is always fixed
- Because each ensemble has the same partition function
Answer and solution
Answer: B
In the canonical ensemble is not fixed, but its distribution is so sharply peaked () that it is effectively fixed. Exceptions occur where fluctuations become large, such as at a critical point.