Canonical transformations and Hamilton-Jacobi theory
Classical mechanics (GATE and NET) · 84 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Canonical transformations and Hamilton-Jacobi theory.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQWarm-up
Hamilton-Jacobi theory looks for a canonical transformation, generated by Hamilton's principal function , for which the new Hamiltonian is- , so all the new coordinates and momenta are constants
- , the same function as before
Answer and solution
Answer: A
With a type-2 generating function, . Demanding gives the Hamilton-Jacobi equation , and then Hamilton's equations say : the whole motion is encoded in constants. -
MCQWarm-up
For a Hamiltonian with no explicit time dependence and energy , Hamilton's principal function separates asAnswer and solution
Answer: B
Try . Then and the HJ equation becomes , the time-independent HJ equation for Hamilton's characteristic function . The separation is additive, because is an action (in quantum mechanics it sits in the exponent, ). -
MCQWarm-up
For a periodic motion in one degree of freedom, the action variable is defined as- along the path
- divided by the period
- over one cycle
- at the turning point
Answer and solution
Answer: C
, the area enclosed by the orbit in phase space. It is a function of the energy alone, and its conjugate angle grows uniformly in time. (Some books divide by ; then the angle grows by per cycle.) -
NATWarm-up
Take the action variable as over one cycle. A harmonic oscillator of frequency Hz has energy 6 J. Its action is ______ J s.Answer and solution
Answer: 2 J s (±0.01)
The orbit is an ellipse with semi-axes and , of area . So J s, and . -
MCQWarm-up
In Hamilton-Jacobi theory the old momenta are obtained from Hamilton's principal function asAnswer and solution
Answer: D
is a type-2 generating function with the constant new momenta . The type-2 relations are and . -
MCQWarm-up
The length of a pendulum is changed very slowly compared with its period. Which quantity stays (nearly) constant?- The energy
- The ratio of energy to frequency
- The amplitude of swing
- The maximum speed
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The action is an adiabatic invariant: it is unchanged by slow variations of a parameter. For small oscillations . Energy, amplitude and speed all change as the length changes. -
MCQWarm-up
Hamilton's principal function has the dimension of- energy
- action (energy times time)
- momentum
- power
Answer and solution
Answer: B
is an energy, so is energy times time. Equivalently , and is an action. Along the motion equals the action integral , measured in J s like Planck's constant.Why people get this wrong: is an energy; itself carries one more power of time.
-
MCQStandard
For a free particle of mass in one dimension, the Hamilton-Jacobi equation isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
Replace by in and add . The equation is first order and nonlinear (the square of the derivative), unlike the Schrödinger equation, which is second order and linear. A complete solution is . -
NATStandard
A free particle of mass 2 kg and energy 9 J has characteristic function . The momentum is ______ kg m/s.Answer and solution
Answer: 6 kg m/s (±0.01)
kg m/s, constant as it must be for a free particle. -
MCQStandard
Take the action variable as over one cycle. Once the Hamiltonian is written as , the frequency of the motion (cycles per unit time) is- for every system
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Hamilton's equation for the angle: , a constant, so , and increases by 1 per cycle. is the period. equals only for the harmonic oscillator, where is linear in . because is cyclic.Why people get this wrong: You get the frequency without solving the motion: find , invert and differentiate.
-
NATStandard
Take the action variable as over one cycle. For a particle bouncing between the walls of a box, . If the action is doubled (same box), the energy is multiplied by ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 4
, so doubling multiplies by 4. (Here , since the momentum is constant in magnitude over the path .) -
MCQStandard
In action-angle variables for a periodic system, the Hamiltonian is . Which statement is correct?- is constant and grows linearly in time
- is constant and grows linearly in time
- Both and oscillate sinusoidally
- Both are constants
Answer and solution
Answer: B
since does not depend on ( is cyclic), so is constant. is then constant, so . -
MSQStandard
Which statements about a complete solution of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation are correct?- is a type-2 generating function with new momenta
- The new momenta are constants of the motion
- The quantities are constants of the motion
- must be a periodic function of each
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Since the new Hamiltonian is zero, both new momenta and new coordinates are constant. Solving for gives the motion. is generally not periodic: for a free particle grows with , and for a periodic motion gains each cycle. -
NATStandard
Take the action variable as over one cycle. An oscillator of mass 1 kg and angular frequency rad/s has energy 4 J. Its action is ______ J s.Answer and solution
Answer: 12.566 J s (±0.02)
The phase-space ellipse has area J s. Equivalently with Hz.Why people get this wrong: Using in place of gives , which is the action with the convention, not .
-
MCQStandard
Along the actual trajectory, the total time derivative of Hamilton's principal function equals- the Lagrangian
Answer and solution
Answer: D
( is constant). So constant: Hamilton's principal function is the action along the true path. -
MCQStandard
The Hamilton-Jacobi equation for a particle is fully separable in spherical polar coordinates when the potential has the form- only
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The kinetic part is . Multiplying through by isolates only if the part of carries the factor ; then multiplying by isolates only if its part carries . A central potential is the special case . -
NATStandard
Take the action variable as over one cycle. A particle of mass 1 kg moves freely between rigid walls 2 m apart with energy 2 J. Its action is ______ J s.Answer and solution
Answer: 8 J s (±0.01)
The speed is constant, kg m/s. Over one cycle the particle goes there and back, m, with constant: J s. The phase-space orbit is a rectangle of width and height . -
MCQStandard
Mathematically, the Hamilton-Jacobi equation is- a first-order nonlinear partial differential equation
- a second-order linear partial differential equation
- a set of first-order ordinary differential equations
- a first-order linear partial differential equation
Answer and solution
Answer: A
It involves only first derivatives of , but through (quadratic in the momenta for ), so it is nonlinear. Hamilton's equations are the ODEs; the HJ equation replaces them by one PDE, whose characteristics are the trajectories. -
MCQStandard
A charge (mass ) moves in fields with potentials and . Its Hamilton-Jacobi equation is- , since does no work
Answer and solution
Answer: D
. The Hamilton-Jacobi equation is , with the canonical momentum replaced by . So . The magnetic force does no work, but still enters the Hamiltonian through the canonical momentum.Why people get this wrong: Both signs matter: is the kinetic momentum, and the equation is .
-
NATStandard
A diatomic molecule rotates freely in a plane with moment of inertia kg m². Applying , its energy is ______ meV (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 2.31 meV (±0.02)
Free rotation: is constant, so gives . Then J meV for .Why people get this wrong: Using instead of gives a value times too large.
-
NATExam level
A ball bounces elastically on a floor in uniform gravity, (). Its action varies as . If the action is doubled, the energy is multiplied by ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 1.587 (±0.005)
, so and the factor is . Unlike the oscillator, the frequency falls as the energy rises: higher bounces take longer. -
MCQExam level
For the oscillator , take with . Setting (a constant) gives- , independent of
Answer and solution
Answer: B
. Then gives . The constant conjugate to the energy is a shift of the time origin. -
NATExam level
For the Kepler problem the Hamiltonian in action variables is . The number of distinct frequencies of the bound motion is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 1
depends on the three actions only through their sum, so : all three frequencies are equal. This complete degeneracy is why Kepler orbits close (one period for the radial and angular motion). The same degeneracy shows up as the -fold degeneracy of hydrogen. -
MCQExam level
The spring constant of an oscillator is increased slowly so that its angular frequency doubles. Its energy- stays the same
- halves
- quadruples
- doubles
Answer and solution
Answer: D
The adiabatic invariant is , so : the energy doubles. The work comes from whoever stiffens the spring. Quantum version: the oscillator stays in the same level , with energy .Why people get this wrong: Energy is not conserved, because the Hamiltonian depends on time; the action is the quantity that survives.
-
NATExam level
A simple pendulum swings with a small angular amplitude while its string is pulled up slowly through a hole, from length 1 m to 0.25 m. The ratio of final to initial angular amplitude is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 2.828 (±0.02)
Adiabatic invariant: = constant, with , so . For small swings , so and . Ratio . The swing grows as the string shortens. -
MCQExam level
A particle falls in uniform gravity, . Solving the Hamilton-Jacobi equation with and setting givesAnswer and solution
Answer: C
. Then . Squaring: , i.e. . is the top of the flight. -
MCQExam level
Writing in the Schrödinger equation and letting , the phase obeys- the diffusion equation
- Laplace's equation
- the continuity equation only
- the classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Substituting gives (plus terms from ). As the right side drops out and satisfies the HJ equation; the amplitude equation becomes the continuity equation. This is the WKB (semiclassical) limit: classical trajectories are the rays normal to the wavefronts = constant. -
NATExam level
Take the action variable as over one cycle. Apply the Bohr-Sommerfeld rule to a particle in a box of width (). The ratio is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 9
gives , which happens to match the exact quantum result. . (For hard walls the extra phase from the two reflections cancels the Maslov , so no half-integer appears.) -
MSQExam level
Take the action variable as over one cycle. For a one-dimensional periodic motion, which statements are correct?- has the dimensions of angular momentum (J s)
- The angle variable increases by exactly 1 in each cycle
- is an adiabatic invariant
- The frequency equals
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
has units of momentum times length, the same as . Over one cycle . Slow changes of parameters leave fixed. is the period, not the frequency. -
NATExam level
A particle of mass 1 kg moves in the potential with N. Its action is . Using , the period at J is ______ s.Answer and solution
Answer: 8 s (±0.01)
s. Check: from the particle decelerates under the constant force , stopping after s; a full cycle is four such pieces, 8 s.