Home / Courses / CSIR NET Physics / Practice / Heat capacity: Einstein and Debye

Heat capacity: Einstein and Debye

Solid state physics and devices · 87 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. NATWarm-up

    According to the law of Dulong and Petit, the molar heat capacity of a monatomic solid at high temperature is ______ J mol−1 K−1 (to two decimal places). Use R=8.314 J mol−1 K−1.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 24.94 J/(mol K) (±0.03)

    Each atom is a 3D oscillator with 3×(12kBT+12kBT)=3kBT of energy by equipartition. Per mole U=3RT and C=3R=24.94 J mol−1 K−1.

    Why people get this wrong: Counting only kinetic energy gives 32R, the monatomic gas value.

  2. MCQWarm-up

    At very low temperatures the lattice heat capacity of a three-dimensional insulating crystal varies as
    1. T
    2. T3
    3. e−θ/T
    4. T3/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Only long-wavelength acoustic phonons, with ℏω≲kBT, are excited. Their number in 3D grows as T3 (a sphere of radius k∝T in k-space), each holding about kBT, so U∝T4 and C∝T3: the Debye law.

    Why people get this wrong: e−θ/T is the Einstein model's prediction, which falls too fast; T is the electronic term in metals; T3/2 belongs to ferromagnetic magnons.

  3. MCQWarm-up

    The Einstein model of a solid assumes that
    1. the crystal is an elastic continuum with sound waves up to a cutoff frequency
    2. the electrons carry most of the heat
    3. every atom vibrates independently as a quantum oscillator with the same frequency
    4. atoms obey classical equipartition at all temperatures
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Einstein (1907) treated the 3N vibrational degrees of freedom as identical quantum oscillators of one frequency ωE. This explained why C falls below 3R at low T, the first success of quantum theory in solids. The continuum with a cutoff is Debye's later model.

    Why people get this wrong: Classical equipartition is exactly what Einstein replaced.

  4. MCQWarm-up

    The Debye temperature θD is defined by
    1. kBθD=ℏωD, with ωD the Debye cutoff frequency
    2. the melting point of the crystal
    3. the temperature at which C=12⋅3R
    4. kBθD=EF
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    θD=ℏωD/kB converts the highest phonon frequency of the Debye model into a temperature. Well above θD all modes are excited (classical limit, 3R); well below it only a few are (T3).

    Why people get this wrong: EF/kB is the Fermi temperature, about a hundred times larger in metals.

  5. MCQWarm-up

    Classical equipartition fails for lattice vibrations at low temperature because
    1. the atoms stop moving entirely at low T
    2. modes with ℏω≫kBT are rarely excited, since the energy comes in quanta
    3. the crystal expands
    4. the number of modes grows as T falls
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    A quantum oscillator has mean thermal energy ℏω/(eℏω/kBT−1), which is kBT when ℏω≪kBT but exponentially small when ℏω≫kBT. High-frequency modes "freeze out" and no longer store heat.

    Why people get this wrong: Atoms keep their zero-point motion even at T=0; it just does not change with T, so it adds nothing to C.

  6. MCQWarm-up

    At high temperature, the lattice heat capacity of NaCl per mole of formula units, in J mol−1 K−1, is closest to (R=8.314 J mol−1 K−1)
    1. 24.9
    2. 74.8
    3. 49.9
    4. 12.5
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    One mole of NaCl contains 2NA ions, each contributing 3kB: C=2×3R=6R=49.9 J mol−1 K−1.

    Why people get this wrong: Using 3R per mole of formula units forgets that each formula unit has two atoms.

  7. MCQWarm-up

    At room temperature, which of these metals has the largest specific heat capacity per kilogram?
    1. Lead
    2. Copper
    3. Aluminium
    4. Lithium
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Near the Dulong-Petit limit every mole of atoms needs about 3R=25 J/K, whatever the element. Per kilogram that is 3R/M, largest for the lightest atoms: lithium (M=6.9 g/mol) gives about 3.6 kJ kg−1 K−1, against 0.12 for lead. (Lithium's Debye temperature, about 340 K, keeps it a little below 3R, but it still wins easily.)

    Why people get this wrong: The law fixes the heat capacity per mole of atoms, not per kilogram.

  8. MCQStandard

    In the Einstein model, the heat capacity at T=θE, as a fraction of the Dulong-Petit value 3R, is
    1. 0.500
    2. 0.921
    3. 0.632
    4. 1.000
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    C/3R=x2ex(ex−1)2 with x=θE/T=1: 2.7183(1.7183)2=2.71832.9525=0.921. Even at T=θE the solid is within 8% of the classical value.

    Why people get this wrong: Expecting one half at the characteristic temperature; that happens near T≈0.34θE.

  9. NATStandard

    A monatomic solid has θD=300 K. Using the Debye T3 law C=12π45R(T/θD)3, its molar heat capacity at 10 K is ______ J mol−1 K−1 (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.072 J/(mol K) (±0.001)

    12π45R=233.8×8.314=1944 J mol−1 K−1. (10/300)3=3.70×10−5. C=1944×3.70×10−5=0.072 J mol−1 K−1, about 0.3% of 3R.

    Why people get this wrong: Using 3R(T/θD)3 leaves out the large factor 4π4/5=77.9.

  10. MCQStandard

    At temperatures well below θE, the Einstein model predicts a heat capacity that
    1. falls exponentially, as (θE/T)2e−θE/T, faster than experiment
    2. falls as T3, in agreement with experiment
    3. stays at 3R
    4. rises as T falls
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    For x=θE/T≫1, x2ex/(ex−1)2≈x2e−x. A single frequency means there are no low-energy modes, so heat capacity dies exponentially. Real crystals have acoustic phonons down to zero frequency, which give the slower T3 fall.

    Why people get this wrong: The T3 law needs a spectrum reaching down to ω=0, which Einstein's model lacks.

  11. MCQStandard

    In the Debye model the cutoff frequency ωD is chosen so that
    1. ℏωD=kBT at room temperature
    2. the total number of vibrational modes equals 3N for N atoms
    3. the phonon wavelength equals the crystal size
    4. ωD equals the Einstein frequency
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Debye uses the continuum density of states g(ω)=3Vω22π2v3 (three polarisations) and cuts it off where the count reaches 3N: ∫0ωDgdω=3N, giving ωD=v(6π2N/V)1/3. This keeps the right high-temperature limit 3NkB.

    Why people get this wrong: The cutoff is a property of the crystal, not of the temperature.

  12. MCQStandard

    Well below its Debye temperature, an insulating crystal is warmed from 10 K to 20 K. By what factor is its lattice heat capacity multiplied?
    1. 2
    2. 4
    3. 16
    4. 8
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    C∝T3, so doubling T multiplies C by 23=8.

    Why people get this wrong: Using the T4 of the energy gives 16.

  13. MSQStandard

    Which statements about the Debye model are correct?
    1. At high temperature it gives C=3NkB.
    2. At low temperature it gives C∝T3.
    3. It uses a phonon density of states g(ω)∝ω2 up to a cutoff.
    4. Soft solids of heavy atoms have high Debye temperatures.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    With g∝ω2 up to ωD and 3N modes, the high-T limit is equipartition and the low-T limit is T3. θD∝v∝stiffness/density: soft, heavy solids (Pb, 105 K) have low θD; stiff, light ones (diamond, 2230 K) have high θD.

    Why people get this wrong: Heavy and soft means slow sound, hence low ωD and low θD.

  14. NATStandard

    A solid has Einstein temperature θE=240 K. Its Einstein frequency νE is ______ THz (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 5 THz (±0.01)

    hνE=kBθE, so νE=1.381×10−23×2406.626×10−34=5.00×1012 Hz =5.00 THz. (Rule of thumb: 1 THz ↔ 48 K.)

    Why people get this wrong: Using ℏ instead of h gives the angular frequency ωE, 2π times larger.

  15. MCQStandard

    For a metal at a few kelvin, C=γT+βT3. A graph that gives γ and β directly as a straight line is
    1. C against T
    2. C against T3
    3. ln⁡C against ln⁡T
    4. C/T against T2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Divide by T: C/T=γ+βT2. Against T2 this is a line with intercept γ (electrons) and slope β (phonons, from which θD follows).

    Why people get this wrong: A log-log plot is curved here because two powers compete.

  16. NATStandard

    Diamond has θD≈2230 K. Using the Debye T3 law, its molar heat capacity at 50 K is ______ J mol−1 K−1 (to four decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.0219 J/(mol K) (±0.0003)

    (50/2230)3=(0.02242)3=1.127×10−5. C=1944×1.127×10−5=0.0219 J mol−1 K−1. Diamond is "cold" even at room temperature: its heat capacity there is only about a quarter of 3R, the anomaly Einstein first explained.

    Why people get this wrong: Applying the T3 law at room temperature for diamond: it holds only for T≲θD/50.

  17. MCQStandard

    Which of these solids has the highest Debye temperature?
    1. lead
    2. sodium
    3. copper
    4. diamond
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Approximate values: Pb 105 K, Na 158 K, Cu 343 K, diamond 2230 K. Light atoms held by stiff covalent bonds give fast sound and a high cutoff frequency.

    Why people get this wrong: Hardness and melting point are related but not the same; what matters is v∝stiffness/mass.

  18. MSQStandard

    Which statements about the heat capacity of solids as T→0 are correct?
    1. It must vanish, as the third law of thermodynamics requires.
    2. It vanishes because oscillator energies are quantised.
    3. Classical equipartition predicts the same behaviour at low temperature.
    4. In metals the electronic part falls more slowly (linearly) than the lattice part.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    The entropy S=∫C/TdT must stay finite as T→0, so C→0. Quantisation makes the excitation of each mode exponentially rare when ℏω≫kBT. Classical physics predicts 3R at all temperatures (statement 3 false). Electrons give γT, which beats βT3 at the lowest temperatures.

    Why people get this wrong: Dulong-Petit is a classical result and has no temperature dependence at all.

  19. NATStandard

    In the Einstein model, the molar heat capacity of a monatomic solid at T=2θE is ______ J mol−1 K−1 (to two decimal places). Use R=8.314 J mol−1 K−1.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 24.43 J/(mol K) (±0.03)

    x=θE/T=0.5: x2ex(ex−1)2=0.25×1.6487(0.6487)2=0.41220.4208=0.9794. C=24.94×0.9794=24.43 J mol−1 K−1. (The high-T expansion 1−x2/12=0.979 agrees.)

    Why people get this wrong: Using x=T/θE=2 instead of θE/T.

  20. MSQStandard

    Which statements comparing the Einstein and Debye models are correct?
    1. Both give 3R per mole of atoms at high temperature.
    2. Both use quantised oscillators with Bose-Einstein occupation.
    3. Both predict the same low-temperature behaviour.
    4. Debye includes a spread of frequencies reaching down to zero; Einstein uses one frequency.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    Each model treats 3N quantum oscillators with mean energy ℏω/(eℏω/kBT−1), so both reach equipartition at high T. They differ in the spectrum: Einstein one frequency (exponential freeze-out), Debye a continuum g∝ω2 from zero up to ωD (T3 law). So their low-T behaviour is very different.

    Why people get this wrong: Agreement at high T says nothing about low T, where the spectrum near ω=0 decides everything.

  21. MSQStandard

    Low-temperature heat capacity data of a metal are plotted as C/T against T2 and fall on a straight line. Which statements are correct?
    1. The intercept on the C/T axis is the electronic coefficient γ.
    2. The slope gives β, from which θD follows.
    3. A larger density of states at the Fermi level gives a larger intercept.
    4. The slope is proportional to θD3.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    C/T=γ+βT2. The intercept is γ=π23kB2g(EF), so it grows with the density of states at EF (heavy-fermion metals have huge γ). The slope is β=12π45R/θD3, inversely proportional to θD3: stiff solids have small slopes.

    Why people get this wrong: The slope goes as 1/θD3, not θD3.

  22. NATStandard

    Using the Dulong-Petit law, the specific heat capacity of copper (M=63.55 g/mol) at high temperature is ______ J kg−1 K−1 (R=8.314 J mol−1 K−1).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 392.5 (±4)

    Molar heat capacity 3R=24.94 J mol−1 K−1. One kilogram is 1/0.06355=15.74 mol, so c=24.94×15.74=392.5 J kg−1 K−1. The measured value at room temperature, 385, is slightly lower because T=300 K is not far above copper's Debye temperature (343 K).

    Why people get this wrong: Dividing by 63.55 instead of 0.06355 (grams instead of kilograms) gives 0.39.

  23. NATStandard

    A 0.20 kg aluminium block (c=900 J kg−1 K−1) at 100∘C is dropped into 0.50 kg of water (c=4186 J kg−1 K−1) at 20∘C in an insulated container of negligible heat capacity. The final temperature is ______ ∘C (one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 26.3 (±0.1)

    Heat lost by the block equals heat gained by the water: 0.20×900(100−T)=0.50×4186(T−20), i.e. 180(100−T)=2093(T−20). So T=18000+41860180+2093=598602273=26.3∘C. The water's heat capacity is over eleven times the block's, so the result sits close to 20∘C.

    Why people get this wrong: Averaging the two temperatures by mass ignores the very different specific heats.

  24. NATExam level

    A monatomic solid has 6.0×1028 atoms per m3 and an average sound speed of 3500 m/s. Its Debye temperature is ______ K (to the nearest kelvin).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 408 K (±2)

    kD=(6π2n)1/3=(3.553×1030)1/3=1.526×1010 m−1. ωD=vkD=5.34×1013 rad/s. θD=ℏωD/kB=1.0546×10−34×5.34×1013/1.381×10−23=408 K.

    Why people get this wrong: Using (3π2n)1/3, the free-electron kF formula with spin, gives too small a value.

  25. NATExam level

    Low-temperature data for a monatomic metal give C/T=γ+βT2 with β=0.0484 mJ mol−1 K−4. Using β=12π45R/θD3, the Debye temperature is ______ K (to the nearest kelvin).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 342 K (±1)

    θD3=19444.84×10−5=4.016×107 K3, so θD=342 K (copper).

    Why people get this wrong: Forgetting that β was given in mJ: keep the units the same as 1944 J mol−1 K−1.

  26. NATExam level

    For copper, γ=0.695 mJ mol−1 K−2 and β=0.0484 mJ mol−1 K−4. The temperature at which the electronic and lattice heat capacities are equal is ______ K (to two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3.79 K (±0.02)

    γT=βT3⇒T=γ/β=14.36=3.79 K. Below this the electrons dominate; above it the phonons.

    Why people get this wrong: Setting γ=βT3 (dropping a T) gives T=2.43 K.

  27. MCQExam level

    A crystal in which atoms vibrate only within a two-dimensional sheet (in-plane acoustic modes with linear dispersion) has, at low temperature, a lattice heat capacity proportional to
    1. T
    2. T3/2
    3. T2
    4. T3
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    In d dimensions with ω=vk, the number of modes below ω goes as ωd, so g(ω)∝ωd−1. Then U∝∫ωd−1ℏω/(eℏω/kBT−1)dω∝Td+1 and C∝Td: T2 in 2D. (Out-of-plane flexural modes of real graphene have ω∝k2 and behave differently.)

    Why people get this wrong: Applying the 3D T3 law without thinking about the dimension.

  28. NATExam level

    One mole of a monatomic solid with θD=200 K is heated from 2.0 K to 6.0 K. Using the T3 law, the heat required is ______ J (to four decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.0778 J (±0.0005)

    C=aT3 with a=1944/2003=2.430×10−4 J mol−1 K−4. Q=∫26aT3dT=a4(64−24)=6.075×10−5×1280=0.0778 J.

    Why people get this wrong: Multiplying C at one temperature by ΔT: C changes 27-fold over this range.

  29. NATExam level

    In the Debye model, the zero-point vibrational energy of one mole of a monatomic solid is 98RθD. For θD=300 K this is ______ J/mol (to the nearest whole number).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2806 J/mol (±3)

    E0=∑12ℏω=12∫0ωDg(ω)ℏωdω with g=9Nω2/ωD3: E0=98NℏωD=98NkBθD. Per mole: 1.125×8.314×300=2806 J/mol. It does not depend on T, so it adds nothing to C, but it does reduce the cohesive energy.

    Why people get this wrong: Using 32RθD (as if every mode had the maximum frequency).

  30. MCQExam level

    Two models of the same solid are fitted to agree at high temperature, with θE≈θD. At T=0.05θD,
    1. the Debye model gives a much larger heat capacity than the Einstein model
    2. the Einstein model gives a much larger heat capacity
    3. both give 3R
    4. both give exactly zero
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    At T=0.05θ: Debye C/3R≈4π45(0.05)3=9.7×10−3. Einstein: x=20, x2e−x=400×2.1×10−9=8×10−7. The Debye value is about ten thousand times larger, because low-frequency acoustic modes are still active.

    Why people get this wrong: Assuming similar characteristic temperatures mean similar low-T behaviour.

← All topics · Timed mock test →