Home / Courses / CSIR NET Physics / Practice / The Ising model and Landau theory (NET)

The Ising model and Landau theory (NET)

Statistical physics · 84 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

New to this topic? Read the lesson first: The Ising model and Landau theory.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. NATWarm-up

    A ferromagnetic Ising model H=−J∑⟨ij⟩sisj (J>0) lives on a square lattice of N sites with periodic boundaries. Its ground-state energy per spin is ______ J.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: -2

    Each site has z=4 neighbours, so there are zN/2=2N bonds. All spins aligned make every bond contribute −J: E0=−2NJ, i.e. −2J per spin. The ground state is twofold degenerate (all up or all down).

    Why people get this wrong: Counting z=4 bonds per spin double counts each bond.

  2. MCQWarm-up

    In zero field, which Ising systems with short-range ferromagnetic coupling show a spontaneous magnetisation at some T>0?
    1. Only the one-dimensional chain
    2. The square lattice (2D) and the cubic lattice (3D), but not the 1D chain
    3. All of them, in every dimension
    4. None: spontaneous magnetisation needs a field
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    In 1D a single domain wall costs only 2J but gains entropy kln⁡N, so order is destroyed at any T>0. In 2D a wall around a domain costs energy proportional to its length, which beats the entropy at low T (Peierls): there is a transition, at kTc=2.269J on the square lattice (Onsager). The lower critical dimension of the Ising model is 1.
  3. NATWarm-up

    Mean-field theory predicts kTc=zJ for the Ising model. For a face-centred cubic lattice, kTc/J is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 12

    Each spin feels the average field zJ⟨s⟩ of its z neighbours; m=tanh⁡(zJm/kT) has a nonzero solution for kT<zJ. The fcc lattice has z=12, so kTc=12J in mean field (the true value is about 9.8J).
  4. MCQWarm-up

    Landau's free energy for an Ising-like transition, F=F0+a(T−Tc)m2+bm4−hm, contains no m3 term because
    1. the free energy must be symmetric under m→−m when h=0
    2. cubic terms are always small
    3. it would make F unbounded
    4. Landau theory only works in 4 dimensions
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The Ising Hamiltonian is invariant under flipping all spins when h=0, so F(m)=F(−m) and only even powers appear. Where symmetry allows a cubic term (e.g. the nematic-isotropic or three-state Potts transition), the transition becomes first order.
  5. MCQWarm-up

    With ni=(1+si)/2 (ni=0 or 1), the Ising model maps onto a lattice gas. The ferromagnetic coupling and the magnetic field correspond to
    1. repulsion between atoms; temperature
    2. attraction between neighbouring atoms; chemical potential
    3. hard-core exclusion only; pressure
    4. attraction; volume
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Substituting s=2n−1 into −J∑sisj−h∑si gives −4J∑ninj−(2h−2zJ)∑ni+ const. A ferromagnet (J>0) is a gas with nearest-neighbour attraction 4J, and the field plays the role of the chemical potential. The Ising critical point is a liquid-gas critical point, which is why they share exponents.
  6. NATWarm-up

    How many microstates does an Ising model of 3×3 spins have?
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 512

    Each of the 9 spins is ±1 independently: 29=512 configurations. For 10×10 there are 2100≈1030, which is why Monte Carlo sampling is needed instead of summing every state.
  7. MCQWarm-up

    An Ising ferromagnet H=−J∑⟨ij⟩sisj (J>0, each pair of neighbours counted once) has N spins on a square lattice with periodic boundaries. Its ground-state energy is
    1. −NJ
    2. −2NJ
    3. −4NJ
    4. −NJ/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    In the ground state all spins are parallel, so every bond contributes −J. Each spin has z=4 neighbours, and each bond is shared by two spins, so there are Nz/2=2N bonds. E0=−2NJ.

    Why people get this wrong: −4NJ counts each bond twice, once from each end.

  8. NATStandard

    Two Ising spins interact through H=−Js1s2. At kT=J, the probability that they are parallel is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.881 (±0.001)

    Four states: two parallel (energy −J) and two antiparallel (+J). Z=2eK+2e−K with K=J/kT=1. P∥=2e2e+2e−1=11+e−2=0.881. Equivalently ⟨s1s2⟩=tanh⁡K=0.762=2P∥−1.
  9. NATStandard

    In the zero-field Ising chain, ⟨sisi+r⟩=(tanh⁡K)r with K=J/kT. At K=0.50, ⟨s0s3⟩ is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.099 (±0.001)

    With bond variables τi=sisi+1 (independent in zero field, each with mean tanh⁡K), s0s3=τ0τ1τ2, so the correlation is tanh3⁡K=0.46213=0.0987. It decays exponentially at any T>0: no long-range order.
  10. MCQStandard

    Three Ising spins on a triangle have antiferromagnetic coupling H=J(s1s2+s2s3+s3s1), J>0. The ground-state energy and its degeneracy are
    1. −3J, 2 states
    2. −J, 2 states
    3. −3J, 6 states
    4. −J, 6 states
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Not all three bonds can be antiparallel (frustration). The best is two antiparallel and one parallel: E=−J−J+J=−J. Only all-equal states (2 of 8) have E=+3J, so the other 6 states all have E=−J. Frustration leaves a large ground-state degeneracy; on the triangular lattice it gives residual entropy 0.323k per spin.
  11. NATStandard

    In a Metropolis simulation of the square-lattice Ising model at kT=2.0J, a proposed flip raises the energy by 8J. The probability that it is accepted is ______ (to four decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.0183 (±0.0002)

    Metropolis accepts with probability min⁡(1,e−ΔE/kT). Here e−8J/2J=e−4=0.0183. Flipping a spin si changes the energy by ΔE=2Jsi∑jsj∈{−8J,−4J,0,4J,8J}; 8J is a spin aligned with all four neighbours.
  12. MCQStandard

    Why does the Metropolis rule Pacc=min⁡(1,e−ΔE/kT) sample the Boltzmann distribution?
    1. It satisfies detailed balance with respect to e−E/kT, and the moves are ergodic
    2. It always lowers the energy
    3. It visits every state equally often
    4. It is exact only at T=0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    For two states with E2>E1: P(1→2)/P(2→1)=e−(E2−E1)/kT/1, which equals p2/p1 for Boltzmann weights. Detailed balance makes the Boltzmann distribution stationary, and ergodicity (any state reachable) makes it the unique limit.
  13. NATStandard

    The Bethe (cluster) approximation gives Kc=12ln⁡zz−2. For the square lattice (z=4), the predicted kTc/J is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2.885 (±0.002)

    Kc=12ln⁡2=0.3466, so kTc/J=1/Kc=2.885. Compared with mean field (4) and the exact Onsager value (2.269), Bethe is better because it treats one spin and its neighbours exactly. It still gives mean-field exponents.
  14. MSQStandard

    Which statements about mean-field theory of the Ising model are correct?
    1. It always overestimates Tc, because it neglects fluctuations
    2. It wrongly predicts a transition for the 1D chain (at kTc=2J)
    3. It becomes exact for long-range interactions or above four dimensions
    4. It gives the exact 2D exponent β=1/8
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Fluctuations disorder the system, so ignoring them raises Tc; mean field even predicts order in 1D. For infinite-range coupling or d>4 (the upper critical dimension) mean-field exponents are exact. Mean field gives β=1/2; 1/8 is Onsager-Yang.
  15. NATStandard

    In a 1D Ising chain of N spins, one domain wall costs 2J and can sit in about N places. With J/kT=5, the free energy of creating a wall becomes negative for N larger than about ______ (to the nearest whole number).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 22026 (±2)

    ΔF=2J−kTln⁡N<0 when N>e2J/kT=e10=22026. A long enough chain always breaks into domains: no order at T>0. In 2D a domain wall of length L costs 2JL while its entropy also grows only ∝L, so order survives at low T.
  16. MCQStandard

    The critical exponents of the 2D Ising model are
    1. β=1/2, γ=1, ν=1/2, α=0 (jump)
    2. β=0.326, γ=1.237, ν=0.630
    3. β=1/8, γ=7/4, ν=1, α=0 (logarithmic)
    4. β=1/4, γ=1, ν=1/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Onsager (1944) and Yang (1952): C∼ln⁡|t|, m∼(−t)1/8, χ∼|t|−7/4, ξ∼|t|−1, η=1/4, δ=15. The first option is mean field, the second 3D Ising, the last the tricritical mean-field values.
  17. NATStandard

    In Landau theory F=a(T−Tc)m2+bm4−hm. The ratio of the susceptibility above Tc to that below Tc, at equal |T−Tc|, is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2

    Above: m0=0 and 2a(T−Tc)m=h, so χ+=12a(T−Tc). Below: m02=a(Tc−T)2b and F′′=−2a(Tc−T)+12bm02=4a(Tc−T), so χ−=14a(Tc−T). Ratio χ+/χ−=2, a universal mean-field amplitude ratio (about 4.4 in 3D Ising, 37.7 in 2D).
  18. MCQStandard

    For the liquid-gas transition, viewed as a lattice gas (Ising) transition, the natural order parameter is
    1. the pressure
    2. the temperature
    3. the density difference ρliquid−ρgas
    4. the latent heat
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    In lattice-gas language the magnetisation m=2n−1 maps to the density. Along the coexistence curve ρl−ρg∝(Tc−T)β with β≈0.326, the 3D Ising value.
  19. NATStandard

    In the fully aligned ground state of the simple cubic Ising ferromagnet (z=6, coupling J, no field), flipping one spin raises the energy by ______ J.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 12

    The flipped spin now disagrees with all 6 neighbours. Each of those bonds goes from −J to +J, a change of 2J, so the cost is 6×2J=12J. At low temperature such flips are suppressed by e−12J/kT, which is why the magnetisation stays very close to saturation there.

    Why people get this wrong: Each broken bond costs 2J (from −J to +J), not J.

  20. MCQStandard

    A 10×10 square lattice with periodic boundaries has how many nearest-neighbour bonds?
    1. 100
    2. 400
    3. 50
    4. 200
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Each of the 100 sites has 4 neighbours, and each bond joins two sites: 100×4/2=200. Equivalently, one horizontal and one vertical bond per site.

    Why people get this wrong: 400 counts every bond twice.

  21. NATExam level

    Four Ising spins form a ring with H=−J(s1s2+s2s3+s3s4+s4s1). Its partition function is Z=(2cosh⁡K)4+(2sinh⁡K)4. At K=J/kT=1, the probability of finding all four spins aligned is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.901 (±0.001)

    Transfer matrix: Z=TrT4=λ+4+λ−4 with λ±=2cosh⁡K,2sinh⁡K: Z=3.08624+2.35044=90.72+30.52=121.2. (Check by counting: 2 states at E=−4J, 12 at 0, 2 at +4J: 2e4+12+2e−4=121.2.) Aligned: 2e4/Z=109.2/121.2=0.901.
  22. MCQExam level

    For an open Ising chain of N spins (free ends) in zero field, the partition function is
    1. (2cosh⁡K)N
    2. 2(2cosh⁡K)N−1
    3. (2cosh⁡K)N+(2sinh⁡K)N
    4. 2NcoshN⁡K
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Change variables to the first spin and the N−1 independent bond variables τi=sisi+1: Z=2∏i=1N−1(eK+e−K)=2(2cosh⁡K)N−1. The ring gives (2cosh⁡K)N+(2sinh⁡K)N; both have the same free energy per spin as N→∞.
  23. NATExam level

    The Onsager-Yang spontaneous magnetisation of the square-lattice Ising model is m=[1−sinh−4⁡(2J/kT)]1/8. At kT=2.0J, m is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.911 (±0.002)

    sinh⁡(2J/kT)=sinh⁡1=1.1752, so sinh4⁡=1.9074 and 1−1/1.9074=0.4757. Then m=0.47571/8=0.911. Even at 0.88Tc the magnetisation is above 0.9: with β=1/8 it rises almost vertically below Tc.
  24. NATExam level

    For the simple cubic Ising model, the exact (numerical) critical temperature is kTc=4.512J. What fraction is this of the mean-field prediction? Answer to three decimal places.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.752 (±0.001)

    Mean field: kTc=zJ=6J. Ratio 4.512/6=0.752. For the square lattice the ratio is 2.269/4=0.567, and for the chain 0/2=0: fluctuations matter more in lower dimensions.
  25. MSQExam level

    Kramers-Wannier duality maps the square-lattice Ising model at coupling K to one at K∗ with sinh⁡2Ksinh⁡2K∗=1. Which statements follow?
    1. High-temperature and low-temperature expansions are related
    2. If there is a single transition, it must be at the self-dual point sinh⁡2Kc=1
    3. The self-dual point gives kTc/J=2/ln⁡(1+2)
    4. Duality fixes the exponent β=1/8
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Duality exchanges small K (high T) and large K∗ (low T): the high-temperature (bond) expansion of one equals the low-temperature (domain wall) expansion of the other. A unique singularity must sit at K=K∗: sinh⁡2Kc=1, Kc=12ln⁡(1+2)=0.4407, kTc=2.269J. Exponents need the full solution.
  26. NATExam level

    For the Ising chain in a field, m=sinh⁡(βh)sinh2⁡(βh)+e−4K. At K=1 and βh=0.10, m is ______ (to three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.595 (±0.002)

    sinh⁡0.1=0.10017, sinh2⁡=0.010033, e−4=0.018316. m=0.10017/0.028349=0.10017/0.16837=0.595. A weak field gives a large magnetisation because neighbours are strongly correlated (the chain is close to its T=0 critical point), but m→0 as h→0.
  27. MCQExam level

    At T=Tc in Landau theory, F=bm4−hm. The critical isotherm is
    1. m∝h
    2. m∝h1/2
    3. m∝h1/3, so δ=3
    4. m∝h1/15
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    ∂F/∂m=4bm3−h=0, so m=(h/4b)1/3: δ=3. (The 2D Ising value is 15, 3D about 4.8.)
  28. NATExam level

    A system has F=a(T−T0)m2−cm3+bm4 with a=2, c=4, b=1 and T0=50 (consistent units). The first-order transition happens at T1 = ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 52 (±0.01)

    At T1 the ordered minimum has the same free energy as m=0: F=m2[A−cm+bm2] with A=a(T−T0) must have a double root, so c2=4Ab. A=c2/4b=16/4=4, so T1−T0=4/a=2 and T1=52. The order parameter jumps from 0 to m∗=c/2b=2.

    Why people get this wrong: The transition is above T0: the cubic term lets order appear before the m2 coefficient changes sign.

  29. MCQExam level

    Adding a gradient term, F=∫[c(∇m)2+a(T−Tc)m2+bm4]ddr, the correlation length above Tc is ξ+=c/a(T−Tc). Below Tc, at the same |T−Tc|, the correlation length is
    1. ξ+
    2. 2ξ+
    3. infinite
    4. ξ+/2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Fluctuations δm around the minimum cost c(∇δm)2+12F′′δm2. Above: F′′/2=a(T−Tc). Below: F′′/2=2a(Tc−T) (twice as stiff, as in the susceptibility). So ξ−=c/2a|T−Tc|=ξ+/2. Both give ν=1/2.
  30. NATExam level

    An antiferromagnet obeys χ=C/(T+θ) above its Néel point. Measurements give χ=2.0×10−3 at 300 K and 1.6×10−3 at 400 K. The value of θ is ______ K.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 100 (±0.5)

    χ(T+θ)=C at both temperatures: 2.0×10−3(300+θ)=1.6×10−3(400+θ), so 0.6+0.002θ=0.64+0.0016θ and θ=0.04/0.0004=100 K. In two-sublattice mean field with only intersublattice coupling, TN=θ=100 K.

    Why people get this wrong: For a ferromagnet the sign is T−θ; for an antiferromagnet T+θ.

← All topics · Timed mock test →