Lattice vibrations and phonons
Solid state physics and devices · 88 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQWarm-up
For a chain of atoms of mass and spacing joined by springs of constant (nearest neighbours only), the dispersion relation isAnswer and solution
Answer: B
Newton for atom : . With : . So , linear only for small .Why people get this wrong: The linear form is just the long-wavelength limit; the cosine form would give a maximum frequency at .
-
MCQWarm-up
At the edge of the first Brillouin zone (), the group velocity of a wave on a monatomic chain is- equal to the speed of sound
- infinite
- zero
- twice the speed of sound
Answer and solution
Answer: C
, which vanishes at . Neighbouring atoms move in exact opposition: a standing wave, the Bragg-reflected combination of waves travelling both ways, which carries no energy.Why people get this wrong: The phase velocity is not zero there; only the group velocity is.
-
MCQWarm-up
A 3D crystal has two atoms in each primitive cell. How many phonon branches does it have?- 2
- 3
- 6
- 12
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Each atom can move in 3 directions, so a cell has degrees of freedom and there are 6 branches: 3 acoustic (one longitudinal, two transverse) and optical.Why people get this wrong: Counting only the atoms (2) or only the directions (3).
-
MCQWarm-up
A phonon is- a quantum of energy in one normal mode of lattice vibration
- an electron bound to a vibrating ion
- a photon trapped inside a crystal
- the smallest piece of a crystal that can vibrate
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Each normal mode of a harmonic lattice is an independent oscillator with energies . Raising by one adds one phonon of that mode. Phonons are bosons: any number can occupy a mode.Why people get this wrong: A phonon belongs to the whole crystal (a collective mode), not to one atom.
-
NATWarm-up
A monatomic chain has atoms of mass kg joined by springs of N/m. Its highest vibration angular frequency is ______ rad/s (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 6.32 10¹³ rad/s (±0.01)
rad/s, reached at the zone boundary.Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the factor 2 gives , the frequency of one mass on one spring.
-
MCQWarm-up
In thermal equilibrium, the mean number of phonons in a mode of frequency is given by- Fermi-Dirac statistics with
- Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics
- Bose-Einstein statistics with
- Bose-Einstein statistics with fixed by the number of atoms
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Phonons are bosons whose number is not conserved (the lattice creates and destroys them freely), so the chemical potential is zero: . This is exactly the mean excitation of a quantum oscillator.Why people get this wrong: Phonon number is not tied to the number of atoms; only the number of modes is.
-
MCQWarm-up
An optical phonon has frequency THz. With eV s, its energy is about- meV
- meV
- meV
- meV
Answer and solution
Answer: C
eV meV, comparable to at about K. A handy rule: THz meV.Why people get this wrong: meV is ; with a frequency in hertz the energy is (or ).
-
NATStandard
A chain of atoms of mass 40 u with spacing Å and spring constant N/m carries long-wavelength sound at a speed of ______ m/s (to the nearest 10 m/s). Use u kg.Answer and solution
Answer: 4510 m/s (±10)
For small , , so . kg, s, m/s.Why people get this wrong: Using the mass in u without converting to kg.
-
MCQStandard
In the long-wavelength limit (), acoustic phonons of a monatomic chain- have a frequency independent of
- have , with equal phase and group velocities (no dispersion)
- have , like free particles
- have zero group velocity
Answer and solution
Answer: B
gives . Phase and group velocity both equal : the chain behaves as a continuous elastic string, which is why ordinary sound does not disperse.Why people get this wrong: is the dispersion of magnons in a ferromagnet (and of free particles), not of phonons.
-
MCQStandard
In a diatomic chain (masses and ), the optical mode at has- both atoms moving together with equal amplitudes
- only the heavier atoms moving
- zero frequency
- neighbouring atoms moving in opposite directions with amplitudes in the ratio , so the centre of mass stays still
Answer and solution
Answer: D
At every cell does the same thing, so the motion is just the two atoms of a cell oscillating against each other on their springs: , i.e. , with . In an ionic crystal this sets up an oscillating dipole that couples to infrared light, hence "optical".Why people get this wrong: Moving together with equal amplitudes is the acoustic mode at (a rigid translation, ).
-
NATStandard
A diatomic chain has masses kg and kg joined alternately by identical springs of N/m. The optical-branch frequency at is ______ rad/s (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 7.75 10¹³ rad/s (±0.01)
s, so rad/s.Why people get this wrong: Using instead of : each atom has two springs.
-
MSQStandard
For a diatomic chain with masses and equal springs , which statements are correct?- At the zone boundary the acoustic frequency is .
- At the zone boundary the optical frequency is .
- The gap between the branches grows as the two masses get closer.
- A monatomic chain also has an optical branch.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B
At , and the roots become (only the heavy atoms move) and (only the light ones). The gap shrinks to zero as ; then the chain is monatomic with half the period, and its single branch, folded back, is all that remains. A one-atom basis has no optical branch.Why people get this wrong: In the boundary modes one kind of atom stays at rest: the heavy atoms set the acoustic, the light the optical frequency.
-
NATStandard
Cubic perovskite SrTiO has five atoms in its primitive cell. The number of optical phonon branches is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 12
branches in all. Three are acoustic (frequency as : the whole crystal translating). The other are optical.Why people get this wrong: Answering 15 (all branches) or 10 ().
-
MCQStandard
A phonon of wave vector in a crystal- carries crystal momentum , defined only up to
- carries real momentum that moves the crystal's centre of mass
- has no momentum of any kind
- has momentum
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Atom displacements are unchanged by , so is fixed only modulo . behaves like a momentum in collisions (with neutrons, electrons, photons, other phonons) but is conserved only up to . Except for , a phonon carries no physical momentum: the atoms just oscillate about fixed sites.Why people get this wrong: is the momentum of a photon of the same frequency, irrelevant here.
-
MCQStandard
In an Umklapp (U) process between phonons,- the total crystal momentum is exactly conserved and heat flow is unaffected
- the wave vectors satisfy with , which degrades the heat current
- a phonon is absorbed by an electron
- the number of phonons stays fixed
Answer and solution
Answer: B
When falls outside the first zone, it is brought back by a reciprocal vector: . The new phonon may travel roughly backwards, so the net phonon flow is reversed: U processes give an insulator its finite thermal resistance. Normal processes () conserve the total phonon momentum and alone cannot relax a heat current.Why people get this wrong: Normal processes redistribute energy among phonons but cannot by themselves stop a heat current.
-
MCQStandard
On a monatomic chain with sound speed , the group velocity at (half way to the zone edge) isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
.Why people get this wrong: Assuming the velocity falls linearly to zero at the zone edge ().
-
MSQStandard
Which statements about measuring phonon dispersion are correct?- Inelastic neutron scattering uses conservation of energy and of crystal momentum.
- Thermal neutrons have energies (tens of meV) comparable to phonon energies.
- For 1 Å X-rays (about 12 keV) a phonon changes the photon energy by only about one part in .
- Raman scattering of visible light probes phonons across the whole Brillouin zone.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Neutron: and ; measuring both gives point by point. A 25 meV neutron changes its energy by a large fraction when it makes a 10 meV phonon; a 12 keV photon changes by , which needs special meV-resolution instruments. Visible photons have of a zone, so Raman sees only optical phonons.Why people get this wrong: Light can only give a small ; whole-zone dispersion needs neutrons (or inelastic X-rays).
-
MCQStandard
On a monatomic chain with spacing , a wave with and one with describe- exactly the same atomic displacements
- waves of different frequency
- waves moving in opposite directions with the same speed
- a mode and its optical partner
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The displacements are . The two values differ by , and . The atoms (the only things that exist) move identically; the shorter wave just wiggles between atoms where there is nothing. So can always be taken in the first zone.Why people get this wrong: A continuous string would distinguish them; a lattice cannot.
-
NATStandard
The optical phonon of silicon at gives a Raman shift of cm. Its energy is ______ meV (to one decimal place).Answer and solution
Answer: 64.5 meV (±0.1)
; cm corresponds to meV. meV (frequency THz). The shift of the scattered light equals the phonon energy created (Stokes) or absorbed (anti-Stokes).Why people get this wrong: Forgetting to convert cm to m (a factor of 100).
-
MCQStandard
A chain of atoms (spacing ) with periodic (Born-von Kármán) boundary conditions has allowed wave vectors spaced byAnswer and solution
Answer: B
Periodicity requires , so with an integer. Taking consecutive values (one zone of width ) gives exactly distinct modes, one per atom.Why people get this wrong: is the spacing for fixed ends (standing waves with only); the count of modes is the same.
-
MSQStandard
For a monatomic chain (mass , spring , spacing ), which statements are correct?- The highest frequency is .
- is periodic in with period .
- At neighbouring atoms move in opposite directions.
- The speed of sound does not depend on .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
peaks at and repeats every . At , . The sound speed is proportional to (for fixed and ).Why people get this wrong: Statement 4 forgets that the sound speed is the slope at small , which brings in .
-
NATStandard
The Raman-active optical phonon of natural silicon (take all atoms as Si) is at cm. In a crystal made entirely of Si, with the same spring constants, it is at ______ cm (to one decimal place).Answer and solution
Answer: 502.4 cm⁻¹ (±0.3)
The interatomic forces come from the electrons and do not depend on the nuclear mass, so every phonon frequency scales as . cm. Isotope shifts like this are used to check which atoms take part in a vibration.Why people get this wrong: Frequencies scale as , not : the shift is about , not .
-
MSQStandard
A monatomic chain (mass , spring constant ) is stretched so that its spacing doubles, with and unchanged. Which statements are correct?- The highest frequency is unchanged.
- The speed of long-wavelength sound doubles.
- The first Brillouin zone becomes half as wide.
- The number of vibrational modes per atom changes.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
: the maximum does not involve . Sound speed is proportional to . The zone width halves. There is still one mode per atom in 1D: fewer per unit length of zone, but the zone is narrower in proportion.Why people get this wrong: The maximum frequency depends on masses and springs only; the spacing sets the scale.
-
NATExam level
A diatomic chain has atoms of 40 u and 20 u joined alternately by identical springs of N/m. The width of the frequency gap at the zone boundary is ______ rad/s (to two decimal places). Use u kg.Answer and solution
Answer: 1.25 10¹³ rad/s (±0.01)
At : rad/s and rad/s. Gap rad/s. No travelling wave exists at these frequencies; a wave sent in is damped.Why people get this wrong: Using instead of in the boundary frequencies.
-
NATExam level
Neutron measurements on a crystal show that its longitudinal acoustic branch along a direction of atomic spacing Å follows with rad/s. The longitudinal sound speed in that direction is ______ m/s.Answer and solution
Answer: 5000 m/s (±5)
For small : , so m/s.Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the from .
-
MCQExam level
For a monatomic chain with sound speed , the phase velocity at the zone boundary isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
. The group velocity there is zero, but the phase velocity is not.Why people get this wrong: Confusing phase and group velocity at the zone edge.
-
NATExam level
A monatomic chain of atoms (periodic boundary conditions) has maximum frequency . The number of normal modes with is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 300
Modes are evenly spaced in ( of them in ). means , i.e. : one third of the zone. So modes. In general .Why people get this wrong: Assuming modes are evenly spread in (giving 450).
-
MCQExam level
The phonon density of states of a monatomic chain, near its maximum frequency ,- falls smoothly to zero
- is constant
- diverges as
- diverges as
Answer and solution
Answer: D
. Near , , giving . This van Hove singularity comes from the flat dispersion () at the zone edge; in 3D such points give kinks rather than divergences.Why people get this wrong: Expecting the density to vanish at the top of the band; it is largest there in 1D.
-
NATExam level
NaCl has static dielectric constant and high-frequency value . By the Lyddane-Sachs-Teller relation, at is ______ (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 1.62 (±0.01)
LST: . . The longitudinal mode is stiffer because its oscillating polarisation makes a restoring electric field that the transverse mode lacks.Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the square root.
-
MSQExam level
Which statements about optical phonons near are correct?- In an ionic crystal the TO phonon absorbs infrared light strongly.
- In silicon (two identical atoms per cell) the optical phonon is Raman active but not infrared active.
- The optical phonon frequency goes to zero at .
- In a polar crystal the LO frequency is above the TO frequency.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, D
Oppositely charged ions moving against each other form an oscillating dipole: IR absorption at . In Si the two atoms are identical, so the vibration has no dipole (not IR active), but it modulates the polarisability (Raman active, 520 cm). Optical branches have finite frequency at ; it is the acoustic ones that vanish. In polar crystals the LO mode is pushed up by its macroscopic field.Why people get this wrong: Thinking "optical" means "seen with light" in every crystal; the name comes from ionic crystals.