Photons: the photoelectric and Compton effects
Modern physics · 5 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
NATTop rank
A photon of energy keV () is Compton-scattered by a free electron at rest. At what scattering angle does the scattered photon carry exactly as much energy as the recoiling electron? Answer in degrees.Answer and solution
Answer: 60 degrees (±0.5)
Equal shares means . With : requires , so and .Why people get this wrong: For a keV photon the same condition gives ; the answer depends on the photon energy.
-
MSQTop rank
Which statements are correct?- A free electron at rest cannot absorb a photon completely, because energy and momentum cannot both be conserved.
- In the photoelectric effect the leftover momentum is taken up by the rest of the metal (the lattice).
- The Compton formula follows from photon momentum together with relativistic energy and momentum conservation.
- A classical electromagnetic wave scattered by a free charge (Thomson scattering) shows the same angle-dependent wavelength shift.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
First: if the electron absorbed the photon, with ; squaring gives , impossible. Second: true, which is why only bound electrons show the photoelectric effect. Third: true, that is exactly Compton's derivation. Fourth: false; in Thomson scattering the charge oscillates at the wave's frequency and re-radiates at that same frequency: no shift.Why people get this wrong: The shift is a quantum (particle) effect; the classical limit of Compton scattering is unshifted Thomson scattering.
-
NATTop rank
An ultra-relativistic electron with Lorentz factor meets a eV laser photon head-on, and the photon is scattered straight back along the electron's direction. In the limit where (so the electron's recoil in its own rest frame can be neglected), the scattered photon's energy in the laboratory is about ______ MeV.Answer and solution
Answer: 8 MeV (±0.2)
Go to the electron's rest frame: the photon is blue-shifted to about (head-on Doppler factor ). Since keV is far below keV, it scatters back with nearly the same energy. Transforming back to the lab gives another factor . Total eV MeV. (Keeping the recoil gives MeV.)Why people get this wrong: Using one Doppler factor of instead of two factors of . This is how lasers and electron beams make gamma rays.
-
MCQTop rank
In Compton scattering, as the photon scattering angle goes from to , the angle between the recoil electron and the incident beam- goes from down to
- goes from up to
- stays at
- goes from up to
Answer and solution
Answer: A
. At , , so and (a grazing photon gives the electron a tiny sideways kick). At , , so : head-on. The electron never moves backwards.Why people get this wrong: The photon and electron go to opposite sides; when the photon goes straight back the electron goes straight forward.
-
NATTop rank
Photons of a single energy are scattered by free electrons, and the back-scattered photons () are found to have energy keV, while those at have keV. Using only these two readings (not the known value of ), find in keV (to the nearest keV).Answer and solution
Answer: 510 keV (±2)
Write . At : . At : . Subtract: , so and keV. The same subtraction gives keV, a check on the data: the true value is keV, so the photons had .Why people get this wrong: Work with reciprocals of energy: is linear in , energies themselves are not.