Home / Courses / CSIR NET Physics / Practice / Poisson brackets and canonical transformations

Poisson brackets and canonical transformations

Classical mechanics (GATE and NET) · 84 questions and templates for CSIR NET Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). The fundamental bracket {q,p} equals
    1. 1
    2. 0
    3. −1
    4. iℏ
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    {q,p}=∂q∂q∂p∂p−∂q∂p∂p∂q=1⋅1−0=1. In quantum mechanics this becomes [qˆ,pˆ]=iℏ, which is why iℏ is tempting but wrong here.

    Why people get this wrong: Some books define the bracket with the opposite sign and get −1; always check the convention given.

  2. MCQWarm-up

    For a function f(q,p) with no explicit time dependence and Hamiltonian H, the bracket {f,H} equals
    1. ∂f/∂t
    2. df/dt along the motion
    3. −df/dt along the motion
    4. Hdf/dt
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    dfdt=∂f∂qq˙+∂f∂pp˙=∂f∂q∂H∂p−∂f∂p∂H∂q={f,H}. With explicit time dependence, add ∂f/∂t.
  3. NATWarm-up

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). The value of {x,px2} when px=3 is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 6

    {x,px2}=∂x∂x∂(px2)∂px=2px=6. Bracketing with x acts like ∂/∂px.
  4. MCQWarm-up

    For any Hamiltonian, the bracket {H,H} is
    1. 1
    2. 2H
    3. 0
    4. H2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The bracket is antisymmetric, {f,g}=−{g,f}, so {f,f}=0 for every f. With dH/dt={H,H}+∂H/∂t, this is why a time-independent H is conserved.
  5. MCQWarm-up

    A function f(q,p) with no explicit time dependence is a constant of the motion if and only if
    1. {f,q}=0
    2. {f,p}=0
    3. f is a function of H only
    4. {f,H}=0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    df/dt={f,H}, so f is conserved exactly when its bracket with H vanishes. Functions of H are conserved, but so are many others (for example Lz in a central field).

    Why people get this wrong: Being a function of H is sufficient, not necessary.

  6. NATWarm-up

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). The value of {q2,p} at q=2 is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 4

    {q2,p}=∂(q2)∂q⋅1=2q=4. Bracketing with p acts like ∂/∂q.
  7. MCQWarm-up

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). The bracket {q,sin⁡p} equals
    1. cos⁡p
    2. −cos⁡p
    3. sin⁡q
    4. 0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    ∂q∂q∂(sin⁡p)∂p−∂q∂p∂(sin⁡p)∂q=1×cos⁡p−0=cos⁡p. In general {q,f(p)}=f′(p): the bracket with q acts as ∂/∂p.

    Why people get this wrong: With this sign convention {q,⋅} differentiates with respect to p with a plus sign; {p,⋅} gives −∂/∂q.

  8. MCQStandard

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). For the angular momentum L→=r→×p→, the bracket {Lx,Ly} equals
    1. Lz
    2. −Lz
    3. 0
    4. L2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    With Lx=ypz−zpy and Ly=zpx−xpz, only the pair (z,pz) contributes, so {Lx,Ly}={ypz,zpx}+{zpy,xpz}. Here {ypz,zpx}=ypx{pz,z}=−ypx and {zpy,xpz}=xpy{z,pz}=xpy. Sum: xpy−ypx=Lz. In general {Li,Lj}=ϵijkLk, the classical twin of [Lˆi,Lˆj]=iℏϵijkLˆk.
  9. NATStandard

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). The value of {xy,px} at the point (x,y)=(5,3) is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3

    {xy,px}=∂(xy)∂x=y=3.

    Why people get this wrong: Only the x derivative enters, because px is conjugate to x; the value of x does not matter.

  10. MSQStandard

    Which of these identities hold for all smooth functions f,g,h on phase space?
    1. {f,g}=−{g,f}
    2. {fg,h}=f{g,h}+{f,h}g
    3. {f,{g,h}}+{g,{h,f}}+{h,{f,g}}=0
    4. {f,gh}={f,g}{f,h}
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Antisymmetry, the product (Leibniz) rule and the Jacobi identity all follow from the definition. The last is false: the product rule gives {f,gh}=g{f,h}+{f,g}h.
  11. MCQStandard

    Which of these transformations of one degree of freedom is canonical?
    1. Q=p, P=q
    2. Q=p, P=−q
    3. Q=2q, P=2p
    4. Q=q2, P=p
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Test {Q,P}q,p=1. A: {p,q}=−1. B: {p,−q}=1, canonical: swapping coordinate and momentum is allowed if one sign is flipped. C: 4. D: 2q.

    Why people get this wrong: A plain swap reverses the sign of the bracket; it reverses time's arrow in Hamilton's equations.

  12. NATStandard

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). The value of {Lz,x}, with Lz=xpy−ypx, at the point (x,y)=(1,2) is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2

    x has no momentum dependence, so {Lz,x}=−∂Lz∂px∂x∂x=−(−y)=y=2.

    Why people get this wrong: Dropping the minus sign in front of the second term of the bracket gives −2.

  13. MCQStandard

    For H=p22m+V(q), the bracket {q,H} is
    1. −V′(q)
    2. p2/2m
    3. p/m
    4. 0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    {q,H}=∂H/∂p=p/m=q˙, the velocity, as it must be since q˙={q,H}. Similarly {p,H}=−V′(q)=p˙.
  14. MCQStandard

    The type-2 generating function F2(q,P)=qP (with p=∂F2/∂q, Q=∂F2/∂P) generates
    1. the exchange Q=p, P=−q
    2. a rotation of phase space by 90°
    3. a scaling Q=2q, P=p/2
    4. the identity transformation
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    p=∂F2/∂q=P and Q=∂F2/∂P=q: nothing changes. The exchange is generated instead by the type-1 function F1=qQ.
  15. NATStandard

    For H=12(p2+q2), the rate of change ddt(qp) at the instant when q=1 and p=3 is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 8

    d(qp)dt={qp,H}=∂(qp)∂q∂H∂p−∂(qp)∂p∂H∂q=p⋅p−q⋅q=9−1=8. Averaged over a period this is zero, which is the virial theorem (⟨T⟩=⟨V⟩ for the oscillator).
  16. MSQStandard

    A particle moves in a central potential, H=p22m+V(r). Which quantities have zero Poisson bracket with H?
    1. Lz
    2. L2
    3. px
    4. H
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, D

    H depends only on p2 and r2, which are unchanged by rotations, and L→ generates rotations, so each Li (and hence L2) brackets to zero with H. {H,H}=0 always. {px,H}=−∂V/∂x≠0: the force changes the momentum.
  17. MCQStandard

    If f and g are constants of the motion (no explicit time dependence), Poisson's theorem says that
    1. {f,g} is also a constant of the motion
    2. {f,g}=0
    3. fg=H
    4. f+g is not conserved
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    By the Jacobi identity, {{f,g},H}=−{{g,H},f}−{{H,f},g}=0 when {f,H}={g,H}=0. Example: Lx and Ly conserved implies Lz={Lx,Ly} conserved.

    Why people get this wrong: The new constant may be trivial (zero, or a function of the old ones); the theorem does not promise something new.

  18. NATStandard

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). The value of {q3,p2} at q=1, p=2 is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 12

    {q3,p2}=3q2⋅2p−0=6q2p=6×1×2=12.
  19. NATStandard

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). The value of {q2p,qp2} at q=1, p=2 is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 12

    f=q2p: fq=2qp, fp=q2. g=qp2: gq=p2, gp=2qp. {f,g}=(2qp)(2qp)−(q2)(p2)=3q2p2. At q=1, p=2: 3×1×4=12.

    Why people get this wrong: Taking the cross products in the wrong order gives −12; the first factor's q-derivative goes with the second factor's p-derivative.

  20. MSQStandard

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). For one degree of freedom and any Hamiltonian H(q,p), which brackets are zero for all q and p?
    1. {q2,q5}
    2. {H,H3}
    3. {q,p}
    4. {qp,q/p}
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B

    Functions of q alone have no p-derivatives, so {q2,q5}=0. By the chain rule {H,H3}=3H2{H,H}=0; any two functions of the same function commute. {q,p}=1. For f=qp, g=q/p: fqgp−fpgq=p(−qp2)−q⋅1p=−2qp, not zero.

    Why people get this wrong: qp and q/p are built from the same two variables, but that does not make them commute.

  21. MCQStandard

    For q>0 the new coordinate is Q=q2. Which new momentum makes (Q,P) canonical?
    1. P=2qp
    2. P=p2q
    3. P=pq2
    4. P=pq2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Need {Q,P}=QqPp−QpPq=2qPp=1, so Pp=1/2q and P=p2q (plus any function of q). This is the general rule for a point transformation: P=p/(dQ/dq), so that PdQ=pdq. Check another way: {Q,2qp}=2q⋅2q=4q2≠1.

    Why people get this wrong: Velocities transform with dQ/dq, momenta with its inverse.

  22. MCQExam level

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). The bracket {Lz,px} equals
    1. −py
    2. py
    3. 0
    4. px
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    {Lz,px}=∂Lz∂x=py (from Lz=xpy−ypx). In general {Li,pj}=ϵijkpk: the momentum is a vector, and Lz rotates it.
  23. NATExam level

    The linear transformation Q=2q+p, P=3q+dp is canonical. The value of d is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2

    {Q,P}=∂Q∂q∂P∂p−∂Q∂p∂P∂q=2d−3=1, so d=2. A linear map of one degree of freedom is canonical exactly when its determinant is 1 (it preserves area).
  24. MCQExam level

    The new coordinate is Q=qep. Which choice of new momentum makes the transformation canonical?
    1. P=e−p
    2. P=qe−p
    3. P=−e−p
    4. P=pe−p
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    For P=P(p) only: {Q,P}=∂Q∂qP′(p)=epP′(p). This equals 1 when P′=e−p, i.e. P=−e−p (plus a constant). Check qe−p: {Q,P}=ep(−qe−p)−qep⋅e−p=−2q.

    Why people get this wrong: e−p gives {Q,P}=−1; the sign matters.

  25. NATExam level

    The generating function F2(q,P)=12q2P defines a canonical transformation through p=∂F2/∂q and Q=∂F2/∂P. At the phase-space point q=2, p=6, the new momentum P is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3

    p=qP gives P=p/q=3, and Q=q2/2=2. Check: {Q,P}=q⋅1q−0=1.
  26. MCQExam level

    For a type-1 generating function F1(q,Q,t), the transformation equations are
    1. p=−∂F1/∂q, P=∂F1/∂Q
    2. p=∂F1/∂q, P=∂F1/∂Q
    3. q=∂F1/∂p, Q=∂F1/∂P
    4. p=∂F1/∂q, P=−∂F1/∂Q
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    From pq˙−H=PQ˙−K+dF1/dt: matching the q˙ and Q˙ terms gives p=∂F1/∂q and P=−∂F1/∂Q, with K=H+∂F1/∂t. Example: F1=qQ gives p=Q, P=−q.
  27. MSQExam level

    For a time-independent transformation (q,p)→(Q,P) of one degree of freedom, which statements correctly test or describe a canonical transformation?
    1. {Q,P}q,p=1
    2. The Jacobian ∂(Q,P)/∂(q,p) equals 1
    3. Hamilton's equations keep their form in the new variables, with K(Q,P)=H(q,p)
    4. It must leave the Hamiltonian's functional form unchanged, K(Q,P)=H(Q,P)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    For one degree of freedom the Jacobian determinant is exactly {Q,P}, so A and B are the same test (area preservation). C is the defining property; for a time-independent transformation K is simply H expressed in the new variables. D is false: the whole point is that K may look very different, as with H=12(p2+q2)→K=P in action-angle form.
  28. NATExam level

    Use {f,g}=∑i(∂f∂qi∂g∂pi−∂f∂pi∂g∂qi). A particle is at (x,y,z)=(1,2,0) with momentum (px,py,pz)=(3,1,0). The value of {Lx,Ly} there is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: -5

    {Lx,Ly}=Lz=xpy−ypx=1×1−2×3=−5.
  29. MCQExam level

    The Hamilton-Jacobi equation for Hamilton's principal function S(q,α,t) is
    1. ∂S∂t+H(q,∂S∂q,t)=0
    2. ∂S∂t=H(q,∂S∂q,t)
    3. ∂S∂q+H(q,p,t)=0
    4. {S,H}=0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    S is a type-2 generating function chosen so that the new Hamiltonian vanishes: K=H+∂S/∂t=0 with p=∂S/∂q. Then all new coordinates and momenta are constants.
  30. NATExam level

    For a free particle of mass 2 kg, a complete solution of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation is S=αx−α2t2m. Setting ∂S/∂α=β (a constant) with α=6 kg m/s gives the motion; the particle's speed is ______ m/s.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3 m/s

    ∂S/∂α=x−αt/m=β, so x=β+(α/m)t: uniform motion at α/m=3 m/s. Also p=∂S/∂x=α, the constant momentum.

← All topics · Timed mock test →