Home / Courses / GATE Physics / Practice / The collective model and nuclear deformation

The collective model and nuclear deformation

Nuclear physics · 64 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    In the ground band of a well-deformed even-even nucleus, the level energies follow
    1. E∝I
    2. E∝I2 exactly, like a classical rotor with I in place of L
    3. E∝I(I+1)
    4. E∝(I+12)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    A quantum symmetric top with moment of inertia ℐ about an axis perpendicular to the symmetry axis has E=ℏ22ℐI(I+1), from ⟨I→2⟩=I(I+1)ℏ2 (with K=0).

    Why people get this wrong: E∝I+12 is a harmonic vibrator's ladder in phonon number, not in spin.

  2. MCQWarm-up

    The ground-state rotational band of an even-even deformed nucleus has the spin-parity sequence
    1. 0+,1+,2+,3+,…
    2. 0+,2+,4+,6+,…
    3. 0+,1−,2+,3−,…
    4. 12+,32+,52+,…
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The intrinsic state has K=0 and is symmetric under a rotation by π about an axis perpendicular to the symmetry axis (reflection symmetry of the shape). That removes odd I, leaving 0+,2+,4+,…, all positive parity.

    Why people get this wrong: 0+,1−,2+,3− is the pattern of a pear-shaped (octupole) nucleus without reflection symmetry.

  3. MCQWarm-up

    For an ideal rigid rotor, the ratio R4/2=E(4+)/E(2+) is
    1. 2.00
    2. 2.50
    3. 4.00
    4. 3.33
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    E(4)/E(2)=(4×5)/(2×3)=20/6=10/3=3.33. Measured values near 3.3 identify good rotors (most rare-earth nuclei with 150<A<190 and the actinides).

    Why people get this wrong: 4.00 would follow from E∝I2.

  4. MCQWarm-up

    For a harmonic quadrupole vibrator, E(41+)/E(21+) is
    1. 2.00
    2. 3.33
    3. 1.00
    4. 2.50
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The 21+ is one quadrupole phonon (ℏω). Two phonons give a degenerate 0+,2+,4+ triplet at 2ℏω. So E(41+)/E(21+)=2.

    Why people get this wrong: 2.50 is the γ-soft (O(6)) limit, between vibrator and rotor.

  5. MCQWarm-up

    Permanently deformed nuclei are found mainly
    1. at or near the magic numbers
    2. only among the lightest nuclei (A < 20)
    3. far from closed shells, e.g. the rare earths (150 < A < 190) and the actinides (A > 220)
    4. only in odd-odd nuclei
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Closed shells favour spherical shapes. With many valence nucleons of both kinds outside closed shells, the long-range quadrupole correlations win over pairing and the nucleus deforms: hence low 2+ energies and rotational bands mid-shell.

    Why people get this wrong: Doubly magic nuclei (¹⁶O, ²⁰⁸Pb) are the most spherical and have high first 2⁺ energies.

  6. NATWarm-up

    The first 2+ state of a good rotor is at 90 keV. Its 4+ level is at ______ keV.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 300 keV (±0.5)

    E(I)=E(2+)I(I+1)/6, so E(4+)=90×20/6=300 keV.

    Why people get this wrong: 2×90=180 keV is the vibrator answer.

  7. MCQWarm-up

    In a spherical even-even nucleus, the one-phonon state of quadrupole surface vibrations has spin and parity
    1. 2+
    2. 0+
    3. 3−
    4. 1−
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    A quadrupole phonon carries angular momentum λ=2 and parity (−1)λ=+. Adding one to the 0+ ground state gives a 2+ state, usually the lowest excited state of a vibrational nucleus. 3− belongs to an octupole phonon; 1− to a dipole mode, which for the surface is just a shift of the centre of mass.

    Why people get this wrong: Choosing 3−, the octupole phonon.

  8. NATStandard

    A rotational ground band has E(2+)=80 keV. The 6+ member lies at ______ keV.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 560 keV (±0.5)

    E(6)/E(2)=42/6=7, so E(6+)=560 keV.

    Why people get this wrong: The energies grow quadratically, not linearly, with spin.

  9. NATStandard

    A rotor has its first 2+ state at 90 keV. The rotational constant ℏ2/2ℐ is ______ keV.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 15 keV (±0.05)

    E(2)=ℏ22ℐ×2×3, so ℏ2/2ℐ=90/6=15 keV, i.e. ℐ/ℏ2=33 MeV−1.

    Why people get this wrong: Divide by I(I+1) = 6, not by I = 2.

  10. MCQStandard

    In a K=0 rotational band with constant ℏ2/2ℐ, the E2 gamma rays I→I−2 have energies that
    1. are all equal
    2. increase by a constant step of 8ℏ2/2ℐ from one transition to the next
    3. decrease with spin
    4. increase as I3
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Eγ(I)=ℏ22ℐ[I(I+1)−(I−2)(I−1)]=ℏ22ℐ(4I−2). Raising I by 2 adds 8ℏ2/2ℐ: a "picket fence" of evenly spaced lines in the gamma spectrum.

    Why people get this wrong: The levels are not evenly spaced, but the gamma rays between them are.

  11. MCQStandard

    Two identical quadrupole phonons (each with angular momentum 2, parity +) can couple to which total spins?
    1. 0+,1+,2+,3+,4+
    2. 2+ only
    3. 0+,2+,4+
    4. 1+,3+
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Two j=2 objects give J=0 to 4, but phonons are bosons, so the state must be symmetric: only even J survive (for identical integer spins, the J=2j,2j−2,… states are symmetric). Hence the two-phonon triplet 0+,2+,4+.

    Why people get this wrong: Odd J would be antisymmetric under exchange of the two phonons.

  12. MCQStandard

    A nucleus with a positive intrinsic quadrupole moment Q0 is
    1. prolate (cigar-shaped, elongated along its symmetry axis)
    2. oblate (flattened, like a disc)
    3. spherical
    4. pear-shaped
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Q0=∫ρ(3z2−r2)dV in the body frame. Charge stretched along z makes 3z2>r2 on average: Q0>0, prolate. Most deformed nuclei are prolate, with β≈0.2 to 0.35.

    Why people get this wrong: The measured (spectroscopic) moment of a 2⁺ state in a prolate nucleus is negative; the intrinsic one is positive.

  13. NATStandard

    The spectroscopic quadrupole moment of a state of spin I in a band of projection K is Q=Q03K2−I(I+1)(I+1)(2I+3). For the 2+ state of a K=0 band with Q0=7.0 b, Q = ______ b.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: -2 b (±0.01)

    Q=7.0×0−63×7=7.0×(−2/7)=−2.0 b. The negative sign for a prolate nucleus comes from the averaging of the rotating body over orientations in the lab.

    Why people get this wrong: The lab-frame moment has the opposite sign to Q₀ for K = 0, I = 2.

  14. MCQStandard

    A strongly deformed even-even nucleus has Q0≈7 b. Its measured (spectroscopic) quadrupole moment in the 0+ ground state is
    1. about 7 b
    2. about −2 b
    3. zero, because a spin-0 state cannot show a quadrupole moment in the lab
    4. about +2 b
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    A state of spin 0 (or 1/2) is spherically symmetric on average in the lab, so its spectroscopic Q vanishes whatever the intrinsic shape (the formula gives zero for I=K=0). The deformation is measured instead through B(E2;0+→2+) or the Q of the 2+ state.

    Why people get this wrong: Intrinsic deformation and lab-frame quadrupole moment are different things.

  15. MSQStandard

    Which observations indicate collective (many-nucleon) behaviour in an even-even nucleus?
    1. Doubly magic nuclei have the lowest first 2⁺ energies of all.
    2. Strongly enhanced E2 transitions, many times a single-particle (Weisskopf) estimate.
    3. A ratio E(4⁺)/E(2⁺) close to 3.3.
    4. A first 2⁺ state at only a few tens of keV.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B, C, D

    Rotation and vibration involve many nucleons moving coherently, so E2 rates reach hundreds of Weisskopf units, the 21+ is very low (e.g. 80 keV against several MeV in 208Pb) and the spectrum follows I(I+1). Doubly magic nuclei have the highest 2+ energies, the opposite of collectivity.

    Why people get this wrong: Low 2⁺ energies go with mid-shell, not magic, nuclei.

  16. MCQStandard

    An odd-A deformed nucleus has a rotational band built on a K=5/2 intrinsic state. The band's spins are
    1. 52,92,132,… (steps of 2)
    2. 12,32,52,…
    3. 52 only
    4. 52,72,92,… (steps of 1)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    I≥K, and for K≠0 all values I=K,K+1,K+2,… occur (the reflection argument that removes odd I for K=0 does not apply). Both ΔI=1 (M1/E2) and ΔI=2 (E2) transitions are seen in such bands.

    Why people get this wrong: Only K = 0 bands skip every second spin.

  17. NATStandard

    A K=7/2 band in an odd-A nucleus has ℏ2/2ℐ=12 keV. The energy of the 9/2 member above the 7/2 band head is ______ keV.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 108 keV (±0.5)

    E(I)=EK+ℏ22ℐ[I(I+1)−K(K+1)]. 92⋅112−72⋅92=24.75−15.75=9, so ΔE=12×9=108 keV =ℏ22ℐ⋅2(K+1).

    Why people get this wrong: Using I² instead of I(I+1) gives 96 keV.

  18. NATStandard

    Using EGDR≈79A−1/3 MeV, the giant dipole resonance energy of 208Pb is ______ MeV (one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 13.3 MeV (±0.1)

    2081/3=5.925. E=79/5.925=13.3 MeV. The measured peak is at 13.4 MeV. The A−1/3 law matches a restoring force set by the symmetry energy acting over a nuclear radius.

    Why people get this wrong: Using A−1/2 or A1/3 by mistake gives answers far from the measured 13.4 MeV.

  19. MCQStandard

    For an ideal rotor (even-even, K=0), the ratio E(6+)/E(2+) is
    1. 3.33
    2. 6
    3. 9
    4. 7
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    E(I)∝I(I+1), so E(6+)/E(2+)=6×72×3=426=7. (3.33 is the 4+/2+ ratio, and 9 would follow from E∝I2.)

    Why people get this wrong: Using E∝I2, which gives 9.

  20. NATExam level

    Treat a nucleus with A=170 as a rigid sphere of radius R=1.2A1/3 fm and mass AmN (mNc2=939 MeV), so ℐrig=25AmNR2. Then ℏ2/2ℐrig is ______ keV (two decimal places; ℏc=197.3 MeV fm).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 6.9 keV (±0.02)

    R=1.2×1701/3=6.648 fm, R2=44.20 fm2. ℐc2=0.4×170×939×44.20=2.822×106 MeV fm2. ℏ2/2ℐ=(ℏc)2/2ℐc2=38937/5.644×106 MeV =6.90 keV. A rigid rotor would put the 2+ at 41 keV; real nuclei here have it near 80 keV.

    Why people get this wrong: Rigid rotation overestimates the moment of inertia by about a factor of 2.

  21. MCQExam level

    Measured moments of inertia of deformed nuclei lie between the irrotational-flow value and the rigid-body value (typically 30 to 50% of rigid). The main reason is
    1. nucleons are too heavy to rotate
    2. pairing correlations make the nucleons partly superfluid, so not all of them follow the rotation rigidly
    3. the Coulomb force opposes rotation
    4. nuclei rotate only about their symmetry axis
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Without pairing, independent nucleons in a deformed well give close to the rigid value (Inglis cranking). Pairing makes the nucleus behave partly like a superfluid, which can only rotate irrotationally (a much smaller ℐ∝β2). As pairing weakens at high spin, ℐ rises towards rigid.

    Why people get this wrong: Rotation about the symmetry axis is not collective at all for a quantum system; it does not produce bands.

  22. NATExam level

    For a nucleus with A=170, a rigid rotor would have ℏ2/2ℐrig=6.90 keV. The measured first 2+ is at 82 keV. The ratio ℐ/ℐrig is ______ (two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.5 (±0.01)

    ℏ2/2ℐ=82/6=13.67 keV. ℐ/ℐrig=6.90/13.67=0.50: about half the rigid value, as pairing predicts.

    Why people get this wrong: The moment of inertia is inversely proportional to the rotational constant.

  23. NATExam level

    To first order in β, Q0=35πZR2β. For Z=68, A=166 (R=1.2A1/3 fm) and β=0.30, Q0 is ______ b (two decimal places; 1 b =100 fm2).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 6.72 b (±0.02)

    R=1.2×1661/3=6.595 fm, R2=43.50 fm2. 3/5π=0.7569. Q0=0.7569×68×43.50×0.30=672 fm2=6.72 b, about 30 times the quadrupole moment of a single proton spread over the nucleus.

    Why people get this wrong: 1 barn is 100 fm², so 672 fm² is 6.72 b, not 67.2 b.

  24. MCQExam level

    In the liquid-drop model, a small spheroidal deformation ε changes the surface and Coulomb energies to ES=ES0(1+25ε2) and EC=EC0(1−15ε2). The spherical shape becomes unstable (spontaneous fission without a barrier) when
    1. EC0>ES0
    2. EC0>2ES0
    3. ES0>2EC0
    4. EC0>25ES0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    ΔE=ε25(2ES0−EC0). The sphere is stable while this is positive. Instability when EC0>2ES0, i.e. fissility x=EC0/2ES0>1, which with EC0=acZ2/A1/3 and ES0=asA2/3 means Z2/A>2as/ac≈50.

    Why people get this wrong: Surface energy rises twice as fast with ε² as Coulomb energy falls; hence the factor 2.

  25. NATExam level

    With semi-empirical coefficients as=17.8 MeV and ac=0.711 MeV, the liquid-drop limit of stability against fission, (Z2/A)crit=2as/ac, is ______ (nearest whole number).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 50

    2×17.8/0.711=50.1. Uranium-238 has Z2/A=35.6: below the limit, so it has a barrier (about 6 MeV) and fissions spontaneously only by slow tunnelling.

    Why people get this wrong: Not as/ac (25): the factor 2 comes from the different ε2 coefficients.

  26. NATExam level

    A K=0 band has ℏ2/2ℐ=14 keV. The gamma ray from the 8+ to the 6+ member has energy ______ keV.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 420 keV (±0.5)

    Eγ=ℏ22ℐ[8⋅9−6⋅7]=14×30=420 keV =14×(4×8−2).

    Why people get this wrong: Using 8² − 6² = 28 gives 392 keV.

  27. MCQExam level

    Many even-even nuclei have a low-lying collective 3− state. It is usually interpreted as
    1. a quadrupole (λ = 2) phonon
    2. a rotational state of the ground band
    3. a breathing (λ = 0) mode
    4. an octupole (λ = 3) surface vibration, with parity (−1)^λ = −1
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    A surface mode R=R0[1+∑αλμYλμ] has phonons of spin λ and parity (−1)λ. λ=2 gives 2+, λ=3 gives 3− (pear-like oscillation), λ=0 a high-lying compression mode, and λ=1 is just a translation of the centre of mass, not an excitation.

    Why people get this wrong: Odd parity cannot appear in a K = 0 positive-parity ground band.

  28. MCQExam level

    An even-even nucleus has levels at 0 (0⁺), 0.56 (2⁺), and a close group at 1.13 (4⁺), 1.13 (0⁺) and 1.21 (2⁺) MeV. This spectrum is best described as
    1. a rigid rotor
    2. a near-harmonic quadrupole vibrator (two-phonon triplet at about twice the 2⁺ energy)
    3. a doubly magic nucleus with particle-hole states
    4. an octupole-deformed rotor
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    E(4+)/E(2+)=1.13/0.56=2.0, and the 0+,2+,4+ cluster at about 2E(2+) is the two-phonon triplet, slightly split by anharmonicity. A rotor would put 4+ at 3.33×0.56=1.87 MeV.

    Why people get this wrong: A second 0⁺ near the 4⁺ is a hallmark of two-phonon states.

  29. NATExam level

    Two consecutive E2 transitions in a K=0 band of constant moment of inertia have energies 300 keV (I→I−2) and 380 keV (I+2→I). The spin I is ______.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 8

    The step between consecutive lines is 8ℏ2/2ℐ=80 keV, so ℏ2/2ℐ=10 keV. Then Eγ(I)=10(4I−2)=300 gives 4I−2=30, I=8. Spin assignments in high-spin bands are made this way.

    Why people get this wrong: The upper transition belongs to I + 2 → I; do not mix up which spin each line starts from.

  30. MCQExam level

    The giant dipole resonance seen in photo-absorption by nuclei is
    1. an isovector E1 oscillation of all protons against all neutrons
    2. a rotation of the whole nucleus
    3. a single-particle transition of the last nucleon
    4. an isoscalar monopole (breathing) oscillation
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    A photon's E1 field pushes protons one way; the centre of mass cannot move, so neutrons move the other way. This collective out-of-phase (isovector) motion, at 13-25 MeV, takes up nearly the whole classical E1 sum rule. The breathing mode is a different, isoscalar E0 resonance.

    Why people get this wrong: "Dipole" means the electric dipole moment oscillates, which needs protons and neutrons to move in opposite senses.

← All topics · Timed mock test →