Home / Courses / GATE Physics / Practice / The deuteron and the nuclear force

The deuteron and the nuclear force

Nuclear physics · 61 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    The spin and parity Jπ of the deuteron ground state are
    1. 0+
    2. 1+
    3. 1−
    4. 2+
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Measured J=1. Proton and neutron spins are parallel (S=1) in a mainly L=0 state, with a little L=2; both have parity (−1)L=+1. So Jπ=1+.

    Why people get this wrong: 0+ would be the spin-singlet np state, which is not bound.

  2. MCQWarm-up

    How many bound excited states does the deuteron have?
    1. One, at 2.2 MeV
    2. Two
    3. None: the ground state is its only bound state
    4. Infinitely many, as in hydrogen
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The deuteron is bound by only 2.22 MeV, a few per cent of the well depth. There is no room for a second bound level, and the spin-singlet np state just misses binding (a virtual state about 66 keV above threshold). Everything about the deuteron is learned from its ground state and from scattering.

    Why people get this wrong: The short-range nuclear well has finitely many levels, unlike the Coulomb potential.

  3. NATWarm-up

    Using mp=1.007276 u, mn=1.008665 u and the deuteron (nucleus) mass 2.013553 u, with 1 u =931.494 MeV/c2, the deuteron binding energy is ______ MeV (three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 2.224 MeV (±0.002)

    Δm=1.007276+1.008665−2.013553=0.002388 u. B=0.002388×931.494=2.224 MeV: about 1.1 MeV per nucleon, far below the 8 MeV typical of heavier nuclei.

    Why people get this wrong: With atomic masses, use hydrogen (not the bare proton) so the electron masses cancel.

  4. MCQWarm-up

    In Yukawa's picture the long-range part of the nuclear force comes from exchange of pions. The range this gives is about
    1. 0.01 fm
    2. 1.4 fm
    3. 14 fm
    4. 140 fm
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    A virtual particle of mass m can exist for Δt∼ℏ/mc2 and travel about ℏ/mc. For the pion, ℏc/mπc2=197.3/139.6=1.41 fm, the range of the nuclear force.

    Why people get this wrong: Using the nucleon mass instead of the pion mass gives 0.21 fm.

  5. MCQWarm-up

    The deuteron has a small positive electric quadrupole moment. This shows that
    1. the nuclear force is purely central
    2. the proton and neutron are in a pure S state
    3. the deuteron is spherical
    4. the nuclear force has a non-central (tensor) part that mixes in a D state
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    A pure L=0 state is spherical: zero quadrupole moment. A central force conserves L, so it cannot mix in L=2. The measured Q=+0.286 fm2 (a slightly prolate, cigar shape along the spin) needs a force that depends on the angle between the spins and rˆ: the tensor force.

    Why people get this wrong: A positive Q means prolate (elongated along the spin), not oblate.

  6. MCQWarm-up

    Charge independence of the nuclear force means that
    1. the force between two nucleons does not depend on whether they are pp, nn or np, in the same quantum state
    2. the nuclear force ignores electric charge but depends on spin only
    3. protons and neutrons have the same charge inside nuclei
    4. the Coulomb force is negligible in all nuclei
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Compared in the same space-spin state (e.g. 1S0), the pp, nn and np nuclear forces are nearly equal once the Coulomb force is removed. In isospin language the force depends on total isospin T but not on T3. (Charge symmetry is the weaker statement pp = nn.)

    Why people get this wrong: The np force in the deuteron (triplet) differs from pp because the state differs, not because of charge.

  7. MCQWarm-up

    The deuteron's binding energy per nucleon is about
    1. 1.11 MeV
    2. 2.22 MeV
    3. 7.07 MeV
    4. 8.8 MeV
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The total binding energy is 2.22 MeV shared by two nucleons, so B/A=1.11 MeV, far below the 7 to 9 MeV of heavier nuclei (7.07 MeV is 4He, 8.8 MeV is near iron). The deuteron is a very loosely bound system.

    Why people get this wrong: Quoting the total binding energy, 2.22 MeV, as the per-nucleon value.

  8. NATStandard

    Estimate the range ℏ/mπc of the force from charged-pion exchange (mπ±c2=139.57 MeV, ℏc=197.33 MeV fm), to three decimal places.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.414 fm (±0.002)

    ℏ/mπc=ℏc/mπc2=197.33/139.57=1.414 fm, the Compton wavelength (divided by 2π) of the pion.

    Why people get this wrong: Using hc instead of ℏc gives 2π times too long a range.

  9. NATStandard

    Outside the range of the force the deuteron wavefunction falls as u(r)∝e−κr with κ=2μB/ℏ, where μ=mN/2 (mNc2=938.9 MeV) and B=2.225 MeV. The decay length 1/κ is ______ fm (two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 4.32 fm (±0.01)

    2μc2=mNc2=938.9 MeV, so ℏcκ=938.9×2.225=45.71 MeV and 1/κ=197.33/45.71=4.32 fm, about three times the range of the force: the deuteron is a loose, extended system.

    Why people get this wrong: The reduced mass is mN/2; with the full nucleon mass in place of 2μ you would be off by 2.

  10. MCQStandard

    Which orbital-spin states can combine to give the deuteron's Jπ=1+ with T=0?
    1. 1S0 and 3P1
    2. 3S1 and 1P1
    3. 3S1 and 3D1
    4. 3P1 and 1D2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Parity + needs even L. For np with T=0, the generalised Pauli principle (−1)L+S+T=−1 needs L+S odd: with even L, S=1. Then J=1 allows L=0 or 2: 3S1 and 3D1. The tensor force mixes them.

    Why people get this wrong: 1P1 has J=1 but odd parity.

  11. MCQStandard

    There is no bound dineutron (nn). The main reason is that
    1. the Pauli principle forbids the nn ³S₁ state, and the ¹S₀ force is just too weak to bind
    2. neutrons do not feel the nuclear force
    3. the Coulomb force pushes the neutrons apart
    4. the nn force is always repulsive
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Two identical neutrons in a relative S state must have an antisymmetric spin state, S=0. The 1S0 nuclear force is strongly attractive but just fails to bind (scattering length −18.9 fm, a virtual state). The binding 3S1 state is available only to np, which is why the deuteron exists. This is spin dependence of the nuclear force.

    Why people get this wrong: Neutrons are neutral; the Coulomb force plays no role for nn.

  12. NATStandard

    A gamma ray splits a deuteron at rest (B=2.2246 MeV, Mdc2=1875.6 MeV). The threshold photon energy exceeds B by the recoil term B2/2Mdc2, which is ______ keV (two decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 1.32 keV (±0.01)

    At threshold the products move off together with the photon's momentum Eγ/c, carrying kinetic energy Eγ2/2Mdc2≈B2/2Mdc2=4.949/3751.2 MeV =1.32 keV. So Eγth=2.2259 MeV.

    Why people get this wrong: Recoil is small but measurable; the 2.22 MeV capture gamma from n + p → d + γ is lower by the same amount.

  13. MCQStandard

    For two spin-1/2 nucleons, the operator σ→1⋅σ→2 has eigenvalues
    1. +1 in the triplet and −3 in the singlet
    2. +3 in the triplet and −1 in the singlet
    3. 1/4 in the triplet and −3/4 in the singlet
    4. 0 in both
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    S→=ℏ2(σ→1+σ→2), so σ→1⋅σ→2=2ℏ2S2−3=2S(S+1)−3: +1 for S=1, −3 for S=0. A term Vσ(r)σ→1⋅σ→2 makes the force spin dependent.

    Why people get this wrong: 1/4 and −3/4 are the eigenvalues of s→1⋅s→2/ℏ2, a quarter of these.

  14. MSQStandard

    Which are properties of the nucleon-nucleon force?
    1. It has a short range, of order 1 to 2 fm.
    2. It is independent of the spins of the nucleons.
    3. It saturates: each nucleon binds only to a few neighbours.
    4. It becomes strongly repulsive at separations below about 0.5 fm.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, C, D

    Short range: nuclei barely feel each other beyond a few fm, and the force falls off as e−r/1.4 fm. Saturation: B/A≈8 MeV for all but light nuclei and the density is constant, which needs a repulsive core and exchange character. Spin dependence is clear: the np triplet is bound, the singlet is not.

    Why people get this wrong: Spin independence is ruled out by the deuteron itself (bound only in S = 1).

  15. NATStandard

    If the deuteron were a pure 3S1 state, its magnetic moment would be μp+μn. With μp=2.7928μN and μn=−1.9130μN, this is ______ μN (three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.88 μN (±0.001)

    With L=0 only the spins contribute, and with both spins aligned along J: μ=μp+μn=2.7928−1.9130=0.8798μN. The measured 0.8574μN is 2.5% smaller, a sign of the D state.

    Why people get this wrong: The neutron moment is negative; adding magnitudes gives 4.7 μN.

  16. MCQStandard

    Slow neutrons are captured by protons in water: n + p → d + γ. The gamma ray energy is close to
    1. 0.511 MeV
    2. 1.11 MeV
    3. 2.22 MeV
    4. 4.45 MeV
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The neutron brings almost no kinetic energy, so the photon carries the binding energy, 2.224 MeV, less a recoil of about 1.3 keV. This line is used to calibrate gamma detectors and to measure the deuteron binding energy precisely.

    Why people get this wrong: Half the binding energy (1.11 MeV) is the binding per nucleon.

  17. MCQStandard

    The total isospin of the deuteron is
    1. T = 1, like the pp and nn systems
    2. T = 0
    3. T = 1/2, like a single nucleon
    4. not defined, because the deuteron contains different particles
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The two-nucleon state must be antisymmetric overall: (−1)L+S+T=−1. The deuteron has L=0 (mainly) and S=1, so T must be even: T=0, the antisymmetric isospin singlet (pn−np)/2. There are no T=0 pp or nn states, so no partners exist.

    Why people get this wrong: T3=0 for any np pair, but T can be 0 or 1; the deuteron is T=0.

  18. MCQStandard

    In the deuteron ground state the spins of the neutron and the proton are
    1. antiparallel, total spin S=0
    2. not in any definite total-spin state
    3. always opposite to the orbital angular momentum
    4. parallel, total spin S=1 (mainly with L=0)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    The deuteron has J=1 and even parity, so L=0 or 2 with S=1 (a 3S1 state with a few per cent 3D1). The spin-singlet 1S0 np state is not bound: the nuclear force is spin dependent and more attractive when the spins are parallel.

    Why people get this wrong: Pairing the spins to zero as in even-even nuclei; for the np system the bound state is the triplet.

  19. NATStandard

    A one-pion-exchange potential falls off as V(r)∝e−r/ar with a=ℏ/mπc=1.414 fm. The ratio V(2.0 fm)/V(1.0 fm) is ______ (three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.246 (±0.002)

    V(2)V(1)=12e−(2−1)/1.414=0.5×e−0.707=0.5×0.493=0.246. Compared with a Coulomb-like 1/r (which would give 0.5), the exponential cuts the force off beyond about 1.4 fm.

    Why people get this wrong: Dropping the 1/r factor and keeping only the exponential.

  20. NATExam level

    Model the np force as an attractive square well of radius 2.0 fm. The smallest depth that can hold an L=0 bound state (binding energy tending to zero) is ______ MeV (one decimal place). Use μc2=469.5 MeV and ℏc=197.3 MeV fm.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 25.6 MeV (±0.1)

    Inside u=Asin⁡kr; at zero binding the outside solution is flat, so u′(R)=0: kR=π/2. With k=2μV0/ℏ: V0=π2(ℏc)28μc2R2=9.870×389278×469.5×4.0=25.6 MeV.

    Why people get this wrong: A 3D well, unlike a 1D one, needs a minimum depth to bind: kR must reach π/2.

  21. MCQExam level

    For a square well of radius about 2.1 fm that reproduces B=2.22 MeV, the depth comes out near 34 MeV, and the inside wave number satisfies kR slightly above π/2. What does this say?
    1. The deuteron is deeply bound, with most of its wavefunction inside the well
    2. The deuteron is barely bound: the well only just manages to turn the wavefunction over, and most of the probability lies outside the range of the force
    3. The well must be repulsive
    4. There must be a second bound state
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    A second level would need kR≥3π/2, far away. With kR just past π/2 the wavefunction hardly bends down inside, joins a slowly decaying tail (1/κ=4.3 fm) and spends about 60% of its time outside r=R. A loose system: the deuteron's rms radius (about 2 fm for the matter, 4 fm for np separation) is large.

    Why people get this wrong: A 34 MeV well with a 2.2 MeV binding means the state is near the top, not the bottom.

  22. NATExam level

    The np scattering lengths are as=−23.7 fm (singlet) and at=5.4 fm (triplet). Weighting the spin states statistically, the zero-energy np cross section is ______ barn (one decimal place).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 20.4 b (±0.1)

    At zero energy σ=4πa2 for each channel. Unpolarised: 14 singlet and 34 triplet, σ=π(as2+3at2)=π(561.7+87.5)=2039 fm2=20.4 b (1 b =100 fm2). The large value comes from the singlet: Wigner's evidence for spin dependence.

    Why people get this wrong: Averaging the scattering lengths before squaring, or forgetting the 1/4 and 3/4 weights.

  23. MCQExam level

    The np singlet scattering length is large and negative (−23.7 fm). This means that the 1S0 np system
    1. is strongly repulsive
    2. has a deeply bound state
    3. is not bound, but has a virtual state just above zero energy (the attraction just fails to bind)
    4. has no interaction at low energy
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    For an attractive well, a goes from small negative values (weak), through −∞ as the well becomes just strong enough to bind, to large positive values (a weakly bound state with a≈1/κ). Large negative a means just short of binding: a virtual state. The triplet at=+5.4 fm goes with the bound deuteron.

    Why people get this wrong: The sign of a, not its size, tells bound (positive) from unbound (negative) for an attractive well.

  24. NATExam level

    The short-range repulsion is often modelled by exchange of the ω meson (mωc2=782.7 MeV). The range ℏ/mωc is ______ fm (three decimal places).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 0.252 fm (±0.001)

    ℏc/mωc2=197.33/782.7=0.252 fm. Heavier mesons act at shorter distances: pion (1.4 fm, long-range attraction and tensor force), two-pion/σ (about 0.4 to 0.7 fm, mid-range attraction), ω (0.25 fm, repulsion).

    Why people get this wrong: The vector meson ω gives repulsion between nucleons, unlike the scalar exchange.

  25. MSQExam level

    Which statements about the deuteron are correct?
    1. Its wavefunction is mostly ³S₁, with a few per cent ³D₁.
    2. Its magnetic moment equals μp + μn exactly.
    3. Its size is larger than the range of the nuclear force.
    4. Its quadrupole moment is positive, so the charge distribution is elongated along the spin (prolate).
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, C, D

    The tensor force mixes about 4 to 6% 3D1 into the 3S1; this lowers μd to 0.857μN (below 0.880) and gives Q=+0.286 fm2, prolate. The wavefunction tail e−r/4.3 fm reaches well beyond the 1.4 fm range.

    Why people get this wrong: The difference 0.880 − 0.857 is small but well outside the measurement error.

  26. MCQExam level

    Two neutrons scatter at very low energy (relative S wave only). Their spin-orbital state must be
    1. 3S1
    2. 1P1
    3. 3D1
    4. 1S0
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Identical fermions need an antisymmetric total state. With L=0 (symmetric in space) the spin state must be antisymmetric: S=0, 1S0. Equivalently T=1 for nn and (−1)L+S+T=−1 gives L+S even.

    Why people get this wrong: 3S1 is the deuteron channel; it needs T=0, which nn cannot have.

  27. NATExam level

    How many distinct 2S+1LJ states are allowed for two protons in a relative L=1 (P-wave) state?
    Answer and solution

    Answer: 3

    pp has T=1. (−1)L+S+T=−1 with L=1, T=1 needs S odd: S=1. Then J=0,1,2: 3P0, 3P1, 3P2, three states. (1P1 is allowed only for np with T=0.)

    Why people get this wrong: Including 1P1 gives 4, but that state is symmetric in spin and space combined.

  28. MCQExam level

    Binding energy per nucleon is roughly constant (about 8 MeV) and nuclear density is the same in all heavy nuclei. If every nucleon attracted every other with a long-range force, the total binding would instead grow as
    1. A
    2. A²
    3. A^{1/3}
    4. A^{2/3}
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    With A(A−1)/2 attracting pairs, B∝A2 and nuclei would shrink as A grows. The observed B∝A (saturation) means each nucleon interacts only with its near neighbours: a short-range force with a repulsive core (and exchange character) that stops collapse.

    Why people get this wrong: A2/3 is the surface correction, not the all-pairs result.

  29. MCQExam level

    Which of these two-nucleon states is forbidden for two protons?
    1. 1S0
    2. 3P1
    3. 1D2
    4. 3S1
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    The generalised Pauli principle needs (−1)L+S+T=−1. Two protons have T=1, so L+S must be even. 1S0: 0+0 even, allowed. 3P1: 1+1 even, allowed. 1D2: 2+0, allowed. 3S1: 0+1 odd, forbidden; it needs T=0, which only np can have (the deuteron).

    Why people get this wrong: 3S1 is the deuteron's main state, which is exactly why there is no bound diproton in it.

  30. MCQExam level

    At nucleon separations below about 0.5 fm, the nucleon-nucleon potential is
    1. strongly repulsive (a "hard core")
    2. zero
    3. attractive and Coulomb-like
    4. attractive and growing without limit
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    High-energy phase shifts (the 1S0 one turns negative above about 250 MeV) need strong short-range repulsion. It keeps nucleons apart and explains why nuclear matter saturates at a fixed density instead of collapsing. In meson-exchange models it comes from ω exchange; in QCD, from quark Pauli blocking and gluon exchange.

    Why people get this wrong: The attraction is at intermediate range (about 1-2 fm), not at the shortest distances.

← All topics · Timed mock test →