The Ising model and Landau theory (NET)
Statistical physics · 50 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
NATWarm-up
A ferromagnetic Ising model () lives on a square lattice of sites with periodic boundaries. Its ground-state energy per spin is ______ .Answer and solution
Answer: -2
Each site has neighbours, so there are bonds. All spins aligned make every bond contribute : , i.e. per spin. The ground state is twofold degenerate (all up or all down).Why people get this wrong: Counting bonds per spin double counts each bond.
-
MCQWarm-up
In zero field, which Ising systems with short-range ferromagnetic coupling show a spontaneous magnetisation at some ?- Only the one-dimensional chain
- The square lattice (2D) and the cubic lattice (3D), but not the 1D chain
- All of them, in every dimension
- None: spontaneous magnetisation needs a field
Answer and solution
Answer: B
In 1D a single domain wall costs only but gains entropy , so order is destroyed at any . In 2D a wall around a domain costs energy proportional to its length, which beats the entropy at low (Peierls): there is a transition, at on the square lattice (Onsager). The lower critical dimension of the Ising model is 1. -
NATWarm-up
Mean-field theory predicts for the Ising model. For a face-centred cubic lattice, is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 12
Each spin feels the average field of its neighbours; has a nonzero solution for . The fcc lattice has , so in mean field (the true value is about ). -
MCQWarm-up
Landau's free energy for an Ising-like transition, , contains no term because- the free energy must be symmetric under when
- cubic terms are always small
- it would make unbounded
- Landau theory only works in 4 dimensions
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The Ising Hamiltonian is invariant under flipping all spins when , so and only even powers appear. Where symmetry allows a cubic term (e.g. the nematic-isotropic or three-state Potts transition), the transition becomes first order. -
MCQWarm-up
With ( or 1), the Ising model maps onto a lattice gas. The ferromagnetic coupling and the magnetic field correspond to- repulsion between atoms; temperature
- attraction between neighbouring atoms; chemical potential
- hard-core exclusion only; pressure
- attraction; volume
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Substituting into gives const. A ferromagnet () is a gas with nearest-neighbour attraction , and the field plays the role of the chemical potential. The Ising critical point is a liquid-gas critical point, which is why they share exponents. -
NATWarm-up
How many microstates does an Ising model of spins have?Answer and solution
Answer: 512
Each of the 9 spins is independently: configurations. For there are , which is why Monte Carlo sampling is needed instead of summing every state. -
MCQWarm-up
An Ising ferromagnet (, each pair of neighbours counted once) has spins on a square lattice with periodic boundaries. Its ground-state energy isAnswer and solution
Answer: B
In the ground state all spins are parallel, so every bond contributes . Each spin has neighbours, and each bond is shared by two spins, so there are bonds. .Why people get this wrong: counts each bond twice, once from each end.
-
NATStandard
Two Ising spins interact through . At , the probability that they are parallel is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.881 (±0.001)
Four states: two parallel (energy ) and two antiparallel (). with . . Equivalently . -
NATStandard
In the zero-field Ising chain, with . At , is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.099 (±0.001)
With bond variables (independent in zero field, each with mean ), , so the correlation is . It decays exponentially at any : no long-range order. -
MCQStandard
Three Ising spins on a triangle have antiferromagnetic coupling , . The ground-state energy and its degeneracy are- , 2 states
- , 2 states
- , 6 states
- , 6 states
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Not all three bonds can be antiparallel (frustration). The best is two antiparallel and one parallel: . Only all-equal states (2 of 8) have , so the other 6 states all have . Frustration leaves a large ground-state degeneracy; on the triangular lattice it gives residual entropy per spin. -
NATStandard
In a Metropolis simulation of the square-lattice Ising model at , a proposed flip raises the energy by . The probability that it is accepted is ______ (to four decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.0183 (±0.0002)
Metropolis accepts with probability . Here . Flipping a spin changes the energy by ; is a spin aligned with all four neighbours. -
MCQStandard
Why does the Metropolis rule sample the Boltzmann distribution?- It satisfies detailed balance with respect to , and the moves are ergodic
- It always lowers the energy
- It visits every state equally often
- It is exact only at
Answer and solution
Answer: A
For two states with : , which equals for Boltzmann weights. Detailed balance makes the Boltzmann distribution stationary, and ergodicity (any state reachable) makes it the unique limit. -
NATStandard
The Bethe (cluster) approximation gives . For the square lattice (), the predicted is ______ (to three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 2.885 (±0.002)
, so . Compared with mean field (4) and the exact Onsager value (2.269), Bethe is better because it treats one spin and its neighbours exactly. It still gives mean-field exponents. -
MSQStandard
Which statements about mean-field theory of the Ising model are correct?- It always overestimates , because it neglects fluctuations
- It wrongly predicts a transition for the 1D chain (at )
- It becomes exact for long-range interactions or above four dimensions
- It gives the exact 2D exponent
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Fluctuations disorder the system, so ignoring them raises ; mean field even predicts order in 1D. For infinite-range coupling or (the upper critical dimension) mean-field exponents are exact. Mean field gives ; is Onsager-Yang. -
NATStandard
In a 1D Ising chain of spins, one domain wall costs and can sit in about places. With , the free energy of creating a wall becomes negative for larger than about ______ (to the nearest whole number).Answer and solution
Answer: 22026 (±2)
when . A long enough chain always breaks into domains: no order at . In 2D a domain wall of length costs while its entropy also grows only , so order survives at low . -
MCQStandard
The critical exponents of the 2D Ising model are- , , , (jump)
- , ,
- , , , (logarithmic)
- , ,
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Onsager (1944) and Yang (1952): , , , , , . The first option is mean field, the second 3D Ising, the last the tricritical mean-field values. -
NATStandard
In Landau theory . The ratio of the susceptibility above to that below , at equal , is ______.Answer and solution
Answer: 2
Above: and , so . Below: and , so . Ratio , a universal mean-field amplitude ratio (about 4.4 in 3D Ising, 37.7 in 2D). -
MCQStandard
For the liquid-gas transition, viewed as a lattice gas (Ising) transition, the natural order parameter is- the pressure
- the temperature
- the density difference
- the latent heat
Answer and solution
Answer: C
In lattice-gas language the magnetisation maps to the density. Along the coexistence curve with , the 3D Ising value. -
NATStandard
In the fully aligned ground state of the simple cubic Ising ferromagnet (, coupling , no field), flipping one spin raises the energy by ______ .Answer and solution
Answer: 12
The flipped spin now disagrees with all 6 neighbours. Each of those bonds goes from to , a change of , so the cost is . At low temperature such flips are suppressed by , which is why the magnetisation stays very close to saturation there.Why people get this wrong: Each broken bond costs (from to ), not .
-
MCQStandard
A square lattice with periodic boundaries has how many nearest-neighbour bonds?Answer and solution
Answer: D
Each of the sites has neighbours, and each bond joins two sites: . Equivalently, one horizontal and one vertical bond per site.Why people get this wrong: counts every bond twice.
-
NATExam level
Two Ising spins have with . At and , the mean value is ______ (three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.931 (±0.002)
Energies: : ; : ; and : . Weights at : and (three states). . .Why people get this wrong: The mixed states contribute and to and cancel; only the two aligned states matter for .
-
NATExam level
Three Ising spins on a ring have with . At , the mean energy is ______ (two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: -2.79 (±0.01)
All aligned (2 states): every bond satisfied, . Otherwise (6 states) exactly one bond is satisfied and two are broken: . . .Why people get this wrong: On a ring of three, a single flipped spin breaks two bonds, not one.
-
MCQExam level
In the Bragg-Williams (mean-field) treatment of the Ising model, the free energy per spin is with . Expanded in powers of , the coefficient of isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
Expand: , so . Then The coefficient changes sign at , and the coefficient is positive, so the transition is continuous: a Landau free energy derived from the lattice model.Why people get this wrong: The quartic term comes from the entropy, so it carries , with a positive sign since is added.
-
NATExam level
The exact critical temperature of the honeycomb-lattice Ising ferromagnet () is . Mean-field theory gives . The mean-field value is ______ times the exact one (three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 1.975 (±0.003)
Exact: . Mean field: . Ratio . The error is largest for lattices with few neighbours, where the local field fluctuates most; for the face-centred cubic lattice () mean field is only about 23% too high.Why people get this wrong: Using in the exact formula gives a ratio near , less than 1, which mean-field theory never gives.
-
MSQExam level
Below , Landau-Ginzburg theory allows a flat domain wall between regions with and . Which statements are correct?- The wall's thickness is of the order of the correlation length .
- The wall grows thicker as from below.
- The wall's free energy per unit area falls to zero as .
- At the centre of the wall, .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Minimising gives with , twice the correlation length below , so the wall widens as diverges. Its energy per area scales as , vanishing at , which is why domains form and vanish freely near the transition. By symmetry at the centre.Why people get this wrong: The profile is odd about the centre: , not .
-
MSQExam level
For a ferromagnetic Ising system in a uniform field , which statements about its phase diagram in the plane are correct?- Below , sweeping through zero causes a first-order transition.
- On that line the magnetisation jumps from to .
- The line of first-order transitions ends at the critical point , .
- Above , the magnetisation also jumps when passes through zero.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Below the two ordered states are degenerate at ; any field picks one, so jumps from to : a first-order line along . As the jump shrinks to zero, ending the line at the critical point. Above , varies smoothly through zero. This is the same picture as the liquid-gas coexistence line ending at its critical point.Why people get this wrong: Above there is no spontaneous magnetisation, so nothing jumps.
-
MCQHard
The square-lattice Ising antiferromagnet () in zero field orders below a Néel temperature of- zero: it never orders
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The square lattice is bipartite: flipping every spin on one sublattice () turns each bond term into and maps the antiferromagnet onto the ferromagnet with the same partition function in zero field. So , Onsager's value, with staggered magnetisation as the order parameter. On the non-bipartite triangular lattice the antiferromagnet is frustrated and does not order.Why people get this wrong: The mapping needs zero field and a bipartite lattice; a uniform field becomes a staggered one under the flip.
-
MSQHard
Which statements about Monte Carlo simulation of the Ising model are true?- The Metropolis rule satisfies detailed balance with respect to the Boltzmann distribution
- Near , single-spin-flip updates suffer critical slowing down: correlation times grow as a power of the system size
- Cluster algorithms (Swendsen-Wang, Wolff) greatly reduce critical slowing down
- On a finite lattice the simulated heat capacity truly diverges at
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Metropolis: , detailed balance. Near large correlated regions must be turned spin by spin, so with . Flipping whole clusters at once brings well below 2. In a finite system is a finite sum of exponentials, analytic in : the heat capacity has a rounded peak whose height grows with , but no true divergence.Why people get this wrong: True singularities need the thermodynamic limit; finite-size data show peaks that sharpen with size.
-
NATHard
A system has Landau free energy density with J m K, J m and K. The jump in its heat capacity per unit volume on cooling through is ______ J m K.Answer and solution
Answer: 50 J m⁻³ K⁻¹ (±0.1)
Below : and . Then , which at is J m K. Above , and this part of is zero: a finite jump, in mean-field theory.Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the factor in gives instead of 50.
-
MSQHard
Which statements about Landau theory are true?- It assumes the free energy can be expanded as a power series in the order parameter near the transition
- If the system is symmetric under , only even powers appear
- An allowed cubic term generally makes the transition first order
- It treats fluctuations correctly in three dimensions, so its exponents are exact there
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Landau theory expands analytically and keeps the terms the symmetry allows. With a cubic term, develops a second minimum away from before the quadratic coefficient vanishes, so jumps (as in liquid-crystal and some structural transitions). It is a mean-field theory: it neglects fluctuations, which dominate near below four dimensions, so in 3D its exponents (, ) are not exact.Why people get this wrong: Landau theory is qualitatively right in 3D but quantitatively wrong near ; it is exact only above the upper critical dimension.