The second law, engines and entropy
Kinetic theory and thermodynamics · 34 questions and templates for GATE Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQWarm-up
A large reservoir at K gives J of heat to a system. The entropy of the reservoir changes by- J/K
- J/K
- , because a reservoir's temperature does not change
- J/K
Answer and solution
Answer: B
A reservoir stays at one temperature, so the heat leaves it reversibly as far as the reservoir is concerned: J/K. The sign is negative because heat leaves it. Whether the total entropy rises depends on the temperature of the system that receives the heat.Why people get this wrong: A constant temperature does not mean constant entropy; is exactly the formula for a reservoir.
-
MCQStandard
For any cycle, with the heat taken in at a boundary where the temperature is , the Clausius inequality says- for every cycle
- for every cycle
- , with equality for a reversible cycle
- , with equality for a reversible cycle
Answer and solution
Answer: C
An irreversible engine rejects more heat than a reversible one for the same heat taken in, which makes negative. Only for reversible cycles is , which is what makes a state function. -
NATStandard
A current of A flows for s through a resistor that is kept at K by a large water bath. The entropy of the universe rises by ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 3.33 (±0.03)
The resistor dissipates J. Its own state is the same at the end (same temperature), so its entropy does not change. All J goes into the bath at K: J/K. Ordered electrical work has become disordered heat: an irreversible process.Why people get this wrong: Giving the resistor an entropy change as well counts the same heat twice; its state is unchanged.
-
MSQStandard
Which statements are correct?- The entropy of an isolated system never decreases.
- The entropy of a system that is not isolated can decrease, if it gives out heat.
- A reversible adiabatic process leaves the entropy of the system unchanged.
- Over one cycle of a real (irreversible) heat engine, the entropy of the universe is unchanged, because the working substance returns to its starting state.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
The second law forbids a decrease only for the total entropy of an isolated system. A system that gives out heat (a cooling cup of tea) loses entropy, but its surroundings gain more. Reversible and adiabatic means . Over a cycle the working substance's entropy is unchanged (a state function), but the reservoirs gain entropy in an irreversible engine, so the universe's entropy rises.Why people get this wrong: The working substance returning to its start says nothing about the reservoirs.
-
MCQExam level
Two samples of the same gas at the same temperature and pressure are separated by a partition, which is removed. The entropy change is- per two moles, as for different gases
- negative
- per two moles
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Nothing measurable changes: put the partition back and you recover the original state. With identical (indistinguishable) particles the entropy is extensive and . Getting here is the Gibbs paradox, which is resolved by the in the partition function. -
MSQExam level
A system goes from state 1 to state 2 once by a reversible path and once by an irreversible path, exchanging heat with its surroundings. Which statements are correct?- The entropy change of the system is the same for both paths
- The entropy change of the surroundings is the same for both paths
- The total entropy change of system plus surroundings is , and zero for the reversible path
- Along the irreversible path, equals the entropy change of the system
Answer and solution
Answer: A, C
A: is a state function. B: false, the surroundings receive different heat. C: second law. D: false, for the irreversible path (Clausius inequality). -
MCQExam level
Through a given point on the – diagram of an ideal gas pass an isochore and an isobar. Which is steeper?- The isochore, with slope
- The isobar, with slope
- Both have the same slope
- The isobar, with slope
Answer and solution
Answer: A
gives . Since , the isochore is steeper. (So an Otto cycle on a – diagram has steeper sides than a Brayton cycle.) -
MCQExam level
A system has independent spins, each of which can point up or down with equal energy. Its entropy isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
There are equally likely microstates, so . Entropy is extensive, so it must be proportional to . -
NATExam level
A refrigerator removes heat at W from its inside at K and uses W of electrical power, rejecting heat to a kitchen at K. The rate of entropy production is ______ W/K (three decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 0.231 (±0.003)
Energy balance: heat to the kitchen W. Entropy flows: the kitchen gains W/K and the inside loses W/K (the working fluid runs in a cycle). Net production W/K. A reversible fridge would need only W; the extra W ends as heat at K, and W/K, the same answer.Why people get this wrong: Forgetting the electrical power in the heat sent to the kitchen gives a negative (impossible) result.
-
MSQExam level
In which of these processes does the entropy of the system itself (not the universe) stay the same?- A reversible adiabatic compression of a gas
- A free expansion of an ideal gas into a vacuum, in an insulated box
- A slow adiabatic compression in which friction between piston and cylinder heats the gas
- One complete cycle of an irreversible engine, for its working substance
Answer and solution
Answer: A, D
Reversible and adiabatic gives . In the free expansion no heat enters, but the volume grows at fixed , so ; "adiabatic" alone does not mean "isentropic". With friction the gas receives extra internal energy without heat crossing the boundary, so its entropy rises. Entropy is a state function, so over any complete cycle the working substance returns to the same , reversible or not.Why people get this wrong: holds only for reversible changes; adiabatic irreversible processes raise the entropy.
-
MCQExam level
A memory bit, which may hold 0 or 1 with equal probability, is reset to 0 by a device in contact with surroundings at temperature . The least heat that must be released to the surroundings is- zero, if the reset is done slowly enough
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Before the reset the bit has two equally likely states, entropy ; afterwards it has one, entropy . The second law requires the surroundings' entropy to rise by at least , so heat of at least must be released (Landauer's principle). Slowness can reach this minimum but cannot remove it. At K it is J per bit.Why people get this wrong: Reversible does not mean free: a reversible erasure still sends of heat out.
-
NATHard
The same two blocks (heat capacity J/K each, at K and K) are now brought to a common temperature by running a reversible engine between them. The work obtained is ______ kJ.Answer and solution
Answer: 17.16 kJ (±0.1)
Reversible means total : , so K. Work = heat lost by the hot block minus heat gained by the cold one kJ.Why people get this wrong: Using K: that is the result with no engine, when no work is taken out.
-
NATHard
An ideal Diesel cycle with air () has compression ratio and cut-off ratio . Its efficiency is ______ %.Answer and solution
Answer: 63.2 % (±0.3)
. Here and . So .Why people get this wrong: The Diesel factor is always larger than 1, so at the same compression ratio a Diesel cycle is less efficient than an Otto cycle.
-
MSQHard
Which of these processes increase the entropy of the universe?- Free expansion of a gas into vacuum
- Quasi-static isothermal expansion of a gas in contact with a reservoir at the same temperature
- Heat conduction through a rod between two bodies at different temperatures
- Current flowing through a resistor kept at constant temperature by a cooling bath
Answer and solution
Answer: A, C, D
B is reversible: the gas gains and the reservoir loses . A, C and D are irreversible: unrestrained expansion, heat across a finite temperature difference and dissipation of work as heat (D: the bath gains while the resistor is unchanged). -
MSQHard
Working between two reservoirs at and only, which ideal reversible cycles reach the Carnot efficiency ?- Carnot cycle
- Stirling cycle with a perfect regenerator
- Ericsson cycle with a perfect regenerator
- Otto cycle
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
Any reversible cycle that exchanges heat with the outside only at and has Carnot efficiency. In Stirling and Ericsson cycles the regenerator stores and returns the heat of the isochoric or isobaric legs internally. The Otto cycle takes in heat over a range of temperatures (below ), so its efficiency is lower. -
NATHard
Two moles of an ideal gas at K expand isothermally (in contact with a reservoir at K) against a constant external pressure of atm, from atm to atm. The entropy of the universe increases by ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 3.21 J/K (±0.03)
Gas: J/K. Work done , and since . Reservoir: J/K. Total J/K. -
MCQHard
Which statement is NOT consistent with the third law of thermodynamics?- Absolute zero cannot be reached in a finite number of steps
- A classical ideal gas keeps a constant all the way down to
- Heat capacities tend to zero as
- The thermal expansion coefficient tends to zero as
Answer and solution
Answer: B
With constant , as , which violates the third law. Real gases become quantum (degenerate) at low . B follows from staying finite; C from the Maxwell relation ; D is the unattainability form. -
NATHard
At low temperatures the molar heat capacity of a crystal follows the Debye law with J mol K. Its molar entropy at K is ______ J mol K.Answer and solution
Answer: 0.533 J mol$^{-1}$ K$^{-1}$ (±0.005)
With : J mol K. Note for a law.Why people get this wrong: Answering : the entropy is an integral of , not itself.
-
MCQHard
A body of constant heat capacity at temperature drives a reversible engine that rejects heat to the surroundings at , until the body cools to . The total work obtained isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
The body gives up of heat and loses entropy . A reversible engine must hand that entropy to the surroundings, which costs heat . The rest is work.Why people get this wrong: Option A uses the Carnot efficiency at the starting temperature for all the heat, but the body cools, so the efficiency falls as it runs.
-
MSQHard
A metal rod joins a reservoir at to one at and carries heat at a steady rate . Which statements are correct?- Entropy is produced at the rate .
- The entropy of the rod increases steadily.
- Entropy is produced in every part of the rod where the temperature gradient is non-zero.
- If , the rate of entropy production is .
Answer and solution
Answer: A, C, D
The cold reservoir gains , the hot one loses , and the rod is in a steady state, so its entropy is constant (B false). Total: A. Locally, conduction down a gradient produces entropy at the rate per volume, positive wherever (C). D: .Why people get this wrong: Thinking entropy piles up in the rod; in a steady state it is carried out as fast as it is made.
-
NATHard
One mole of a monatomic ideal gas at K and pressure is in an insulated cylinder. The external pressure is suddenly raised to and held there; the gas is compressed until it settles at K and pressure . The entropy change of the gas is ______ J/K (to two decimal places).Answer and solution
Answer: 1.23 J/K (±0.02)
Entropy is a state function, so use a reversible path between the end states: J/K. It is positive even though no heat entered: the sudden compression is irreversible. (Check of 420 K: gives .)Why people get this wrong: Saying because ; only along a reversible path.
-
MCQHard
A reversible cycle is a right triangle on a - diagram: a vertical rise at from to , then a straight line from down to with , then a horizontal return at . Its efficiency isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
Heat taken in is the area under the sloping line, where : . Heat rejected is along the bottom: . The net work is the triangle's area, . Efficiency . For K and K that is , below Carnot's , because heat is taken in at an average temperature of only K.Why people get this wrong: Taking (as for a Carnot rectangle) gives .
-
NATHard
A reversible engine takes heat from a furnace at K and rejects heat to the outdoors at K. All its work drives a reversible heat pump that takes heat from the outdoors and delivers it to a house at K. For each joule taken from the furnace, the heat delivered to the house is ______ J.Answer and solution
Answer: 11.2 (±0.1)
The engine turns J of each furnace joule into work; its remaining J goes outdoors. The heat pump's coefficient of performance is , so J of work delivers J to the house. Burning fuel directly in the house would give only J: the second law makes heating by heat pump far more efficient.Why people get this wrong: Adding the engine's rejected J to the house heat is wrong here: it goes to the outdoors, not to the house.
-
NATHard
A body of heat capacity J/K at K and a body of heat capacity J/K at K (both constant) drive a reversible engine until they reach a common temperature. The work obtained is ______ kJ.Answer and solution
Answer: 55.1 (±0.3)
Reversible means no total entropy change: , so K. The work is the heat given by the hot body minus the heat received by the cold one: kJ.Why people get this wrong: Using the plain heat-capacity-weighted mean ( K), which is the result of direct contact with no engine, gives zero work.
-
NATTop rank
The surroundings are at C. What is the minimum work needed to turn 1 kg of water at C into ice at C? ( J kg K, latent heat kJ/kg.) Answer in kJ.Answer and solution
Answer: 27.4 kJ (±0.3)
A reversible refrigerator leaves the universe's entropy unchanged. The water loses kJ of heat and entropy J/K. The surroundings must gain that entropy, i.e. receive kJ. Work = heat delivered − heat extracted kJ.Why people get this wrong: Using a single Carnot COP for the whole job: the cooling part from 20 to 0 °C runs at changing temperature.
-
NATTop rank
A reversible engine takes J per cycle from a reservoir at K, exchanges heat with reservoirs at K and K, and delivers J of work per cycle. The heat it takes from the K reservoir per cycle (negative if it gives heat to that reservoir) is ______ J.Answer and solution
Answer: -1200 J
Let , be the heats taken from the K and K reservoirs. Energy: . Reversible: . Substituting : , so and J. It gives J to the K reservoir and takes J from the K one.Why people get this wrong: Assuming the coldest reservoir must receive heat. Only the total entropy balance decides.
-
MSQTop rank
For a simple system described by its entropy , which statements are correct?- is homogeneous of degree 1:
- For a stable system is a concave function of
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
From : . So , and D has the wrong sign. A is extensivity. C: concavity, , is the same as . -
MCQTop rank
A system of nuclear spins in a magnetic field has been prepared at a negative absolute temperature. It is put in thermal contact with an ordinary body at K. Heat flows- from the spin system to the body
- from the body to the spin system
- in neither direction, since for the spins can be smaller than 300 K
- in either direction, depending on
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Heat flows so that total entropy rises. is negative for the spins: they gain entropy by losing energy. The body gains entropy by gaining energy. So energy flows from the spins to the body, whatever the size of . Negative temperatures are "hotter than infinite temperature".Why people get this wrong: Comparing magnitudes. The order of hotness runs , and is the natural variable.
-
MCQTop rank
A Carnot-type engine exchanges heat with reservoirs at K and K through finite thermal conductances, so heat flows only if the working fluid is cooler than the hot reservoir and warmer than the cold one. Tuning the fluid temperatures for maximum power, the efficiency (the Curzon-Ahlborn result) isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
A reversible engine (infinitely slow) gives Carnot's but zero power. With finite heat-flow rates, maximising the power gives . This is lower than Carnot, but it is close to what real power stations achieve.Why people get this wrong: is the reversible limit, reached only at zero power; (half of Carnot) is a rule of thumb, not the result.