Home / Courses / IIT JAM Physics / Practice / Commutators and the uncertainty relation

Commutators and the uncertainty relation

Quantum mechanics · 9 questions and templates for IIT JAM Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    The commutator [xˆ,pˆ] of position and momentum in one dimension is
    1. −iℏ
    2. ℏ
    3. 0
    4. iℏ
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Act on a test function: [xˆ,pˆ]f=x(−iℏf′)−(−iℏ)(xf)′=−iℏxf′+iℏf+iℏxf′=iℏf. So [xˆ,pˆ]=iℏ.

    Why people get this wrong: Getting the sign backwards; [pˆ,xˆ]=−iℏ.

  2. MCQWarm-up

    Two observables A and B have a complete set of common eigenvectors if and only if
    1. they anticommute
    2. they commute
    3. both have only positive eigenvalues
    4. their commutator is a non-zero constant
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    If [A,B]=0 the two Hermitian operators can be diagonalised together; conversely, if they are both diagonal in one basis they commute. Such observables are called compatible.
  3. MSQWarm-up

    Which pairs of operators commute?
    1. xˆ and pˆy
    2. xˆ and pˆx
    3. Lˆz and Lˆ2
    4. xˆ and yˆ
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, C, D

    The canonical relations are [xi,pj]=iℏδij, so x and py commute but x and px do not. Positions commute among themselves. L2 commutes with every component of L→.
  4. MCQWarm-up

    If A and B are Hermitian operators, their commutator [A,B] is
    1. Hermitian
    2. anti-Hermitian, so that i[A,B] is Hermitian
    3. unitary
    4. always zero
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Take the adjoint: [A,B]†=(AB−BA)†=B†A†−A†B†=BA−AB=−[A,B]. An operator equal to minus its adjoint is anti-Hermitian. Multiplying by i fixes this: (i[A,B])†=−i(−[A,B])=i[A,B]. The canonical example is [xˆ,pˆ]=iℏ, which is i times a real number.

    Why people get this wrong: Assuming that anything built from Hermitian operators is Hermitian; even the product AB is Hermitian only when A and B commute.

  5. MCQStandard

    Which operator commutes with the Hamiltonian H=pˆ2/2m of a free particle?
    1. xˆ
    2. pˆ
    3. xˆpˆ
    4. xˆ2
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    [pˆ,pˆ2]=0, so momentum is conserved. [xˆ,pˆ2]=2iℏpˆ≠0, and xˆpˆ, xˆ2 also fail.
  6. MCQExam level

    For H=pˆ2/2m+V(xˆ), which statement is NOT correct in general?
    1. d⟨x⟩dt=⟨p⟩m
    2. d⟨p⟩dt=−⟨V′(x)⟩
    3. If V is at most quadratic in x, ⟨x⟩(t) follows a classical trajectory exactly
    4. d⟨p⟩dt=−V′(⟨x⟩) for every potential
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    [H,xˆ]=−iℏpˆ/m gives the first line. [H,pˆ]=[V,pˆ]=iℏV′(xˆ) gives d⟨p⟩/dt=−⟨V′(x)⟩. The average of the force equals the force at the average position only when V′ is linear in x, that is for V at most quadratic; then the centre obeys Newton's law exactly. For V=λx4, ⟨x3⟩≠⟨x⟩3 and the last statement fails.

    Why people get this wrong: Reading Ehrenfest's theorem as "quantum mechanics reduces to Newton's law for the mean" in every potential.

← All topics · Timed mock test →