Home / Courses / IIT JAM Physics / Practice / Identical particles

Identical particles

Quantum mechanics · 14 questions and templates for IIT JAM Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQWarm-up

    The total wavefunction (space and spin) of a system of two identical fermions must be
    1. antisymmetric under exchange of the two particles
    2. symmetric under exchange
    3. symmetric in space and antisymmetric in spin, always
    4. unchanged in magnitude only, with any phase
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Exchange P12 commutes with H for identical particles and P122=1, so states have P12=±1. Nature chooses: −1 for fermions (half-integer spin), +1 for bosons (integer spin). For fermions the space part can be symmetric if the spin part is antisymmetric, or the other way round; only the product must be antisymmetric.

    Why people get this wrong: The third option is only one of the two possibilities (the singlet case).

  2. MCQWarm-up

    Which of these behaves as a boson?
    1. An electron
    2. A neutral 4He atom
    3. A neutral 3He atom
    4. A proton
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Count the fermions inside: 4He has 2 protons, 2 neutrons and 2 electrons, 6 fermions, so its total spin is an integer and it is a boson (hence superfluid 4He). 3He has 5 fermions: a fermion. Electrons and protons are spin-12 fermions.
  3. MCQWarm-up

    Two non-interacting electrons (spin 12) are in a 1D infinite well whose single-particle levels are n2E1. The ground-state energy of the pair is
    1. E1
    2. 5E1
    3. 2E1
    4. 8E1
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Both can occupy n=1 if their spins form the antisymmetric singlet, so E=E1+E1=2E1. For spinless fermions (or electrons forced into a triplet) one must go to n=2: E1+4E1=5E1.
  4. MCQWarm-up

    The Pauli exclusion principle follows from antisymmetry because
    1. fermions repel each other electrically
    2. fermions have spin
    3. bosons occupy only even states
    4. an antisymmetric product of two identical one-particle states, ϕ(1)ϕ(2)−ϕ(2)ϕ(1), is zero
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    If both particles had the same one-particle state (space and spin), the antisymmetrised wavefunction would vanish identically. So no two identical fermions share a complete set of quantum numbers. It has nothing to do with charge: neutrons obey it too.
  5. MCQWarm-up

    Which of these is a fermion?
    1. a neutral 4He atom
    2. a neutral 3He atom
    3. a deuteron
    4. a neutral 1H atom
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Count the spin-12 constituents: an odd number makes a fermion. 3He: 2 protons + 1 neutron + 2 electrons = 5, odd: fermion. 4He: 6, deuteron: 2, 1H: 2 (proton + electron), all even: bosons.

    Why people get this wrong: Count electrons too for neutral atoms; a hydrogen atom is a boson although the proton and electron are fermions.

  6. MCQStandard

    The spin-statistics connection states that
    1. all particles with spin are fermions
    2. bosons have half-integer spin
    3. statistics depends on the temperature
    4. particles with integer spin are bosons and particles with half-integer spin are fermions
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Photons (spin 1), pions (0) and 4He atoms are bosons; electrons, protons, neutrons and 3He atoms are fermions. Within non-relativistic quantum mechanics it is a postulate; relativistic quantum field theory proves it.
  7. MCQStandard

    Two electrons occupy the same spatial orbital ϕ(r→) (as in the helium ground state). Their spin state must be
    1. the singlet
    2. one of the triplet states
    3. either a singlet or a triplet
    4. any product state such as |↑↑⟩
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The spatial part ϕ(r→1)ϕ(r→2) is symmetric under exchange. The total state must be antisymmetric, so the spin part must be antisymmetric: the singlet 12(|↑↓⟩−|↓↑⟩). This is the Pauli rule "two electrons per orbital, with opposite spins".

    Why people get this wrong: |↑↑⟩ is a triplet state; it would need an antisymmetric spatial part, impossible with one orbital.

  8. MSQStandard

    Which of these are acceptable wavefunctions (up to normalisation) for two identical spinless bosons, with ϕa≠ϕb?
    1. ϕa(x1)ϕb(x2)+ϕb(x1)ϕa(x2)
    2. ϕa(x1)ϕa(x2)
    3. ϕa(x1)ϕb(x2)−ϕb(x1)ϕa(x2)
    4. ϕa(x1)ϕb(x2)
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B

    Spinless bosons need ψ(x1,x2)=ψ(x2,x1). The symmetrised sum and the doubly occupied product are symmetric. The difference is antisymmetric (fermions), and the plain product is neither: it labels which particle is in which state.

    Why people get this wrong: A product of two different orbitals is not symmetric unless it is symmetrised.

  9. MSQExam level

    Which of these composite objects behave as bosons?
    1. A neutral 4He atom
    2. A Cooper pair of electrons
    3. A deuteron
    4. A neutral 3He atom
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A, B, C

    Count the spin-12 constituents: even means boson. 4He atom: 2 protons, 2 neutrons, 2 electrons = 6 (boson). Cooper pair: 2 electrons (boson). Deuteron: proton + neutron (boson, spin 1). 3He atom: 2 protons, 1 neutron, 2 electrons = 5 (fermion), which is why liquid 3He behaves so differently from 4He.

    Why people get this wrong: Counting only the nucleons of the 3He atom (3) gives the right answer here, but forgetting electrons fails for ions and other atoms.

← All topics · Timed mock test →