The second law, engines and entropy
Kinetic theory and thermodynamics · 72 questions and templates for IIT JAM Physics, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: The second law, engines and entropy.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQWarm-up
The maximum possible efficiency of a heat engine working between reservoirs at K and K isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
Carnot: .Why people get this wrong: is , the fraction of heat thrown away, not the efficiency.
-
MCQWarm-up
Which statement is the Kelvin–Planck form of the second law?- No cyclic device can take heat from a single reservoir and turn it completely into work
- Heat cannot flow from a hot body to a cold body
- The energy of an isolated system is constant
- Every reversible engine has 100% efficiency
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Kelvin–Planck forbids a perfect engine: some heat must always be rejected to a colder body. (The Clausius statement forbids heat flowing by itself from cold to hot; B has the direction backwards. C is the first law.) -
NATWarm-up
1 kg of ice melts at C (latent heat kJ/kg). The entropy of the water increases by ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 1222.8 J/K (±6)
Melting happens at constant temperature, so J/K.Why people get this wrong: Dividing by (Celsius) is impossible, a reminder that must be absolute.
-
MCQWarm-up
The coefficient of performance (heat removed / work input) of a Carnot refrigerator working between K and K isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
For a reversible refrigerator .Why people get this wrong: is the COP of a heat pump, which counts the heat delivered to the hot side.
-
MSQWarm-up
For a reversible adiabatic process, which statements are true?- The entropy of the system does not change
- The process is isentropic
- No heat is exchanged
- The temperature stays constant
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
, so a reversible adiabat is an isentrope. The temperature usually changes (an ideal gas cools on adiabatic expansion). -
NATWarm-up
Two moles of an ideal gas expand isothermally to twice their volume. The entropy of the gas increases by ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 11.53 J/K (±0.06)
J/K. This is true whether the expansion is reversible or not, because is a state function. -
MCQWarm-up
A large reservoir at K gives J of heat to a system. The entropy of the reservoir changes by- J/K
- J/K
- , because a reservoir's temperature does not change
- J/K
Answer and solution
Answer: B
A reservoir stays at one temperature, so the heat leaves it reversibly as far as the reservoir is concerned: J/K. The sign is negative because heat leaves it. Whether the total entropy rises depends on the temperature of the system that receives the heat.Why people get this wrong: A constant temperature does not mean constant entropy; is exactly the formula for a reservoir.
-
MCQStandard
One mole of an ideal gas undergoes free expansion into vacuum, doubling its volume, in an insulated container. The entropy change of the gas is- , because no heat was exchanged
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Entropy is a state function. Find a reversible path between the same states: an isothermal expansion (the temperature is the same at both ends). Along it . The actual process is irreversible, so .Why people get this wrong: only for a reversible path. Here but .
-
NATStandard
A reversible heat pump keeps a house at C while it is C outside. Its coefficient of performance (heat delivered / work input) is ______ (to one decimal place).Answer and solution
Answer: 14.9 (±0.1)
. Each joule of electricity moves almost 15 J of heat indoors, in the ideal limit.Why people get this wrong: Using Celsius, . Only the difference may be taken in Celsius.
-
MCQStandard
An inventor claims an engine that takes J per cycle from a reservoir at K, rejects heat to one at K and gives J of work per cycle. The claim- violates the first law
- is possible only if the engine is reversible
- violates the second law, because the maximum work is J
- is possible, because J < J
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Carnot efficiency , so at most J of work. Energy is conserved ( J rejected), so the first law is fine; the second law is broken. -
NATStandard
1 kg of water ( J kg K) is heated from C to C. Its entropy increases by ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 779.5 J/K (±4)
J/K.Why people get this wrong: Using with a single temperature: the temperature changes during heating, so integrate.
-
MCQStandard
The efficiency of an ideal air-standard Otto cycle with compression ratio isAnswer and solution
Answer: A
Heat enters and leaves at constant volume, and the two adiabats link temperatures by . Then . -
MSQStandard
Which statements are correct?- The entropy of an isolated system increases in any irreversible process inside it
- The entropy of a system can decrease
- In a reversible process the total entropy of system plus surroundings stays constant
- The entropy of an isolated system can decrease if the process is slow enough
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
A and C are the second law. B: a system that gives out heat (a cooling cup of tea) loses entropy, while its surroundings gain more. D: slowness never makes of an isolated system negative; at best (reversible) it is zero. -
MCQStandard
On a temperature–entropy (–) diagram, a Carnot cycle is- a rectangle whose area is the heat absorbed
- a pair of hyperbolas joined by vertical lines
- a single straight line, because entropy is conserved
- a rectangle whose area is the net work per cycle
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Two isotherms (horizontal lines at and ) and two reversible adiabats (vertical lines, constant ). The area . The heat absorbed is the area under the top line, . -
NATStandard
J of heat flows directly from a reservoir at K to a reservoir at K. The entropy of the universe increases by ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 2 J/K
Hot reservoir: J/K. Cold reservoir: J/K. Total J/K. Positive, as it must be for heat flowing down a temperature difference. -
MCQStandard
The third law of thermodynamics (Nernst–Planck form) states that- energy cannot be created or destroyed
- the entropy of a perfect crystal tends to zero as
- the entropy of any system is zero at C
- no engine can be more efficient than a Carnot engine
Answer and solution
Answer: B
As a perfect crystal settles into its single ground state, , so . C is a consequence of the second law, D is the first law. -
MCQStandard
For any cycle, with the heat taken in at a boundary where the temperature is , the Clausius inequality says- for every cycle
- for every cycle
- , with equality for a reversible cycle
- , with equality for a reversible cycle
Answer and solution
Answer: C
An irreversible engine rejects more heat than a reversible one for the same heat taken in, which makes negative. Only for reversible cycles is , which is what makes a state function. -
MCQStandard
A device works as a refrigerator with coefficient of performance (heat removed from the cold side per unit work). Run as a heat pump between the same two places (heat delivered to the hot side per unit work), its coefficient of performance isAnswer and solution
Answer: C
Per cycle, energy conservation gives . So . This holds for any device, reversible or not.Why people get this wrong: Thinking the heat pump COP is the inverse; both measure useful heat per unit work, and the hot side also gets the work.
-
MCQStandard
A reversible engine works between C and C. Its efficiency isAnswer and solution
Answer: D
Convert to kelvin: K, K. .Why people get this wrong: Using Celsius temperatures (); the Carnot formula needs absolute temperatures.
-
MCQStandard
Which of these processes is reversible (in the thermodynamic sense)?- A gas expanding freely into a vacuum
- Heat flowing from a body at 350 K to one at 300 K
- Two different gases mixing by diffusion
- An ideal gas compressed very slowly by a frictionless piston, in contact with a reservoir at the gas's own temperature
Answer and solution
Answer: D
A reversible process can be undone with no change left anywhere; it must be quasi-static, frictionless, and exchange heat only across vanishing temperature differences. The slow frictionless isothermal compression meets all three. Free expansion, heat flow across a finite gap and mixing all raise the entropy of the universe.Why people get this wrong: Choosing heat flow because the temperatures are close; any finite temperature difference creates entropy.
-
NATStandard
A current of A flows for s through a resistor that is kept at K by a large water bath. The entropy of the universe rises by ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 3.33 (±0.03)
The resistor dissipates J. Its own state is the same at the end (same temperature), so its entropy does not change. All J goes into the bath at K: J/K. Ordered electrical work has become disordered heat: an irreversible process.Why people get this wrong: Giving the resistor an entropy change as well counts the same heat twice; its state is unchanged.
-
MSQStandard
Which statements are correct?- The entropy of an isolated system never decreases.
- The entropy of a system that is not isolated can decrease, if it gives out heat.
- A reversible adiabatic process leaves the entropy of the system unchanged.
- Over one cycle of a real (irreversible) heat engine, the entropy of the universe is unchanged, because the working substance returns to its starting state.
Answer and solution
Answer: A, B, C
The second law forbids a decrease only for the total entropy of an isolated system. A system that gives out heat (a cooling cup of tea) loses entropy, but its surroundings gain more. Reversible and adiabatic means . Over a cycle the working substance's entropy is unchanged (a state function), but the reservoirs gain entropy in an irreversible engine, so the universe's entropy rises.Why people get this wrong: The working substance returning to its start says nothing about the reservoirs.
-
NATExam level
One mole of helium and one mole of neon, both at the same temperature and pressure, are allowed to mix. The entropy of mixing is ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 11.53 J/K (±0.06)
Each gas expands into twice its volume: J/K. In general with mole fractions . -
MCQExam level
Two samples of the same gas at the same temperature and pressure are separated by a partition, which is removed. The entropy change is- per two moles, as for different gases
- negative
- per two moles
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Nothing measurable changes: put the partition back and you recover the original state. With identical (indistinguishable) particles the entropy is extensive and . Getting here is the Gibbs paradox, which is resolved by the in the partition function. -
NATExam level
Two identical blocks, each of heat capacity J/K, at K and K are put in contact, insulated from everything else. When they reach equilibrium, the total entropy has increased by ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 58.89 J/K (±0.3)
Equal heat capacities, so K. J/K. -
MCQExam level
Two Carnot engines work in series between K and K: the first rejects its heat to an intermediate reservoir at , from which the second takes it. If both engines produce the same work, is- K
- K
- K
- K
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Let the first absorb ; then and . Equal work: gives , so K (the arithmetic mean). For equal efficiencies it would be the geometric mean, K.Why people get this wrong: Equal work and equal efficiency give different answers: arithmetic mean versus geometric mean.
-
NATExam level
An ideal Otto cycle with air () has compression ratio . Its efficiency is ______ %.Answer and solution
Answer: 56.5 % (±0.3)
. -
MSQExam level
A system goes from state 1 to state 2 once by a reversible path and once by an irreversible path, exchanging heat with its surroundings. Which statements are correct?- The entropy change of the system is the same for both paths
- The entropy change of the surroundings is the same for both paths
- The total entropy change of system plus surroundings is , and zero for the reversible path
- Along the irreversible path, equals the entropy change of the system
Answer and solution
Answer: A, C
A: is a state function. B: false, the surroundings receive different heat. C: second law. D: false, for the irreversible path (Clausius inequality). -
MCQExam level
The entropy change of moles of an ideal gas heated reversibly at constant pressure from to isAnswer and solution
Answer: B
at constant pressure, so . Equivalently with . -
NATExam level
1 kg of water ( J kg K) at C is put in contact with a large reservoir at C until it reaches C. The entropy of the universe increases by ______ J/K.Answer and solution
Answer: 184 J/K (±1.5)
Water: J/K. Reservoir gives J at fixed K: J/K. Total J/K.