Home / Courses / LSAT prep / Practice / Method of reasoning

Method of reasoning

Describe the reasoning · 9 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Method of reasoning.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQStandard

    Some say that tomatoes are vegetables. But botanists define a fruit as the part of a plant that grows from the flower and holds the seeds, and tomatoes do exactly that. So tomatoes are fruit.

    The argument proceeds by

    1. applying a definition to a particular case
    2. drawing an analogy between two different things
    3. showing that a view leads to a contradiction
    4. generalising from a few examples
    5. citing an expert's personal opinion
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The argument gives the botanical definition of fruit and shows tomatoes meet it. That is applying a definition to a case.

  2. MCQStandard

    It is claimed that the new law will reduce littering. But a nearly identical law was passed in a neighbouring city five years ago, and littering there has not declined. So this law is unlikely to reduce littering either.

    The argument proceeds by

    1. appealing to the opinion of experts
    2. drawing an analogy between two similar cases
    3. attacking the character of the law’s supporters
    4. applying a definition to a particular case
    5. showing that a claim leads to a contradiction
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The argument predicts the result here from what happened with a "nearly identical law" elsewhere. That is an argument by analogy. B.

  3. MCQExam level

    Kai: Sugar taxes are pointless, because people will just buy sugary drinks anyway. Ana: When one country added a sugar tax, sales of sugary drinks fell by a quarter within two years.

    Ana responds to Kai by

    1. questioning Kai's motives
    2. offering evidence that conflicts with the assumption behind Kai's claim
    3. agreeing with Kai's conclusion but for a different reason
    4. pointing out that Kai uses a word in two senses
    5. claiming that sugar is harmless
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Kai assumes the tax does not change buying. Ana gives a real case where buying fell, which counts against that assumption.

  4. MCQExam level

    If the museum's claim were right that the vase is from the tenth century, it would have to be made with a glaze that, according to chemists, was not invented until the fourteenth century. So the vase cannot be from the tenth century.

    The argument proceeds by

    1. proposing a new explanation for an old fact
    2. arguing that because something is possible it is likely
    3. showing that a claim, if true, would lead to something known to be false
    4. appealing to the popularity of a view
    5. questioning the reliability of chemists
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The argument supposes the claim is true, shows it leads to an impossibility (a glaze that did not exist yet), and rejects the claim. That is reduction to the absurd.

  5. MCQExam level

    Some argue that all advertising is harmful because it manipulates people. But if all persuasion were harmful because it influences people, then teaching children to wash their hands would be harmful too, which no one believes.

    The argument proceeds by

    1. citing an authority who disagrees with the claim
    2. distinguishing two meanings of a word
    3. showing that the principle behind a claim, if accepted, would lead to an unacceptable result
    4. offering statistical evidence against a claim
    5. questioning the motives of those who make a claim
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The argument extends the reasoning to an obviously acceptable case (handwashing lessons) and shows it gives an absurd verdict. C.

  6. MCQHard

    Just as a gardener must pull weeds before they spread, a city must fix small problems like broken streetlights before they lead to larger decline. So the city should repair its streetlights promptly.

    The argument proceeds by

    1. rejecting an alternative as impossible
    2. appealing to an authority on city planning
    3. showing that a claim contradicts itself
    4. using a comparison with a similar situation to support a recommendation
    5. citing statistics about crime
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    The argument compares the city to a garden and uses what is true of weeds to support a recommendation about streetlights. That is reasoning by analogy.

  7. MCQHard

    Researcher: Some attribute the fall in the lake’s fish population to overfishing. But fishing in the lake was banned three years before the decline began. The decline more likely resulted from the dam built upstream that year.

    The argument proceeds by

    1. showing that two explanations are compatible
    2. appealing to the authority of fishery officials
    3. arguing that because two events occurred together, neither caused the other
    4. ruling out one explanation of a phenomenon and proposing another
    5. generalising from a single case to all lakes
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    The ban rules out overfishing; the dam is offered instead. D.

  8. MCQTop rank

    Researcher: The decline in local bee numbers has been blamed on a new pesticide. Yet bees have declined just as much in areas where the pesticide was never used, and bee numbers have also fallen in the many years before the pesticide was introduced. Something else must be the main cause.

    The researcher's argument proceeds by

    1. proving that a different cause is responsible
    2. arguing that the pesticide is harmless to all insects
    3. questioning the accuracy of bee counts
    4. showing that the proposed cause is present in cases where the effect is absent
    5. showing that the effect occurs where the proposed cause is absent
    Answer and solution

    Answer: E

    The researcher points to places and times where bees declined without the pesticide. Effect without the cause weakens the causal claim. D is the reverse pattern (cause without effect). A goes too far: the researcher never names the other cause.

    Why people get this wrong: D and E describe opposite patterns; read them carefully.

  9. MCQTop rank

    Critic: The novelist claims her books are not autobiographical. Yet she has said in interviews that every character she writes is based on someone she knows. Either her interviews or her claim must be mistaken.

    The argument proceeds by

    1. rejecting a claim because of the person who made it
    2. drawing a general conclusion from a single example
    3. showing that a claim is true by eliminating alternatives
    4. using an analogy to support a prediction
    5. pointing out an apparent inconsistency between two statements made by the same person
    Answer and solution

    Answer: E

    The critic sets two of the novelist’s own statements against each other and concludes one must be wrong. E. It does not reject either claim because of who she is, so A is wrong.

← All topics · Timed mock test →