Paradox
Inference and paradox · 9 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Resolve the paradox.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQStandard
After the city added a new lane to the highway, traffic jams on it became worse, not better.
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?
- Some drivers prefer the left lane.
- Traffic jams are common in big cities.
- The highway has speed cameras.
- The new lane was built quickly.
- The extra lane made the highway more attractive, so many drivers who used to take other routes or the train switched to it.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
More room should mean less traffic. E explains the surprise: the extra room drew more drivers, so traffic grew to fill it. Both facts can now be true together.
-
MCQStandard
A city made its buses free to ride. Ridership rose sharply, yet the number of cars on the city’s roads did not fall.
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?
- Most new bus riders had previously walked or cycled rather than driven.
- Buses produce less pollution per passenger than cars.
- The city also bought new buses.
- Some drivers dislike buses.
- Fuel prices rose during the year.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
If new riders came from walking and cycling, buses filled up without taking cars off the road. A. E would, if anything, push people out of cars, deepening the puzzle.
-
MCQExam level
A hospital that is famous for treating heart disease has a higher death rate among its heart patients than a small local hospital nearby.
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?
- The famous hospital takes the most serious heart cases from across the region, while the local hospital sends its serious cases there.
- The local hospital is newer.
- Some patients prefer smaller hospitals.
- Heart disease is the leading cause of death.
- The famous hospital has more doctors.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The famous hospital treats far sicker patients, so more of them die even if its care is better. A explains how the excellent hospital can have a worse death rate.
-
MCQExam level
Sales of umbrellas in the city were higher in the dry summer than in the rainy spring.
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?
- Umbrellas are cheaper in summer.
- In summer, many tourists buy umbrellas to shade themselves from the strong sun, and the city receives far more tourists in summer.
- Most umbrellas last several years.
- It rains in the city every month.
- Umbrella shops close in winter.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
B gives a second use for umbrellas (sun shade) and a large group of summer buyers (tourists). That explains high summer sales without rain. A could help a little, but price alone would not usually outweigh the need in rainy weather.
-
MCQExam level
Hospitals with the most experienced heart surgeons have higher death rates after heart surgery than hospitals with less experienced surgeons.
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?
- Heart surgery has become safer over time.
- The most difficult and high-risk heart cases are usually sent to hospitals with the most experienced surgeons.
- Experienced surgeons earn higher salaries.
- Some hospitals have no heart surgeons.
- Less experienced surgeons perform fewer operations.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
If experienced surgeons take the riskiest patients, higher death rates reflect the patients, not worse care. B.
-
MCQHard
In a region where wolves were brought back after decades away, the number of deer fell, yet the number of young aspen trees, which deer eat, rose sharply even in areas where deer numbers had not fallen much.
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?
- Other animals also eat aspen.
- Wolves eat some plants.
- With wolves around, deer avoid lingering in open valleys where aspens grow, even when the deer population is large.
- Aspen trees grow slowly.
- Deer numbers had been rising before the wolves returned.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The puzzle is that aspens recovered even where deer numbers stayed high. C explains it: deer change where they feed when wolves are present, so the aspens are eaten less without fewer deer.
Why people get this wrong: The answer must explain the part of the puzzle that seems odd, here the areas with many deer.
-
MCQHard
After a country raised the tax on cigarettes, the government’s revenue from the cigarette tax increased, even though the number of cigarettes sold fell.
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?
- The government spent the revenue on health care.
- Cigarettes are also sold in neighbouring countries.
- The tax rise per pack was large enough that the extra tax on each pack sold outweighed the drop in packs sold.
- Some smokers switched to cheaper brands.
- Smoking rates had been falling for years.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Revenue = tax per pack × packs. A big enough rise in the first outweighs a fall in the second. C. B would suggest cross-border buying, making the puzzle worse.
-
MCQTop rank
Since the factory introduced a bonus for every week without a reported injury, the number of reported injuries has fallen sharply. Yet the number of workers visiting the local clinic for work-related injuries has risen.
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?
- The bonus is paid weekly.
- Most injuries at the factory are minor.
- The clinic opened new hours.
- Some workers stopped reporting injuries at work to protect the team's bonus, and had them treated at the clinic instead.
- The factory hired more workers.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
D explains both facts at once: injuries did not really fall; reporting at work fell because of the bonus, and the injuries showed up at the clinic instead. E helps a little with clinic visits but would not explain a sharp fall in reports.
Why people get this wrong: The best answer explains both sides of the discrepancy.
-
MCQTop rank
In a region where a disease spread by mosquitoes is common, villages that received free bed nets reported more cases of the disease in the following year than villages that did not.
Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy described above?
- Some villagers did not use their nets.
- The disease is also found in other regions.
- Mosquitoes bite mainly at night.
- Free bed nets were given first to the villages that had the highest rates of the disease before the programme began.
- Bed nets can last several years.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
If the nets went to the worst-hit villages, they could still have more cases afterwards even if the nets helped. D. A explains only why the nets might not help, not why case counts were higher.
Why people get this wrong: Explaining only one side of the clash.