Home / Courses / LSAT prep / Practice / Point at issue

Point at issue

Describe the reasoning · 8 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Point at issue: where two speakers disagree.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQStandard

    Omar: Our town should build a public pool. Swimming is excellent exercise, and many families cannot afford private clubs.
    Beth: A pool would cost far more to run each year than the town can afford. The town should not build one.

    The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that Omar and Beth disagree over whether

    1. many families cannot afford private clubs
    2. the pool would be expensive to build
    3. exercise is important
    4. swimming is good exercise
    5. the town should build a public pool
    Answer and solution

    Answer: E

    Omar says the town should build a pool; Beth says it should not. Beth never challenges the exercise or affordability points, so we cannot say they disagree about those.

    Why people get this wrong: A correct answer needs a view from both speakers.

  2. MCQStandard

    Lena: Schools should start later in the morning. Teenagers who get more sleep do better in class.
    Dev: Starting later would push after-school sports and jobs into the evening. Schools should keep their current start times.

    The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that Lena and Dev disagree over whether

    1. schools should start later in the morning
    2. teenagers who get more sleep do better in class
    3. after-school sports are valuable
    4. teenagers have after-school jobs
    5. school buses are expensive
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Lena says schools should start later; Dev says they should keep current times. A. Dev never disputes the sleep claim (B).

  3. MCQExam level

    Ines: Remote work raises productivity, since workers save time on commuting.
    Paul: Saving time on commuting is real, but many remote workers are interrupted more at home, so overall productivity does not rise.

    The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that Ines and Paul disagree over whether

    1. remote work raises productivity
    2. remote workers are interrupted at home
    3. commuting is tiring
    4. offices should close
    5. remote workers save time on commuting
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    Paul agrees that commuting time is saved ("is real") but denies that productivity rises. Ines claims it rises. So they disagree over A and agree on E.

    Why people get this wrong: Watch for concessions: Paul agrees with E.

  4. MCQExam level

    Aiko: The council’s plan to plant trees on Market Street will make the street more pleasant and attract shoppers.
    Rafael: The trees will certainly make the street more pleasant. But shoppers choose where to go based on prices and parking, not trees.

    The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that Aiko and Rafael disagree over whether

    1. parking on Market Street is limited
    2. planting trees on Market Street will attract shoppers
    3. trees will make Market Street more pleasant
    4. shoppers care about prices
    5. the council should plant trees
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Rafael agrees the trees will make the street pleasant but denies they will attract shoppers. B. C is a point of agreement.

    Why people get this wrong: Choosing a point the second speaker concedes.

  5. MCQHard

    Critic: The novel's ending is weak because it leaves the main mystery unsolved.
    Writer: An unsolved mystery can be a strength. It leaves readers thinking about the story long after they finish it, which is what makes this ending powerful.

    The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that the critic and the writer disagree over whether

    1. the novel leaves the main mystery unsolved
    2. the novel's ending is weak
    3. readers think about the story after finishing it
    4. all novels should solve their mysteries
    5. the novel is popular
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    Both accept that the mystery is unsolved. The critic says this makes the ending weak; the writer says it makes the ending powerful. They disagree over whether the ending is weak. D goes beyond what the critic said about this novel.

  6. MCQHard

    Nadia: The museum should allow photography. Visitors who share photos online bring in new visitors, and modern cameras do not damage paintings.
    Owen: Flash photography can fade some pigments over time, so allowing photography would put the collection at risk.

    The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that Nadia and Owen disagree over whether

    1. some pigments are older than others
    2. visitors enjoy taking photographs
    3. allowing photography would put the paintings at risk of damage
    4. photos shared online bring in new visitors
    5. the museum needs more visitors
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Nadia says cameras do not damage paintings; Owen says photography risks fading. They clash on C. Owen says nothing about online sharing.

  7. MCQTop rank

    Lena: The study proves that the reading programme works: children in it read better after a year.
    Marco: Children read better after any year of school. Without a comparison group, the study does not show the programme made a difference, though it may well have.

    The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that Lena and Marco disagree over whether

    1. a comparison group is impossible to arrange
    2. children in the programme read better after a year
    3. the study shows that the reading programme made a difference
    4. the reading programme does not work
    5. children read better after a year of school
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    Marco accepts that the children improved and even says the programme "may well" have worked. He denies only that the study shows it. Lena says the study proves it. So they disagree over C. D is a trap: Marco never says the programme fails.

  8. MCQTop rank

    Grace: Because the new vaccine prevented infection in 90 percent of trial participants, it will greatly reduce infections once it is given to the public.
    Hamid: The trial participants were all healthy adults. The public includes many older people and people with weak immune systems, in whom vaccines often work less well.

    The dialogue provides the most support for the claim that Grace and Hamid disagree over whether

    1. vaccines often work less well in older people
    2. the trial participants were healthy adults
    3. the vaccine should be given to the public
    4. the trial results justify the prediction that the vaccine will greatly reduce infections in the public
    5. the vaccine prevented infection in 90 percent of trial participants
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    Hamid accepts the trial result but questions whether it carries over to the public. The dispute is whether the trial supports Grace’s prediction, D. Hamid does not deny E.

← All topics · Timed mock test →