Detail and inference
Reading Comprehension · 23 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Detail and inference questions.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQStandard
Beneath most forests runs a network of fungal threads, called mycorrhizae, that wrap around tree roots or grow into them. The relationship is an exchange. The fungi, which cannot make their own food, receive sugars that trees produce through photosynthesis. In return, their threads, far thinner and more numerous than roots, gather water and minerals such as phosphorus from a volume of soil the tree could never reach alone.
Because a single fungus can connect to many trees at once, researchers in the 1990s began to ask whether these networks also carry resources between trees. Experiments using carbon isotopes as tracers showed that they can: carbon fixed by one tree turned up in the roots of its neighbours. Popular accounts soon described a "wood-wide web" through which mother trees feed their seedlings and warn neighbours of insect attacks.
More recent reviews have urged caution. The amount of carbon moved between trees in most field studies is small, often a few percent of what a seedling needs, and it is not always clear whether it travels through fungal threads or through the soil. Moreover, the fungi are not neutral carriers. They move resources along whichever paths benefit the fungi themselves, which may or may not coincide with the needs of any tree. The underground network is real, and it is important to forest health, but the image of trees deliberately caring for one another goes well beyond the evidence.
According to the passage, what do the fungi receive from trees?
- water gathered by the roots
- phosphorus from deep soil
- carbon isotopes
- protection from insects
- sugars produced by photosynthesis
Answer and solution
Answer: E
Paragraph 1: the fungi "receive sugars that trees produce through photosynthesis". Water and phosphorus go the other way, from fungi to trees.
Why people get this wrong: Reversing which partner gives what.
-
MCQExam level
Beneath most forests runs a network of fungal threads, called mycorrhizae, that wrap around tree roots or grow into them. The relationship is an exchange. The fungi, which cannot make their own food, receive sugars that trees produce through photosynthesis. In return, their threads, far thinner and more numerous than roots, gather water and minerals such as phosphorus from a volume of soil the tree could never reach alone.
Because a single fungus can connect to many trees at once, researchers in the 1990s began to ask whether these networks also carry resources between trees. Experiments using carbon isotopes as tracers showed that they can: carbon fixed by one tree turned up in the roots of its neighbours. Popular accounts soon described a "wood-wide web" through which mother trees feed their seedlings and warn neighbours of insect attacks.
More recent reviews have urged caution. The amount of carbon moved between trees in most field studies is small, often a few percent of what a seedling needs, and it is not always clear whether it travels through fungal threads or through the soil. Moreover, the fungi are not neutral carriers. They move resources along whichever paths benefit the fungi themselves, which may or may not coincide with the needs of any tree. The underground network is real, and it is important to forest health, but the image of trees deliberately caring for one another goes well beyond the evidence.
The passage states that the experiments of the 1990s used carbon isotopes in order to
- trace whether carbon fixed by one tree reached other trees
- measure how fast trees grow
- kill harmful fungi
- count the fungal threads in a forest
- show that seedlings make no carbon of their own
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The isotopes were "tracers": carbon fixed by one tree "turned up in the roots of its neighbours". That is tracing movement between trees.
-
MCQExam level
Water is usually described as essential to life, and for most organisms the description is accurate: a cell that loses most of its water suffers damage it cannot repair. Yet a scattered group of organisms, including certain mosses, roundworms and the microscopic animals known as tardigrades, can lose nearly all their water, remain dry and motionless for years, and then resume normal activity within hours of being wetted. Biologists call this state anhydrobiosis, "life without water."
The danger of drying is not simply the absence of water but what happens to the cell’s other contents as water leaves. Proteins fold into precise shapes that depend on surrounding water molecules; as the cell dries, they tend to unfold and stick to one another, and the membranes that enclose the cell and its compartments can fuse or rupture. An organism that survives drying must somehow hold these structures in place.
For several decades the leading explanation centred on a sugar called trehalose. Some anhydrobiotic organisms, such as brine shrimp and certain roundworms, accumulate large amounts of it as they dry. Trehalose appears to replace water around proteins and membranes and, as drying finishes, to form a glassy solid in which the cell’s contents are suspended, unable to move far enough to collide and clump. Experiments in which trehalose protected isolated proteins and membranes from drying damage supported this picture.
Tardigrades complicated it. Measurements found that many tardigrade species produce little or no trehalose, far too little to explain their resistance. Researchers searching for an alternative identified a family of proteins found in tardigrades and not, so far as is known, in other animals. These proteins have no fixed shape in solution; as the animal dries, they too appear to form a glass-like material. When the genes for them were inserted into yeast and bacteria, those organisms became noticeably more tolerant of drying, and when their activity was reduced in tardigrades, the animals survived drying less often.
The discovery does not overturn the trehalose explanation so much as reveal that it described one solution among several. Different lineages, it now appears, arrived at the same basic strategy, turning the drying cell’s interior to glass, using different molecules. The finding has drawn interest beyond biology, from researchers who hope that similar materials might one day let vaccines and medicines be stored without refrigeration.
According to the passage, one danger a drying cell faces is that
- it forms a glassy solid
- its proteins tend to unfold and stick together
- it produces too much trehalose
- its genes are inserted into other organisms
- it absorbs water too quickly when wetted
Answer and solution
Answer: B
Paragraph 2: proteins "tend to unfold and stick to one another" and membranes may fuse or rupture. B. Forming glass (A) is the protection, not the danger.
-
MCQExam level
Water is usually described as essential to life, and for most organisms the description is accurate: a cell that loses most of its water suffers damage it cannot repair. Yet a scattered group of organisms, including certain mosses, roundworms and the microscopic animals known as tardigrades, can lose nearly all their water, remain dry and motionless for years, and then resume normal activity within hours of being wetted. Biologists call this state anhydrobiosis, "life without water."
The danger of drying is not simply the absence of water but what happens to the cell’s other contents as water leaves. Proteins fold into precise shapes that depend on surrounding water molecules; as the cell dries, they tend to unfold and stick to one another, and the membranes that enclose the cell and its compartments can fuse or rupture. An organism that survives drying must somehow hold these structures in place.
For several decades the leading explanation centred on a sugar called trehalose. Some anhydrobiotic organisms, such as brine shrimp and certain roundworms, accumulate large amounts of it as they dry. Trehalose appears to replace water around proteins and membranes and, as drying finishes, to form a glassy solid in which the cell’s contents are suspended, unable to move far enough to collide and clump. Experiments in which trehalose protected isolated proteins and membranes from drying damage supported this picture.
Tardigrades complicated it. Measurements found that many tardigrade species produce little or no trehalose, far too little to explain their resistance. Researchers searching for an alternative identified a family of proteins found in tardigrades and not, so far as is known, in other animals. These proteins have no fixed shape in solution; as the animal dries, they too appear to form a glass-like material. When the genes for them were inserted into yeast and bacteria, those organisms became noticeably more tolerant of drying, and when their activity was reduced in tardigrades, the animals survived drying less often.
The discovery does not overturn the trehalose explanation so much as reveal that it described one solution among several. Different lineages, it now appears, arrived at the same basic strategy, turning the drying cell’s interior to glass, using different molecules. The finding has drawn interest beyond biology, from researchers who hope that similar materials might one day let vaccines and medicines be stored without refrigeration.
The passage states that tardigrades complicated the trehalose explanation because
- tardigrades live only in water
- brine shrimp produce no trehalose
- many tardigrade species produce far too little trehalose to account for their resistance to drying
- tardigrades die when they are dried
- trehalose was found to damage proteins
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Paragraph 4 opens with C. B reverses paragraph 3, where brine shrimp accumulate large amounts.
-
MCQExam level
Consumer contracts, the terms a person accepts when opening a bank account, renting a car or signing up for a phone plan, are famously hard to read. They are long, written in dense legal vocabulary and arranged in a way that buries important terms among routine ones. Studies of consumer behaviour consistently find that almost no one reads them in full. The law nonetheless treats a person who signs, or clicks "I agree," as bound by every term.
Defenders of traditional drafting offer two justifications. First, legal terms have settled meanings, established by years of court decisions; replacing them with everyday words, which are vaguer, would create uncertainty and lead to more disputes. Second, since consumers do not read contracts anyway, the style in which they are written makes little practical difference.
Neither argument withstands close examination. The first overstates both the precision of legal language and the vagueness of ordinary English. Many traditional phrases survive not because they have a fixed meaning but because drafters copy them from older documents; some, such as pairs of near-synonyms, add length without adding meaning. Where a technical term really is needed, a plain-language contract can use it and explain it. Several jurisdictions that require consumer contracts to be written in plain language have not reported any increase in litigation as a result.
The second argument mistakes an effect for a cause. Consumers may skip contracts precisely because they know the documents will be impenetrable. When terms are short and clearly arranged, at least some readers check the provisions that matter most to them, such as fees, cancellation rights and automatic renewals. And readership by individual consumers is not the only benefit. Clear contracts are easier for consumer advocates and journalists to compare, and when a company’s unfavourable terms can be understood at a glance, competitors have a reason to advertise better ones.
None of this requires abandoning the principle that a person is bound by what they sign. It requires only that the law take seriously the condition that makes the principle fair: that the terms could, with reasonable effort, actually have been understood.
According to the passage, defenders of traditional drafting argue that
- consumer contracts are usually short
- courts refuse to enforce contracts no one has read
- legal terms have settled meanings established by court decisions
- consumers read contracts carefully before signing
- plain-language contracts are cheaper to write
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Paragraph 2 gives two arguments; C is the first. D contradicts their second argument, which assumes consumers do not read.
-
MCQExam level
Consumer contracts, the terms a person accepts when opening a bank account, renting a car or signing up for a phone plan, are famously hard to read. They are long, written in dense legal vocabulary and arranged in a way that buries important terms among routine ones. Studies of consumer behaviour consistently find that almost no one reads them in full. The law nonetheless treats a person who signs, or clicks "I agree," as bound by every term.
Defenders of traditional drafting offer two justifications. First, legal terms have settled meanings, established by years of court decisions; replacing them with everyday words, which are vaguer, would create uncertainty and lead to more disputes. Second, since consumers do not read contracts anyway, the style in which they are written makes little practical difference.
Neither argument withstands close examination. The first overstates both the precision of legal language and the vagueness of ordinary English. Many traditional phrases survive not because they have a fixed meaning but because drafters copy them from older documents; some, such as pairs of near-synonyms, add length without adding meaning. Where a technical term really is needed, a plain-language contract can use it and explain it. Several jurisdictions that require consumer contracts to be written in plain language have not reported any increase in litigation as a result.
The second argument mistakes an effect for a cause. Consumers may skip contracts precisely because they know the documents will be impenetrable. When terms are short and clearly arranged, at least some readers check the provisions that matter most to them, such as fees, cancellation rights and automatic renewals. And readership by individual consumers is not the only benefit. Clear contracts are easier for consumer advocates and journalists to compare, and when a company’s unfavourable terms can be understood at a glance, competitors have a reason to advertise better ones.
None of this requires abandoning the principle that a person is bound by what they sign. It requires only that the law take seriously the condition that makes the principle fair: that the terms could, with reasonable effort, actually have been understood.
The passage cites the experience of jurisdictions that require plain-language contracts as evidence that
- legal terms are never needed
- companies have stopped using automatic renewals
- courts prefer traditional drafting
- plain language has not led to more litigation
- consumers now read every contract in full
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Paragraph 3: they "have not reported any increase in litigation as a result", answering the worry that plain words cause more disputes. D.
-
MCQExam level
Craft guilds, the associations of master artisans that regulated trades such as weaving, metalworking and baking in many medieval and early modern European towns, have long had a poor reputation among economists. In the classic account, guilds were cartels. By limiting the number of masters, fixing prices and forbidding outsiders to practise the trade, they raised their members’ incomes at the expense of customers and of the many workers kept out. Their eventual abolition, on this account, freed markets that had been held back for centuries.
A number of historians have argued that this picture leaves out what guilds did for buyers. In a world without brand names, standardised measures or reliable courts, a customer buying cloth or silver faced a serious problem: it was hard to tell good work from bad before purchase, and costly to seek a remedy afterwards. Guilds addressed this by inspecting goods and stamping approved items with a mark, by enforcing rules on materials, such as the proportion of pure metal in silverware, and by punishing members whose work fell short. A buyer from a distant town who saw the mark of a respected guild could trust the goods without knowing the maker. On this view, guilds lowered the cost of trust and so made trade possible that would otherwise not have occurred.
The two accounts need not exclude each other, and the most careful recent work treats them as describing different sides of the same institution. The same powers that let a guild guarantee quality, the power to inspect and to exclude, also let it restrict entry and keep prices high. Which side predominated seems to have depended on circumstances. Where a town’s goods were sold mainly to distant buyers, a guild’s reputation was its members’ most valuable asset, and quality rules were enforced strictly. Where guilds served a captive local market, the evidence of price fixing and exclusion is stronger.
The question matters beyond economic history. Modern professions, from medicine to law, also combine licensing that protects the public with barriers to entry that protect members, and debates about them often repeat the old disagreement. The history of guilds suggests that asking whether such bodies are good or bad is less useful than asking under what conditions their protective function outweighs their restrictive one.
According to the passage, the classic account holds that guilds
- were abolished because they failed to inspect goods
- served only distant buyers
- were the origin of modern brand names
- raised members’ incomes at the expense of customers and excluded workers
- protected buyers from poor-quality goods
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Paragraph 1 gives the "cartel" account: D. E is the historians’ alternative view.
-
MCQExam level
Craft guilds, the associations of master artisans that regulated trades such as weaving, metalworking and baking in many medieval and early modern European towns, have long had a poor reputation among economists. In the classic account, guilds were cartels. By limiting the number of masters, fixing prices and forbidding outsiders to practise the trade, they raised their members’ incomes at the expense of customers and of the many workers kept out. Their eventual abolition, on this account, freed markets that had been held back for centuries.
A number of historians have argued that this picture leaves out what guilds did for buyers. In a world without brand names, standardised measures or reliable courts, a customer buying cloth or silver faced a serious problem: it was hard to tell good work from bad before purchase, and costly to seek a remedy afterwards. Guilds addressed this by inspecting goods and stamping approved items with a mark, by enforcing rules on materials, such as the proportion of pure metal in silverware, and by punishing members whose work fell short. A buyer from a distant town who saw the mark of a respected guild could trust the goods without knowing the maker. On this view, guilds lowered the cost of trust and so made trade possible that would otherwise not have occurred.
The two accounts need not exclude each other, and the most careful recent work treats them as describing different sides of the same institution. The same powers that let a guild guarantee quality, the power to inspect and to exclude, also let it restrict entry and keep prices high. Which side predominated seems to have depended on circumstances. Where a town’s goods were sold mainly to distant buyers, a guild’s reputation was its members’ most valuable asset, and quality rules were enforced strictly. Where guilds served a captive local market, the evidence of price fixing and exclusion is stronger.
The question matters beyond economic history. Modern professions, from medicine to law, also combine licensing that protects the public with barriers to entry that protect members, and debates about them often repeat the old disagreement. The history of guilds suggests that asking whether such bodies are good or bad is less useful than asking under what conditions their protective function outweighs their restrictive one.
The passage mentions the proportion of pure metal in silverware as an example of
- a price that guilds fixed
- a reason guilds were abolished
- a mark stamped on approved goods
- a modern licensing requirement
- a rule about materials that a guild enforced
Answer and solution
Answer: E
"by enforcing rules on materials, such as the proportion of pure metal in silverware". E.
-
MCQHard
Beneath most forests runs a network of fungal threads, called mycorrhizae, that wrap around tree roots or grow into them. The relationship is an exchange. The fungi, which cannot make their own food, receive sugars that trees produce through photosynthesis. In return, their threads, far thinner and more numerous than roots, gather water and minerals such as phosphorus from a volume of soil the tree could never reach alone.
Because a single fungus can connect to many trees at once, researchers in the 1990s began to ask whether these networks also carry resources between trees. Experiments using carbon isotopes as tracers showed that they can: carbon fixed by one tree turned up in the roots of its neighbours. Popular accounts soon described a "wood-wide web" through which mother trees feed their seedlings and warn neighbours of insect attacks.
More recent reviews have urged caution. The amount of carbon moved between trees in most field studies is small, often a few percent of what a seedling needs, and it is not always clear whether it travels through fungal threads or through the soil. Moreover, the fungi are not neutral carriers. They move resources along whichever paths benefit the fungi themselves, which may or may not coincide with the needs of any tree. The underground network is real, and it is important to forest health, but the image of trees deliberately caring for one another goes well beyond the evidence.
It can be inferred from the passage that the authors of the "more recent reviews" would most likely agree that
- fungi always act in the interest of the oldest tree
- some carbon may reach seedlings by routes other than fungal threads
- mycorrhizal networks do not exist
- trees deliberately send carbon to their offspring
- seedlings get most of their carbon from neighbouring trees
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The reviews say "it is not always clear whether it travels through fungal threads or through the soil", so they would accept that some may travel through soil. They do not deny the network exists ("The underground network is real").
-
MCQHard
Beneath most forests runs a network of fungal threads, called mycorrhizae, that wrap around tree roots or grow into them. The relationship is an exchange. The fungi, which cannot make their own food, receive sugars that trees produce through photosynthesis. In return, their threads, far thinner and more numerous than roots, gather water and minerals such as phosphorus from a volume of soil the tree could never reach alone.
Because a single fungus can connect to many trees at once, researchers in the 1990s began to ask whether these networks also carry resources between trees. Experiments using carbon isotopes as tracers showed that they can: carbon fixed by one tree turned up in the roots of its neighbours. Popular accounts soon described a "wood-wide web" through which mother trees feed their seedlings and warn neighbours of insect attacks.
More recent reviews have urged caution. The amount of carbon moved between trees in most field studies is small, often a few percent of what a seedling needs, and it is not always clear whether it travels through fungal threads or through the soil. Moreover, the fungi are not neutral carriers. They move resources along whichever paths benefit the fungi themselves, which may or may not coincide with the needs of any tree. The underground network is real, and it is important to forest health, but the image of trees deliberately caring for one another goes well beyond the evidence.
The passage suggests that the popular "wood-wide web" accounts are flawed mainly because they
- claim that fungi make their own food
- ignore the role of phosphorus
- attribute purposes to trees that the evidence does not support
- deny that fungi connect to more than one tree
- are based on experiments without tracers
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The last sentence says the image of trees "deliberately caring for one another goes well beyond the evidence". The flaw is reading intention into the network.
-
MCQHard
Water is usually described as essential to life, and for most organisms the description is accurate: a cell that loses most of its water suffers damage it cannot repair. Yet a scattered group of organisms, including certain mosses, roundworms and the microscopic animals known as tardigrades, can lose nearly all their water, remain dry and motionless for years, and then resume normal activity within hours of being wetted. Biologists call this state anhydrobiosis, "life without water."
The danger of drying is not simply the absence of water but what happens to the cell’s other contents as water leaves. Proteins fold into precise shapes that depend on surrounding water molecules; as the cell dries, they tend to unfold and stick to one another, and the membranes that enclose the cell and its compartments can fuse or rupture. An organism that survives drying must somehow hold these structures in place.
For several decades the leading explanation centred on a sugar called trehalose. Some anhydrobiotic organisms, such as brine shrimp and certain roundworms, accumulate large amounts of it as they dry. Trehalose appears to replace water around proteins and membranes and, as drying finishes, to form a glassy solid in which the cell’s contents are suspended, unable to move far enough to collide and clump. Experiments in which trehalose protected isolated proteins and membranes from drying damage supported this picture.
Tardigrades complicated it. Measurements found that many tardigrade species produce little or no trehalose, far too little to explain their resistance. Researchers searching for an alternative identified a family of proteins found in tardigrades and not, so far as is known, in other animals. These proteins have no fixed shape in solution; as the animal dries, they too appear to form a glass-like material. When the genes for them were inserted into yeast and bacteria, those organisms became noticeably more tolerant of drying, and when their activity was reduced in tardigrades, the animals survived drying less often.
The discovery does not overturn the trehalose explanation so much as reveal that it described one solution among several. Different lineages, it now appears, arrived at the same basic strategy, turning the drying cell’s interior to glass, using different molecules. The finding has drawn interest beyond biology, from researchers who hope that similar materials might one day let vaccines and medicines be stored without refrigeration.
It can be inferred from the passage that the tardigrade proteins and trehalose are similar in that both
- have a fixed shape in solution
- were first discovered in yeast
- are sugars
- appear to protect cells by forming a glass-like material as drying finishes
- are found in every animal
Answer and solution
Answer: D
Trehalose forms "a glassy solid"; the proteins "too appear to form a glass-like material". The last paragraph names the shared strategy: "turning the drying cell’s interior to glass". D. The proteins have "no fixed shape", so A is wrong.
-
MCQHard
Water is usually described as essential to life, and for most organisms the description is accurate: a cell that loses most of its water suffers damage it cannot repair. Yet a scattered group of organisms, including certain mosses, roundworms and the microscopic animals known as tardigrades, can lose nearly all their water, remain dry and motionless for years, and then resume normal activity within hours of being wetted. Biologists call this state anhydrobiosis, "life without water."
The danger of drying is not simply the absence of water but what happens to the cell’s other contents as water leaves. Proteins fold into precise shapes that depend on surrounding water molecules; as the cell dries, they tend to unfold and stick to one another, and the membranes that enclose the cell and its compartments can fuse or rupture. An organism that survives drying must somehow hold these structures in place.
For several decades the leading explanation centred on a sugar called trehalose. Some anhydrobiotic organisms, such as brine shrimp and certain roundworms, accumulate large amounts of it as they dry. Trehalose appears to replace water around proteins and membranes and, as drying finishes, to form a glassy solid in which the cell’s contents are suspended, unable to move far enough to collide and clump. Experiments in which trehalose protected isolated proteins and membranes from drying damage supported this picture.
Tardigrades complicated it. Measurements found that many tardigrade species produce little or no trehalose, far too little to explain their resistance. Researchers searching for an alternative identified a family of proteins found in tardigrades and not, so far as is known, in other animals. These proteins have no fixed shape in solution; as the animal dries, they too appear to form a glass-like material. When the genes for them were inserted into yeast and bacteria, those organisms became noticeably more tolerant of drying, and when their activity was reduced in tardigrades, the animals survived drying less often.
The discovery does not overturn the trehalose explanation so much as reveal that it described one solution among several. Different lineages, it now appears, arrived at the same basic strategy, turning the drying cell’s interior to glass, using different molecules. The finding has drawn interest beyond biology, from researchers who hope that similar materials might one day let vaccines and medicines be stored without refrigeration.
Which one of the following findings described in the passage most directly supports the claim that the tardigrade proteins help protect against drying?
- Tardigrades can stay dry for years.
- Brine shrimp accumulate trehalose as they dry.
- Proteins depend on water molecules to keep their shape.
- Some mosses survive drying.
- Yeast and bacteria given the genes for the proteins became more tolerant of drying.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
Adding the genes made other organisms more drying-tolerant, which is direct evidence that the proteins do the protecting. E. (Reducing their activity in tardigrades is further support.)
-
MCQHard
Consumer contracts, the terms a person accepts when opening a bank account, renting a car or signing up for a phone plan, are famously hard to read. They are long, written in dense legal vocabulary and arranged in a way that buries important terms among routine ones. Studies of consumer behaviour consistently find that almost no one reads them in full. The law nonetheless treats a person who signs, or clicks "I agree," as bound by every term.
Defenders of traditional drafting offer two justifications. First, legal terms have settled meanings, established by years of court decisions; replacing them with everyday words, which are vaguer, would create uncertainty and lead to more disputes. Second, since consumers do not read contracts anyway, the style in which they are written makes little practical difference.
Neither argument withstands close examination. The first overstates both the precision of legal language and the vagueness of ordinary English. Many traditional phrases survive not because they have a fixed meaning but because drafters copy them from older documents; some, such as pairs of near-synonyms, add length without adding meaning. Where a technical term really is needed, a plain-language contract can use it and explain it. Several jurisdictions that require consumer contracts to be written in plain language have not reported any increase in litigation as a result.
The second argument mistakes an effect for a cause. Consumers may skip contracts precisely because they know the documents will be impenetrable. When terms are short and clearly arranged, at least some readers check the provisions that matter most to them, such as fees, cancellation rights and automatic renewals. And readership by individual consumers is not the only benefit. Clear contracts are easier for consumer advocates and journalists to compare, and when a company’s unfavourable terms can be understood at a glance, competitors have a reason to advertise better ones.
None of this requires abandoning the principle that a person is bound by what they sign. It requires only that the law take seriously the condition that makes the principle fair: that the terms could, with reasonable effort, actually have been understood.
In saying that the second argument "mistakes an effect for a cause," the author means that
- courts have caused consumers to stop reading
- plain language causes consumers to stop reading
- consumers who read contracts cause companies to change them
- the cause of long contracts is that consumers demand them
- consumers’ failure to read contracts may result from the contracts being impenetrable rather than being a fixed fact that makes style irrelevant
Answer and solution
Answer: E
Defenders treat non-reading as a given; the author says people skip contracts "precisely because they know the documents will be impenetrable". The style partly causes the non-reading. E.
-
MCQHard
Consumer contracts, the terms a person accepts when opening a bank account, renting a car or signing up for a phone plan, are famously hard to read. They are long, written in dense legal vocabulary and arranged in a way that buries important terms among routine ones. Studies of consumer behaviour consistently find that almost no one reads them in full. The law nonetheless treats a person who signs, or clicks "I agree," as bound by every term.
Defenders of traditional drafting offer two justifications. First, legal terms have settled meanings, established by years of court decisions; replacing them with everyday words, which are vaguer, would create uncertainty and lead to more disputes. Second, since consumers do not read contracts anyway, the style in which they are written makes little practical difference.
Neither argument withstands close examination. The first overstates both the precision of legal language and the vagueness of ordinary English. Many traditional phrases survive not because they have a fixed meaning but because drafters copy them from older documents; some, such as pairs of near-synonyms, add length without adding meaning. Where a technical term really is needed, a plain-language contract can use it and explain it. Several jurisdictions that require consumer contracts to be written in plain language have not reported any increase in litigation as a result.
The second argument mistakes an effect for a cause. Consumers may skip contracts precisely because they know the documents will be impenetrable. When terms are short and clearly arranged, at least some readers check the provisions that matter most to them, such as fees, cancellation rights and automatic renewals. And readership by individual consumers is not the only benefit. Clear contracts are easier for consumer advocates and journalists to compare, and when a company’s unfavourable terms can be understood at a glance, competitors have a reason to advertise better ones.
None of this requires abandoning the principle that a person is bound by what they sign. It requires only that the law take seriously the condition that makes the principle fair: that the terms could, with reasonable effort, actually have been understood.
The author would most likely agree with which one of the following?
- Clear contract terms can benefit consumers even when most individual consumers do not read them.
- Technical legal terms should never appear in consumer contracts.
- People should not be bound by contracts they have not read.
- Pairs of near-synonyms make contracts more precise.
- Journalists are more careful readers than consumers.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Paragraph 4: advocates, journalists and competitors benefit from clear terms. A. B contradicts "a plain-language contract can use it and explain it"; C contradicts the last paragraph.
-
MCQHard
Craft guilds, the associations of master artisans that regulated trades such as weaving, metalworking and baking in many medieval and early modern European towns, have long had a poor reputation among economists. In the classic account, guilds were cartels. By limiting the number of masters, fixing prices and forbidding outsiders to practise the trade, they raised their members’ incomes at the expense of customers and of the many workers kept out. Their eventual abolition, on this account, freed markets that had been held back for centuries.
A number of historians have argued that this picture leaves out what guilds did for buyers. In a world without brand names, standardised measures or reliable courts, a customer buying cloth or silver faced a serious problem: it was hard to tell good work from bad before purchase, and costly to seek a remedy afterwards. Guilds addressed this by inspecting goods and stamping approved items with a mark, by enforcing rules on materials, such as the proportion of pure metal in silverware, and by punishing members whose work fell short. A buyer from a distant town who saw the mark of a respected guild could trust the goods without knowing the maker. On this view, guilds lowered the cost of trust and so made trade possible that would otherwise not have occurred.
The two accounts need not exclude each other, and the most careful recent work treats them as describing different sides of the same institution. The same powers that let a guild guarantee quality, the power to inspect and to exclude, also let it restrict entry and keep prices high. Which side predominated seems to have depended on circumstances. Where a town’s goods were sold mainly to distant buyers, a guild’s reputation was its members’ most valuable asset, and quality rules were enforced strictly. Where guilds served a captive local market, the evidence of price fixing and exclusion is stronger.
The question matters beyond economic history. Modern professions, from medicine to law, also combine licensing that protects the public with barriers to entry that protect members, and debates about them often repeat the old disagreement. The history of guilds suggests that asking whether such bodies are good or bad is less useful than asking under what conditions their protective function outweighs their restrictive one.
It can be inferred from the passage that a guild selling mainly to distant buyers would be likely to
- enforce its quality rules strictly to protect its reputation
- show the strongest evidence of price fixing
- have no mark of approval
- allow anyone to join
- stop inspecting goods
Answer and solution
Answer: A
Paragraph 3: where goods went to distant buyers, reputation was "most valuable" and "quality rules were enforced strictly". A. B matches captive local markets.
-
MCQHard
Craft guilds, the associations of master artisans that regulated trades such as weaving, metalworking and baking in many medieval and early modern European towns, have long had a poor reputation among economists. In the classic account, guilds were cartels. By limiting the number of masters, fixing prices and forbidding outsiders to practise the trade, they raised their members’ incomes at the expense of customers and of the many workers kept out. Their eventual abolition, on this account, freed markets that had been held back for centuries.
A number of historians have argued that this picture leaves out what guilds did for buyers. In a world without brand names, standardised measures or reliable courts, a customer buying cloth or silver faced a serious problem: it was hard to tell good work from bad before purchase, and costly to seek a remedy afterwards. Guilds addressed this by inspecting goods and stamping approved items with a mark, by enforcing rules on materials, such as the proportion of pure metal in silverware, and by punishing members whose work fell short. A buyer from a distant town who saw the mark of a respected guild could trust the goods without knowing the maker. On this view, guilds lowered the cost of trust and so made trade possible that would otherwise not have occurred.
The two accounts need not exclude each other, and the most careful recent work treats them as describing different sides of the same institution. The same powers that let a guild guarantee quality, the power to inspect and to exclude, also let it restrict entry and keep prices high. Which side predominated seems to have depended on circumstances. Where a town’s goods were sold mainly to distant buyers, a guild’s reputation was its members’ most valuable asset, and quality rules were enforced strictly. Where guilds served a captive local market, the evidence of price fixing and exclusion is stronger.
The question matters beyond economic history. Modern professions, from medicine to law, also combine licensing that protects the public with barriers to entry that protect members, and debates about them often repeat the old disagreement. The history of guilds suggests that asking whether such bodies are good or bad is less useful than asking under what conditions their protective function outweighs their restrictive one.
Which one of the following best expresses the point of the claim that the same powers let a guild both guarantee quality and restrict entry?
- Guilds had no power to keep prices high.
- The protective and restrictive sides of guilds came from one set of powers, so the two accounts describe one institution.
- Guilds always used their powers in the same way.
- Inspection was unrelated to the power to exclude.
- The classic account is simply false.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The paragraph says the accounts describe "different sides of the same institution" because inspection and exclusion powers serve both ends. B. E is too strong.
-
MCQTop rank
Beneath most forests runs a network of fungal threads, called mycorrhizae, that wrap around tree roots or grow into them. The relationship is an exchange. The fungi, which cannot make their own food, receive sugars that trees produce through photosynthesis. In return, their threads, far thinner and more numerous than roots, gather water and minerals such as phosphorus from a volume of soil the tree could never reach alone.
Because a single fungus can connect to many trees at once, researchers in the 1990s began to ask whether these networks also carry resources between trees. Experiments using carbon isotopes as tracers showed that they can: carbon fixed by one tree turned up in the roots of its neighbours. Popular accounts soon described a "wood-wide web" through which mother trees feed their seedlings and warn neighbours of insect attacks.
More recent reviews have urged caution. The amount of carbon moved between trees in most field studies is small, often a few percent of what a seedling needs, and it is not always clear whether it travels through fungal threads or through the soil. Moreover, the fungi are not neutral carriers. They move resources along whichever paths benefit the fungi themselves, which may or may not coincide with the needs of any tree. The underground network is real, and it is important to forest health, but the image of trees deliberately caring for one another goes well beyond the evidence.
Which one of the following findings would most clearly support the reviews' point that the fungi are "not neutral carriers"?
- Fungal threads are thinner than tree roots.
- Carbon isotopes are present in all living things.
- Some forests have more fungal species than others.
- Fungi send more carbon toward trees that supply them with more sugar, regardless of which trees most need it.
- Seedlings in shade grow more slowly than seedlings in sun.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
"Not neutral" means the fungi move resources to suit themselves. A finding that they favour the trees that feed them best, whatever the trees' needs, shows exactly that.
-
MCQTop rank
Water is usually described as essential to life, and for most organisms the description is accurate: a cell that loses most of its water suffers damage it cannot repair. Yet a scattered group of organisms, including certain mosses, roundworms and the microscopic animals known as tardigrades, can lose nearly all their water, remain dry and motionless for years, and then resume normal activity within hours of being wetted. Biologists call this state anhydrobiosis, "life without water."
The danger of drying is not simply the absence of water but what happens to the cell’s other contents as water leaves. Proteins fold into precise shapes that depend on surrounding water molecules; as the cell dries, they tend to unfold and stick to one another, and the membranes that enclose the cell and its compartments can fuse or rupture. An organism that survives drying must somehow hold these structures in place.
For several decades the leading explanation centred on a sugar called trehalose. Some anhydrobiotic organisms, such as brine shrimp and certain roundworms, accumulate large amounts of it as they dry. Trehalose appears to replace water around proteins and membranes and, as drying finishes, to form a glassy solid in which the cell’s contents are suspended, unable to move far enough to collide and clump. Experiments in which trehalose protected isolated proteins and membranes from drying damage supported this picture.
Tardigrades complicated it. Measurements found that many tardigrade species produce little or no trehalose, far too little to explain their resistance. Researchers searching for an alternative identified a family of proteins found in tardigrades and not, so far as is known, in other animals. These proteins have no fixed shape in solution; as the animal dries, they too appear to form a glass-like material. When the genes for them were inserted into yeast and bacteria, those organisms became noticeably more tolerant of drying, and when their activity was reduced in tardigrades, the animals survived drying less often.
The discovery does not overturn the trehalose explanation so much as reveal that it described one solution among several. Different lineages, it now appears, arrived at the same basic strategy, turning the drying cell’s interior to glass, using different molecules. The finding has drawn interest beyond biology, from researchers who hope that similar materials might one day let vaccines and medicines be stored without refrigeration.
The author’s view of the trehalose explanation is that it
- correctly describes how some organisms survive drying but is not the only way organisms do so
- has been completely disproved
- explains tardigrade survival fully
- was never supported by experiments
- applies only to roundworms
Answer and solution
Answer: A
"The discovery does not overturn the trehalose explanation so much as reveal that it described one solution among several." A.
-
MCQTop rank
Water is usually described as essential to life, and for most organisms the description is accurate: a cell that loses most of its water suffers damage it cannot repair. Yet a scattered group of organisms, including certain mosses, roundworms and the microscopic animals known as tardigrades, can lose nearly all their water, remain dry and motionless for years, and then resume normal activity within hours of being wetted. Biologists call this state anhydrobiosis, "life without water."
The danger of drying is not simply the absence of water but what happens to the cell’s other contents as water leaves. Proteins fold into precise shapes that depend on surrounding water molecules; as the cell dries, they tend to unfold and stick to one another, and the membranes that enclose the cell and its compartments can fuse or rupture. An organism that survives drying must somehow hold these structures in place.
For several decades the leading explanation centred on a sugar called trehalose. Some anhydrobiotic organisms, such as brine shrimp and certain roundworms, accumulate large amounts of it as they dry. Trehalose appears to replace water around proteins and membranes and, as drying finishes, to form a glassy solid in which the cell’s contents are suspended, unable to move far enough to collide and clump. Experiments in which trehalose protected isolated proteins and membranes from drying damage supported this picture.
Tardigrades complicated it. Measurements found that many tardigrade species produce little or no trehalose, far too little to explain their resistance. Researchers searching for an alternative identified a family of proteins found in tardigrades and not, so far as is known, in other animals. These proteins have no fixed shape in solution; as the animal dries, they too appear to form a glass-like material. When the genes for them were inserted into yeast and bacteria, those organisms became noticeably more tolerant of drying, and when their activity was reduced in tardigrades, the animals survived drying less often.
The discovery does not overturn the trehalose explanation so much as reveal that it described one solution among several. Different lineages, it now appears, arrived at the same basic strategy, turning the drying cell’s interior to glass, using different molecules. The finding has drawn interest beyond biology, from researchers who hope that similar materials might one day let vaccines and medicines be stored without refrigeration.
The author mentions vaccines and medicines in the last sentence primarily in order to
- explain why tardigrades produce little trehalose
- note a possible practical use of the research outside biology
- argue that vaccines should contain trehalose
- show that tardigrade proteins are found in medicines
- suggest that refrigeration damages proteins
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The sentence says the finding "has drawn interest beyond biology" from researchers hoping similar materials might let medicines be stored without refrigeration. B.
-
MCQTop rank
Consumer contracts, the terms a person accepts when opening a bank account, renting a car or signing up for a phone plan, are famously hard to read. They are long, written in dense legal vocabulary and arranged in a way that buries important terms among routine ones. Studies of consumer behaviour consistently find that almost no one reads them in full. The law nonetheless treats a person who signs, or clicks "I agree," as bound by every term.
Defenders of traditional drafting offer two justifications. First, legal terms have settled meanings, established by years of court decisions; replacing them with everyday words, which are vaguer, would create uncertainty and lead to more disputes. Second, since consumers do not read contracts anyway, the style in which they are written makes little practical difference.
Neither argument withstands close examination. The first overstates both the precision of legal language and the vagueness of ordinary English. Many traditional phrases survive not because they have a fixed meaning but because drafters copy them from older documents; some, such as pairs of near-synonyms, add length without adding meaning. Where a technical term really is needed, a plain-language contract can use it and explain it. Several jurisdictions that require consumer contracts to be written in plain language have not reported any increase in litigation as a result.
The second argument mistakes an effect for a cause. Consumers may skip contracts precisely because they know the documents will be impenetrable. When terms are short and clearly arranged, at least some readers check the provisions that matter most to them, such as fees, cancellation rights and automatic renewals. And readership by individual consumers is not the only benefit. Clear contracts are easier for consumer advocates and journalists to compare, and when a company’s unfavourable terms can be understood at a glance, competitors have a reason to advertise better ones.
None of this requires abandoning the principle that a person is bound by what they sign. It requires only that the law take seriously the condition that makes the principle fair: that the terms could, with reasonable effort, actually have been understood.
The final paragraph functions primarily to
- give a further example of a confusing contract
- clarify that the author’s proposal keeps the rule that signers are bound, while insisting on the condition that makes that rule fair
- introduce a new objection to plain-language contracts
- summarise the defenders’ position
- argue that consumer contracts should be abolished
Answer and solution
Answer: B
"None of this requires abandoning the principle ... It requires only that the law take seriously the condition that makes the principle fair." B.
-
MCQTop rank
Consumer contracts, the terms a person accepts when opening a bank account, renting a car or signing up for a phone plan, are famously hard to read. They are long, written in dense legal vocabulary and arranged in a way that buries important terms among routine ones. Studies of consumer behaviour consistently find that almost no one reads them in full. The law nonetheless treats a person who signs, or clicks "I agree," as bound by every term.
Defenders of traditional drafting offer two justifications. First, legal terms have settled meanings, established by years of court decisions; replacing them with everyday words, which are vaguer, would create uncertainty and lead to more disputes. Second, since consumers do not read contracts anyway, the style in which they are written makes little practical difference.
Neither argument withstands close examination. The first overstates both the precision of legal language and the vagueness of ordinary English. Many traditional phrases survive not because they have a fixed meaning but because drafters copy them from older documents; some, such as pairs of near-synonyms, add length without adding meaning. Where a technical term really is needed, a plain-language contract can use it and explain it. Several jurisdictions that require consumer contracts to be written in plain language have not reported any increase in litigation as a result.
The second argument mistakes an effect for a cause. Consumers may skip contracts precisely because they know the documents will be impenetrable. When terms are short and clearly arranged, at least some readers check the provisions that matter most to them, such as fees, cancellation rights and automatic renewals. And readership by individual consumers is not the only benefit. Clear contracts are easier for consumer advocates and journalists to compare, and when a company’s unfavourable terms can be understood at a glance, competitors have a reason to advertise better ones.
None of this requires abandoning the principle that a person is bound by what they sign. It requires only that the law take seriously the condition that makes the principle fair: that the terms could, with reasonable effort, actually have been understood.
Which one of the following, if true, would most strengthen the author’s response to the second argument?
- Courts in many jurisdictions apply the same rules to all contracts.
- Long contracts take more time to print.
- When a lender shortened its contract and moved fees to the first page, the share of customers who looked at the fee section rose markedly.
- Most consumer contracts are written by lawyers.
- Some consumers prefer contracts that use legal vocabulary.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The author claims clearer terms lead at least some readers to check what matters. C shows exactly that effect.
-
MCQTop rank
Craft guilds, the associations of master artisans that regulated trades such as weaving, metalworking and baking in many medieval and early modern European towns, have long had a poor reputation among economists. In the classic account, guilds were cartels. By limiting the number of masters, fixing prices and forbidding outsiders to practise the trade, they raised their members’ incomes at the expense of customers and of the many workers kept out. Their eventual abolition, on this account, freed markets that had been held back for centuries.
A number of historians have argued that this picture leaves out what guilds did for buyers. In a world without brand names, standardised measures or reliable courts, a customer buying cloth or silver faced a serious problem: it was hard to tell good work from bad before purchase, and costly to seek a remedy afterwards. Guilds addressed this by inspecting goods and stamping approved items with a mark, by enforcing rules on materials, such as the proportion of pure metal in silverware, and by punishing members whose work fell short. A buyer from a distant town who saw the mark of a respected guild could trust the goods without knowing the maker. On this view, guilds lowered the cost of trust and so made trade possible that would otherwise not have occurred.
The two accounts need not exclude each other, and the most careful recent work treats them as describing different sides of the same institution. The same powers that let a guild guarantee quality, the power to inspect and to exclude, also let it restrict entry and keep prices high. Which side predominated seems to have depended on circumstances. Where a town’s goods were sold mainly to distant buyers, a guild’s reputation was its members’ most valuable asset, and quality rules were enforced strictly. Where guilds served a captive local market, the evidence of price fixing and exclusion is stronger.
The question matters beyond economic history. Modern professions, from medicine to law, also combine licensing that protects the public with barriers to entry that protect members, and debates about them often repeat the old disagreement. The history of guilds suggests that asking whether such bodies are good or bad is less useful than asking under what conditions their protective function outweighs their restrictive one.
The author would most likely recommend that a debate about a modern licensing body focus on
- whether it existed in the Middle Ages
- how it marks approved products
- the conditions under which its protection of the public outweighs its restriction of entry
- whether the body is good or bad in general
- how many members it has
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Last sentence: asking good or bad "is less useful than asking under what conditions their protective function outweighs their restrictive one." C; D is what the author calls less useful.
-
MCQTop rank
Craft guilds, the associations of master artisans that regulated trades such as weaving, metalworking and baking in many medieval and early modern European towns, have long had a poor reputation among economists. In the classic account, guilds were cartels. By limiting the number of masters, fixing prices and forbidding outsiders to practise the trade, they raised their members’ incomes at the expense of customers and of the many workers kept out. Their eventual abolition, on this account, freed markets that had been held back for centuries.
A number of historians have argued that this picture leaves out what guilds did for buyers. In a world without brand names, standardised measures or reliable courts, a customer buying cloth or silver faced a serious problem: it was hard to tell good work from bad before purchase, and costly to seek a remedy afterwards. Guilds addressed this by inspecting goods and stamping approved items with a mark, by enforcing rules on materials, such as the proportion of pure metal in silverware, and by punishing members whose work fell short. A buyer from a distant town who saw the mark of a respected guild could trust the goods without knowing the maker. On this view, guilds lowered the cost of trust and so made trade possible that would otherwise not have occurred.
The two accounts need not exclude each other, and the most careful recent work treats them as describing different sides of the same institution. The same powers that let a guild guarantee quality, the power to inspect and to exclude, also let it restrict entry and keep prices high. Which side predominated seems to have depended on circumstances. Where a town’s goods were sold mainly to distant buyers, a guild’s reputation was its members’ most valuable asset, and quality rules were enforced strictly. Where guilds served a captive local market, the evidence of price fixing and exclusion is stronger.
The question matters beyond economic history. Modern professions, from medicine to law, also combine licensing that protects the public with barriers to entry that protect members, and debates about them often repeat the old disagreement. The history of guilds suggests that asking whether such bodies are good or bad is less useful than asking under what conditions their protective function outweighs their restrictive one.
Which one of the following best describes the organisation of the passage?
- A history is told in chronological order and ends with the abolition of guilds.
- A modern problem is described and solved by a historical example.
- A theory is proposed and then tested against statistical data.
- A traditional view is stated, an alternative view is presented, the two are reconciled, and the lesson is applied more broadly.
- Two views are presented and the second is shown to be false.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
P1 cartel view; P2 trust view; P3 reconciliation; P4 application to modern professions. D.