Home / Courses / LSAT prep / Practice / Role of a statement

Role of a statement

Argument structure · 10 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.

New to this topic? Read the lesson first: The role a statement plays.

Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)

Written questions with solutions

The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.

  1. MCQStandard

    The library should stay open until 10 p.m. on weeknights. Most students who use it work daytime jobs, and the busiest hour of the day is the last one before closing.

    The claim that the busiest hour is the last one before closing plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is the main conclusion of the argument.
    2. It is a premise offered in support of the main conclusion.
    3. It is an intermediate conclusion supported by another claim.
    4. It is a view the argument sets out to reject.
    5. It is an example that illustrates a general principle.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The conclusion is "The library should stay open until 10 p.m." The busiest-hour fact is one of two reasons for it, so it is a premise. It is not supported by anything else, so it is not an intermediate conclusion.

  2. MCQStandard

    The town should repair the old footbridge rather than build a new one. Repairs would cost half as much, and the old bridge is a well-loved landmark.

    The claim that repairs would cost half as much plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is a view the argument rejects.
    2. It is a concession to an opposing view.
    3. It is a premise offered in support of the main conclusion.
    4. It is the main conclusion of the argument.
    5. It is an intermediate conclusion supported by another claim.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The conclusion is the first sentence; the cost claim is one of two reasons for it. C.

  3. MCQExam level

    Some say the new stadium will pay for itself through tourism. It will not. Studies of eleven stadiums built in the past twenty years found that visitors mostly spent money they would have spent elsewhere in the same region. So the stadium's tax subsidy will be a net cost to the region.

    The claim that the new stadium will pay for itself through tourism plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is the argument's main conclusion.
    2. It is evidence offered for the argument's main conclusion.
    3. It is a claim the argument rejects, as a step toward its main conclusion.
    4. It is a general principle the argument applies.
    5. It is an assumption the argument depends on.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: C

    The arguer reports the claim ("Some say") and then denies it ("It will not"). Rejecting it is the step that leads to the main conclusion, that the subsidy will be a net cost. So it is an opposing view the argument rejects.

    Why people get this wrong: Claims after "Some say" or "It is often argued" are usually opposing views, not the author's own.

  4. MCQExam level

    Pharmacist: Generic drugs contain the same active ingredient in the same dose as the brand-name versions. Therefore they work the same way in the body. Since they also cost far less, patients should ask for generics whenever one is available.

    The claim that generic drugs work the same way in the body as brand-name versions plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is a qualification that limits the scope of the main conclusion.
    2. It is the main conclusion of the argument.
    3. It is a premise that receives no support in the argument.
    4. It is a conclusion that is then used to support the main conclusion.
    5. It is a claim that the pharmacist argues against.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    "Therefore" shows the claim is supported (by the same-ingredient fact). It then supports the final recommendation that patients ask for generics. A claim that is both supported and supporting is an intermediate (sub) conclusion.

    Why people get this wrong: Calling an intermediate conclusion the main conclusion because it follows "Therefore".

  5. MCQExam level

    Some say that the city’s new recycling programme has failed because recycling rates are still low. But the programme began only two months ago, and similar programmes elsewhere took a year to show results. So it is too early to judge the programme.

    The claim that the city’s new recycling programme has failed plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is a premise that supports the conclusion.
    2. It is an example of a general principle.
    3. It is an intermediate conclusion.
    4. It is a view that the argument opposes.
    5. It is the main conclusion of the argument.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: D

    "Some say" introduces an opposing claim; the argument concludes it is "too early to judge". D.

  6. MCQHard

    Ecologist: Planting fast-growing trees is often promoted as the cheapest way to absorb carbon. Fast growth is a real advantage. But fast-growing plantations are usually harvested within fifteen years, releasing much of the stored carbon, whereas a protected native forest keeps storing it for centuries. Protecting existing forests is thus the better climate policy.

    The claim that fast growth is a real advantage plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is the evidence on which the main conclusion is based.
    2. It explains why native forests store carbon for centuries.
    3. It is the main conclusion of the argument.
    4. It supports the claim that plantations are the cheapest way to absorb carbon.
    5. It concedes a point in favour of a view the ecologist goes on to reject.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: E

    The ecologist admits something good about plantations and then says "But", turning to the reasons they are worse. A statement that grants a point to the other side before the turn is a concession.

    Why people get this wrong: Concessions sit just before "But" or "However" and work against the author's own conclusion.

  7. MCQHard

    Many people believe that reading in dim light damages the eyes. In fact, it causes only temporary strain, which disappears after rest. Eye doctors therefore do not need to warn patients against reading in dim light, although they may wish to mention that bright light makes reading more comfortable.

    The claim that reading in dim light causes only temporary strain plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is a premise that supports the conclusion that doctors need not warn against reading in dim light.
    2. It is a claim the argument presents as a common but mistaken belief.
    3. It is a recommendation the argument makes to eye doctors.
    4. It is a qualification added to the main conclusion.
    5. It is the main conclusion, and the rest of the argument illustrates it.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    The conclusion is flagged by "therefore": doctors do not need to warn patients. The temporary-strain fact is the reason, so it is a premise. The common but mistaken belief is the earlier claim that dim light damages the eyes (B describes that one), and the qualification is the part after "although" (D).

  8. MCQHard

    Since nearly all the region’s rainfall comes in winter, its reservoirs fill only in those months. The reservoirs must therefore hold enough water to last through the dry summer. For this reason, the proposal to reduce reservoir capacity should be rejected.

    The claim that the reservoirs must hold enough water to last through the dry summer plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is the main conclusion of the argument.
    2. It is a premise that is not supported by any other claim.
    3. It is a view the argument sets out to refute.
    4. It is an illustration of the main conclusion.
    5. It is an intermediate conclusion that supports the main conclusion.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: E

    It is drawn from the rainfall facts ("therefore") and then supports rejecting the proposal ("For this reason"). Supported and supporting: an intermediate conclusion. E.

    Why people get this wrong: Mistaking an intermediate conclusion for the main one.

  9. MCQTop rank

    Economist: Raising the minimum wage is said to cost jobs, because firms will hire fewer workers when labour costs rise. Yet when a region raised its minimum wage by ten percent, employment there kept pace with nearby regions that did not. One likely reason is that better-paid workers quit less often, which saves firms the large cost of hiring and training replacements. So the familiar prediction that higher minimum wages cost jobs may not hold.

    The claim that better-paid workers quit less often plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is the main conclusion of the argument.
    2. It is offered as part of an explanation of why the regional result is not surprising.
    3. It is evidence that the regional study was flawed.
    4. It is a premise of the argument that the economist rejects.
    5. It is a prediction derived from the argument's conclusion.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: B

    The regional result (jobs did not fall) seems to clash with the usual prediction. The economist offers a reason it could happen: lower turnover saves firms money. The claim is part of that explanation, which makes the main conclusion (the prediction may not hold) more believable.

  10. MCQTop rank

    Critic: It is true that the new opera house has improved the city’s image abroad. But it cost three times its budget, and the money came from funds meant for public libraries. The opera house was therefore a poor use of public money.

    The claim that the new opera house has improved the city’s image abroad plays which one of the following roles in the argument?

    1. It is a point conceded before the argument presents reasons for its conclusion.
    2. It is the main conclusion of the argument.
    3. It is evidence offered to support the main conclusion.
    4. It is an intermediate conclusion.
    5. It is a claim the argument attempts to show is false.
    Answer and solution

    Answer: A

    "It is true that ... But" marks a concession: the critic grants the point without disputing it, then argues the other way. A. E is wrong because the critic accepts it.

← All topics · Timed mock test →