Command of evidence: text
Information and ideas · 8 questions and templates for SAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Command of evidence: quotations.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQStandard
A team of biologists claims that city-dwelling blackbirds sing at a higher pitch than forest blackbirds because low notes are drowned out by traffic noise.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the claim?
- Blackbirds in the same city sing at a higher pitch on busy streets than in quiet parks.
- Blackbirds in cities eat different food from blackbirds in forests.
- Forest blackbirds sing more often in spring than in autumn.
- Some city blackbirds have learned to nest on buildings.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The claim links pitch to traffic noise. A finding that pitch is higher where traffic is louder, in the same city, ties the two together directly. The other findings have nothing to do with noise or pitch.
-
MCQStandard
A team of ecologists claims that dragonflies in a certain wetland prefer to lay eggs in ponds without fish, because fish eat dragonfly larvae.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the ecologists’ claim?
- Fish in the wetland also eat insects that land on the water.
- Dragonfly eggs were found far more often in the wetland’s fishless ponds than in ponds with fish.
- Dragonflies can fly several kilometres in a day.
- Some ponds in the wetland dry out in late summer.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The claim is about where dragonflies lay eggs. Finding many more eggs in fishless ponds is direct support. Flight range and drying ponds say nothing about the preference.
-
MCQExam level
An economist argues that a city's new free bus service caused downtown shops' sales to rise in its first year.
Which finding, if true, would most directly weaken the economist's argument?
- Downtown shops were open longer hours on weekends.
- Sales rose by the same amount that year in similar towns with no free buses.
- Many shoppers said they liked the free buses.
- The buses ran every ten minutes during the day.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
If similar towns saw the same rise without free buses, something else (such as a good economy) probably caused it. That directly weakens the claim that the buses did. The last option offers another possible cause, but only on weekends and without showing it explains the rise.
-
MCQExam level
In her 1920s letters, the fictional scientist Ruth Calder often described her research with a mix of patience and humour.
Which quotation from Calder's letters most effectively illustrates the claim?
- "I have measured the samples three times and found the same result."
- "Science requires careful work and exact records."
- "The crystals refuse to grow again this week; I suspect they are on holiday, and I shall simply wait for their return."
- "The laboratory is cold, and the equipment is old."
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The claim has two parts: patience and humour. Only the first quotation shows both: she will "simply wait" (patience) for crystals that are "on holiday" (humour). The others show neither or only one.
Why people get this wrong: Checking only one part of a two-part claim.
-
MCQExam level
An economist argues that when a town opens a weekly farmers’ market, nearby grocery stores do not lose customers but instead gain them, because the market brings shoppers into the area.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the economist’s argument?
- Many shoppers at farmers’ markets pay in cash.
- Some grocery stores sell food from local farms.
- In towns that opened weekly markets, sales at nearby grocery stores rose on market days compared with other days.
- Farmers’ markets often sell vegetables that grocery stores also sell.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The argument predicts more grocery customers when the market runs. Higher grocery sales on market days fits exactly. Selling the same vegetables would, if anything, suggest competition.
-
MCQHard
Some researchers think that sleep helps the brain store new memories. To test this, they taught two groups of volunteers a list of words in the evening. One group then slept; the other stayed awake through the night.
Which result, if true, would most directly support the researchers' idea?
- Both groups remembered the same number of words.
- The volunteers who stayed awake felt more tired the next day.
- The volunteers learned the words faster in the evening than in the morning.
- The group that slept remembered more of the words the next morning than the group that stayed awake.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
The idea is that sleep helps memory, so the sleeping group should remember more. Equal results would count against it; tiredness and learning speed do not test memory storage.
-
MCQHard
A student claims that a certain bird species learns its song by copying adult birds rather than knowing it from birth.
Which finding, if true, would most directly weaken the student’s claim?
- Adult birds of the species sing most often in spring.
- Young birds of the species begin singing a few weeks after hatching.
- Some other bird species learn songs from their parents.
- Young birds of the species raised in complete isolation from adults still sang the normal adult song.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
If birds that never heard an adult still sing the normal song, they did not need to copy it, which undercuts the claim. The other findings do not test where the song comes from.
-
MCQHard
In a novel, the narrator describes her grandfather as a man who hid his kindness behind a stern face.
Which quotation from the novel most effectively illustrates this description?
- “He never smiled when he handed me the coins for the bus, but he always gave me twice what the fare cost.”
- “He laughed loudly at every joke, even the bad ones.”
- “He spent his mornings reading the newspaper by the window.”
- “He was strict with everyone, and he never gave anyone anything.”
Answer and solution
Answer: A
The description needs both parts: a stern surface and hidden kindness. No smile (stern) but double the fare (kind) shows both. The laughing quotation shows no sternness; the last shows no kindness.
Why people get this wrong: Choosing a quotation that shows only half of the description.