Module 2: Choosing the chart · Lesson 2.3 · about 10 min
Pie charts and parts of a whole: when they work
Pie charts show parts of a whole, but only work with two or three clearly different slices. When a pie is fine, when to use bars or a 100 % stacked bar instead, and why 3D pies mislead.
Module 2 · about 10 minutes · read first: 2.1. You’ll know when a pie chart is fine, and what to use when it isn’t.
1. Why this matters
Pie charts are the most argued-about chart. Some designers ban them; managers often ask for them. The truth is in between: a pie works for one job, with few slices, and fails at the rest. Knowing the difference lets you give a manager what they need without a debate.
2. The idea in one picture
A pie that works: two slices, one of them about half.
West stores made half of 2025 sales
In Lesson 2.1’s chooser, compare “Part of a whole” with the 3D pie: the tilt makes Electronics look larger than it is.
3. The rules
A pie or doughnut is fine when:
- The slices are parts of one whole (shares of sales, of customers, of budget).
- There are two or three slices, or one slice you want to show against “everything else”.
- The message is a rough share (“about half”, “a quarter”), not a precise ranking.
Use something else when:
- There are more than three slices, or slices of similar size: use a sorted bar chart with percentages.
- You compare shares across groups or years: use 100 % stacked bars side by side (two pies next to each other are very hard to compare).
- You want to show change: use a line or bar chart of the share.
Never use 3D, exploded slices, or a legend far from the slices.
Principle
Principle: a pie encodes values as angles and areas, which we judge less accurately than lengths. We do know halves and quarters of a circle well (think of a clock), so pies work for those and fail for “is 17 % bigger than 15 %?”.
Physical meaning: a quarter of a pie is a right angle, a corner we see every day. A 17 % slice is an odd angle with nothing to compare it to.
4. Worked example
A manager asks for “a pie of sales by store”. Five stores, 30 % down to 12 %. Three of them (Falls Centre 22 %, Rideau 19 %, Harbour Front 17 %) are close in size, so in a pie they look almost the same.
What to offer instead: “Here’s a bar chart with the percentage on each bar: Queen Street leads with 30 %. If you’d like a pie for the slide, West stores vs the rest (51 % vs 49 %) works nicely as one.”
5. Practice
- Northbay categories in 2025: Electronics 36 %, Home 28 %, Outdoor 25 %, Grocery 11 %. Pie or bars?
- You want to show that online sales went from 8 % to 15 % of the total. Which chart?
- Is a pie of “growth % by store” acceptable?
Answers
- Bars (sorted, with %), since there are four slices and three are fairly close. A single 100 % stacked bar is also good.
- Two 100 % stacked bars (one per year) or a simple line/bar of the share over time.
- No: growth rates aren’t parts of a whole, so they can’t be slices.
Next, Lesson 2.4: tables, cards and small multiples.
Check yourself
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Northbay Goods is a made-up shop and its numbers are generated. The writing checks are simple rules run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere or kept.