All lessons

Module 2: Choosing the chart · Lesson 2.3 · about 10 min

Pie charts and parts of a whole: when they work

Pie charts show parts of a whole, but only work with two or three clearly different slices. When a pie is fine, when to use bars or a 100 % stacked bar instead, and why 3D pies mislead.

Module 2 · about 10 minutes · read first: 2.1. You’ll know when a pie chart is fine, and what to use when it isn’t.

1. Why this matters

Pie charts are the most argued-about chart. Some designers ban them; managers often ask for them. The truth is in between: a pie works for one job, with few slices, and fails at the rest. Knowing the difference lets you give a manager what they need without a debate.

2. The idea in one picture

A pie that works: two slices, one of them about half.

When a pie is fine

West stores made half of 2025 sales

West (3 stores)Central and East (2 stores)
Two slices, one of them about half: a pie or doughnut shows "part of a whole" well here (51 %). With five or more similar slices, use bars.

In Lesson 2.1’s chooser, compare “Part of a whole” with the 3D pie: the tilt makes Electronics look larger than it is.

3. The rules

A pie or doughnut is fine when:

  1. The slices are parts of one whole (shares of sales, of customers, of budget).
  2. There are two or three slices, or one slice you want to show against “everything else”.
  3. The message is a rough share (“about half”, “a quarter”), not a precise ranking.

Use something else when:

  • There are more than three slices, or slices of similar size: use a sorted bar chart with percentages.
  • You compare shares across groups or years: use 100 % stacked bars side by side (two pies next to each other are very hard to compare).
  • You want to show change: use a line or bar chart of the share.

Never use 3D, exploded slices, or a legend far from the slices.

Principle

Principle: a pie encodes values as angles and areas, which we judge less accurately than lengths. We do know halves and quarters of a circle well (think of a clock), so pies work for those and fail for “is 17 % bigger than 15 %?”.

Physical meaning: a quarter of a pie is a right angle, a corner we see every day. A 17 % slice is an odd angle with nothing to compare it to.

4. Worked example

A manager asks for “a pie of sales by store”. Five stores, 30 % down to 12 %. Three of them (Falls Centre 22 %, Rideau 19 %, Harbour Front 17 %) are close in size, so in a pie they look almost the same.

What to offer instead: “Here’s a bar chart with the percentage on each bar: Queen Street leads with 30 %. If you’d like a pie for the slide, West stores vs the rest (51 % vs 49 %) works nicely as one.”

5. Practice

  1. Northbay categories in 2025: Electronics 36 %, Home 28 %, Outdoor 25 %, Grocery 11 %. Pie or bars?
  2. You want to show that online sales went from 8 % to 15 % of the total. Which chart?
  3. Is a pie of “growth % by store” acceptable?
Answers
  1. Bars (sorted, with %), since there are four slices and three are fairly close. A single 100 % stacked bar is also good.
  2. Two 100 % stacked bars (one per year) or a simple line/bar of the share over time.
  3. No: growth rates aren’t parts of a whole, so they can’t be slices.

Next, Lesson 2.4: tables, cards and small multiples.

Check yourself

1When is a pie chart a reasonable choice?
2Why are 3D pie charts misleading?
3Do a pie's slices have to add up to a meaningful whole?

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Northbay Goods is a made-up shop and its numbers are generated. The writing checks are simple rules run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere or kept.