Weaken
Assumption family · 10 questions and templates for LSAT prep, in order from warm-up to top rank. Check each answer, then read the full solution.
New to this topic? Read the lesson first: Weaken.
Loading questions… (they need JavaScript; nothing you type is sent anywhere)
Written questions with solutions
The same questions as a list, so you can print them or read without the practice box. Templates (fresh numbers) appear only in the practice box above.
-
MCQStandard
Since the restaurant added a vegetarian menu, its monthly sales have risen by a fifth. The vegetarian menu must be drawing in new customers.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- Many restaurants offer vegetarian food.
- The restaurant's owner is vegetarian.
- Vegetarian dishes cost less to make.
- The month the menu was added, a large office building opened next door and its workers now eat at the restaurant.
- Some customers order from both menus.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
D gives another cause for the rise that has nothing to do with the menu: hundreds of new office workers. If that is the reason, the conclusion about the menu loses its support.
-
MCQStandard
Students who sit in the front row of lecture halls earn higher grades than students who sit at the back. So sitting near the front helps students learn.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- Lecture halls vary in size.
- Some lecturers walk around the room while speaking.
- Grades are based partly on attendance.
- Front-row seats fill up early.
- Students who already care most about their grades tend to choose seats near the front.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
E suggests the causation runs from motivation to seat choice: keen students pick the front and would earn high grades anywhere. The seat may do nothing.
Why people get this wrong: Missing a third factor that causes both.
-
MCQExam level
A survey of readers of a gardening magazine found that eighty percent prefer organic fertiliser. So most gardeners in the country prefer organic fertiliser.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- Organic fertiliser is more expensive than chemical fertiliser.
- Some readers did not answer the fertiliser question.
- The magazine is sold across the country.
- The survey had over five thousand responses.
- The magazine is published by an organic farming association and mainly attracts readers with an interest in organic methods.
Answer and solution
Answer: E
The sample is readers of one magazine. If that magazine attracts organic fans, the sample is biased, and its result says little about gardeners in general. A large biased sample is still biased, so D does not help much.
Why people get this wrong: A big sample does not fix an unrepresentative one.
-
MCQExam level
Health officer: People who take vitamin D supplements have fewer bone fractures than people who do not. So vitamin D supplements protect against fractures.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- People who take supplements are much more likely to exercise regularly and eat well, both of which strengthen bones.
- Fractures are more common in older people.
- Vitamin D supplements are inexpensive.
- Some people take vitamin D for other reasons.
- Vitamin D is also made by the skin in sunlight.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
A shows supplement users differ in other ways (exercise, diet) that themselves protect bones. Those habits could explain the difference in fractures without vitamin D doing anything.
-
MCQExam level
A town replaced its old streetlights with brighter ones on Elm Street. In the year after, night-time car accidents on Elm Street fell by half. So brighter streetlights would cut night-time accidents across the whole town.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- In the same year, Elm Street was closed to through traffic for nine months for sewer work.
- Brighter streetlights use less electricity.
- Some residents complained the new lights were too bright.
- Most of the town’s accidents happen in daylight.
- Elm Street is one of the town’s longest streets.
Answer and solution
Answer: A
With Elm Street closed to through traffic for most of the year, far fewer cars drove it, which explains the drop without the lights. D is about daytime accidents, which the argument does not address.
-
MCQHard
City official: Last year we added more police patrols downtown, and reported thefts there dropped by a quarter. The extra patrols clearly reduced theft downtown.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- Thefts in the rest of the city also fell.
- Many downtown shops began asking customers to report thefts online through a new site that city records do not include.
- Police patrols are expensive.
- Downtown has more shops than other parts of the city.
- The number of patrol officers in the city has risen in each of the last five years.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
The evidence is reported thefts in city records. If many reports moved to a site those records do not count, the drop may be in reporting, not in theft. A weakens a little (something citywide), but B goes straight at the evidence.
Why people get this wrong: Check whether the evidence measures the thing itself or only reports of it.
-
MCQHard
Advertisement: Ninety percent of dentists surveyed said that they would recommend SmileBright toothpaste to their patients. So SmileBright is the toothpaste most dentists think is best.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- The survey was carried out by an independent firm.
- The dentists surveyed live in many different cities.
- Dentists in the survey were asked about SmileBright alone, and most said they would also recommend several competing brands.
- SmileBright costs more than most toothpastes.
- Some dentists in the survey do not use SmileBright themselves.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
Being willing to recommend something is not the same as thinking it is the best. C shows the dentists would recommend many brands, so the ninety percent figure does not show SmileBright is preferred over others.
-
MCQHard
Editor: Our newspaper’s online articles that include a photograph are shared twice as often as those that do not. To increase sharing, we should add a photograph to every article.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- Articles about sport are shared more than articles about politics.
- Editors currently add photographs mainly to the articles they expect to be most popular, such as major breaking news.
- Photographs make pages load more slowly.
- Some readers share articles without reading them.
- The newspaper employs several photographers.
Answer and solution
Answer: B
If photographs go mostly on articles already expected to be popular, the photo is a marker of popularity rather than its cause. Adding photos to dull articles may change little. B.
Why people get this wrong: Reversing selection and cause.
-
MCQTop rank
Biologist: In lakes where a certain fish was introduced, populations of a native frog fell sharply within five years. The fish, which eats tadpoles, is therefore the main cause of the frogs' decline in those lakes.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- The fish was introduced for sport fishing.
- Tadpoles can hide in weeds.
- The fish also eats insects.
- In nearby lakes where the fish was never introduced, the same frog declined just as sharply over the same years, at the same time as a fungal disease spread through the region.
- The frog lays eggs only in spring.
Answer and solution
Answer: D
D gives a control group: lakes without the fish lost frogs just as fast. If the decline happens with or without the fish, the fish cannot be the main cause, and the fungus is a likely alternative.
-
MCQTop rank
Researcher: In a study, people who were told that a wine was expensive rated it as tasting better than people who tasted the same wine but were told it was cheap. Therefore, a wine’s price has no relationship to its actual quality.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- People also rate food higher when told it is expensive.
- Price labels are required by law in some countries.
- In separate blind tastings, where no prices were given, expensive wines were on average rated higher than cheap ones.
- Some people in the study did not usually drink wine.
- The study used only red wine.
Answer and solution
Answer: C
The study shows price labels bias ratings; it does not show price is unrelated to quality. Blind tastings in which expensive wines still score higher, C, directly contradict the conclusion. A actually fits the study’s finding.
Why people get this wrong: Choosing an answer that supports the premise rather than attacking the conclusion.