Home / Learn / Exam prep / LSAT prep / Lesson 3.4
All lessons

Module 3: The assumption family · Lesson 3.4 · about 20 min

Weaken

Weaken questions ask which new fact most damages an argument. Learn to attack the assumption, show an alternative cause, or reveal a bad comparison, and to avoid answers that attack premises or miss the conclusion.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 3 · about 20 minutes · read first: 3.3. By the end you will find the fact that most damages an argument, and steer around the answers built to look damaging.

Weaken is strengthen in reverse. Find the gap between evidence and claim, then pick the fact that widens it: an alternative cause, a reason the assumption fails, or a flaw in a comparison.

1. The question stem

“Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?”, “…casts the most doubt on…”, “…undermines…”. Accept each answer as true; ask which one most reduces the support for the conclusion.

2. The three most common weakeners

"Employees at firms that offer free gym membership take fewer sick days. So offering free gym membership would reduce sick days at our firm."
Evidence: a correlation between gym perks and fewer sick days. Claim: the perk would cause fewer sick days here.
Assumption: the gym membership is the cause, not something else about those firms.
Alternative cause: those firms employ younger office staff, who take fewer sick days anyway. That explains the correlation without the gym, so the argument is badly weakened.
  1. Alternative cause (as above).
  2. The assumption fails: “Most employees given free membership never use it.”
  3. Bad comparison: the two groups or places differ in an important way (“our firm’s employees work night shifts in a warehouse”).
Weaken
makes the conclusion less likely to follow from the evidence
Out of scope
an answer about a different group, time or issue than the conclusion
Physical meaning
An argument is only as strong as its weakest link. A good weakener puts pressure on exactly the link the author did not defend.

3. Traps

  • Attacks a premise. “Some of the sick-day data was estimated” questions the facts, which the LSAT treats as given. Usually wrong.
  • Out of scope. About gym costs, or about people outside the comparison.
  • Wrong direction. Strengthens instead (it happens under time pressure: reread the stem).
  • Too weak to matter. “Some employees prefer swimming” barely touches the conclusion.
Try it: a full question

“Since the town banned cars from the market square, shops on the square report 20% higher sales. The car ban therefore helped local shops.”

Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?

(A) Some shoppers drive to the edge of the square and walk in. (B) In the same period, a large office building opened beside the square, bringing hundreds of workers. (C) Shops on the square sell mostly clothing and food. (D) The town council voted for the ban by a narrow margin. (E) Sales at shops on the square vary from month to month.

Answer: (B). The new office workers are an alternative cause for higher sales. (A) is consistent with the ban helping. (C) and (D) are irrelevant. (E) is too vague to explain a 20% rise.

“The best weakener proves the conclusion false.” That is rarely available. Pick the answer that does the most damage to the support; it may only show the conclusion is less likely.

Practice set

Original questions in the LSAT’s own five-option format, from warm-up to test level. Read the argument, predict the answer, then choose; every question has a full explanation of why the right answer is right and the others are not.

  • Accept the answers as true; pick the one that most reduces support for the conclusion.
  • Weaken with an alternative cause, a failed assumption, or a bad comparison.
  • Don’t attack the premises; watch for out-of-scope, wrong-direction and too-weak answers.
  • Predict the weakener from the gap before reading the choices.

Check yourself

1What should a weakener attack?
2"Sales rose after we lowered prices, so lower prices raised sales." Which weakens it most?
3Must a weakener show the conclusion is false?

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. LSAT is a trademark of the Law School Admission Council (LSAC), which is not involved with and does not endorse fibub. Every argument, passage and question here is original. Test details were checked on LSAC's website on 22 November 2026; check the official source before test day.