All lessons

Module 4: Writing tasks · Lesson 4.4 · about 18 min

Write for an Academic Discussion

How to write the TOEFL 2026 academic discussion post: take a position, add a new idea, develop it with an example. Two model posts, timed tasks, 26 drills.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 4 · about 18 minutes. By the end you will know what the Academic Discussion task asks, a five-step method to write a strong post quickly, and how to add an idea your classmates did not. You will see two model posts at different levels and practice with three timed tasks.

Your post is one voice in a class conversation: answer the professor's question clearly, add something new, and explain it well enough that a classmate could reply.

1. What the task looks like

Write for an Academic Discussion is the third task type in the Writing section of the 2026 TOEFL iBT (about 23 minutes and about 12 items in all). You see an online discussion board for a university class. A professor asks a question about a topic from the course, such as city planning, education, the environment or media. Two students have already posted short answers, often with different views. You write your own post that takes part in the discussion.

ETS does not publish the exact time or a word limit for this task on the pages we checked; the test screen shows the time. For practice, this lesson uses 10 minutes, and aims for about 100 words or more, which is common advice for a post that is properly developed. These are practice settings, not official rules.

You do not need special knowledge of the subject. Every question can be answered from everyday experience and common sense.

2. What it really tests

  1. Answering the question. Your position on exactly what the professor asked.
  2. Development. Reasons, explained, with a specific example or detail.
  3. Contribution. Something that moves the discussion on, not a copy of what was said.
  4. Organization. A clear opening position, connected ideas, a closing line.
  5. Language use. Accurate grammar and a range of academic but natural vocabulary.

An everyday picture: imagine joining friends who are debating where to eat. If you only say “I agree with Sam”, nobody learns anything. If you say “I agree with Sam, and the new place also has a student discount on weekdays”, you have moved the decision forward. Your post should do the second thing.

3. The method: five steps in about ten minutes

Step 1. Read the professor’s question twice (about 1 minute). Find the exact question: “Should cities…?”, “Which is better…?”, “Is this good or bad…?” Then read both student posts and note each one’s main reason in two or three words.

Step 2. Choose a position and a new reason. Pick the side you can explain best, not the one you think sounds smartest. Find one reason or angle that neither student used. A middle position (“yes, but gradually”) is fine if it is clear.

Step 3. Plan four lines. Position. Reason. Example or explanation. Link to a classmate or a closing line.

Step 4. Write (about 6 minutes). Open with your position in one sentence. Develop your reason with an example, a cause and effect, or a comparison. Connect to a classmate’s idea (agree and add, or disagree politely). Close with one sentence that restates your view.

Step 5. Check (about 1 minute). Did you answer the exact question? Is there a new idea? Then fix verb endings, articles, plurals and spelling.

4. Worked example

Professor Huang (original): Some universities now require every first-year student to take a course on personal finance: budgeting, loans, saving. Others think students should choose their own courses. Should a personal finance course be required? Explain your view.

Lena: Yes. Many students take out loans without understanding interest. A required course would prevent serious mistakes.

Omar: I think it should be optional. Students already have heavy schedules, and people can learn about money online for free.

Step 1. The question: should the course be required? Lena: yes, to prevent loan mistakes. Omar: no, schedules are full and free videos exist.

Step 2. Position: required, but short. New angle: the students who most need it are the least likely to look for free videos; and a short course does not have to add to the schedule.

Step 3. Plan: (1) required, short, no extra credits. (2) people who need it most do not search for it. (3) example: a cousin with credit card debt. (4) answer Omar: one-unit course fits schedules.

Now two posts written from similar plans.

Model A: a clear, basic post (likely to score in the middle range)

I agree with Lena that the course should be required. Many students do not know about money. For example, my friend got a credit card in his first year and he spent too much money. He did not understand interest, so he had a big debt. If he took a finance course, he would not have this problem. Omar says students can learn online, but many students do not do it. In conclusion, I think the course should be required because it helps students.

Why it works, and what holds it back. Answering the question: a clear position. Development: there is a personal example, which is good. Contribution: the example mostly repeats Lena’s point (loans and interest); the answer to Omar (“many students do not do it”) is a new idea but is not explained. Organization: logical, but “In conclusion” is heavy for a short post. Language use: mostly accurate, with simple, repeated words (“money”, “problem”); “If he took… he would not have” should be “If he had taken… he would not have had”, because it is about the past. About 85 words.

Model B: a developed post that adds to the discussion (likely to score near the top)

In my view, a personal finance course should be required, as long as it is short and does not add to students’ total credit load. Omar is right that excellent free videos exist, but the students who most need them are often the least likely to go looking for them. My cousin is a good example: in her first week of college she signed up for a credit card at a campus booth, and by the summer she owed over two thousand dollars, simply because nobody had explained how interest grows. A single required unit, perhaps six online sessions, would reach students like her before they make that kind of mistake, without making anyone’s schedule heavier. For these reasons, I think a short, practical course would be worth far more than the time it takes.

Why it scores higher. Answering the question: clear position with a sensible condition. Contribution: answers Omar with a new point (the people who need help do not search for it) and solves his schedule worry (a short unit). Development: a specific example with time, place and amount, linked directly to the point. Organization: position, response to a classmate, example, solution, closing, all connected. Language use: a wide range of accurate structures (“as long as”, “the least likely to”, “simply because nobody had explained”), natural academic tone. About 135 words.

5. Ways to add a new idea

When both classmates have taken the obvious reasons, try one of these angles:

Angle Question to ask yourself Example (bike lanes)
A different group of people Who else is affected? Children walking to school are safer
Time What happens in the short term versus the long term? Shops may lose customers at first, then gain walkers
Cost Who pays, and is it worth it? Bike lanes cost less than widening roads
A condition When would the answer change? Yes, but only on streets with other bus options
A solution Can you fix the other side’s worry? Delivery hours early in the morning
Personal experience What happened to you or someone you know? My city’s new lane changed how I get to work

Self-check before you finish

  • My first sentence answers the professor’s exact question
  • I added at least one idea that neither classmate gave
  • My main reason is explained with an example or detail
  • I connected to a classmate (agree and add, or disagree politely)
  • My post has a closing sentence
  • About 100 words or more (practice target), checked for errors

“I must not use ‘I’ in academic writing.” That rule belongs to some formal essays, not to this task. A class discussion board is a conversation, so “I think”, “In my experience” and “I agree with Lena, and I would add…” are natural. What matters is that your opinion is clear and supported, and that the tone stays respectful and neutral (no slang, no insults).

Useful discussion phrases:

  • Position: In my view, … / I believe that… / I would argue that… / I partly agree with…
  • Adding to a classmate: Building on Lena’s point, I would add that… / Omar raises a good point, and…
  • Polite disagreement: I see why Theo feels this way; however, … / While Mia is right that…, I think…
  • Explaining: This is because… / As a result, … / This means that…
  • Examples: For example, … / A good example is… / In my experience, …
  • Closing: For these reasons, … / Overall, I think… / That is why I believe…

6. Drills

These drills train the decisions behind a good post: understanding the question, choosing a position, finding a new idea, supporting it, linking and closing.

Academic Discussion: 26 original items on four discussion boards plus general post skills.

7. Timed practice

Each discussion below is original. Start the timer, spend a minute reading and planning, write, then use the checklist. Your text stays in your browser; download it if you want to keep it.

Practice task 1: 10 minutes (practice time), aim for about 100 words or more.
Practice task 2: work from home or the office.
Practice task 3: the gap year.

After each post, read Model B again and ask: did I add something new, and did I explain it with a real example? Those two things make the biggest difference.

  • You read a professor’s question and two students’ posts, then write your own post; the test screen shows the time.
  • Practice with 10 minutes and about 100 words or more (practice settings, common advice).
  • Method: read the question twice, choose a position and a new reason, plan four lines, write, check.
  • Add something new: a different group, time, cost, condition, solution or personal experience.
  • One or two reasons explained with a specific example beat a long list; “I” and classmates’ names are fine.

Check yourself

1Two classmates have already posted. What makes your post stand out?
2How many reasons should a short post usually develop?
3Is it fine to mention a classmate by name and use "I"?

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. fibub is an independent free site, not part of ETS or TOEFL, and every question here is original. The test format and score rules change: check ets.org/toefl and each university's own requirements. Practice runs in your browser; nothing you type or record is sent anywhere.