Module 6: Critical Reasoning · Lesson 6.4 · about 14 min
Evaluate and flaw questions
Evaluate questions ask which fact would most help judge an argument: test each choice both ways. Flaw questions ask you to name what is wrong with the reasoning: learn the eight flaws the GMAT uses most.
Module 6 · about 14 minutes. By the end you will pick evaluate answers with the two-way test and name the flaw in any argument.
1. Evaluate: the two-way test
Stems: “Which would be most useful to know in order to evaluate the argument?” Each choice is a question. Answer it both ways:
A choice whose answer would not change your view either way (“Do nurses like the checklist?”) is wrong.
2. Flaw: name what is wrong
A flaw question describes the reasoning in abstract words (“treats a necessary condition as sufficient”). Translate each choice back into the argument before you pick.
| Flaw | Looks like |
|---|---|
| Cause from correlation | “A and B happen together, so A causes B.” |
| Biased sample | Poll of gardening-site visitors speaks for the nation. |
| Reversed condition | “All X are Y; this is Y; so it is X.” |
| Attacking the person | Reject the claim because of who said it. |
| Circular reasoning | The conclusion is hidden in the evidence. |
| False choice | Only two options are offered when there are more. |
| Rate vs total | A percentage change is treated as a count change. |
| Part to whole | What is true of each part is assumed true of the whole. |
“Choices that describe a flaw in hard words must be wrong.” Flaw choices are always abstract. Translate the right one and it describes the argument exactly; translate a wrong one and it describes something the argument never did.
3. Practice
- Evaluate: answer each choice “yes” and “no”; the right one changes the argument both ways.
- Flaw: translate abstract choices back into the argument.
- Know the eight common flaws, especially cause from correlation, biased samples and reversed conditions.
- A flaw choice must describe something the argument actually does.
Check yourself
Sources
- GMAC, GMAT Verbal Reasoning section (checked 2026-11-22): https://www.mba.com/exams/gmat-exam/about/exam-structure
- OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy (CC BY 4.0), section 5.5 Informal fallacies: https://openstax.org/books/introduction-philosophy/pages/5-5-informal-fallacies
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Independent free course, not part of or endorsed by GMAC. GMAT is a trademark of the Graduate Management Admission Council. Every question here is original. Test rules change: check mba.com before you book.