Home / Learn / Exam prep / GMAT prep / Lesson 6.4
All lessons

Module 6: Critical Reasoning · Lesson 6.4 · about 14 min

Evaluate and flaw questions

Evaluate questions ask which fact would most help judge an argument: test each choice both ways. Flaw questions ask you to name what is wrong with the reasoning: learn the eight flaws the GMAT uses most.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 6 · about 14 minutes. By the end you will pick evaluate answers with the two-way test and name the flaw in any argument.

Both question types point at the same weak spot in the argument. Evaluate asks what you would need to know about it; flaw asks you to name it.

1. Evaluate: the two-way test

Stems: “Which would be most useful to know in order to evaluate the argument?” Each choice is a question. Answer it both ways:

"Since the hospital introduced a hand-washing checklist, infections fell 30%. So the checklist caused the fall."
Choice: "Did infections also fall at similar hospitals without the checklist?"
Yes → something else (a mild season, a new cleaning contract) probably caused the fall: the argument weakens.
No → the checklist hospital stands out: the argument strengthens. One question, two directions: this is the answer.

A choice whose answer would not change your view either way (“Do nurses like the checklist?”) is wrong.

2. Flaw: name what is wrong

A flaw question describes the reasoning in abstract words (“treats a necessary condition as sufficient”). Translate each choice back into the argument before you pick.

Flaw Looks like
Cause from correlation “A and B happen together, so A causes B.”
Biased sample Poll of gardening-site visitors speaks for the nation.
Reversed condition “All X are Y; this is Y; so it is X.”
Attacking the person Reject the claim because of who said it.
Circular reasoning The conclusion is hidden in the evidence.
False choice Only two options are offered when there are more.
Rate vs total A percentage change is treated as a count change.
Part to whole What is true of each part is assumed true of the whole.
Read each short argument and choose its flaw. The sorter explains the answer and shows the same flaw in a business setting.

“Choices that describe a flaw in hard words must be wrong.” Flaw choices are always abstract. Translate the right one and it describes the argument exactly; translate a wrong one and it describes something the argument never did.

3. Practice

  • Evaluate: answer each choice “yes” and “no”; the right one changes the argument both ways.
  • Flaw: translate abstract choices back into the argument.
  • Know the eight common flaws, especially cause from correlation, biased samples and reversed conditions.
  • A flaw choice must describe something the argument actually does.

Check yourself

1How do you test an evaluate answer?
2"She owns a bike shop, so her case for bike lanes should be rejected." The flaw is...
3"All members got top marks; Kai got top marks; so Kai is a member." The flaw is...

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Independent free course, not part of or endorsed by GMAC. GMAT is a trademark of the Graduate Management Admission Council. Every question here is original. Test rules change: check mba.com before you book.