Module 6: Critical Reasoning · Lesson 6.3 · about 15 min
Strengthen and weaken
How to weaken an argument by attacking its assumption (another cause, a side effect, a bad sample) and how to strengthen it by closing the gap, with the "if true" rule and traps to avoid.
Module 6 · about 15 minutes. By the end you will weaken or strengthen any argument by working on its assumption.
1. Treat every choice as true
“Which of the following, if true, most weakens…” means: accept each choice as a fact and measure how much it changes your belief in the conclusion. Do not argue with the evidence; the passage’s facts stand.
2. How to weaken
The usual weakeners match the gaps from Lesson 6.1:
| Argument type | Weaken by showing |
|---|---|
| Cause from a link | another cause; the cause runs the other way; the link is chance |
| Plan | a side effect cancels the benefit; the plan cannot be carried out |
| Sample | the sample is not typical |
| Numbers | the numbers measure different things (sales vs profit, rate vs total) |
| Analogy | the cases differ in a way that matters |
3. How to strengthen
Strengtheners close the gap: rule out other causes, show the side effect is small, show the sample is typical, or show the effect changes when the cause changes (“in colder springs, the birds nested later”).
“A weakener must prove the conclusion false.” It only has to make the conclusion less likely. “Most weakens” means the biggest effect among the five, not a knock-out blow.
4. Traps
- Out of scope: a true-sounding fact about something next to the topic (the cost of the cameras).
- Opposite direction: a strengthener in a weaken question, or the reverse. Mark each choice +, − or 0 as you read.
- Shifting the measure: the conclusion is about profit and the choice talks about sales.
- Trend before: “crashes had been rising for years” does not give another cause of the drop.
5. Practice
- Accept every choice as true; judge only its effect.
- Weaken = attack the assumption (other cause, side effect, bad sample, wrong measure).
- Strengthen = support the assumption (rule out other causes, show cause and effect move together).
- Mark choices +, − or 0 to avoid picking the opposite job.
- A weakener lowers the conclusion’s likelihood; it need not disprove it.
Check yourself
Sources
- GMAC, GMAT Verbal Reasoning section (checked 2026-11-22): https://www.mba.com/exams/gmat-exam/about/exam-structure
- Hill A. B. (1965), The environment and disease: association or causation?, Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine 58: 295-300 (classic tests for cause). https://doi.org/10.1177/003591576505800503
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Independent free course, not part of or endorsed by GMAC. GMAT is a trademark of the Graduate Management Admission Council. Every question here is original. Test rules change: check mba.com before you book.