Home / Learn / Science / Sky watching / Lesson 5.2
All lessons

Module 5: What to observe and how · Lesson 5.2 · about 25 min

Deep-sky objects: Messier and NGC

Star clusters, nebulae and galaxies are the deep sky. Charles Messier listed 110 of the brightest in the 1700s; the New General Catalogue lists thousands more. Surface brightness, not total magnitude, decides how easy each one is.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 5 · about 25 minutes · read first: 4.2 Aperture: the bucket that catches light, 3.2 Light pollution and the Bortle scale, 1.7 How bright is it? The magnitude scale · maths: logarithms. You’ll be able to name the kinds of deep-sky object, read their catalogue numbers, and predict which ones you can see by surface brightness.

Star clusters, nebulae and galaxies are the deep sky; surface brightness, not total magnitude, decides how easy each is to see, so a bright but large galaxy can be harder than a faint small one.

1. Why this matters

The deep sky is where most amateur observing time goes: hundreds of targets, each a different kind of astrophysics. Understanding why some 9th-magnitude objects are easy and others invisible saves frustration, and the same surface-brightness idea drives professional detection limits.

2. Kinds of object

  • Open clusters: young stars born together, loose, in the Milky Way’s disc (the Pleiades, M45).
  • Globular clusters: dense balls of 100,000+ ancient stars in the galaxy’s halo (M13).
  • Emission nebulae: gas glowing red from hydrogen, lit by hot young stars (the Orion Nebula, M42).
  • Reflection nebulae: dust reflecting starlight, often blue.
  • Planetary nebulae: shells thrown off by dying Sun-like stars (the Ring Nebula, M57). Nothing to do with planets: they looked like discs in early telescopes.
  • Supernova remnants: debris of exploded stars (the Crab Nebula, M1).
  • Galaxies: other star systems millions of light-years away (Andromeda, M31; the Whirlpool, M51).

3. Catalogues

  • Messier (M): 110 bright objects, mostly visible from mid-northern latitudes, listed by Charles Messier in the 1700s.
  • NGC and IC: the New General Catalogue (1888) and its Index Catalogues list about 13,000 objects. The open OpenNGC database keeps modern positions, sizes and magnitudes.
  • Caldwell (C): 109 popular objects Messier missed, including southern ones.
μ = m + 2.5 log₁₀ A
Average surface brightness: magnitude spread over area A (arcsec²).
A = π(30a)(30b)
Area of an ellipse a′ × b′ in square arcseconds.
Messier / NGC
Catalogues: 110 bright objects / about 7,800 objects.
Physical meaning
Imagine two lamps with the same bulb, one behind a small frosted window and one behind a whole frosted wall. The small window glows bright; the wall is a faint glow you might miss. Galaxies are the same: total light matters less than how concentrated it is.

“A telescope makes faint nebulae brighter.” No telescope can make an extended object’s surface brighter than it looks to the naked eye; it only makes it bigger, so your eye can see detail. That is why dark skies matter as much as aperture.

4. Surface brightness

A galaxy’s total magnitude is all its light added up as if squeezed into a point. But you see it spread over an area. Its average surface brightness compares directly with the sky’s (Lesson 3.2): if the galaxy is fainter per square arcsecond than the sky, it is very hard to see.

Try it: spread the light out
average surface brightness
compared with the sky
The galaxy is drawn as a round glow; its brightness per square arcsecond is the total magnitude spread over its area. When it is fainter than the sky itself it is hard to see by eye, however bright its total magnitude sounds. Made-up object. Real galaxies are brighter in the core than this average.

Things to notice:

  • Make the object bigger with the same magnitude: it fades towards the sky.
  • Darken the sky: the same object stands out. That is why dark sites matter so much for galaxies.

Compare two galaxies of similar total brightness:

M33, the Triangulum Galaxy. Total magnitude 5.7: bright enough for the naked eye in theory.
But spread out. It covers 70′ × 40′, over twice the area of the full Moon. Its surface brightness is about 23 mag/arcsec²: fainter than a dark sky.
M51, the Whirlpool. Total magnitude 8.4, ten times fainter in total.
But compact. Only 11′ × 7′, so its surface brightness is about 21.7 mag/arcsec²: it stands out better in a telescope.
The lesson. Low power and dark skies for big, faint objects; more power for small, bright ones.
Maths and principle

Average surface brightness of an object of total magnitude m covering an area A (square arcseconds):

μ=m+2.5log10⁡A

For an ellipse with axes a×b arcminutes, A=π×(30a)×(30b) arcsec².

Effect of magnification: a telescope can’t raise surface brightness above the naked-eye value; higher power spreads the light over a bigger apparent area, dimming it but making it larger, which helps the eye up to a point.

Try it: M33, the Triangulum Galaxy, total magnitude about 5.7 but about 70′ × 40′: μ=5.7+2.5log10⁡(π×2100×1200)=5.7+2.5×6.90=23.0. That is fainter than even a dark sky (about 21.8), which is why M33 is notoriously hard despite its “naked-eye” magnitude.

5. Worked example

Which is easier: M57, the Ring Nebula (magnitude about 8.8, about 1.4′ × 1.0′), or M101, the Pinwheel Galaxy (about 7.9, about 29′ × 27′)?

  • M57: μ=8.8+2.5log10⁡(π×42×30)=8.8+2.5×3.60=17.8.
  • M101: μ=7.9+2.5log10⁡(π×870×810)=7.9+2.5×6.35=23.8.

M57 is 6 magnitudes brighter per square arcsecond and shows even from a suburb; M101, although brighter in total, needs a dark sky. (Values are approximate catalogue figures, rounded.)

6. Practice

More practice (answers below):

  1. What is the average surface brightness of a 10th-magnitude galaxy 4′ × 2′?
  2. Why is the Pleiades easy in a city but the Andromeda Galaxy’s outer arms are not?
  3. What kind of object is M42?
Answers
  1. 10+2.5log10⁡(π×120×60)=10+2.5×4.35=20.9.
  2. The Pleiades are bright stars (points); Andromeda’s arms are faint spread-out light with surface brightness well below a city sky.
  3. An emission nebula, a star-forming region.
  • Deep-sky objects: open and globular clusters, nebulae, galaxies.
  • Surface brightness μ = m + 2.5 log₁₀(area) decides visibility.
  • Use low power for large faint objects; dark skies help most.
  • Messier (110) and NGC (about 7,800) are the classic lists.

Try it on the real sky: get a list of the best deep-sky objects for your sky and telescope tonight with the observing session planner planner, and check when each is highest with target altitude planner.

New words: open cluster, globular cluster, emission, reflection and planetary nebula, galaxy, Messier catalogue, NGC, surface brightness.

Check yourself

1Why did Charles Messier make his catalogue?
2Two galaxies both have total magnitude 9. One is 3′ across, the other 30′. Which is easier to see?
3Which is a globular cluster?

Sources

  • Messier objects: Messier, C. (1781), Connaissance des Temps; modern data via SEDS Messier database and NASA
  • NGC/IC data: OpenNGC (CC-BY-SA 4.0), github.com/mattiaverga/OpenNGC

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers in the examples are made up to show the idea unless a source is given. Simulations run in your browser on made-up data; nothing you type is sent anywhere. Astronomy only: nothing here is astrology.