Module 3: Dark skies and your eyes · Lesson 3.3 · about 25 min
Seeing and transparency
Seeing is how steady the air is; transparency is how clear it is. Seeing blurs stars into fuzzy discs and limits detail on planets; transparency dims faint objects. They are different, and a night can be good for one and bad for the other.
Module 3 · about 25 minutes · read first: 3.2 Light pollution and the Bortle scale, 2.6 Airmass: why low objects look dim · maths: some physics. You’ll be able to tell seeing from transparency, estimate the blur of a star from both the telescope and the air, and decide what to observe on a given night.
1. Why this matters
Planetary observers live and die by seeing; deep-sky observers by transparency. Knowing which you have tonight tells you whether to point at Saturn or at a faint galaxy, and why a bigger telescope sometimes shows no more detail than a small one. Professional observatories are built on mountain tops in deserts for both reasons.
2. Seeing: the air’s wobble
The atmosphere is full of pockets of air at slightly different temperatures, and so with slightly different refractive index. As light crosses them it is bent this way and that, thousands of times a second. The result:
- To the eye, stars twinkle (scintillation).
- In a telescope, a star becomes a dancing, smeared blob instead of a sharp point, and planets “boil”.
Seeing is measured as the width of a star’s blurred image (its FWHM, full width at half maximum) in arcseconds: about 0.5″ at the best mountain sites on a great night, 1″ to 2″ typical for good amateur sites, 3″ or more on a poor night or near a warm roof.
3. Transparency: the air’s clarity
Transparency is how much light gets through at all: affected by haze, humidity, dust, smoke and thin cloud. A transparent night shows deep blue twilight, a crisp Milky Way and faint stars near the horizon. Strangely, very transparent nights after a cold front often have poor seeing (turbulent air), while hazy, still nights can have excellent seeing.
- Seeing
- Blur from turbulent air; measured in arcseconds.
- r₀
- Fried parameter: size of a patch of steady air (5 to 20 cm typical).
- ε ≈ 0.98 λ / r₀
- Seeing blur at wavelength λ.
- Transparency
- How much light gets through: haze, dust, thin cloud.
- Physical meaning
- Seeing is like looking at a coin at the bottom of a rippling pool: the water is clear, but the ripples make the coin dance. Transparency is muddy water: still but dim. Telescopes bigger than r₀ cannot beat the ripples, which is why big observatories sit on calm mountain tops.
“A clear sky full of stars is always a good night for planets.” The clearest nights often follow cold fronts with turbulent air and bad seeing. Planets look best on calm, slightly hazy nights.
4. The telescope’s own limit
Even with perfect air, a telescope cannot show a point as a point: light waves passing through a round opening spread into a small pattern (the Airy disc). The smallest separation two equal stars can have and still be resolved is set by the aperture (Lesson 4.4 goes further). The figure combines both blurs.
Things to notice:
- With seeing set to 0, a bigger aperture always splits closer pairs.
- With seeing at 2″, going beyond about 100 mm barely helps: the air, not the telescope, sets the limit. Big telescopes still collect more light, though.
Compare two nights through the same telescope:
Maths and principle
Diffraction (Rayleigh criterion): two stars are just resolved when
Seeing from turbulence: the Fried parameter is the size of a patch of air over which the wavefront is roughly flat (typically 5 to 20 cm in green light). The seeing blur is about
so a telescope larger than is limited by the air, not by its aperture.
Combining blurs: for rough work, blurs add “in quadrature”: .
Try it: cm at 550 nm: rad .
5. Worked example
A 250 mm telescope on a night of 2.5″ seeing. Can it split a double star 1.5″ apart?
- Rayleigh limit: rad . The telescope alone could split it easily.
- Combined blur (using the diffraction FWHM, a little narrower than the Rayleigh figure): .
- The gap (1.5″) is smaller than the blur, so the pair merges into one elongated blob. Try again on a steadier night, or wait for moments of good seeing: the air settles for fractions of a second, which is why patient observers (and “lucky imaging” cameras) still catch fine detail.
6. Practice
More practice (answers below):
- Find the Rayleigh limit of a 100 mm telescope.
- On a night with cm, what is the seeing?
- The Moon looks sharp and steady, but faint galaxies are invisible. Which observing would you choose?
Answers
- rad = 1.38″.
- rad = 2.2″.
- Good seeing, poor transparency: the Moon, planets and double stars.
- Seeing (steadiness) and transparency (clarity) are different.
- Seeing blur ε ≈ 0.98 λ/r₀; typical 1″ to 3″.
- Big telescopes are usually limited by seeing, not aperture.
- Pick galaxies for transparent nights and planets for steady ones.
Try it with real numbers: measure the blur of stars in your own images with the star FWHM checker, or work out your telescope’s resolution with the telescope calculator.
New words: seeing, transparency, scintillation, FWHM, Airy disc, Rayleigh criterion, Fried parameter.
Check yourself
Sources
- Fried, D. L. (1966), Optical resolution through a randomly inhomogeneous medium, JOSA 56, 1372
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers in the examples are made up to show the idea unless a source is given. Simulations run in your browser on made-up data; nothing you type is sent anywhere. Astronomy only: nothing here is astrology.