Home / Learn / Exam prep / CSIR NET Physics / Lesson 10.3
All lessons

Module 10: Nuclear and particle physics · Lesson 10.3 · about 45 min

The collective model and nuclear deformation

When nucleons move together: the evidence for deformed nuclei, the deformation parameter β and the intrinsic quadrupole moment, the spectroscopic quadrupole moment Q = Q₀[3K² − I(I+1)]/[(I+1)(2I+3)], rotational bands E = (ħ²/2𝓘)I(I+1) with gamma-ray ladders and K bands in odd-A nuclei, the moment of inertia between rigid and irrotational values, quadrupole vibrations and phonon multiplets, and the ratio E(4⁺)/E(2⁺) that tells a rotor from a vibrator.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 10 · about 45 minutes. The shell model treats each nucleon as moving alone in an average potential. It works superbly near magic numbers, and fails between them: rare-earth and actinide nuclei have quadrupole moments 20 times larger than one proton could give, and their low levels form ladders with energies that go like I(I+1). The collective model of Bohr and Mottelson explains both. The nucleus as a whole takes a deformed shape, and that shape can rotate and vibrate.

Far from closed shells, many nucleons outside the core polarise it into a spheroid. A deformed body has a direction, so it can rotate, and the rotational levels E = (ħ²/2𝓘)I(I+1) are low (tens of keV) because 𝓘 is large. A spherical nucleus cannot rotate in the quantum sense, but its surface can vibrate, giving equally spaced phonon levels. One number, E(4⁺)/E(2⁺), tells the two apart: 10/3 for a rotor, 2 for a vibrator.

1. Describing the shape

Write the nuclear surface as a multipole expansion and keep the quadrupole term for an axially symmetric shape:

R(θ)=R0[1+βY20(θ)],Q0=35πZR02β(1+0.16β)
`$\beta > 0$`
prolate (cigar), the usual case in rare earths and actinides, `$\beta \approx 0.2$` to `$0.35$`
`$\beta < 0$`
oblate (disc)
`$Q_0$`
intrinsic quadrupole moment, measured in the body frame: `$Q_0 = \int\rho(3z'^2 - r^2)\,d\tau/e$`
`$\gamma$`
a second parameter for non-axial (triaxial) shapes; `$\gamma = 0$` is axial

Worked example. Take Z=68, A=170, β=0.30. R0=1.2×1701/3=6.65 fm, R02=44.2 fm². Q0=0.757×68×44.2×0.30×1.048=715 fm² = 7.2 b. One proton in an orbit of radius R0 gives at most about R02=0.44 b, so 7 b is a clear sign of many nucleons moving together.

What the lab measures

The lab sees the intrinsic shape averaged over the rotation. For a state of spin I in a band with projection K on the symmetry axis:

Q=Q03K2−I(I+1)(I+1)(2I+3)

I = 0 or ½. Q = 0 always: no direction in space to measure. Every even-even ground state has Q = 0, deformed or not.

First 2⁺ in a K = 0 band. Q = Q₀(0 − 6)/(3 × 7) = −(2/7)Q₀: negative for a prolate nucleus, because the rotation axis is perpendicular to the long axis.

Odd-A band head, I = K. Q = Q₀ I(2I − 1)/[(I + 1)(2I + 3)], always smaller than Q₀ and approaching it only for large I.

B(E2). The reduced transition rate 2⁺ → 0⁺ is B(E2) = (5/16π)e²Q₀², often 100 to 300 single-particle (Weisskopf) units in deformed nuclei: the cleanest measure of collectivity.

Worked example. An odd-A nucleus with Q0=7.0 b and ground state I=K=7/2: Q=7.0×(7/2)(6)/[(9/2)(10)]=7.0×21/45=3.3 b.

2. Rotational bands

A rigid symmetric top with moment of inertia ℐ about an axis perpendicular to the symmetry axis has E=ℏ2[I(I+1)−K2]/2ℐ plus intrinsic energy (see rotational spectra for the same physics in molecules). A quantum system cannot rotate about its own symmetry axis collectively, so K comes from the intrinsic (single-particle) motion.

EI=ℏ22ℐI(I+1)  (K=0: I=0,2,4,…),EI=EK+ℏ22ℐ[I(I+1)−K(K+1)]  (I=K,K+1,…)
Ratios in a K = 0 band
`$E_4/E_2 = 20/6 = 3.33$`, `$E_6/E_2 = 7$`, `$E_8/E_2 = 12$`
E2 gamma rays
`$I \to I - 2$` has `$E_\gamma = (\hbar^2/2\mathcal I)(4I - 2)$`: 6, 14, 22, 30, ... units, rising in equal steps of `$8\hbar^2/2\mathcal I$`
Only even I for K = 0
the intrinsic state is symmetric under a 180° turn about an axis perpendicular to the symmetry axis, which removes the odd spins
K = ½ bands
Coriolis coupling adds a decoupling term `$a(-1)^{I+1/2}(I + \tfrac12)$`, which staggers the levels

Worked example. A deformed nucleus has its 2⁺ at 80 keV. Then ℏ2/2ℐ=13.3 keV and the band should run 4⁺ 267, 6⁺ 560, 8⁺ 960 keV, with gamma rays of 80, 187, 293, 400 keV. In ¹⁶⁶Er the measured levels are 81, 265, 545 and 911 keV: close, and slightly low at high spin. That is centrifugal stretching: the faster rotation deforms the nucleus a little more, raising ℐ. A two-term fit E=AI(I+1)−BI2(I+1)2 with B∼10−3A captures it.

How big is 𝓘?

Two classical limits bracket the measured value.

ℐrigid=25AmR02(1+0.31β),ℐirrot=98πAmR02β2

For A=170, R0=6.65 fm: ℏ2/2ℐrigid=(197.33)2/(2×0.4×170×931.5×44.2)≈7 keV (6.4 keV with the 1+0.31β factor), while the irrotational value with β=0.3 is about 13 times smaller in ℐ (so about 85 keV). The measured 13 keV sits in between: about half the rigid value. Pairing makes the nucleus partly superfluid, so not all nucleons follow the rotation. At high spin, pairs break (the Coriolis force aligns a pair of high-j nucleons) and ℐ jumps up: backbending.

3. Vibrations of a spherical nucleus

Near closed shells the nucleus stays spherical on average but its surface can oscillate. The lowest mode is quadrupole (λ=2, the λ=1 mode would move the centre of mass). Each quantum, a phonon, carries 2+:

One phonon. A 2⁺ state at ħω (typically 0.5 to 1.5 MeV).

Two phonons. Two identical bosons of spin 2 couple only to symmetric states: total I = 0, 2, 4 (not 1 or 3), all at 2ħω.

Three phonons. I = 0, 2, 3, 4, 6 at 3ħω.

Ratio. E(4⁺)/E(2⁺) = 2. Real vibrational nuclei (Cd, Te isotopes) show a triplet near 2ħω, split by anharmonic terms. Octupole (3⁻) phonons appear higher, near 2 to 3 MeV.

Rotor and vibrator built from the same first 2⁺ energy. Left: a K = 0 band with its E2 gamma rays rising in equal steps. Middle (optional): an odd-A band on K = 3/2 or 7/2, with every spin from K upward. Right: harmonic quadrupole phonon multiplets. The 4⁺ sits at 10/3 of the 2⁺ for the rotor and at 2 for the vibrator.

Telling them apart in an exam. Look at, in order: the energy of the first 2⁺ (low, below 100 keV, means deformed); E(4+)/E(2+) (3.33 rotor, 2.0 vibrator, around 2.5 in between, γ-soft); the existence of a 0⁺, 2⁺, 4⁺ triplet near 2E(2+); large B(E2) values. Nuclei between the limits are described by the interacting boson model, which interpolates with symmetry labels.

4. Deformed single-particle levels

In a deformed well the (2j+1)-fold degeneracy of each shell-model level splits by |Ω|, the projection of j on the symmetry axis, each ±Ω pair twofold (the Nilsson model). For prolate shapes, low |Ω| orbits (which lie along the long axis) go down in energy. The odd nucleon’s Ω becomes the band’s K, and its parity the band’s parity. This explains the ground-state spins of odd-A deformed nuclei, which the spherical shell model often gets wrong.

“A nucleus with Q = 0 in its ground state must be spherical.” Every even-even ground state is 0+ and has Q=0 in the lab, even ¹⁶⁶Er with Q0≈7 b. Deformation shows up in the low 2⁺ energy, the I(I+1) band, the large B(E2), and the measured Q(2+)≈−(2/7)Q0. The same averaging is why odd-A nuclei with I=12 never show a quadrupole moment.

  • Shape: R=R0(1+βY20); Q0=(3/5π)ZR02β(1+0.16β); prolate β>0.
  • Lab moment Q=Q0[3K2−I(I+1)]/[(I+1)(2I+3)]: zero for I=0,12; −27Q0 for the 2⁺ of a K = 0 band.
  • K = 0 band: E=(ℏ2/2ℐ)I(I+1), even I, E4/E2=10/3; gamma rays (ℏ2/2ℐ)(4I−2); odd-A: I=K,K+1,… with I(I+1)−K(K+1).
  • ℐirrot<ℐexp≈12ℐrigid; pairing; centrifugal stretching; backbending.
  • Vibrator: 2⁺ phonons; two-phonon 0⁺, 2⁺, 4⁺ at 2ℏω; three-phonon 0, 2, 3, 4, 6; E4/E2=2.
  • B(E2) =(5/16π)e2Q02 measures collectivity; Nilsson levels labelled by Ω give K.

Practise: exam questions on this lesson

Next: lesson 10.4 goes inside the nucleon: isospin, strangeness and the quark model. For coupling angular momenta in these bands, see LS and jj coupling; for the nuclear radius and binding used here, see the JAM lesson on nuclei and radioactivity.

Check yourself

1An even-even nucleus has levels 0⁺ (0), 2⁺ (92 keV), 4⁺ (305 keV), 6⁺ (640 keV). It is best described as
2The ground state of an even-even deformed nucleus has intrinsic quadrupole moment Q₀ = 6 b. The measured (spectroscopic) quadrupole moment of that 0⁺ ground state is
3In an odd-A nucleus with a band built on K = 5/2, the band members have spins

Sources

  • A. Bohr and B. R. Mottelson, Nuclear Structure, vol. II (1975), chapters 4 and 6
  • K. S. Krane, Introductory Nuclear Physics (1988), chapter 5
  • K. Heyde, Basic Ideas and Concepts in Nuclear Physics, 3rd ed. (2004), chapters 12 and 13
  • CSIR-UGC NET Physical Sciences syllabus, Part C nuclear and particle physics, published by the National Testing Agency

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with CSIR, UGC or the National Testing Agency. Check the official CSIR NET website for the current pattern. All questions are original.