Module 10: Nuclear and particle physics · Lesson 10.2 · about 45 min
The deuteron and the nuclear force
What the deuteron tells us about the nuclear force: its binding energy, spin, parity, magnetic moment and quadrupole moment; the square-well model with k cot kR = −κ, the minimum V₀R², the depth and the large probability outside the range; the D-state admixture and the tensor force; low-energy neutron-proton scattering, scattering length and effective range, the singlet virtual state; charge independence, isospin and the Yukawa range.
Module 10 · about 45 minutes. The JAM lesson on nuclei and radioactivity used the nuclear force as a black box that holds nucleons together. The deuteron, one proton and one neutron, is the only two-nucleon bound state, and it is the cleanest place to open the box. Add low-energy neutron-proton scattering and you have almost everything NET asks about the force between two nucleons.
1. What is measured
- Binding energy
- `$B = 2.2246$` MeV, from the 2.22 MeV gamma ray in `$n + p \to d + \gamma$` or the threshold of photodisintegration
- Spin and parity
- `$J^P = 1^+$`, so `$L$` is even and `$S = 1$`: `$^3S_1$` with some `$^3D_1$`
- Magnetic moment
- `$\mu_d = 0.8574\,\mu_N$`, close to but not equal to `$\mu_p + \mu_n = 2.7928 - 1.9130 = 0.8798\,\mu_N$`
- Quadrupole moment
- `$Q = +0.286$` fm²: small but not zero, and positive, so the deuteron is slightly prolate (cigar-shaped). A pure S state would have `$Q = 0$`
- Size
- rms radius 2.1 fm, large for two nucleons
- Excited states
- none bound
2. The square-well model
Use the radial function , reduced mass ( MeV), , and a well of depth and range . With :
Inside (r < R). u″ = −k²u with k = √(2μ(V₀ − B))/ħ. The solution that vanishes at r = 0 is u = A sin kr.
Outside (r > R). u″ = κ²u with κ = √(2μB)/ħ. The solution that stays finite is u = C e−κr.
Match u′/u at R. k cot kR = −κ. Because κ ≪ k, cot kR is small and negative, so kR is just above π/2.
Solve. Given R, find k numerically, then V₀ = ħ²k²/2μ + B. Only the combination V₀R² is fixed closely by B; R itself must come from scattering.
Worked example. Take fm. Solving gives fm⁻¹ (, against ). Then MeV. The tail length is fm, twice the range. Normalising shows that the np pair is outside the well about 63% of the time. Compare the depth that would bind at zero energy with the same range, MeV: the last 2.2 MeV of binding costs about 10 MeV of extra depth.
Why no excited states? A second S state would need , a well nine times deeper in . A P state () needs just to bind at zero energy: a well four times deeper. The real force is far short of both, so the deuteron has one bound state.
3. The D state and the tensor force
A central force conserves , so it cannot mix and . The measured needs a non-central term. The one-pion exchange potential contains the tensor operator
which depends on the angle between the spins and the line joining the nucleons. It conserves and parity, but mixes with . Write . The magnetic moment is
Worked example. , so . The quadrupole moment points the same way (a few percent D state gives fm²). The admixture is model-dependent (meson-exchange corrections shift ), but it is small and it is there.
4. Low-energy np scattering
At low energy only the S wave scatters: . The behaviour as defines the scattering length and the effective range :
- Geometric meaning
- outside the force, the zero-energy `$u(r)$` is a straight line; it crosses zero at `$r = a$`. A bound state bends it over (`$a > 0$`); a state that just misses binding gives a large negative `$a$`
- Triplet (`$S = 1$`)
- `$a_t = +5.42$` fm, `$r_t = 1.75$` fm: the deuteron channel. With `$1/a_t \approx \kappa - \tfrac12r_t\kappa^2 = 0.2316 - 0.0469 = 0.185$` fm⁻¹, `$a_t \approx 5.41$` fm, so the deuteron binding and np scattering agree
- Singlet (`$S = 0$`)
- `$a_s = -23.7$` fm, `$r_s = 2.7$` fm: attractive but unbound, a virtual state about 66 keV above zero
- Unpolarised cross section
- 3 triplet states to 1 singlet: `$\sigma = \pi(3a_t^2 + a_s^2) = 20.4$` b, matching the measured free-proton cross section. Using only the deuteron (`$4\pi a_t^2 = 3.7$` b) misses by a factor of 5: the first proof that the force depends on spin
Scattering of slow neutrons from ortho-hydrogen (proton spins parallel) and para-hydrogen (antiparallel) gives very different cross sections, which fixes the sign of : coherent scattering from the two protons adds amplitudes, so the interference depends on the singlet-triplet difference.
5. Properties of the nuclear force
Short range and strong. About 1 to 2 fm, depth tens of MeV. Yukawa: exchanging a pion of mass mπ gives V ∝ e−r/λ/r with λ = ħ/mπc = 197.33/139.6 = 1.41 fm.
Repulsive core. Below about 0.5 fm the force turns strongly repulsive (heavier ω exchange); with the short range, this gives saturation: binding per nucleon and density stay nearly constant across nuclei.
Spin dependent and tensor. Triplet bound, singlet not; tensor term mixes S and D. A spin-orbit term (seen in polarised scattering) also exists and drives the shell model's magic numbers.
Charge independent. After Coulomb corrections, pp, nn and np forces in the same state are nearly equal (singlet app ≈ ann ≈ −17 to −19 fm, anp = −23.7 fm: a small breaking). This is isospin symmetry: the nucleon is a doublet with T₃ = +½ (p) and −½ (n).
Isospin explains why there is no bound diproton or dineutron. Two nucleons in with have a symmetric space and spin part, so the overall antisymmetry demands an antisymmetric isospin part, : only np can do that. The triplet (pp, nn, and np in ) is the unbound singlet channel. More on isospin in lesson 10.4.
“The deuteron sits deep in its well, like an electron in hydrogen, so its size is set by the range of the force.” It is the opposite. The binding is a small fraction of the depth, is close to , and the wavefunction leaks far outside: the rms radius (2.1 fm) and the tail fm are set mainly by , not by . That is why alone fixes only , and why the deuteron is so easy to break up.
- Deuteron: MeV, , , , fm², no excited states.
- Square well: , fm⁻¹; minimum binding MeV fm²; for fm, MeV and most of the probability is outside.
- D state of about 4% from and : evidence for the tensor force .
- Scattering: ; fm, fm; b.
- Force: short range ( fm), hard core, saturation, spin dependent, tensor, spin-orbit, charge independent (isospin).
Practise: exam questions on this lesson
Next: lesson 10.3 moves from two nucleons to many, where the nucleus as a whole can rotate and vibrate. For the scattering theory used here (partial waves, phase shifts), see the GATE lesson on central forces and scattering; for the angular momentum coupling, see angular momentum.
Check yourself
Sources
- K. S. Krane, Introductory Nuclear Physics (1988), chapter 4
- S. S. M. Wong, Introductory Nuclear Physics, 2nd ed. (1998), chapter 3
- J. M. Blatt and V. F. Weisskopf, Theoretical Nuclear Physics (1952), chapter II
- CSIR-UGC NET Physical Sciences syllabus, Part C nuclear and particle physics, published by the National Testing Agency
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with CSIR, UGC or the National Testing Agency. Check the official CSIR NET website for the current pattern. All questions are original.