All lessons

Module 5: Quantum mechanics · Lesson 5.3 · about 55 min

Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations

Relativistic quantum mechanics for CSIR NET: the Klein-Gordon equation and its density, the Yukawa range of a force, the Dirac equation, alpha, beta and gamma matrices with their traces, free spinors and negative energies, spin and helicity, zitterbewegung, the non-relativistic limit with g = 2, the exact Dirac hydrogen levels and the Klein paradox.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 5 · about 55 minutes. Schrödinger’s equation treats time and space unequally (one time derivative, two space derivatives), so it cannot be relativistic. Making it relativistic produced two equations, two surprises (negative energies and spin) and, after reinterpretation, antimatter. CSIR NET asks about the algebra of the Dirac matrices, the meaning of the negative-energy states and the hydrogen fine structure. The kinematics, E2=p2c2+m2c4 and four-vectors, are in relativistic kinematics and special relativity; the perturbative fine structure is in fine structure.

Quantise E² = p²c² + m²c⁴ directly and you get the Klein-Gordon equation, right for spin 0 but with no positive probability. Demand an equation first order in time and space and you are forced to 4 × 4 matrices: the Dirac equation, which brings spin ½, g = 2 and the fine structure of hydrogen for free, and whose negative-energy solutions are antiparticles.

1. The Klein-Gordon equation

Substitute E→iℏ∂t, p→→−iℏ∇ in E2=p2c2+m2c4:

(1c2∂2∂t2−∇2+m2c2ℏ2)ψ=0,(□+μ2)ψ=0,μ=mcℏ

Plane waves ei(p→⋅r→−Et)/ℏ solve it for E=±p2c2+m2c4: both signs. The conserved current is

ρ=iℏ2mc2(ψ∗∂ψ∂t−ψ∂ψ∗∂t),j→=ℏ2mi(ψ∗∇ψ−ψ∇ψ∗)

For a plane wave ρ=(E/mc2)|ψ|2, negative on the lower branch. The cure (Pauli and Weisskopf) is to read eρ as a charge density: positive for particles, negative for antiparticles. The Klein-Gordon equation describes spin-0 particles such as pions, as a field theory rather than a one-particle wave equation.

Yukawa’s range. The static Klein-Gordon equation with a point source, (∇2−μ2)ϕ=−gδ3(r→), gives

ϕ(r)=g4πe−r/λr,λ=ℏmc

A force carried by a particle of mass m has range equal to its reduced Compton wavelength. For the pion, ℏc/mπc2=197.3/139.6=1.41 fm, the range of the nuclear force; massless photons give the infinite-range Coulomb law. This is the Yukawa potential whose Born cross-section appears in scattering theory.

2. The Dirac equation

Dirac wanted iℏ∂tψ=Hψ with H linear in p→:

iℏ∂ψ∂t=(cα→⋅p→+βmc2)ψ

Squaring must give E2=p2c2+m2c4, which requires

αi2=β2=1,αiαj+αjαi=0 (i≠j),αiβ+βαi=0

Four mutually anticommuting matrices that square to 1 must be traceless with eigenvalues ±1, so even-dimensional; 2 × 2 has room for only three (the Pauli matrices). The smallest choice is 4 × 4, and ψ has four components. In the standard (Dirac) representation

β=(I00−I),αi=(0σiσi0)

Covariant form. With γ0=β, γi=βαi: (iℏγμ∂μ−mc)ψ=0 and {γμ,γν}=2gμν (metric +−−−). Facts that NET tests:

Quantity Value
(γ0)2, (γi)2 +1, −1
Trγμ, trace of any odd number of γs 0
Tr(γμγν) 4gμν
Tr(γμγνγργσ) 4(gμνgρσ−gμρgνσ+gμσgνρ)
γ5=iγ0γ1γ2γ3 (γ5)2=1, {γ5,γμ}=0, Trγ5=0
γμγμ 4

The density ρ=ψ†ψ is positive definite, which is what Dirac was after.

ψ (Dirac)
four-component spinor: two spin states times two energy signs
α, β
4 × 4 anticommuting matrices, each squaring to 1
γμ
covariant matrices, {γμ, γν} = 2gμν
λ = ħ/mc
reduced Compton wavelength: 386 fm for the electron, 1.41 fm for the pion
Helicity
spin along the momentum, Σ·p̂/2, conserved for a free particle
Physical meaning
Spin is not put in by hand: a first-order relativistic equation needs a multi-component wavefunction, and the extra components behave as spin ½ with magnetic moment g = 2.

3. Free particles, spin and the negative sea

For a particle at rest, H=βmc2: two solutions with E=+mc2 (upper components) and two with E=−mc2 (lower). In motion, the positive-energy spinor is

u(p→)=E+mc22mc2(χcσ→⋅p→E+mc2χ)

The lower (“small”) components are of order v/2c: about 0.4% of the upper ones for an electron in hydrogen.

Spin. [H,L→]=−iℏcα→×p→≠0, so orbital angular momentum alone is not conserved. What commutes with H is J→=L→+ℏ2Σ→, with Σ→=diag(σ→,σ→). The electron has spin ½ built in. The helicity h=Σ→⋅pˆ commutes with the free H, so free particles keep their helicity.

Zitterbewegung. The velocity operator is r→˙=i[H,r→]/ℏ=cα→, with eigenvalues ±c. A wave packet built from positive-energy states alone moves smoothly; one that mixes in negative energies jitters at angular frequency 2mc2/ℏ (about 1.6×1021 s⁻¹) with amplitude about ℏ/2mc=1.9×10−13 m. Localising an electron more sharply than its Compton wavelength needs negative-energy components, which is the deeper reason a one-particle picture breaks down there.

Hole theory. Why do electrons not fall into the negative-energy states, radiating forever? Dirac’s answer: all of them are already filled. A hole in the sea behaves as a particle of charge +e and positive energy: the positron (found by Anderson in 1932). Lifting an electron out of the sea, across the gap 2mc2, is pair creation.

The two branches E = ±√(p²c² + m²c⁴) with the 2mc² gap, the light cone and the non-relativistic parabola. The second view plots the exact Dirac binding of hydrogen-like ions against Z: 2s₁/₂ and 2p₁/₂ stay together, and 1s₁/₂ runs out at Z = 137.

Pair-production thresholds. A single photon cannot make a pair in empty space (momentum cannot be conserved). Near a nucleus of mass M the threshold is 2mc2(1+m/M)≈1.022 MeV; near a free electron at rest it is 4mc2=2.044 MeV, from the invariant mass s=m2c4+2Eγmc2≥(3mc2)2.

4. The non-relativistic limit and hydrogen

Coupling to fields by p→→p→−qA→, E→E−qV, and eliminating the small components to order v2/c2 gives

H=(p→−qA→)22m−qℏ2mσ→⋅B→+qV−p48m3c2+12m2c21rdUdrS→⋅L→+ℏ28m2c2∇2U

The second term is the Pauli spin coupling with g = 2 exactly (QED adds α/2π). The last three are the fine-structure terms: relativistic kinetic energy, spin-orbit (with the Thomas factor ½ already included) and the Darwin term, which acts only on s states and comes from zitterbewegung smearing the electron over a Compton wavelength.

Exact Dirac hydrogen. For a point nucleus of charge Ze, with α=1/137.036,

Enj=mc21+(Zαn−δj)2,δj=j+12−(j+12)2−Z2α2

Expanding in Zα:

Enj≈mc2−mc2(Zα)22n2−mc2(Zα)42n4(nj+12−34)

The levels depend on n and j only. For n=2, 2p3/2 lies above the degenerate pair 2s1/2, 2p1/2 by mc2α4/32=4.53×10−5 eV (10.9 GHz) in hydrogen. The Lamb shift, 1058 MHz, separates 2s1/2 from 2p1/2, and is beyond the Dirac equation.

Worked example: a heavy ion

Ground state. For n = 1, j = ½, δ = 1 − √(1 − Z²α²), so n − δ = √(1 − Z²α²) and E1s = mc²√(1 − Z²α²).

Lead, Z = 82. Zα = 0.5984, √(1 − 0.3581) = 0.8012, E = 409.4 keV, so the binding energy is 511.0 − 409.4 = 101.6 keV.

Compare Bohr. 13.606 × 82² eV = 91.5 keV. Relativity binds the 1s electron 11% more tightly: the electron moves at about Zαc = 0.6c.

The edge. At Zα = 1 (Z ≈ 137) the square root vanishes and beyond it E is complex for a point nucleus. Real nuclei have finite size, which pushes the critical charge to about Z = 170, where the 1s level would touch −mc² and the vacuum would spark pairs.

5. The Klein paradox

Send an electron of energy E at a potential step of height V0. If V0>E+mc2, the region beyond the step has (E−V0)2>m2c4 with E−V0<−mc2: propagating negative-energy states. The wave is transmitted, and for a sharp step the reflection coefficient can exceed the naive value. The resolution is pair creation at the step: the strong field rips electron-positron pairs from the vacuum, and the positrons travel into the barrier. A step is “sharp” if it rises by 2mc2 over less than a Compton wavelength, a field of order m2c3/eℏ=1.3×1018 V/m (the Schwinger field). The paradox shows a single-particle Dirac theory is incomplete; quantum field theory finishes the job.

“The Dirac equation predicts spin because it is relativistic.” Not quite. Spin ½ and g=2 come from the equation being first order with a multi-component wavefunction. The non-relativistic Pauli-Schrödinger equation written as (σ→⋅π→)2/2m, with π→=p→−qA→, also gives g=2 (Lévy-Leblond). What relativity adds is the negative-energy solutions, the Thomas factor and the exact fine structure.

  • Klein-Gordon (□+m2c2/ℏ2)ψ=0, spin 0; ρ∝E can be negative, so it is a charge density. Static Green’s function: Yukawa e−r/λ/r, λ=ℏ/mc (pion 1.41 fm).
  • Dirac H=cα→⋅p→+βmc2, αi2=β2=1, all anticommute, 4 × 4 minimum; {γμ,γν}=2gμν, Trγμγν=4gμν, odd traces vanish, (γ5)2=1.
  • J→=L→+ℏ2Σ→ conserved; helicity conserved when free; velocity cα→ has eigenvalues ±c; zitterbewegung at 2mc2/ℏ, amplitude ℏ/2mc.
  • Holes are positrons; pair threshold 2mc2 near a nucleus, 4mc2 on a free electron.
  • Non-relativistic limit: Pauli term with g=2, plus p4, spin-orbit and Darwin terms.
  • Enj=mc2[1+(Zα/(n−δj))2]−1/2, δj=j+12−(j+12)2−Z2α2; depends on n,j; E1s=mc21−Z2α2; hydrogen 2p splitting 4.53 × 10⁻⁵ eV.
  • Klein paradox: step V0>E+mc2 transmits through negative-energy states, really pair creation.

Practise: exam questions on this lesson

NET Part C style, each with a full solution. More on the CSIR NET Physics practice page.

Next: the statistical physics module starts with its roadmap, then fluctuations, diffusion and Brownian motion. For the angular momentum algebra behind j = l ± ½, see angular momentum.

Check yourself

1Why can the Klein-Gordon density ρ = (iħ/2mc²)(ψ*∂ψ/∂t − ψ∂ψ*/∂t) not be read as a probability density?
2What are the eigenvalues of each component of the Dirac velocity operator cα?
3In the exact Dirac spectrum of hydrogen, which levels remain degenerate?

Sources

  • J. J. Sakurai, Advanced Quantum Mechanics (1967), chapter 3
  • J. D. Bjorken and S. D. Drell, Relativistic Quantum Mechanics (1964), chapters 1 to 5
  • F. Schwabl, Advanced Quantum Mechanics, 4th ed. (2008), chapters 5 to 10
  • CODATA 2018 recommended values of the fundamental constants (fine-structure constant, electron mass)
  • CSIR-UGC NET Physical Sciences syllabus, Quantum Mechanics unit, published by the National Testing Agency

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with CSIR, UGC or the National Testing Agency. Check the official CSIR NET website for the current pattern. All questions are original.