Module 2: How arguments work · Lesson 2.1 · about 18 min
Argument anatomy: premises, conclusions and background
How every LSAT argument is built: the conclusion it wants you to accept, the premises offered as evidence, the background that is neither, and the indicator words that point to each.
Module 2 · about 18 minutes · read first: 1.1. By the end you will split any short argument into its conclusion, its premises and its background, which is the first step of nearly every Logical Reasoning question.
1. Claims and reasons in everyday life
“Take an umbrella. The forecast says heavy rain this afternoon.” The speaker wants you to accept one thing (take an umbrella) and gives a reason (the forecast). That is an argument:
- Conclusion: the claim the author wants you to accept.
- Premise: a statement offered as a reason to accept it. On the LSAT, premises are treated as true: you attack the link, not the facts.
- Background: context that sets the scene but is not a reason (who is talking, what the debate is about).
Not every paragraph is an argument. A list of facts with no claim drawn from them (“The museum opened in 1921. It has three floors.”) is not one. Questions about such passages ask what you can infer (Module 5), not what is assumed.
2. Watch an argument come apart
3. Indicator words
| Introduce a conclusion | Introduce a premise |
|---|---|
| therefore, thus, so, hence, consequently | because, since, for, given that |
| it follows that, clearly, this shows that | as shown by, after all, in view of the fact that |
| we can conclude that, accordingly | the reason is that, as |
Words like should, must, probably and it is likely that often mark a conclusion too, because they make a claim that needs support.
- Conclusion
- what the author is trying to prove
- Premise
- evidence given for it, accepted as true on the LSAT
- Background
- context that helps you understand but supports nothing
- Gap
- the distance between what the premises show and what the conclusion claims
- Physical meaning
- Premises are the floor the argument stands on; the conclusion is how high it tries to reach. The bigger the jump from one to the other, the more the argument is assuming.
4. The “therefore test”
When there are no indicator words, try each statement as the conclusion: “[The others], therefore [this one].” The version that makes sense is the right one.
“Wool keeps you warm even when it is wet. Hikers in rainy regions should wear wool socks.” Try it: “Wool keeps you warm when wet, therefore hikers should wear wool socks” makes sense. The reverse (“hikers should wear wool socks, therefore wool keeps you warm when wet”) does not.
Try it: find the conclusion
“Many people assume that coffee dehydrates you. Yet studies of regular coffee drinkers find that their bodies hold on to almost as much water from coffee as from plain water. So for most people, a daily cup of coffee counts towards their fluid intake.”
Answer: the conclusion is the last sentence: a daily cup of coffee counts towards fluid intake for most people. The studies are the premise. “Many people assume that coffee dehydrates you” is background: the opposing view the author is arguing against, not a reason for the conclusion.
Try it: conclusion in the middle
“The new parking rules will not reduce traffic downtown. After all, most drivers downtown are commuters who already pay for monthly parking passes, and the rules only change the price of hourly parking.”
Answer: the conclusion comes first: the new rules will not reduce traffic downtown. “After all” introduces the two premises. Conclusions can sit at the start, the middle or the end.
“The conclusion is always the last sentence.” On the LSAT it is often the first sentence, or tucked in the middle, sometimes followed by “after all” or “since”. Use indicators and the therefore test, never position alone.
Practice set
Original questions in the LSAT’s own five-option format, from warm-up to test level. Read the argument, predict the answer, then choose; every question has a full explanation of why the right answer is right and the others are not.
- An argument = conclusion (the claim) + premises (the reasons); background is neither.
- “Therefore, so, thus” point to conclusions; “because, since, for, after all” point to premises.
- With no indicators, use the therefore test.
- Premises are accepted as true; your job is to judge whether they really support the conclusion.
- The gap between evidence and claim is where assumptions, strengthen, weaken and flaw questions live.
Check yourself
Sources
- LSAC, Logical Reasoning questions (description) https://www.lsac.org/lsat/prepare/types-lsat-questions/logical-reasoning-questions
- fibub LSAT question bank (original arguments) https://fibub.com/learn/courses/lsat/argument-anatomy/
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. LSAT is a trademark of the Law School Admission Council (LSAC), which is not involved with and does not endorse fibub. Every argument, passage and question here is original. Test details were checked on LSAC's website on 22 November 2026; check the official source before test day.