Home / Learn / Exam prep / LSAT prep / Lesson 2.6
All lessons

Module 2: How arguments work · Lesson 2.6 · about 28 min

The common flaws, one by one

The reasoning errors the LSAT tests again and again, each with a plain example and the wording answer choices use for it: causation, sampling, part and whole, necessary and sufficient, attacking the person, and more.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 2 · about 28 minutes · read first: 2.1, 2.4. By the end you will recognise the reasoning errors that appear on almost every LSAT, and the abstract wording answer choices use for each.

The LSAT reuses a short list of reasoning mistakes. Learn each one well enough to name it in a second, and Flaw, Weaken, Assumption and Parallel Flaw questions all get much easier.

1. Why learn names

Flaw answer choices are abstract: “The argument presumes, without providing justification, that a correlation between two things implies that one causes the other.” If you already know “correlation is not causation”, you recognise that sentence instantly. Each flaw below has the plain idea, an example, and the answer-choice wording.

2. Cause and effect

Correlation → causation. "Students who eat breakfast get better grades, so breakfast improves grades." Maybe families that make breakfast also help with homework. Wording: "infers a causal relationship from a correlation".
Reversed cause. "People who own exercise bikes are fitter, so the bikes make them fit." Perhaps fit people are the ones who buy bikes. Wording: "fails to consider that the supposed effect may be the cause".
Before, so because. "The team started winning after the new mascot arrived, so the mascot brought luck." Timing alone proves nothing. Wording: "assumes that because one event followed another, the first caused the second".

3. Evidence that is too thin

Unrepresentative sample. "We asked visitors to the gym's website, and 90% want longer gym hours, so most townspeople do." Website visitors are gym fans. Wording: "draws a conclusion about a group from a sample that may not be representative".
Overgeneralising. "My two neighbours' electric cars broke down, so electric cars are unreliable." Wording: "generalises from too few cases".
Absence of evidence. "No one has proved the old mine is unsafe, so it is safe." Wording: "treats a lack of evidence for a claim as proof that the claim is false".
Possible → certain. "The suspect could have reached the shop in time, so he did." Wording: "takes the mere possibility of something as proof that it occurred".

4. Parts, wholes and numbers

Part → whole (composition). "Every player is excellent, so the team will be excellent." Excellent players can play badly together.
Whole → part (division). "The company is profitable, so each of its branches is profitable."
Percent versus number. "Crime in Lakeside rose 50% but in Hillview only 10%, so Lakeside has more crime." 50% of 4 cases is 2; 10% of 300 is 30. Wording: "confuses a rate of increase with an absolute amount".

5. Logic errors

Necessary versus sufficient. "A permit is required to build a deck. Lee has a permit, so Lee will build a deck." The permit is needed, not enough. (The converse error from Lesson 2.4.) Wording: "mistakes a condition required for an outcome for one that guarantees it".
Circular reasoning. "The book is trustworthy because it says it tells the truth." The conclusion is assumed in the premise. Wording: "presupposes the truth of the conclusion it is trying to establish".
False choice. "Either we close the library or we raise taxes." There may be other options. Wording: "presents two options as the only ones when others exist".
Equivocation. "A feather is light. What is light cannot be dark. So a feather cannot be dark." "Light" changes meaning. Wording: "uses a key term in two different senses".

6. Attacking the wrong target

Attacking the person (ad hominem). "Ms Chen's plan for the river should be rejected: she lost the last election." Her record says nothing about the plan. Wording: "attacks the person making the argument rather than the argument itself".
Straw man. "My opponent wants to reduce the military budget; clearly he wants our country undefended." Wording: "distorts the opponent's position".
Irrelevant authority. "A famous actor says this vitamin cures colds." Fame is not medical expertise. Wording: "relies on the opinion of someone whose expertise is not in the relevant field".
Flaw
a reason the premises, even if true, do not prove the conclusion
"Presumes, without justification"
the classic way answer choices say "it assumes"
"Fails to consider"
the argument ignores a possibility that would undercut it
Physical meaning
A flaw is not a false premise. On the LSAT the premises are accepted as true; a flaw is a broken bridge between true premises and the conclusion.
Try it: name the flaw

“A survey of the city’s tennis club found that 80% of members support building more public tennis courts. Clearly, most of the city’s residents want more tennis courts.”

Answer: unrepresentative sample. Tennis club members are much more likely than the average resident to want courts. Answer-choice wording: “It generalises from a sample that is unlikely to be representative of the population.”

Try it: name the flaw

“In towns where more people own smoke alarms, fewer people die in house fires. So installing smoke alarms saves lives. Therefore the council should pay for alarms in every home.”

Answer: this one is more careful than it looks: it moves from a correlation to a cause. Towns with more alarms may also have newer houses or better fire services. Wording: “It takes a correlation as evidence of a causal link without ruling out other factors.”

“A flaw answer is right if it describes something the argument does.” The answer must describe something the argument does wrong. Arguments often appeal to experts or use examples legitimately; only pick the answer when that move actually weakens the reasoning.

Practice set

Original questions in the LSAT’s own five-option format, from warm-up to test level. Read the argument, predict the answer, then choose; every question has a full explanation of why the right answer is right and the others are not.

  • Cause: correlation, reversed cause and “after, so because” do not prove causation.
  • Evidence: unrepresentative samples, tiny samples, lack of evidence and mere possibility prove little.
  • Parts and numbers: composition, division, and percent versus amount.
  • Logic: necessary versus sufficient, circular reasoning, false choice, equivocation.
  • Wrong target: attacking the person, straw man, irrelevant authority.

Check yourself

1"Cities with more police officers have more crime, so police cause crime." Which flaw?
2"Each brick is light, so the wall is light." Which flaw?
3"There is no proof the drug is harmful, so it is safe." Which flaw?

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. LSAT is a trademark of the Law School Admission Council (LSAC), which is not involved with and does not endorse fibub. Every argument, passage and question here is original. Test details were checked on LSAC's website on 22 November 2026; check the official source before test day.