Module 3: The assumption family · Lesson 3.5 · about 14 min
Evaluate the argument
Evaluate questions ask which question you would most want answered to judge an argument. The right answer is the one whose two possible answers would strengthen and weaken the argument respectively.
Module 3 · about 14 minutes · read first: 3.3, 3.4. By the end you will pick the question that matters most for judging an argument.
1. The question stem
“The answer to which one of the following questions would be most useful in evaluating the argument?” or “…would it be most helpful to know…”. The answers are questions or “whether…” clauses.
2. The variance test
- Variance test
- imagine two opposite answers to the question; a relevant question makes the argument better one way and worse the other
- Irrelevant question
- both answers leave the argument where it was
- Physical meaning
- Evaluate questions ask "what experiment would tell us if the author is right?" The useful experiment is one that could come out either way.
Try it: a full question
“A company found that employees who work from home two days a week report higher job satisfaction. The company concludes that letting everyone work from home two days a week will raise job satisfaction across the company.”
The answer to which one of the following would be most useful in evaluating the argument?
(A) Do the employees who already work from home have jobs that suit home working better than other jobs at the company? (B) How many employees does the company have? (C) Does the company plan to open a new office? (D) Do managers also work from home? (E) Is job satisfaction measured by a survey?
Answer: (A). If yes, the home workers may be happier because of their kind of job, and extending home working to everyone may not help (weaker). If no, the comparison is fair (stronger). The others leave the argument unchanged whichever way they are answered.
“Pick the question I would most like to know the answer to.” Curiosity is not the test. Some interesting questions do not affect the argument at all. Use the variance test on each answer.
Practice set
Original questions in the LSAT’s own five-option format, from warm-up to test level. Read the argument, predict the answer, then choose; every question has a full explanation of why the right answer is right and the others are not.
- Evaluate questions ask which question would best show whether the argument works.
- Find the gap, then pick the question about it.
- Variance test: one answer should strengthen, the opposite answer weaken.
- Reject questions whose answers would not change the argument either way.
Check yourself
Sources
- LSAC, Logical Reasoning questions (description) https://www.lsac.org/lsat/prepare/types-lsat-questions/logical-reasoning-questions
- fibub LSAT question bank (original arguments) https://fibub.com/learn/courses/lsat/evaluate/
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. LSAT is a trademark of the Law School Admission Council (LSAC), which is not involved with and does not endorse fibub. Every argument, passage and question here is original. Test details were checked on LSAC's website on 22 November 2026; check the official source before test day.