Home / Learn / Science / Cosmology A to Z / Lesson 6.5
All lessons

Module 6: The first three minutes and after · Lesson 6.5 · about 14 min

Neutrinos let go

About one second after the start, neutrinos stopped colliding and flew free. They are still here: 336 in every cubic centimetre, at 1.95 K, slightly colder than the microwave background. Why they let go, why they are colder, and how we know they exist.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 6 · about 14 minutes. Read first: 6.4 The first second. Neutrinos barely notice ordinary matter: trillions from the Sun pass through you every second. In the first second, though, the universe was so dense that even neutrinos collided constantly. By the end you will be able to explain when they let go, why they are now colder than the cosmic microwave background, and how many are around you.

At about one second, the universe thinned out enough for neutrinos to fly free. They have travelled untouched ever since, a second "afterglow" older than the microwave background, slightly colder and almost impossible to catch.

1. Letting go

Before 1 second. The universe is a hot soup of photons, electrons, positrons and three kinds of neutrino (electron, muon and tau), all at the same temperature. Neutrinos feel only the weak force and gravity, but the soup is so dense that they still collide many times as the universe doubles in size.
The race. The weak collision rate falls as T⁵ as the soup cools; the expansion rate falls only as T² (Lesson 6.3). Their ratio falls as T³: roughly (kT / 1 MeV)³.
About 1 second, 1010 K. Near kT ≈ 1 MeV the rate drops below the expansion rate. Neutrinos decouple: they stop colliding and fly in straight lines (along the curves of spacetime) for the rest of time.
After. Each neutrino's wavelength stretches with space, just like light's, so the neutrinos keep a thermal spectrum that cools as 1/a. They are a cosmic neutrino background filling all space.

Imagine a crowded dance floor where everyone keeps bumping into everyone. As the room grows and the crowd spreads out, a shy dancer who only rarely bumps into anyone stops meeting people altogether, long before the others do. Neutrinos are the shy dancers.

2. Why they are colder than the light

Just after the neutrinos let go, the temperature fell below the mass energy of the electron (0.511 MeV), and electrons and positrons annihilated into photons. The neutrinos were no longer listening, so all of that energy went to the light. The light cooled more slowly for a while, and ended up warmer than the neutrinos.

How much warmer follows from a careful count. Before annihilation, photons (2 states) plus electrons and positrons (7/8 × 4 states = 3.5) shared the heat: 5.5 units. Afterwards only photons (2) held it, and the total heat (strictly, the entropy) in a stretching volume stays fixed. So (T a)³ for the light grew by 5.5/2 = 11/4 compared with the neutrinos:

Tν=(411)1/3Tγ=0.714×2.7255 K=1.95 K
Tγ
the photon (microwave background) temperature, 2.7255 K today
Tν
the temperature of the relic neutrinos
4/11
2 (photon states) divided by 2 + 3.5 (photons plus electrons and positrons): the light received the electron-positron share of the heat
Physical meaning
Neutrinos are a "fossil" of the universe before electrons and positrons annihilated. Their lower temperature is a direct record of that annihilation, which happened a few seconds after the start.
Temperature times size of the universe, scaled to today, through the first minutes. Anything that simply cools as 1/a draws a flat line. The neutrinos (blue) let go near 1 second and stay flat at 1.95 K. The light (orange) is lifted by electron-positron annihilation, mostly between about 2 and 100 seconds, to today's 2.73 K.

3. How many?

Today each cubic centimetre holds 411 photons from the microwave background. For neutrinos the count per kind (neutrinos plus antineutrinos) is 3/4 × 4/11 of that: 3/4 because neutrinos are fermions, which by the Pauli rule fill their states less densely than photons do, and 4/11 because of their lower temperature (cubed). That makes 112 per kind and 336 per cubic centimetre for all three kinds: in every sugar cube of space.

Neutrinos have small masses (oscillation experiments prove it). The relic neutrinos have typical energies of only about 0.0005 eV today, so at least two of the three kinds are now slow-moving, and together they are a tiny part of the dark matter: well under 1% of the critical density. The Planck satellite’s measurements of the microwave background, with galaxy maps, limit the sum of the three neutrino masses to below about 0.12 eV.

4. How do we know they are there?

Catching one is beyond any current detector: their energy is a billion times less than that of the Sun’s neutrinos. The PTOLEMY project aims to catch them on tritium, an idea from Steven Weinberg in 1962. But their effects are already measured:

  • Helium. More kinds of relic neutrino would speed up the early expansion and make more helium (Lesson 6.6). The measured helium fits three.
  • The microwave background. The neutrinos’ gravity tugs on the sound waves of the young universe (Module 7), shifting the acoustic peaks slightly. In 2015 Brent Follin and colleagues found that shift in the Planck data. Cosmologists express the result as Neff, the effective number of neutrino kinds: Planck finds 2.99 ± 0.17, and the Standard Model predicts 3.044 (a touch above 3 because the neutrinos had not quite let go when the annihilation began).

The ghost particle. Wolfgang Pauli proposed the neutrino in 1930 to rescue energy conservation in radioactive decay, and apologised for suggesting a particle that could never be detected. Clyde Cowan and Frederick Reines caught neutrinos from a nuclear reactor in 1956. The cosmic background of neutrinos is a firm prediction of the hot Big Bang, and its effects on helium and the microwave background have been seen; seeing the neutrinos themselves remains a challenge for the future.

“The cosmic neutrinos are the same as the neutrinos from the Sun.” Solar neutrinos are made in nuclear fusion today, with energies of about a million electronvolts, and about 60 billion of them cross each square centimetre of you every second. The relic neutrinos were set free in the first second and now have energies a billion times smaller. They are far more numerous in space, but far gentler.

  • Weak collisions slow as T⁵, expansion as T²: neutrinos decoupled near kT ≈ 1 MeV, 1010 K, about 1 second after the start.
  • Electron-positron annihilation then heated only the light: Tν = (4/11)1/3 Tγ ≈ 1.95 K today.
  • 112 per cubic centimetre for each of three kinds, 336 in all (3/11 of the photons per kind).
  • Not yet caught directly, but seen through helium and the microwave background: Neff = 2.99 ± 0.17 (Planck) against 3.044 expected.

Check yourself

1When did the cosmic neutrinos stop interacting with the rest of the universe?
2Why are the relic neutrinos (1.95 K) colder than the microwave background (2.73 K)?
3About how many relic neutrinos (all kinds, with antineutrinos) are in each cubic centimetre of space?

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.