Module 11: Inflation and the first instant · Lesson 11.4 · about 18 min
Primordial gravitational waves and the BICEP2 lesson
Inflation should have shaken space-time itself, leaving gravitational waves that twist the CMB's polarisation into B-modes. The 2014 BICEP2 claim, the dust that undid it, and today's limit r < 0.036.
Module 11 · about 18 minutes. Read first: 11.3 Quantum jitters become galaxies, 3.9 Gravitational waves and 7.7 CMB polarisation. The inflaton was not the only thing jittering during inflation. Space-time itself did too. By the end you will be able to explain what the number r measures, why a swirling pattern in the CMB would reveal it, and what the BICEP2 episode teaches about doing science.
1. Space-time jitters too
Gravitational waves are ripples in space-time itself (Lesson 3.9). Quantum physics says the gravitational field jitters like any other, and during inflation those jitters were stretched and frozen exactly like the inflaton’s (Lesson 11.3). Their strength depends on only one thing, the expansion rate H during inflation. Cosmologists compare it with the density ripples:
- Δt²
- the strength of the primordial gravitational waves (the "tensor" ripples)
- M̄P
- the reduced Planck mass, 2.435 × 1018 GeV, which sets how stiff space-time is
- r
- the tensor-to-scalar ratio: gravitational waves compared with density ripples (Δζ² = 2.1 × 10−9)
- ε
- the slow-roll parameter from Lesson 11.2: how fast H was falling
- Physical meaning
- Since H² is set by the energy density V, measuring r measures the energy of inflation: V1/4 ≈ 1.0 × 1016 GeV × (r/0.01)1/4. A detection would be our first direct look at physics a trillion times beyond the LHC.
2. The swirl test: E-modes and B-modes
The CMB is slightly polarised: its light waves vibrate a little more in one direction than another, set when it last scattered off electrons (Lesson 7.7). Draw that direction as a short stick at each point on the sky. Any such pattern splits into two kinds:
- E-modes: sticks point straight towards spots or run in rings around them. They look the same in a mirror. Density ripples make these.
- B-modes: the same sticks turned by 45°, making pinwheels that twist left or right. A mirror swaps the twists. Density ripples cannot make them (at first order). Gravitational waves, which stretch and squeeze space with a twist, can.
Primordial gravitational waves would show up as B-modes on scales of about 1° to 2° (made at the time of the CMB), and on the largest scales (made when the first stars re-ionised the gas, Lesson 10.5). Two impostors also make B-modes: gravitational lensing, which bends E-modes into B-modes on small scales (first detected in 2013), and dust in our own galaxy, whose spinning grains line up with the galaxy’s magnetic field and glow with polarised light.
3. The BICEP2 story
The lesson is not that the team was careless: the B-mode pattern they saw was real, and their instrument was superb. The mistake was confidence in a foreground estimate and announcing before independent checks. Science corrected itself within a year, in public, with the same team as a partner in the correction.
4. Where the hunt stands
Today, r < 0.036 (BICEP/Keck 2021, 95% confidence) and r < 0.032 with Planck data added. That already rules out the simplest model and pushes favoured models towards plateaus, which predict r around 0.003 to 0.004, or even smaller for other models. A non-detection would not kill inflation: many valid models predict r far below anything measurable.
The next experiments are the BICEP Array at the South Pole, the Simons Observatory in Chile’s Atacama desert, and LiteBIRD, a Japanese-led satellite planned for launch in the 2030s that would map the largest scales from space. A larger US ground project, CMB-S4, was planned for the 2030s, but in 2025 the US funding agencies stepped back from it in its planned form.
What about gravitational-wave detectors? In 2023 pulsar-timing arrays found a background of very long gravitational waves, but it is most likely from pairs of supermassive black holes. Simple inflation predicts waves far too weak for LIGO, pulsar timing or the planned LISA mission; the CMB is the best place to look.
The B-mode hunt.
- 1997 Uroš Seljak and Matias Zaldarriaga, and Marc Kamionkowski, Arthur Kosowsky and Albert Stebbins, show that B-modes would single out gravitational waves.
- 2002 DASI detects the CMB's polarisation (E-modes).
- 2013 SPTpol detects B-modes from gravitational lensing.
- Mar 2014 BICEP2 announces r = 0.20.
- Jan 2015 The joint BICEP2/Keck/Planck analysis attributes the signal to dust (published March 2015).
- 2021 BICEP/Keck: r < 0.036.
“BICEP2 proved inflation, then disproved it.” Neither. The 2014 claim was withdrawn because dust could explain it, not because gravitational waves were shown to be absent. The limits since then rule out some models of inflation, not inflation itself. Inflation’s case rests mainly on the evidence of Lesson 11.3.
- Inflation should have made primordial gravitational waves with strength Δt² = 2H²/(π²M̄P²), set only by the energy of inflation.
- The tensor-to-scalar ratio r = 16ε gives that energy: V1/4 ≈ 1016 GeV × (r/0.01)1/4.
- Gravitational waves twist the CMB’s polarisation into B-modes, which density ripples do not make; lensing and galactic dust also make B-modes.
- BICEP2 claimed r = 0.20 in March 2014; a joint analysis with Planck in 2015 showed the signal was consistent with dust.
- Today r < 0.036 (BICEP/Keck 2021), < 0.032 with Planck. ½m²φ² is ruled out; plateau models (r ≈ 0.003) are the next target.
Check yourself
Sources
- BICEP2 Collaboration (2014), Detection of B-mode polarization at degree angular scales by BICEP2, Physical Review Letters 112, 241101 https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.241101
- BICEP2/Keck and Planck Collaborations (2015), Joint analysis of BICEP2/Keck Array and Planck data, Physical Review Letters 114, 101301 https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.114.101301
- BICEP/Keck Collaboration (2021), Improved constraints on primordial gravitational waves using Planck, WMAP, and BICEP/Keck observations through the 2018 observing season, Physical Review Letters 127, 151301 https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.127.151301
- M. Tristram et al. (2022), Improved limits on the tensor-to-scalar ratio using BICEP and Planck data, Physical Review D 105, 083524 https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.105.083524
- U. Seljak and M. Zaldarriaga (1997), Signature of gravity waves in the polarization of the microwave background, Physical Review Letters 78, 2054 https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.78.2054
- M. Kamionkowski, A. Kosowsky and A. Stebbins (1997), A probe of primordial gravity waves and vorticity, Physical Review Letters 78, 2058 https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.78.2058
- M. Kamionkowski and E. D. Kovetz (2016), The quest for B modes of the cosmic microwave background, Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics 54, 227 https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-astro-081915-023433
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.