Home / Learn / Science / Cosmology A to Z / Lesson 1.5
All lessons

Module 1: The oldest questions · Lesson 1.5 · about 16 min

Newton's universe: endless, and in trouble

Newton showed one law of gravity rules apples and the Moon. But it raised a puzzle: why doesn't gravity pull all the stars together? Watch a still universe collapse.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 1 · about 16 minutes. By the end you will be able to explain Newton’s “Moon test”, say why a still universe held together by gravity cannot last, and see why that puzzle points towards an expanding universe.

Newton's law of gravity works everywhere, from apples to galaxies. But applied to the whole universe it raised a question that took 250 years to answer: why hasn't everything fallen together?

1. The same gravity for the apple and the Moon

Newton’s great insight was that the force that makes an apple fall is the same force that holds the Moon in its orbit. He checked it with a calculation known as the Moon test. (How orbits work in detail is covered in the Astronomy course: Newton’s gravity. Here we only need the idea.)

The Moon goes round the Earth about once every 27.3 days, at about 60 Earth radii from the Earth's centre (that 60 came from Lesson 1.3).

With no gravity, the Moon would fly off in a straight line. In one second it moves about 1 km along its path.

To stay on its curved path, it must fall towards the Earth by about 1.36 mm in that second. The Moon is falling all the time; it just keeps missing.

An apple near the ground falls 4.9 m in its first second.

The check. If gravity weakens as 1/distance², at 60 times the distance it is 60² = 3,600 times weaker: 4.9 m ÷ 3,600 = 1.36 mm. It matches. One law rules the sky and the ground.

F=GMmr2
F
the pull between two masses, in newtons
M, m
the two masses, in kg; double either and the pull doubles
r
the distance between their centres; double it and the pull drops to a quarter
G
Newton's gravitational constant, 6.674 × 10−11 N m² kg−2: tiny, which is why you don't feel the pull of the person next to you

Gravity only ever attracts, and it never switches off with distance; it just gets weaker. That combination is what causes trouble for the universe as a whole.

2. Bentley’s question

In 1692 a young clergyman, Richard Bentley, wrote to Newton with a sharp question: if every star attracts every other star, why haven’t they all fallen together into one great lump?

Newton’s answer was that if the stars went on forever, evenly spread in every direction, each star would be pulled equally from all sides and could stay put. But he admitted the balance would be extremely delicate, “as hard as to make the sharpest needle stand upright on its point”. Nudge one star and its neighbours start falling towards it.

Watch what gravity does to a ball of stars that starts at rest:

200 stars start at rest in a ball. Gravity pulls them all inwards, and the ball falls in on itself in about one "free-fall time". Now give them an outward start with the slider: a gentle push only delays the collapse, but a big enough push lets them keep spreading for ever.

The time it takes depends only on how dense the cloud is:

tff=3π32Gρ
tff
the free-fall time: how long a still cloud takes to collapse
ρ (rho)
the average density, in kg per cubic metre

Denser clouds collapse faster: four times the density halves the time. Notice that the size of the cloud doesn’t appear at all, only its density. For a cloud as dense as a galaxy, the answer is a few tens of millions of years, a tiny fraction of the age of the universe.

3. Why this matters

Newton, and almost everyone after him until the 1920s, believed the universe as a whole was static: eternal and unchanging. Bentley’s question shows that a static universe full of matter is like a pencil balanced on its tip. Even Einstein in 1917 had to add an extra term to his equations to hold his universe still (Lesson 5.7).

The simulation hints at the way out: a universe that is expanding doesn’t need to balance. Gravity slows the expansion, but it doesn’t have to make everything collapse. In Module 4 you’ll see that this is exactly what the real universe is doing.

“Gravity stops working far from Earth.” Astronauts on the space station feel weightless because they are falling around the Earth, like the Moon, not because gravity has vanished. Up there it is still about 90% as strong as on the ground.

  • Newton’s Moon test: the Moon falls 1.36 mm each second, exactly 4.9 m ÷ 60², so gravity weakens as 1/distance².
  • Gravity always attracts and never switches off, so a still, evenly filled universe is unstable.
  • A still cloud collapses in a free-fall time that depends only on its density: tens of millions of years for galaxy-like densities.
  • An expanding universe escapes this problem, which is the idea behind modern cosmology.

Check yourself

1The Moon is about 60 Earth radii from the Earth's centre. How much weaker is Earth's gravity there?
2What did Richard Bentley ask Newton in 1692?
3In the simulation, what happens if the stars start moving apart fast enough?

Sources

  • I. Newton (1687), Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica, Book III (the Moon test)
  • I. Newton, letters to Richard Bentley (1692-93), in The Correspondence of Isaac Newton, vol. III, Cambridge
  • Astronomy course on fibub: Newton's gravity and orbits https://fibub.com/learn/courses/astronomy/newtons-gravity/

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.