Module 1: The oldest questions · Lesson 1.7 · about 16 min
Is the Milky Way the whole universe? The Great Debate
In 1920 astronomers argued whether the spiral nebulae were clouds inside the Milky Way or galaxies far beyond it. How Herschel, Shapley, Curtis and Hubble found our real place.
Module 1 · about 16 minutes. By the end you will be able to explain how we found that the Sun is far from the centre of the Milky Way, what the 1920 “Great Debate” was about, and how one kind of star settled it.
1. Where are we in the Milky Way?
On a dark night the Milky Way is a pale band across the sky: the disc of our own galaxy seen from inside. (Its shape and parts are covered in the Astronomy course: the Milky Way.) Finding where we are in it turned out to be surprisingly hard. Step through it:
Herschel, 1785. William and Caroline Herschel counted stars in hundreds of directions. They found about the same number all round the band, so they drew a flat disc with the Sun near the middle.
The trap: dust. The disc is full of dust that blocks starlight. From inside, we only see stars a few thousand light-years away in any direction along the band, so every direction looks alike and we seem to sit at the centre of a bubble.
Shapley, 1918. Harlow Shapley mapped globular clusters, huge balls of old stars that sit above and below the dusty disc. They are bunched towards the constellation Sagittarius, and form a ball around a centre far from us. The galaxy's centre is where they are centred.
Today. The Milky Way is a barred spiral about 100,000 light-years across. The Sun lies about 26,000 light-years from the centre (Shapley's first estimate was too big, because dust made his clusters look farther away).
2. The Great Debate, 26 April 1920
Shapley had made the Milky Way enormous. That raised a second question. Telescopes showed thousands of faint, fuzzy spiral nebulae, like the one in Andromeda. Were they small clouds inside our huge galaxy, or whole galaxies far outside it, “island universes” as the philosopher Kant had guessed in 1755?
At the National Academy of Sciences in Washington, Shapley and Heber Curtis argued it out:
| Shapley | Curtis | |
|---|---|---|
| Size of the Milky Way | huge, about 300,000 light-years | small, about 30,000 light-years |
| Sun’s position | far from the centre | near the centre |
| Spiral nebulae | clouds inside the Milky Way | separate galaxies far away |
Each was partly right. Shapley was right about our place in the Milky Way. Curtis was right about the spiral nebulae. Both had evidence, and both had mistakes. Nobody could settle it, because nobody could measure the distance to a nebula.
Why distance is everything. A small cloud nearby and a giant galaxy far away can look exactly the same on a photograph. Without a distance you cannot tell size from closeness. Almost every big leap in cosmology has come from a new way to measure distance, which is why Module 2 is all about distances.
3. Hubble settles it
In 1923, using the new 2.5-metre telescope on Mount Wilson, Edwin Hubble found a Cepheid star in the Andromeda nebula. Cepheids pulse with a period that reveals their true brightness (Henrietta Leavitt’s discovery; see variable stars in the Astronomy course). Comparing that true brightness with how faint it looked, Hubble put Andromeda about 900,000 light-years away, far beyond even Shapley’s giant Milky Way. Today’s value is about 2.5 million light-years. Lesson 2.3 walks through the measurement.
Andromeda appears about six full Moons wide in long-exposure photos. Here’s what that means if it really is a galaxy like ours:
The universe suddenly became millions of times bigger. The Milky Way was not the universe: it was one galaxy among, as we now estimate, hundreds of billions to around two trillion.
“Hubble discovered that galaxies exist.” Others, from Kant to Curtis, had argued for “island universes”. Hubble’s contribution was the measurement that proved it. Science often works like this: an idea floats for a long time until someone finds the measurement that settles it.
- From inside the dusty disc, every direction looks alike, which fooled Herschel into putting the Sun near the centre.
- Shapley used globular clusters to show the centre lies far away, towards Sagittarius; today we put the Sun about 26,000 light-years out.
- The 1920 Great Debate asked whether spiral nebulae are inside the Milky Way or separate galaxies.
- Hubble’s Cepheids in Andromeda (1923-25) proved it is a separate galaxy, millions of light-years away.
Check yourself
Sources
- H. Shapley and H. D. Curtis (1921), The Scale of the Universe, Bulletin of the National Research Council 2, 171
- E. P. Hubble (1925), Cepheids in spiral nebulae, Publications of the American Astronomical Society 5, 261
- W. Herschel (1785), On the Construction of the Heavens, Philosophical Transactions 75, 213
- Astronomy course on fibub: The Milky Way https://fibub.com/learn/courses/astronomy/milky-way/
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.