Home / Learn / Science / Cosmology A to Z / Lesson 11.5
All lessons

Module 11: Inflation and the first instant · Lesson 11.5 · about 16 min

Why is there matter at all?

The Big Bang should have made equal amounts of matter and antimatter, which would have destroyed each other. One extra particle in about a billion survived. Sakharov's three conditions and the search for why.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 11 · about 16 minutes. Read first: 3.3 E = mc² and 6.4 The first second. Every particle has an antiparticle with the same mass and opposite charge. When they meet, both turn into light. Energy turns into matter only in matched pairs, so a hot Big Bang should have made exactly equal amounts, and they should have wiped each other out. Yet here we are. By the end you will be able to say how big the imbalance was, how we measure it, and what it would take to explain it.

For roughly every billion antiquarks in the early universe there were a billion and one quarks. Everything else annihilated into light. Every atom in every galaxy is made of those one-in-a-billion survivors, and nobody yet knows why they were there.

1. Where is all the antimatter?

Antimatter is real and well understood: positrons are used in hospital PET scans, and at CERN antihydrogen atoms have been made, trapped and even dropped (in 2023 the ALPHA-g experiment showed they fall down, like ordinary matter). But the universe around us is matter:

  • Cosmic rays contain a few antiprotons, a few for every 10,000 protons, about as many as collisions between cosmic rays and gas in space are expected to make.
  • If some galaxies or clusters were antimatter, the gas where matter and antimatter regions touched would glow with gamma rays of a particular energy. We see no such glow. Andrew Cohen, Alvaro De Rújula and Sheldon Glashow showed in 1998 that any antimatter domains would have to be about as large as the observable universe.

So the imbalance is real and universal.

2. Measuring the leftover

When the universe cooled, nearly every particle found an antiparticle and turned into light. The survivors are counted against that light, the CMB photons:

η=nbnγ≈6.1×10−10
nb
the number of baryons (protons and neutrons) per cubic metre: about 0.25 today, one in every four cubic metres
nγ
the number of CMB photons per cubic metre: about 411 million today
η
both numbers fall as 1/a³ as space grows, so their ratio has stayed the same since the light elements formed
Physical meaning
About 1.6 billion photons for every baryon. The excess of matter over antimatter, before the annihilation, was of the same tiny size: roughly one part in a billion.

η is measured two independent ways that agree: from the amount of deuterium made in the first minutes (Lesson 6.6) and from the heights of the CMB’s acoustic peaks (Lesson 7.5), which give Ωbh² = 0.0224.

The hot soup. Light is energetic enough to make particle-antiparticle pairs, and pairs annihilate back into light, in balance.
The universe cools. Light can no longer make the heavy pairs, so matter and antimatter meet and annihilate, flooding space with photons.
The leftover: one particle of matter from roughly every billion pairs, plus about two billion photons.
Today: η ≈ 6 × 10−10. The photons have cooled into the CMB; the survivors are the atoms of every star, planet and person.

3. Sakharov’s three conditions

Could the universe simply have started with a little extra matter? Possibly, but inflation (Lesson 11.2) would have diluted any starting excess to nothing. The excess must have been made afterwards. In 1967 Andrei Sakharov, the Soviet physicist later famous as a human-rights campaigner, listed what any process needs to make more matter than antimatter from an even start:

  1. Baryon number must be able to change. Some reaction must make or destroy baryons; otherwise their total can never move away from zero.
  2. C and CP symmetry must be broken. C swaps particles for antiparticles; CP also swaps left and right, like a mirror. If nature treated the mirror-antimatter version of every reaction exactly the same, every process making extra baryons would be cancelled by one making extra antibaryons.
  3. Out of balance. In perfect thermal equilibrium, every reaction runs as often backwards as forwards and any excess is undone. Something must happen too fast to be reversed, such as a rapid cooling or a sudden phase change.

4. The Standard Model is not enough

The known laws of particle physics have all three ingredients, in principle. At very high temperatures, rare processes called sphalerons change baryon number (with lepton number). CP violation exists: it was discovered in 1964 in the decays of K mesons by James Cronin and Val Fitch (Nobel Prize 1980), and is now measured in B mesons too. But:

  • the CP violation in the quark sector is far too weak, by a factor of billions or more;
  • with the Higgs mass measured at 125 GeV, the electroweak transition at about 10−11 s was smooth, not the sudden out-of-balance event needed.

So the existence of matter is evidence for physics beyond the Standard Model.

5. The leading ideas

  • Leptogenesis (Masataka Fukugita and Tsutomu Yanagida, 1986). Very heavy partners of the neutrinos, which would also explain why ordinary neutrinos are so light, decay slightly more often into leptons than antileptons. Sphalerons then turn about a third of that lepton excess into a baryon excess. It needs CP violation among neutrinos, which experiments are now hunting: in 2020 T2K in Japan reported a first hint, and the DUNE and Hyper-Kamiokande experiments aim to settle it.
  • Electroweak baryogenesis. New particles, such as extra Higgs bosons, could make the electroweak transition sudden and add CP violation. The LHC and measurements of the electron’s electric dipole moment are squeezing this idea hard.
  • Grand-unified baryogenesis. The original idea of the late 1970s: very heavy particles decay unevenly. It struggles if inflation and reheating happened at lower temperatures than those particles need.

None is confirmed. This is one of the biggest open questions in physics.

From the positron to the matter puzzle.

  • 1928 Paul Dirac's equation predicts antimatter.
  • 1932 Carl Anderson finds the positron in cosmic rays.
  • 1955 The antiproton is made at Berkeley.
  • 1964 Cronin and Fitch discover CP violation.
  • 1967 Sakharov states the three conditions.
  • 1985 Vadim Kuzmin, Valery Rubakov and Mikhail Shaposhnikov show that electroweak processes can change baryon number in the hot early universe.
  • 1986 Fukugita and Yanagida propose leptogenesis.
  • 2023 ALPHA-g: antihydrogen falls down.

“Somewhere out there must be an antimatter half of the universe.” It would be lovely and symmetric, but the evidence says no. Where matter and antimatter regions met, the annihilation would light up the boundary in gamma rays, and we see no such boundaries anywhere in the observable universe. The excess is everywhere we can look.

  • Matter and antimatter are made in equal pairs, yet the universe is made of matter; antimatter domains, if any, would have to be as large as the observable universe.
  • The leftover is measured as η = nb/nγ ≈ 6.1 × 10−10, from deuterium and from the CMB, which agree: roughly a one-in-a-billion excess.
  • Sakharov (1967): making the excess needs baryon-number change, C and CP violation, and departure from thermal equilibrium.
  • The Standard Model’s CP violation is far too weak and its electroweak transition too smooth, so new physics is needed.
  • Leading ideas: leptogenesis (heavy neutrinos), electroweak baryogenesis with new particles, and grand-unified baryogenesis. None is confirmed yet.

Check yourself

1What is the baryon-to-photon ratio η, and why does it matter?
2Which of these is one of Sakharov's three conditions?
3Why can't the Standard Model of particle physics explain the matter excess on its own?

Sources

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Numbers are rounded for teaching; measured values come from the sources listed in each lesson. Simulations run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.