Module 10: Co-founders and equity · Lesson 10.4 · about 15 min
Employee stock options (ESOPs)
How startups give employees a stake: setting up an option pool and plan, grants, strike price and valuation (409A in the USA), vesting and exercise windows, and when employees pay tax in India (perquisite and the startup deferral), Canada (CCPC deferral and 50 % deduction) and the USA (ISO and NSO).
Module 10 · about 15 minutes. You’ll set up a fair option plan and explain to an employee exactly when they will pay tax.
1. How options work
An option is the right to buy a share later at a fixed strike price, usually the share’s value on the grant date. Options vest like founder shares (4 years, 1-year cliff). Once vested, the employee can exercise (pay the strike price and get shares), and later sell them, usually only when the company is sold or lists.
Set up an option pool (10 % to 20 % of the company) and a written plan approved by the board and shareholders before you promise options to anyone.
2. When the tax comes
Watch it happen
Grant: 10,000 options at a strike of 10, the share value today. No tax.
Vest: over 4 years, the options become exercisable. No tax.
Exercise: pay 100,000 for 10,000 shares now worth 40 each. The 300,000 spread is taxed as pay in India (unless deferred), deferred to sale for a Canadian CCPC, and not taxed for a US ISO (AMT aside).
Sale: the company is bought at 100 a share. The gain above the exercise value (or above the strike, for a US ISO) is taxed as capital gain.
ESOPs are issued under section 62 of the Companies Act and the share capital rules (special resolution, minimum 1-year vesting). At exercise, the difference between the share’s fair value and the price paid is a perquisite, taxed as salary and deducted through payroll. Employees of startups certified under 80-IAC can defer that tax until the earliest of 48 months from the end of the year, sale of the shares, or leaving the company. At sale, the gain over the exercise-date value is capital gain: 12.5 % for unlisted shares held over 24 months. Founders of DPIIT startups can hold ESOPs for 10 years from incorporation.
At exercise, the stock option benefit (value minus strike) is employment income, with a 50 % deduction if the strike was at least the share value at grant. For a CCPC, the benefit is taxed only when you sell, and the deduction applies if you held the shares 2 years. Any later rise is a capital gain, half taxable. For non-CCPC employers, the deduction is limited on $200,000 of options vesting each year.
ISOs (incentive stock options, employees only): no regular tax at exercise, though the spread counts for the alternative minimum tax; if you sell at least 2 years after grant and 1 year after exercise, the whole gain is long-term capital gain. NSOs (anyone, including advisers): the spread at exercise is wages, with withholding; later gain is capital gain. A 409A valuation sets a defensible strike price. After leaving, employees usually have 90 days to exercise ISOs.
Key idea: Exercising can create a tax bill before any shares can be sold. Explain this to every employee, and consider longer exercise windows or the startup deferral where available.
3. Making options mean something
- Give each employee a short grant letter: number of options, strike price, vesting, how long they have to exercise after leaving.
- Show the percentage of the company, not just the number of options.
- Refresh grants for long-serving staff, and update the cap table with every grant (Lesson 6.6).
- Option
- the right to buy a share at a fixed price later
- Strike price
- the fixed price, usually the share value at grant
- Exercise
- paying the strike price to get the shares
- Perquisite / option benefit
- India / Canada: the value above the strike at exercise, taxed as pay
- ISO / NSO
- USA: tax-favoured employee options / ordinary options
- What it means for you
- Set up the pool and plan before promising options, give every grant in writing with the percentage it represents, and explain when the tax comes.
4. Worked example
Made-up employee. Priya, an engineer at a Bengaluru startup, exercises 10,000 options at ₹10 when shares are valued at ₹40: a perquisite of ₹3 lakh, about ₹93,600 tax at her 31.2 % rate. Her startup has the 80-IAC certificate, so the tax is deferred. Three years later the company is bought at ₹100 a share: she pays the deferred tax, plus 12.5 % (and cess) on the ₹6 lakh capital gain.
“Options are free money with no risk.” Exercising costs the strike price and can trigger tax before any shares can be sold, and most startup shares end up worth nothing. Options are a fair bet on the company, not a sure payment.
5. Practice
- Why is a strike price set at the share’s value on the grant date?
- A US adviser is offered options. ISO or NSO?
- What can make exercising options risky?
Answers
- So the employee is rewarded only for growth after they join, and (in the USA and Canada) to keep the favourable tax treatment.
- NSO: ISOs are only for employees.
- Paying the strike price and possibly tax before the shares can be sold, with no guarantee they will ever be worth more.
- Options vest like founder shares; once vested they can be exercised at the strike price.
- India: perquisite taxed as salary at exercise (deferral for certified startups); later gain is capital gain.
- Canada: benefit with a 50 % deduction; CCPC employees are taxed only when they sell.
- USA: ISOs avoid regular tax at exercise (AMT may apply); NSO spread is wages; a 409A valuation sets the strike.
- Grant letters should state the number, strike, vesting, exercise window and percentage.
Next: When a co-founder leaves.
New words: option, strike price, exercise, option pool, perquisite, stock option benefit, ISO / NSO, 409A valuation, AMT.
Rules as of November 2026. Not legal or tax advice.
Check yourself
Sources
- Ministry of Corporate Affairs, Companies Act section 62 and ESOP rules: https://www.mca.gov.in
- Income Tax Department, ESOP perquisite and startup deferral: https://www.incometax.gov.in
- CRA, Security options deduction: https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency.html
- IRS, Topic 427 Stock options: https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc427
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not legal or tax advice. Laws, rates and fees change, and your situation may differ: follow the official source linked in the lesson and check with a lawyer, chartered accountant or CPA before you act. Calculators run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.