Module 3: Choosing a legal structure · Lesson 3.5 · about 12 min
Choosing your structure: a guided chooser
Five questions decide most structure choices: how many owners, investors or not, how much risk, how much profit you keep in the business, and how much paperwork you can handle. A guided chooser for India, Canada and the USA, with a side-by-side table of every structure.
Module 3 · about 12 minutes. You’ll pick a starting structure for your business with clear reasons, and know what would make you change it.
1. Five questions
- Owners: just you, or several people?
- Investors: will you sell shares to angels or venture capital?
- Risk: could the business run up debts, injure someone or be sued?
- Profit kept: will you leave profit in the business to grow, or live on it?
- Paperwork: how much yearly admin and cost can you handle?
Key idea: Pick for the next two or three years, not forever. Changing structure later is normal (Lesson 3.7), but it costs time and sometimes tax, so if investment is likely soon, start as a company.
2. All the structures side by side
| Proprietorship | Partnership firm | LLP | OPC | Private limited | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owners | 1 | 2 to 50 | 2 or more | 1 | 2 to 200 |
| Liability | Unlimited | Unlimited, shared | Limited | Limited | Limited |
| Registered with | Nobody centrally | State Registrar of Firms (optional) | MCA | MCA | MCA |
| Tax on profit | Your slab rates | 30 % + cess | 30 % + cess | 22 % or 25 % regime | 22 % regime (25.17 % effective) |
| Raise equity | No | No | Rarely | Must convert | Yes |
| Yearly compliance | Low | Low | Medium | Medium to high | High (audit, board meetings, ROC filings) |
| Sole proprietorship | General partnership | Corporation (CCPC) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owners | 1 | 2 or more | 1 or more |
| Liability | Unlimited | Unlimited, shared | Limited |
| Registered with | Province (name, if not your own) | Province | Province or Corporations Canada |
| Tax on profit | Your personal rates (T1) | Each partner’s personal rates | Small business rate ~11 to 12.2 % on first $500k (T2), then personal tax when paid out |
| Raise equity | No | No | Yes |
| Yearly compliance | Low | Low | Medium (T2, annual return, minutes) |
| Sole proprietorship | Single-member LLC | Multi-member LLC | S corp | C corp | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owners | 1 | 1 | 2 or more | Up to 100 US persons | Any |
| Liability | Unlimited | Limited | Limited | Limited | Limited |
| Registered with | County DBA if needed | State | State | State + IRS election | State |
| Federal tax | Schedule C + SE tax | Schedule C + SE tax | 1065 + K-1s | 1120-S, salary + pass-through | 1120 at 21 %, dividends taxed again |
| Raise VC | No | No | Hard | No | Yes |
| Yearly compliance | Low | Low | Low to medium | Medium (payroll) | Medium to high |
Watch it happen
Neha, Jaipur: solo, low risk, lives on the profit: sole proprietorship with GST and Udyam.
Tom and Aisha, Calgary: two founders, software, want angel money: federal corporation.
Luis, Miami: plumber, two vans, $150,000 profit: LLC with an S corp election.
Lesson: same five questions, three different answers, each fitting today’s plan.
- Liability
- who pays if the business owes money or is sued
- Pass-through
- business profit taxed on the owners’ personal returns
- Small business rate
- Canada: low corporate tax on a CCPC’s first C$500,000 of active income
- Deferral
- tax postponed by keeping profit inside a company
- What it means for you
- Answer the five questions for your idea, pick for the next two or three years, and if investment is likely soon, start as a company.
3. Worked example
Made-up founders. Three cases, three answers from the chooser:
- Neha, Jaipur, solo, sells handmade jewellery online, low risk, lives on the profit: sole proprietorship with GST and Udyam.
- Tom and Aisha, Calgary, building software, want angel money: corporation, federal so the name is protected nationally.
- Luis, Miami, plumber with two vans and $150,000 profit: LLC with an S corp election.
“There is one best structure for every startup.” The right structure depends on owners, risk, profit, plans to raise and country. A solo freelancer and a venture-backed team need different answers.
4. Practice
- Run the chooser for your own idea. Write down the answer and the one thing that would change it.
- Why is an Indian LLP rarely used by startups that plan to raise money?
- What does a Canadian sole proprietor give up compared with a CCPC?
Answers
- Your own answer.
- Investors want shares, preferences and ESOPs, which LLPs cannot issue; Indian foreign investment rules for LLPs are also narrower.
- Limited liability, and the option of leaving profit in the business at the small business tax rate.
- Five questions: owners, risk, profit, raising money, place.
- Raising soon: India private limited, Canada corporation, USA Delaware C corp.
- Low risk and solo: a sole proprietorship is fine to start.
- High profit: a company can defer tax (Canada) or save payroll tax (US S corp).
- Changing later is normal but costs time and sometimes tax.
Next: Where to register.
New words: business structure, liability, compliance, equity.
Rules as of November 2026. Not legal or tax advice.
Check yourself
Sources
- Startup India, choosing an entity: https://www.startupindia.gov.in
- Government of Canada, Choose a business structure: https://www.canada.ca/en/services/business/start.html
- SBA, Choose a business structure: https://www.sba.gov/business-guide/launch-your-business/choose-business-structure
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not legal or tax advice. Laws, rates and fees change, and your situation may differ: follow the official source linked in the lesson and check with a lawyer, chartered accountant or CPA before you act. Calculators run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.