Module 9: Hiring and payroll · Lesson 9.5 · about 11 min
The true cost of a hire
What one employee really costs a startup in India, Canada and the USA: salary, the employer’s payroll contributions, benefits, equipment, space, recruiting and time to productivity, compared with a contractor, so you can price your product and plan runway before you hire.
Module 9 · about 11 minutes. You’ll work out what a hire costs in full, and compare it with a contractor before you commit.
1. More than salary
Every employee costs you their salary plus:
- Payroll contributions: PF, ESI and gratuity (India); CPP, EI and vacation pay (Canada); FICA, FUTA and state unemployment (USA). Lessons 9.2 to 9.4.
- Insurance: workers’ compensation (Canada, USA); group health insurance, which in the USA is often the second biggest cost.
- Benefits you choose to offer: health, dental, retirement matching, learning budget.
- Tools: laptop, software seats, phone.
- Space: a desk, co-working seat or home-office allowance.
- Recruiting: job ads, recruiter fees (often 15 % to 25 % of first-year salary), your own interview time.
- Ramp-up: new hires are rarely fully productive for the first one to three months.
Watch it happen
Salary: $70,000 for a Toronto analyst.
Payroll costs: 4 % vacation pay, CPP and EI add about $8,500.
Benefits and tools: $3,000 health and dental, $3,000 laptop and software.
Space and recruiting: $4,800 co-working desk, $3,000 a year of a $6,000 hiring cost.
Total: about $92,300 a year, 1.32 times the salary. Use this, not $70,000, in your runway model.
2. Employee or contractor, by cost
A contractor’s day rate looks high because they cover their own taxes, benefits, tools, holidays and gaps between contracts. Compare like with like: the employee’s full yearly cost against the contractor’s rate × the days you really need. For a short project, the contractor is usually cheaper; for steady, core work, the employee usually is (and contractors in that role may really be employees, Lesson 9.1).
Key idea: Add the full cost of each planned hire to your runway model (Lesson 2.5) before you post the job. Many first-time founders plan on salary alone and run out of cash months early.
3. Making a hire affordable
- Government programmes: wage subsidies for students and young workers (Canada Summer Jobs, provincial programmes; in India, apprenticeship schemes such as NAPS; US Work Opportunity Tax Credit for some groups). Check eligibility before hiring.
- Part-time or fixed-term to start, with the same legal protections.
- Equity (Module 10) in place of part of the salary, for early team members who share the risk.
- Hire in the order of need: the role that frees the founder’s time for selling usually pays back first.
- True cost
- everything a hire costs per year, not just salary
- Payroll on-costs
- the employer’s statutory contributions and taxes
- Ramp-up
- the months before a new hire is fully productive
- Cost multiple
- true cost ÷ salary
- Wage subsidy
- a government programme that pays part of a wage
- What it means for you
- Before posting a job, put the full yearly cost into your runway sheet and check you can afford 12 months of it.
4. Worked example
Made-up founder. Diego plans a $70,000 analyst in Toronto. Vacation pay, CPP and EI add about $8,500; benefits $3,000; laptop and software $3,000; a co-working desk $4,800; a $6,000 job ad and agency fee spread over two years, $3,000. True cost: about $92,300 a year, 1.32 times the salary: $7,700 a month of runway. A contractor at $450 a day for 220 days would cost $99,000, so for a permanent role the hire is cheaper.
“A contractor at $450 a day is far more expensive than a $70,000 employee.” Compare full costs: the employee costs about $92,000 with on-costs, tools and space. For a full year the gap is small, and for a 3-month project the contractor is far cheaper.
5. Practice
- List four costs of a hire beyond salary.
- Why compare a contractor’s rate with the employee’s full cost, not their salary?
- Your runway is 14 months with a $50,000 hire at 1.3 times. What happens if you plan on salary only?
Answers
- Payroll contributions, benefits, tools, space, recruiting, insurance, ramp-up time.
- The contractor’s rate already includes the taxes, benefits and tools the employer would pay for an employee.
- You under-count burn by $15,000 a year, so cash runs out about a month or more earlier than planned.
- True cost = salary + payroll contributions + insurance + benefits + tools + space + recruiting.
- Typical multiples: 1.2 to 1.4 times salary in Canada and the USA (higher with US health insurance); India adds PF, gratuity and insurance.
- Contractors cost more per day but carry their own taxes and tools; compare yearly totals for the days you need.
- Add every planned hire’s full cost to your runway model before you hire.
- Wage subsidies, part-time starts and equity can make early hires affordable.
Next: Offer letters, contracts and workplace safety. Model your runway with the [[cash-runway]] tool.
New words: true cost, payroll on-costs, benefits, ramp-up, wage subsidy.
Rates as of November 2026. Estimates, not financial advice.
Check yourself
Sources
- CRA, payroll rates: https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/businesses/topics/payroll.html
- IRS Publication 15: https://www.irs.gov/publications/p15
- EPFO and ESIC contribution rates: https://www.epfindia.gov.in
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employer Costs for Employee Compensation: https://www.bls.gov/ect/
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not legal or tax advice. Laws, rates and fees change, and your situation may differ: follow the official source linked in the lesson and check with a lawyer, chartered accountant or CPA before you act. Calculators run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.