Module 3: Choosing a legal structure · Lesson 3.4 · about 16 min
USA: LLC, C corporation or S corporation
In the USA the legal entity (LLC or corporation) and its tax treatment (disregarded, partnership, S corp or C corp) are separate choices. How each is taxed, an estimator that compares the federal tax on the same profit, and who should pick which.
Module 3 · about 16 minutes · USA focus. You’ll understand the difference between a legal entity and a tax election, and compare LLC, S corp and C corp taxes on your own numbers. (India and Canada readers: the ideas of “pass-through” and “double tax” come back in Module 8.)
1. Two separate choices
In the USA you choose:
- The legal entity under state law: LLC or corporation. This decides liability protection and paperwork.
- The tax treatment with the IRS. An LLC is taxed by default as a sole proprietorship (one member, “disregarded entity”) or partnership (two or more), but can elect to be taxed as a corporation (Form 8832) and then as an S corp (Form 2553). A corporation is a C corp unless it elects S status.
So “an LLC taxed as an S corp” is a real and common thing.
2. The three tax treatments
- Pass-through (sole prop / LLC / partnership). Profit is taxed once, on the owners’ personal returns, plus self-employment tax of 15.3 % (Social Security 12.4 % up to the wage base of $184,500 for 2026, Medicare 2.9 % on everything) on about 92.35 % of net earnings. Owners may deduct up to 20 % of qualified business income (QBI), now permanent.
- S corporation. Still pass-through for income tax, but owners who work in the business must take a reasonable salary through payroll. Payroll tax applies to the salary; the rest of the profit passes through without self-employment tax. That is the saving.
- C corporation. The company pays 21 % on its profit. When it pays dividends, shareholders pay tax again (qualified dividends at 0, 15 or 20 %). Profit kept in the company is taxed only once, for now.
Federal only, 2026 rules: self-employment and FICA tax 15.3 % on wages up to the $184,500 Social Security wage base (2.9 % above), corporate tax 21 %, qualified dividends taxed at 15 %, and the 20 % qualified business income (QBI) deduction applied in full. Real returns add state tax, income limits on QBI, the 0.9 % additional Medicare tax and payroll costs. Use it to compare, not to file.
Key idea: The S corp saving is roughly 15.3 % of the profit above your reasonable salary, minus the extra cost of payroll and a separate return. It rarely pays below about $40,000 to $60,000 of profit.
3. Who picks what
| Situation | Usual choice |
|---|---|
| Solo freelancer or small business, modest profit | Single-member LLC (Schedule C) |
| Partners in a service or local business | Multi-member LLC (Form 1065) |
| Profitable owner-operator, profit well above a fair salary | LLC or corporation with an S election |
| Raising venture capital, stock options for staff | Delaware C corporation |
| Founder hoping for a big tax-free exit | C corp for QSBS: gains on qualified small business stock held long enough can be excluded (for stock issued after 4 July 2025: 50 % after 3 years, 75 % after 4, 100 % after 5, up to $15 million or 10 times basis) |
S corps cannot have more than 100 shareholders, non-resident alien shareholders or more than one class of stock, so they don’t work with most investors. Founders who are not US citizens or green card holders and don’t live in the USA cannot own S corp shares.
Watch it happen
Form: a designer forms a single-member LLC. By default the IRS ignores it: profit goes on her Schedule C with 15.3 % self-employment tax.
Grow: profit reaches $120,000. She elects S corp status (Form 2553) and pays herself a reasonable $60,000 salary.
Effect: payroll tax applies only to the salary; the rest passes through without it, saving a few thousand dollars after payroll costs.
Raise money later? Investors want a C corporation, so she would convert then.
- LLC
- a state entity with limited liability and flexible tax treatment
- Disregarded entity
- a single-member LLC ignored for federal income tax
- S corporation
- a tax election: pass-through income with owner salaries
- C corporation
- pays 21 % corporate tax; dividends taxed again
- Reasonable salary
- the market pay an S corp owner must take for their work
- What it means for you
- Start with an LLC unless you plan to raise venture money (then a Delaware C corp), and look at an S corp election once profit passes about $40,000 to $60,000.
4. Worked example
Made-up numbers, using the estimator’s simple method (one 22 % rate on all income, no state tax). Carla’s design LLC makes $120,000 profit.
- Single-member LLC: self-employment tax ≈ $16,950; income tax on the rest after the half-SE deduction and the QBI deduction ≈ $19,630. Total ≈ $36,600.
- S corp with a $60,000 salary: payroll tax $9,180; income tax on salary plus pass-through profit after QBI ≈ $22,950. Total ≈ $32,100, before about $1,500 to $3,000 a year for payroll and the 1120-S return.
- C corp, same salary, the rest paid out as dividends: payroll $9,180, income tax on salary $13,200, corporate tax ≈ $11,640, dividend tax ≈ $6,570. Total ≈ $40,600.
The S election saves Carla about $4,500 before its extra costs, so roughly $1,500 to $3,000 a year net. At $200,000 profit the saving grows a lot. Real brackets are progressive and state taxes differ, so check with a CPA.
“An S corp is a type of company you form.” It is a tax election (Form 2553) made by a corporation or an LLC. The legal entity stays an LLC or corporation under state law.
5. Practice
- What form does an LLC file to be taxed as an S corp?
- Why must an S corp owner take a salary?
- A Delaware C corp with $50,000 profit pays how much federal corporate tax?
Answers
- Form 2553 (an LLC electing S status is treated as also electing corporate classification, so Form 8832 isn’t usually needed).
- The IRS requires reasonable pay for work done, so owners can’t avoid payroll tax by taking everything as distributions.
- 21 % × $50,000 = $10,500.
- Two choices: legal entity (LLC or corporation) and tax treatment.
- Pass-through: taxed once on the owner’s return, plus 15.3 % self-employment tax.
- S corp: reasonable salary through payroll, rest passes through without payroll tax; pays above about $40,000 to $60,000 profit.
- C corp: 21 % corporate tax, dividends taxed again; the standard for venture capital and QSBS.
- Elections: Form 8832 (entity classification), Form 2553 (S corp).
Next: Choosing your structure. Estimate your take-home with [[us-paycheck]].
New words: disregarded entity, pass-through, self-employment tax, reasonable salary, double taxation, QSBS, Form 2553.
Federal rules for tax year 2026, as of November 2026. Not tax advice.
Check yourself
Sources
- IRS, Limited liability company (LLC): https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/limited-liability-company-llc
- IRS, S corporations and Form 2553: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/s-corporations
- IRS, Self-employment tax: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/self-employment-tax-social-security-and-medicare-taxes
- SSA, Contribution and benefit base (Social Security wage base): https://www.ssa.gov/oact/cola/cbb.html
- IRS, Qualified business income deduction: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/qualified-business-income-deduction
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not legal or tax advice. Laws, rates and fees change, and your situation may differ: follow the official source linked in the lesson and check with a lawyer, chartered accountant or CPA before you act. Calculators run in your browser; nothing you type is sent anywhere.