Module 8: Nuclear and particle physics · Lesson 8.2 · about 50 min
Binding energy and the semi-empirical mass formula
Binding energy from atomic masses, mass excess and separation energies; the liquid-drop (Weizsäcker) mass formula term by term, with the reasons for each term and its coefficient; the valley of stability, mass parabolas for odd and even A, beta-decay Q values, double beta decay, and the energy and stability limits of fission.
Module 8 · about 50 minutes. The JAM lesson showed the binding curve and why fission and fusion both release energy. Here we build the curve from a model: the nucleus as a charged liquid drop, with two quantum corrections. Five terms and five numbers reproduce the masses of about 3000 nuclides to within a few MeV.
1. Binding energy from masses
Tables list atomic masses, so use the hydrogen atom for each proton; the electron masses cancel (electron binding is negligible here).
- Mass excess
- `$\Delta = [M - A\,\text{u}]c^2$`; tables list it, and `$Q$` values are differences of `$\Delta$`: `$\Delta(^1\text{H}) = 7.289$` MeV, `$\Delta(n) = 8.071$` MeV, `$\Delta(^{12}\text{C}) = 0$` by definition
- Neutron separation energy
- `$S_n = B(Z, A) - B(Z, A-1)$`: energy to pull out the last neutron; similarly `$S_p$` with `$Z - 1$`
- `$B/A$`
- rises steeply to about 8 MeV by `$A = 20$`, peaks at 8.79 MeV near `$^{56}$`Fe and `$^{62}$`Ni, then falls slowly to 7.6 MeV for uranium
Worked example. Fe has u. Then MeV, or 8.79 MeV per nucleon. Separation energies jump at magic numbers: O MeV, but O MeV, a clue to the shell structure of lesson 8.3.
2. The liquid-drop mass formula
with, in one common fit, , , , MeV and MeV for even-even nuclei, for odd-odd and 0 for odd A. (Other fits differ by a few percent; GATE questions give the coefficients.)
Volume. Short-range forces saturate: each nucleon binds to a fixed number of neighbours, so B ∝ A. (With long-range forces every pair would count and B would grow as A².)
Surface. Nucleons at the surface have fewer neighbours. The surface area is 4πR² ∝ A^(2/3). This is the surface tension of the drop, and it matters most for light nuclei.
Coulomb. Z protons spread uniformly through a sphere of radius R = r₀A^(1/3) have energy (3/5)Z(Z − 1)e²/(4πε₀R). With r₀ = 1.2 fm this gives a_C = (3/5)(1.44/1.2) = 0.72 MeV, close to the fitted value: a check from first principles.
Asymmetry. In the Fermi gas of lesson 8.1, protons and neutrons fill separate ladders of levels. Moving nucleons from one ladder to the other to make N ≠ Z costs kinetic energy ∝ (N − Z)²/A. It is a quantum effect (the Pauli principle), with no classical drop analogue.
Pairing. Like nucleons in time-reversed orbits (j, m and j, −m) bind extra strongly. Even-even nuclei gain, odd-odd nuclei lose, and odd-A nuclei sit in between.
Worked example. Fe from the formula: volume 884.8, surface −267.9, Coulomb , asymmetry , pairing ; total 490.6 MeV, 8.76 MeV per nucleon, within 0.4% of the measured 492.3 MeV. The surface term is the biggest correction for iron; in uranium the Coulomb term overtakes it (965 MeV against 703 MeV), which is why the curve falls at large A.
3. The valley of stability and mass parabolas
At fixed A the formula is a quadratic in Z. Setting (and using for ):
For A = 56 this gives 25.2 (iron has 26); for A = 238, 91.9 (uranium has 92). Including the neutron-hydrogen mass difference moves up slightly. The mass of the isobars is then a parabola in Z:
- Odd A: one parabola. Nuclides on the neutron-rich side decay toward , those on the proton-rich side decay by or electron capture. Exactly one isobar is stable (with rare near-degenerate exceptions).
- Even A: two parabolas apart, the odd-odd one above. An odd-odd nucleus near the bottom can often decay both ways (Cu does and ), and two even-even isobars can both be stable, because the single-beta step between them goes up to the odd-odd sheet. They can still change into each other by double beta decay, , with half-lives above years (Ge to Se, Te to Xe).
Beta Q values come straight from atomic masses:
The in is why some proton-rich nuclei can only decay by electron capture: they need at least 1.022 MeV of mass difference to emit a positron.
4. Fission and the limits of stability
Split a nucleus (Z, A) into two halves. The volume and asymmetry terms do not change; the surface grows by a factor and the Coulomb energy falls by . The energy released is
So fission releases energy for everything heavier than about silver, but a barrier holds it back. The barrier vanishes when a small elongation lowers the energy at once. For a spheroid of small eccentricity , the surface energy grows as and the Coulomb energy falls as , so the sphere is unstable when
Uranium ( for U) is well below this limit: its fission barrier is about 6 MeV. Capturing a slow neutron adds MeV to U, enough to go over the barrier; U capturing a neutron gets only 4.8 MeV (odd N, no pairing bonus), which is why U is the fissile isotope.
Worked example. U 2 Pd from the formula: surface MeV cost, Coulomb MeV gained, asymmetry unchanged, pairing . Net MeV, close to the 200 MeV measured for real (asymmetric) fission, most of it as kinetic energy of the fragments.
Fusion is the other side of the curve: light nuclei gain binding by joining because the surface term per nucleon falls. H + H He + n releases 17.6 MeV, much of it from the exceptionally tight He (28.3 MeV, 7.07 MeV per nucleon), which the smooth formula does not capture.
“The mass formula gives exact Q values, so it can replace a mass table.” It is a smooth average, good to a few MeV for heavy nuclei and much worse for light ones and near magic numbers, where shell effects add or remove several MeV. For a Q value that decides whether a decay happens, use measured masses; use the formula for trends, estimates and understanding.
- with atomic masses; .
- SEMF: ; typical 15.8, 18.3, 0.714, 23.2 MeV and .
- ; the asymmetry term comes from the Pauli principle, pairing from time-reversed pairs.
- ; odd A: one parabola, one stable isobar; even A: two parabolas apart.
- , , (atomic masses).
- Symmetric fission releases energy for ; no barrier for ; about 200 MeV per fission.
Practise: exam questions on this lesson
Next: lesson 8.3 explains what the liquid drop cannot: the magic numbers, the jumps in separation energy and the spins and moments of nuclei.
Check yourself
Sources
- K. S. Krane, Introductory Nuclear Physics (1988), chapters 3 and 13
- B. Povh, K. Rith, C. Scholz, F. Zetsche and W. Rodejohann, Particles and Nuclei, 7th ed. (2015), chapter 2
- M. Wang et al., The AME 2020 atomic mass evaluation, Chinese Physics C 45, 030003 (2021)
- GATE Physics (PH) syllabus, Nuclear and Particle Physics section, published by the organising IIT each year
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with the IITs, IISc or the GATE organising institute. The general aptitude part of GATE is not covered here. Check the official GATE website for the current pattern. All questions are original.