Module 8: Nuclear and particle physics · Lesson 8.5 · about 50 min
Nuclear reactions and Q values
Reaction kinematics at MSc level: the Q equation with angles, thresholds in the lab and the double-valued forward cone, relativistic thresholds from the invariant mass; cross-sections, reaction rates and the barn; partial-wave limits, the compound nucleus and Bohr independence, the Breit-Wigner formula and the 1/v law; direct reactions and what stripping tells us about orbits.
Module 8 · about 50 minutes. The JAM lesson on reactions covered notation, Q values from masses, simple thresholds, and fission and fusion. Here we work out the full kinematics with angles, do thresholds relativistically, and see what cross-sections tell us about the mechanism of a reaction.
1. The Q equation
For with at rest, . Eliminate the unobserved with momentum conservation (, non-relativistic):
Measuring , and gives , and with it the mass of an unknown , or the energy of an excited state of (each excited level gives its own, smaller : ). Read as a quadratic in , it gives the outgoing energy:
- Threshold
- for `$Q < 0$`, the smallest `$T_a$` that makes the square root real at `$\theta = 0$`: `$T_{\text{th}} = -Q\,\dfrac{m_Y + m_b}{m_Y + m_b - m_a} \approx -Q\left(1 + \dfrac{m_a}{m_X}\right)$`
- Double values
- just above threshold both signs give positive `$\sqrt{T_b}$`: b comes out only inside a forward cone, with two energies at each angle, because the centre of mass moves faster than b does in the CM frame
- Exothermic
- for `$Q > 0$` there is no threshold, though charged particles still need to get over the Coulomb barrier for a useful rate
Worked example. Li(p, n)Be: MeV. Threshold: MeV, as measured. At threshold all the neutrons move forward with keV: this reaction is a standard source of nearly monoenergetic slow neutrons. A little above threshold, the figure shows the two branches in the forward cone.
2. Relativistic thresholds
When the products include new particles, as in meson production, use the invariant , the same in every frame. In the lab (target at rest) ; at threshold all products are at rest in the CM frame, so :
Worked example. Making antiprotons, : GeV. The Bevatron at Berkeley was built for about 6 GeV for exactly this reason, and found the antiproton in 1955. Only goes into new mass; the rest stays as motion of the centre of mass. This is why colliding beams, with , are so much more efficient than fixed targets.
3. Cross-sections
A beam of particles per second per unit area hitting a thin target of nuclei produces reactions at a rate . The cross-section is an effective area, measured in barns: 1 b = m² = 100 fm², about the geometric size of a heavy nucleus. The differential cross-section counts particles going into solid angle ; partial cross-sections for each exit channel add up to the total.
Partial-wave limits. A beam of wave number can be split into partial waves of angular momentum , which pass the nucleus at impact parameter about . Each partial wave can absorb at most a flux corresponding to an area , with . Summing up to :
The total for a fully absorbing (“black”) nucleus is twice the geometric area: absorption must be accompanied by an equal amount of diffraction (shadow) scattering.
4. The compound nucleus and resonances
At low energy a neutron entering a nucleus shares its energy with all the nucleons and forms a compound nucleus that lives long ( s or more, compared with s for a nucleon to cross the nucleus). It then decays by whatever channels are open. Bohr’s independence hypothesis: the decay depends only on the energy, spin and parity of the compound state, not on how it was formed. The cross-section factorises, .
Near an isolated level of energy and total width , the cross-section has the Breit-Wigner form:
- `$\Gamma = \hbar/\tau$`
- total width of the compound state, the sum of the partial widths `$\Gamma_a, \Gamma_b, \ldots$` for each channel
- Peak
- at `$E = E_R$`, `$\sigma = 4\pi ƛ^2g\,\Gamma_a\Gamma_b/\Gamma^2$`; half height at `$E_R \pm \Gamma/2$`
- `$g$`
- the statistical factor: the fraction of spin states of the entrance channel that can form a compound state of spin `$J$`
- 1/v law
- well below the first resonance, `$\Gamma_n \propto v$` and `$\pi ƛ^2 \propto 1/v^2$`, so `$\sigma \propto 1/v$`; boron and cadmium absorbers follow it for thermal neutrons
Worked example. A neutron resonance at 1.00 eV has eV, eV and . A 1 eV neutron has fm, so fm² b. The peak capture cross-section is b, about a hundred thousand times the geometric area of a heavy nucleus ( b). Slow neutrons are huge to a nucleus.
5. Direct reactions
At higher energies (tens of MeV) the projectile often interacts with one nucleon or the surface and leaves in about s, with no compound nucleus. Examples: stripping (d, p), where the neutron of the deuteron is captured into an orbit of the target; pickup (p, d); inelastic scattering exciting collective states. Direct reactions give forward-peaked angular distributions, while compound-nucleus decay is nearly symmetric about 90°.
In (d, p) the captured neutron brings orbital angular momentum , where is the momentum transfer. So the angle of the first peak of the proton distribution measures , and with it the orbit of the shell model the neutron entered. C(d, p)C ( MeV to the ground state) shows an pattern, as expected for a neutron going into ; the parity of the final state is .
“A reaction with positive Q happens for any beam energy, and a negative-Q reaction starts as soon as the beam brings |Q|.” Positive Q makes it allowed, not likely: two charged nuclei must still tunnel through their Coulomb barrier, which is why fusion needs millions of kelvin. And a negative-Q reaction needs more than |Q|, because the products must keep moving to conserve momentum; for fixed-target particle production the excess can be several times the new rest energy.
- ; an excited state of Y lowers Q by .
- Non-relativistic threshold ; just above it, b is confined to a forward cone with two energies.
- Relativistic threshold ; antiproton production needs .
- ; 1 b = 100 fm²; black disc , twice that.
- Compound nucleus: independence hypothesis; Breit-Wigner ; law at low energy.
- Direct reactions are fast and forward-peaked; stripping angular distributions give of the captured nucleon.
Practise: exam questions on this lesson
Next: lesson 8.6 goes inside the nucleons themselves: leptons, hadrons, quarks and the forces between them.
Check yourself
Sources
- K. S. Krane, Introductory Nuclear Physics (1988), chapter 11
- J. M. Blatt and V. F. Weisskopf, Theoretical Nuclear Physics (1952), chapters 8 and 9
- S. N. Ghoshal, An experimental verification of the theory of compound nucleus, Physical Review 80, 939 (1950)
- GATE Physics (PH) syllabus, Nuclear and Particle Physics section, published by the organising IIT each year
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with the IITs, IISc or the GATE organising institute. The general aptitude part of GATE is not covered here. Check the official GATE website for the current pattern. All questions are original.