Module 7: Solid state physics · Lesson 7.3 · about 45 min
Bonding in solids
Why atoms stick together: ionic crystals with the Madelung constant, Born-Landé and Born-Mayer energies, the Born-Haber cycle and bulk modulus; van der Waals solids with the Lennard-Jones potential and lattice sums; covalent, metallic and hydrogen bonds; radius ratios, zero-point effects and the force constants that set phonon frequencies.
Module 7 · about 45 minutes. The previous lessons described where atoms sit. This one asks what holds them there and how strongly. The answer, an energy curve with a minimum, gives the lattice spacing (its position), the cohesive energy (its depth), the bulk modulus and the spring constants of phonons (its curvature).
1. The general well
Write the energy of a pair, or per atom of the crystal, as
Setting gives and so
Three lessons hide here. The repulsion cancels a fraction of the attraction at the minimum. A minimum exists only if . And the curvature, which sets the bulk modulus and the vibration frequency, grows with : a harder wall means a stiffer solid.
- `$r_0$`
- equilibrium separation (nearest-neighbour distance in the crystal)
- `$-U(r_0)$`
- cohesive or lattice energy: the work to pull the solid apart into atoms (cohesive) or ions (lattice)
- `$U''(r_0)$`
- force constant `$k$`; with the atomic mass it sets vibration frequencies `$\omega\sim\sqrt{k/m}$`
- `$B = V\,d^2U/dV^2$`
- bulk modulus, the curvature measured against volume
2. Ionic crystals
In NaCl each ion is surrounded by 6 opposite ions at , 12 like ions at , 8 opposite at , 6 like at , and so on. The Coulomb energy per ion pair is (, eV Å) with the Madelung constant
The series converges only conditionally: summed shell by shell it swings (6, −2.49, 2.13, −0.87, …). Correct values come from summing neutral groups (Evjen) or the Ewald method. Some values: 1D alternating chain , ZnS 1.638, NaCl 1.748, CsCl 1.763. More neighbours give a larger constant, but only slightly.
Adding a repulsion gives the Born-Landé energy per ion pair and per mole:
with kJ Å/mol. The Born-Mayer form is closer to the true Pauli repulsion and gives .
Worked example (NaCl). , Å, : kJ/mol. The Born-Haber cycle gives about 787 kJ/mol; the remaining 4% is van der Waals attraction and zero-point energy that the simple model ignores. With Born-Mayer, Å and Å, the binding per pair is eV.
The Born exponent is measured from compressibility. With per ion pair in rock salt, works out to
NaCl’s GPa gives .
The Born-Haber cycle links lattice energy (crystal → ions) to cohesive energy (crystal → atoms): cohesive = lattice − ionisation energy of the metal + electron affinity of the non-metal. For NaCl, eV per pair. Transferring the electron costs eV at infinite separation, which the Coulomb attraction pays back within Å.
Which structure? Hard-sphere geometry gives the radius-ratio limits: a cation touches 8 anions in a cube only if (CsCl), 6 in an octahedron if (NaCl), 4 in a tetrahedron if (ZnS). Because the Madelung gain from 6 to 8 neighbours is under 1%, a rattling cation is never worth it.
3. Van der Waals solids and the Lennard-Jones potential
Closed-shell atoms (Ne, Ar, Kr, Xe, also molecules like CH₄) attract through correlated fluctuating dipoles: the London force, energy . The standard model is
zero at , minimum at , curvature . The has a physical origin; the is a convenient stand-in for Pauli repulsion.
In the fcc crystal, sum over all neighbours with the lattice sums and ( = nearest-neighbour distance):
and the bulk modulus . (the steep repulsion is almost all nearest neighbours) but is 20% bigger: the slow tail adds 43% to the cohesive energy compared with nearest neighbours alone (6ε).
Worked example (argon). meV, Å: Å (measured 3.76), cohesive energy meV per atom (measured 80), GPa (measured 2.7). The deviations, largest for light neon and dramatic for helium, are zero-point motion: confining a light atom costs kinetic energy comparable to a 1 meV well, which is why helium stays liquid at 0 K unless squeezed to about 25 bar.
The curvature gives the vibration frequency of an Ar₂ dimer: N/m, , THz. Phonon frequencies in solid argon are of this size, as lesson 7.4 will use.
Switch between the two bonds in the figure: for the ionic crystal raise and see the wall harden and the binding approach the full Madelung energy; for van der Waals compare the isolated pair with the crystal.
4. Covalent, metallic and hydrogen bonds
Covalent. Two atoms share an electron pair. In the Heitler-London picture of H₂ the bonding state has a symmetric spatial wavefunction (charge piled between the nuclei) and therefore an antisymmetric spin singlet. Bonds are directional and saturable: carbon, silicon and germanium use hybrids at (), giving the open diamond structure (4 neighbours, packing fraction 0.34). Cohesive energies are large (Si 4.6 eV, C 7.4 eV per atom), and the bonding electrons are localised, so these solids are insulators or semiconductors. III-V and II-VI compounds (GaAs, ZnSe) keep the tetrahedral bonds but become partly ionic as the electronegativity difference grows.
Metallic. The valence electrons leave their atoms and are shared by the whole crystal. The energy depends mainly on density, not on bond angles, so metals pack densely (fcc, hcp, bcc) and deform plastically. Alkali metals bind weakly (Na 1.1 eV per atom); transition metals bind strongly through partly filled bands (W 8.9 eV). Because the electron gas adds a volume-dependent, non-pairwise energy, metals violate the Cauchy relation that any crystal held by central pair forces (with every atom at an inversion centre) must obey; rare-gas solids nearly satisfy it.
Hydrogen bonds. A hydrogen bonded to O, N or F is attracted to the lone pair of another electronegative atom: mostly electrostatic, 0.1 to 0.5 eV. In ice each molecule makes four of them in a tetrahedron, an open network that collapses partly on melting: water is denser than ice.
| Bond | Typical cohesive energy per atom | Directional? | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| van der Waals | 0.02 to 0.2 eV | no | Ne, Ar, solid CH₄ |
| hydrogen | 0.1 to 0.5 eV per bond | yes | ice, HF |
| metallic | 1 to 9 eV | no | Na, Cu, W |
| ionic | 3 to 4 eV (6 to 8 eV per pair) | no | NaCl, MgO |
| covalent | 4 to 8 eV | yes | Si, Ge, diamond |
“Keeping only nearest neighbours is good enough.” For the Lennard-Jones solid it underestimates the binding by 30%. For an ionic crystal it is worse than useless: the 6 nearest opposite ions give , but the next 12 like ions repel more than the first shell attracts, and the shell-by-shell sum keeps swinging. Long-range forces need the whole lattice, summed carefully.
- : , minimum only if , curvature .
- Madelung: chain , ZnS 1.638, NaCl 1.748, CsCl 1.763; conditionally convergent.
- Born-Landé ; Born-Mayer factor ; for rock salt.
- Born-Haber: cohesive = lattice − ionisation energy + electron affinity.
- Lennard-Jones pair: , depth , . fcc crystal: , per atom, .
- Radius ratios: 0.732 (8-fold), 0.414 (6-fold), 0.225 (4-fold). Covalent bonds pair spins (singlet) and fix angles; metals bind through shared electrons and break the Cauchy relation.
Practise: exam questions on this lesson
Next: lesson 7.4 lets the atoms move in these wells and finds the normal modes of the whole crystal.
Check yourself
Sources
- C. Kittel, Introduction to Solid State Physics, 8th ed. (2005), chapter 3
- N. W. Ashcroft and N. D. Mermin, Solid State Physics (1976), chapters 19 and 20
- M. Born and K. Huang, Dynamical Theory of Crystal Lattices (1954), chapter 1
- GATE Physics (PH) and CSIR NET Physical Sciences syllabi, Solid State Physics sections
Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.
Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with the IITs, IISc or the GATE organising institute. The general aptitude part of GATE is not covered here. Check the official GATE website for the current pattern. All questions are original.