Home / Learn / Exam prep / GATE Physics / Lesson 7.4
All lessons

Module 7: Solid state physics · Lesson 7.4 · about 50 min

Lattice vibrations and phonons

Normal modes of a crystal: the monatomic chain with its dispersion, group and phase velocities and density of states; the diatomic chain with acoustic and optical branches and a gap; branches in 3D; crystal momentum and Umklapp processes; phonon statistics; neutron and Raman measurements; LO-TO splitting and the Lyddane-Sachs-Teller relation.

Key points, meanings and formulas on one page: choose "Save as PDF" in the print box.

Module 7 · about 50 minutes. The bonding lesson gave each pair of atoms a spring constant k=U′′(r0). Now let every atom move. Because the springs connect neighbours, atoms cannot vibrate alone: the motions organise into waves running through the whole crystal, labelled by a wave vector in the Brillouin zone.

A harmonic crystal of N atoms is exactly equivalent to 3N independent oscillators, its normal modes. Each mode is a wave with wave vector k and frequency ω(k). Quantised, each mode holds a whole number of phonons of energy ħω. Heat capacity, thermal conductivity, sound and infrared absorption are all statements about these modes.

1. The monatomic chain

Atoms of mass m, spacing a, nearest-neighbour springs K. Newton’s law for atom n:

mu¨n=K(un+1−un)−K(un−un−1)

Try a wave. Put u_n = A exp[i(kna − ωt)]. Every atom does the same motion, shifted in phase by ka from its neighbour.

Substitute. −mω² = K(e^{ika} + e^{−ika} − 2) = −2K(1 − cos ka) = −4K sin²(ka/2).

Dispersion. ω = 2√(K/m) |sin(ka/2)|: linear at small k, flat at the zone edge, highest value ω_m = 2√(K/m).

Only the first zone matters. k and k + 2π/a give identical displacements at every atom, so all distinct modes have −π/a < k ≤ π/a. With N atoms and periodic boundary conditions the allowed k are spaced by 2π/(Na): exactly N modes.

ω(k)=2Km|sin⁡ka2|,vg=dωdk=aKmcos⁡ka2,vs=aKm
`$v_s$`
sound speed: the slope at small `$k$`, where phase and group velocities agree (no dispersion)
`$v_g$` at `$k = \pi/a$`
zero: neighbours move in exact opposition, a standing wave made by Bragg reflection
`$v_p = \omega/k$` at `$k = \pi/a$`
`$(2/\pi)v_s$`, not zero; in general `$v_p/v_g = \tan(ka/2)/(ka/2)$`
Density of states
modes are evenly spaced in `$k$`, so `$g(\omega) = \dfrac{2N}{\pi}\dfrac1{\sqrt{\omega_m^2 - \omega^2}}$`, which diverges at `$\omega_m$` (a van Hove singularity)

Worked example. Atoms of 40 u, K=15 N/m, a=3.0 Å: K/m=1.50×1013 s⁻¹, so vs=4.5 km/s and ωm=3.0×1013 rad/s (νm=4.8 THz). Modes below ωm/2 fill |k|<π/3a: one third of all modes.

Further neighbours add terms: ω2=4m∑pKpsin2⁡(pka/2). A second-neighbour spring counts four times in the sound speed, vs=a(K1+4K2)/m, because it is stretched twice as much.

2. The diatomic chain

Now alternate masses M1>M2 with equal springs, repeat distance a. Two equations, two amplitudes, and a 2×2 determinant give

ω±2=K(1M1+1M2)±K(1M1+1M2)2−4sin2⁡(ka/2)M1M2
k=0 k=π/a
acoustic ω− 0 (rigid translation) 2K/M1: only heavy atoms move
optical ω+ 2K(1/M1+1/M2): the two atoms opposite, centre of mass fixed 2K/M2: only light atoms move

Between 2K/M1 and 2K/M2 no wave propagates: a gap. It closes when the masses become equal (the chain then has period a/2 and its single branch, folded, is all there is) and widens as M1→∞, when the optical branch becomes flat at 2K/M2 (each light atom rattling between fixed heavy ones, an Einstein oscillator). Equal masses with alternating springs K1,K2 also open a gap, between 2K2/m and 2K1/m: any doubling of the period does.

At small k the acoustic branch is ω≈aK/2(M1+M2)k, the sound speed of the total mass per repeat. In an ionic crystal the optical mode at k=0 moves positive and negative ions against each other, an oscillating dipole that absorbs infrared light: hence the name.

Watch it in the figure. Choose the optical branch near k=0: neighbours move in opposition with amplitudes in the ratio M2:M1. Move to the zone edge: in each branch one kind of atom stops.

Top: one normal mode of the chain (displacements drawn sideways and exaggerated; the real motion is along the chain). Bottom: the dispersion with the chosen mode marked and the gap shaded.

3. Three dimensions

With p atoms per primitive cell and N cells there are 3pN modes in 3p branches: 3 acoustic (one longitudinal LA, two transverse TA, usually lower because shear is softer) and 3p−3 optical. Copper: 3 branches, no optical. Si, NaCl, CsCl, hcp metals: 6 (3 optical). Perovskite SrTiO₃ (5 atoms): 15 (12 optical).

In polar crystals the long-wavelength optical modes split. The longitudinal one carries a macroscopic electric field that stiffens it, and the Lyddane-Sachs-Teller relation fixes the split:

ωLO2ωTO2=ε(0)ε(∞)

For NaCl, 5.9/2.25=1.62. Between ωTO and ωLO the dielectric function is negative and the crystal reflects infrared almost totally (the reststrahlen band). In non-polar Si there is no such field, so LO and TO are degenerate at k=0; its optical phonon is Raman active (520 cm⁻¹, 64.5 meV) but not infrared active. In a displacive ferroelectric one TO mode softens towards zero as T→Tc; by LST, ε(0) then diverges (the Curie-Weiss law).

4. Phonons: quanta, momentum, measurement

Quantising each mode gives energies (n+12)ℏω. A phonon is one quantum. Phonons are bosons whose number is not conserved, so their chemical potential is zero and the mean occupation is the Planck form

⟨n⟩=1eℏω/kBT−1

(0.613 for a 25 meV mode at 300 K). A phonon carries crystal momentum ℏq→, defined modulo ℏG→; it is conserved in collisions only up to ℏG→. When two phonons merge with q→1+q→2 outside the zone, the result is folded back by a G→: on a chain, 0.7π/a+0.6π/a=1.3π/a→−0.7π/a. These Umklapp processes reverse heat flow and give insulators their thermal resistance; normal processes (G→=0) only shuffle energy. Both need anharmonic terms in the potential, which also cause thermal expansion; a perfectly harmonic crystal would neither expand nor resist heat flow.

Kinetic theory gives the lattice thermal conductivity κ=13Cvℓ. At high temperature ℓ∝1/T (more phonons to scatter from); well below θD, Umklapp needs phonons with q∼G/2, whose number falls as e−θD/bT, so κ rises steeply until ℓ reaches the sample size, and then falls with C∝T3.

Measuring dispersion. Inelastic neutron scattering conserves energy and crystal momentum:

Ei−Ef=±ℏω(q→),k→i−k→f=q→+G→

Thermal neutrons (E=81.8/λ2 meV with λ in Å) have energies comparable to phonons, so the energy change is easy to measure. A neutron of 2.000 Å (20.45 meV) that creates a 5.00 meV phonon leaves with 15.45 meV and 2.301 Å. Raman and infrared spectroscopy see only q≈0, because a photon’s wave vector is a thousandth of the zone.

“A phonon is a tiny particle with momentum ℏq, and the diatomic optical branch exists in every crystal.” A phonon is a collective excitation of the whole lattice; apart from q=0 it carries no physical momentum, only crystal momentum, which a reciprocal vector can change. And optical branches need at least two atoms per primitive cell: copper has none, and a “diatomic” chain of equal masses has none either, because its true period is half as long.

  • Monatomic chain: ω=2K/m|sin⁡(ka/2)|, vs=aK/m, vg=vscos⁡(ka/2), zero at the zone edge; N modes in the first zone.
  • 1D density of states 2Nπ(ωm2−ω2)−1/2; number below ω: 2Nπarcsin⁡(ω/ωm).
  • Diatomic chain: optical 2K(1/M1+1/M2) at k=0; gap from 2K/M1 to 2K/M2 at k=π/a; acoustic sound speed aK/2(M1+M2).
  • 3D: 3p branches, 3 acoustic, 3p−3 optical. LST: ωLO2/ωTO2=ε(0)/ε(∞).
  • Phonons: bosons with μ=0; crystal momentum modulo ℏG→; Umklapp q→1+q→2=q→3+G→ limits κ=13Cvℓ.
  • Neutrons measure ω(q→) across the zone; light sees only q≈0.

Practise: exam questions on this lesson

Next: lesson 7.5 puts thermal energy into these modes and gets the heat capacity of solids, from Dulong-Petit to the Debye T3 law. The band structure explorer shows the same chain mathematics for electrons.

Check yourself

1For a diatomic chain with masses M₁ > M₂ and equal springs K, the frequencies at the zone boundary are
2How many optical branches does a crystal with 5 atoms per primitive cell have?
3In an Umklapp process between phonons,

Sources

  • C. Kittel, Introduction to Solid State Physics, 8th ed. (2005), chapters 4 and 5
  • N. W. Ashcroft and N. D. Mermin, Solid State Physics (1976), chapters 22, 24 and 25
  • M. T. Dove, Introduction to Lattice Dynamics (1993), chapters 3 to 6
  • GATE Physics (PH) syllabus, Solid State Physics section, published by the organising IIT each year

Your ticks stay in this browser. Save them as a file on the course home.

Updated 2026-11-22. Not affiliated with the IITs, IISc or the GATE organising institute. The general aptitude part of GATE is not covered here. Check the official GATE website for the current pattern. All questions are original.